Hansard·Grand Committee·Vol. 861

State Schools: GCSE and A-level Arts Subjects

Thursday, 19 November 2026

19 contributions16 members

Contributions

  1. Question for Short Debate

    View contribution permalink →

  2. Asked by

    View contribution permalink →

  3. Baroness Keeley

    To ask His Majesty’s Government what steps they are taking to increase entries for arts subjects at GCSE and A Level in state schools.

    View contribution permalink →

  4. Baroness Keeley (Lab)

    My Lords, since the first Labour Arts Minister, Jennie Lee, through to our current Culture Secretary, Lisa Nandy, there has been a driving passion that all our children should be given the kind of education that used to be the monopoly of the privileged few. That principle remains as important today as it was in 1965. However, due to the education policies of the Conservative-led Government since 2010, for too many young people in state schools, an arts-rich education exists only for those whose parents can pay for extracurricular tuition. Arts education is not just about preparing future artists; it helps young people to develop creativity, confidence, communication skills and critical thinking, whatever careers they eventually pursue. It is vital to the economic success of our country. The creative industries are one of the UK’s great success stories. They contribute almost £146 billion to our economy and employ 2.4 million people. They are globally competitive and increasingly important to the UK’s future prosperity. They also depend on a highly skilled workforce. Around two-thirds of creative workers hold degree-level qualifications, and Skills England predicts that most future growth in priority creative occupations will require qualifications at level 4 or above. Yet despite the demand for creative skills growing, the number of young people studying arts subjects has been through a marked decline. Since 2010, entries for arts subjects have declined dramatically. GCSE entries have fallen by 47%, while arts subjects’ share of A-level entries has fallen by more than a third. As the Campaign for the Arts reports, arts subjects now account for just one in 10 A-level entries—a record low. In 2010, that figure was close to one in six. Some of the steepest falls have been in subjects that were already in decline. Drama’s share of A-level entries has fallen by 58% since 2010. Music entries have more than halved, and they reached their lowest figure on record this year. Even art and design, the most popular arts subject, has fallen to its lowest ever share of A-level entries. These figures matter because they mean fewer opportunities for young people and, in future, a shrinking talent pipeline for one of our most successful sectors. What lies behind this decline? It reflects long-standing decisions about curriculum priorities, accountability measures and resource allocation. Since the introduction of the English baccalaureate alongside Progress 8, schools have been incentivised to prioritise subjects outside the arts. The Cultural Learning Alliance has described the result as a “denuded Arts education landscape”. Its annual scorecards have repeatedly highlighted the erosion of arts provision in state schools and argue that the narrowing of the curriculum options has contributed to the devaluation of creative subjects. But curriculum structure is not the only part of the problem. A recent report on creative subject choices from Cambridge University’s faculty of education found that many young people are actively discouraged from pursuing creative subjects. Students reported being steered away from creative options by teachers and parents, who viewed creative careers as risky or lacking credibility. As one young woman told the researchers: “I enjoyed things like art and media, but I did not choose them because I was advised to focus on subjects that were seen as more practical and better for future study and jobs”. The report concluded that, while interest in creative subjects is widely distributed and can be higher among disadvantaged groups, the resources, cultural capital and institutional support needed for young people to continue along creative pathways after the age of 16 are not equally available. Interest is not the barrier; opportunity is. It is wrong that a young person’s opportunities to study art, music or drama are narrowed because of their family circumstances, because they lack support or because they have been persuaded that creativity is somehow a less legitimate route to achievement than other forms of success. For meaningful choices to exist, schools must have the capacity for those subjects, and that brings me to teacher recruitment. Even where pupils want to study arts subjects, many schools increasingly struggle to provide them because of shortages of specialist teachers. We are facing a crisis in music teacher recruitment and broader shortages of specialist teachers across the arts. Research by Dr Anthony Anderson and Dr Adam Whittaker of Birmingham City University found that there were 280 vacancies for secondary arts teachers in 2024-25, compared with 110 vacancies in 2015-16. This increase in vacancies has occurred against a backdrop of almost half a million additional pupils in secondary schools. Dr Anderson and Dr Whittaker also found that, in the last 10 years, there has been a shift in what specialist arts teachers are teaching, away from key stages 4 and 5 and toward key stage 3. That means fewer opportunities for students to continue studying arts subjects at the point when they are choosing qualifications. In music alone, there are now nearly 900 fewer teachers at key stage 5 than there were 10 years ago, and the number of schools entering pupils for music qualifications has dropped from over 1,600 in 2012 to under 1,300 today. These workforce trends matter because they directly affect whether schools can offer arts qualifications at all. Young people clearly cannot choose subjects that their school no longer provides. There is an old argument that greater emphasis on the arts would somehow come at the expense of achievement in other subjects, but the evidence suggests the opposite. The Researching the Arts in Primary Schools report from the University of Nottingham concluded: “Commitment to the expressive arts does not come at the expense of other subject learning. The majority of the arts-rich schools we studied did at least as well as, if not better, than equivalent schools and schools in their local authority”. We have a world-leading creative sector that needs highly skilled workers. We have young people with an interest in studying the arts, but it has become harder for many of them to access an arts education. This matters for our economy, for opportunity and for fairness. I therefore want to end by asking my noble friend the Minister three questions. First, what steps are the Government taking to reverse the long-term decline in arts subjects being offered in state schools that I have outlined, and how can we persuade school leaders to ensure that creative subjects are valued alongside other disciplines? Secondly, what action are the Government taking to address the shortages of specialist arts and music teachers, particularly at key stages 4 and 5, where access to qualifications seems to be most at risk? Thirdly, how will the Government ensure that access to creative education is determined by interest and aspiration rather than by family circumstances, where the young people live or the school they attend?

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Baroness Bottomley of Nettlestone (Con)

    I congratulate the noble Baroness on her well-prepared and interesting opening speech, and I certainly look forward to the answers from the Minister. I also just needed to say how much I regret that the Chair is sitting as Chair of this Committee and not making a major contribution to the debate—I wonder whether we could prevail on her to do so later. There is a familiar saying attributed to William Butler Yeats: “Education is not the filling of a pail but the lighting of a fire”, and few things ignite that fire quite like music, drama, dance or art. I had the privilege to be Secretary of State for National Heritage when John Major’s National Lottery began to transform investment in Britain’s cultural institutions. Sir Ernest Hall, a great man, famously compared its contribution to that of the Medici family in Florence, burnishing our great national treasure houses. Yet we probably paid insufficient attention to nurturing the next generation of talent. The British Academy should be commended for its important work championing arts education. The research paints a troubling picture, with the proportion of GCSE entries in arts subjects falling from 7% in 2010 to just 5% in 2026. The academy is right to call for a broad, balanced and interconnected school curriculum, and that ambition should be within the reach of every child, as the noble Baroness was saying, whatever their background or circumstances. I particularly want to emphasise the enormous potential of philanthropy. Britain has a remarkable tradition of private generosity towards the arts. Should we not be more ambitious about directing that generosity towards arts education, particularly for disadvantaged communities? The BRIT School and East London Arts and Music demonstrate how industry investment, philanthropic generosity and public education can combine to nurture extraordinary talent, regardless of background. I hope the Minister can comment on BRIT North, purposely opening in Bradford, as there is a suggestion that its promised funding has now been withdrawn. The noble Baroness, Lady Hodge, introduced her constructive review of Arts Council England, and proposed a joint fund involving the Government, philanthropists and charitable institutions to strengthen cultural education. Can the Minister please update us on progress there? Philanthropy brings far more than money; it brings expertise, commitment and relationships, and it can transform young lives. We have invested magnificently in the buildings that house our cultural treasures; it is time to show equal ambition for the children and young people who will create the treasures of tomorrow.

    View contribution permalink →

  6. Baroness Featherstone (LD)

    I congratulate the noble Baroness on obtaining this debate. The decline in the number of young people taking arts subjects at GCSE and A-level is deeply concerning not just for the arts but for the future of our economy and the opportunities available to young people. We have seen a substantial fall in entries for subjects such as music, drama, and design and technology over the past decade, which is not surprising given the scant regard paid by Governments to our fantastically talented population. While there are a number of reasons for this, the impact of decisions made within schools about which subjects to offer, how they are funded and how they are valued has taken its toll. We need to distinguish between a lack of demand among pupils and a lack of opportunity because, if a school no longer offers music GCSE or cannot afford a specialist teacher, entries will inevitably fall, but that tells us very little about whether young people actually want to study the subject. As has been said, this matters particularly in state schools, because families who can afford private lessons, specialist tuition and extracurricular activities compensate for what is missing from the curriculum, but those who cannot are simply left without such opportunities. Our economic well-being is equally concerning, because Britain’s creative industries are among our great economic strengths. They contribute enormously to our national prosperity and they employ millions of people, but the skills that they require are rapidly changing. We can no longer think of creative education in terms of traditional art, music or drama, however important they are; we need young people entering the full range of creative disciplines—design, film, animation, digital media, games, music technology and the many areas where creativity and new technology increasingly converge. Artificial intelligence will undoubtedly change these industries, but it will also make human imagination, originality and creative judgment more important, not less so. If we want Britain to remain a world leader in these fields, we need to ensure that young people have the opportunity to develop those skills well before they reach university or enter employment. I welcome the Government’s latent recognition of the importance of creative education, but recognition alone will not reverse the decline. Schools face very real pressures on budgets, staffing and timetables so, when difficult choices have to be made, creative subjects are often the first to lose out. I therefore ask the Minister: what specific steps do the Government intend to take to increase actual entries at GCSE and A-level, rather than merely improve the place of art subjects within the curriculum? How will they ensure that state schools have the teachers, resources and incentives to make those subjects genuinely accessible? Ultimately, we cannot expect young people to choose subjects that they have never had a proper opportunity to study.

    View contribution permalink →

  7. Lord Hampton (CB)

    My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Keeley, for this debate, and look forward to us meeting again next week at the debate of the noble Baroness, Lady Caine of Kentish Town, on the creative industries. As ever, I declare my interest, in that I am a teacher of GCSE and A-level DT at a state school. I am also teaching food at the moment, much to the amusement of my wife. My son did art through to foundation level and my daughter is doing GCSE at the moment, so I have several dogs in this fight. The need for teaching outstanding art in state schools is easy. We need, as everyone has said, a teacher who is an expert in their subject and who loves it. We need space to work but also space to exhibit, and to inspire the next cohort. We need materials and a Department for Education that thinks that this is important. If we want teachers who know and love the subject, the best place to get them is the workplace. I got into teaching in my 50s via Schools Direct, which was the government scheme whereby the school employed you, the Government paid you and you got your university fees paid. Unfortunately, nowadays, that is open only to people who are already in schools to upskill them so that they can get their QTS. I just do not know how somebody who is not young can possibly afford to retrain as a teacher. If the arts teachers do not get bursaries, how are they going to pay their university fees and live for a year? So I have one question for the Minister: when are the Government going to reopen Schools Direct to all people in the workplace—to the career changers—and tap into the vast reservoir of a potential army of inspirational and creative teachers?

    View contribution permalink →

  8. Baroness Morris of Yardley (Lab)

    My Lords, I, too, thank the noble Baroness, Lady Keeley, for introducing this debate and giving us an opportunity to discuss this. There is a strange contradiction at the centre of any debate about young people and the creative arts. Outside schools, we have a vibrant, excellent, growing and glowing group of young people with immense talent who are practising arts wherever they are. Inside school, there is a decline in the number of hours that it is taught and the number of people taking exams. I cannot think of any other subject for which that is the case. If they do not teach physics in school, they are not going around doing physics outside of school—and the same can be true for any other subject. You might argue, “If they are doing it without school, what is the problem? We are world-leading in the creative industries. It is not as though what does not happen in school feeds to a paucity of expertise outside school”. But exams matter in the mix of things that are part of this debate. They matter, first, because they are a key to some routes to the creative industries that would not be available if you do not have a GCSE or A-level. They are the key to higher education, the conservatoires and some aspects of the creative industries. They are also key to answering the problem raised by the noble Lord, Lord Hampton: getting more teachers. If you look at the different parts of the creative arts and how much they reach their target in initial teacher training and recruitment, art and design do best. If you look at the number of children studying arts subjects, more study art and design than any of the other creative subjects. There is a direct link between the number of teachers we train and the number of students who do A-levels and GCSEs, so it does matter. More than that, it is a sign of the value that society places on this subject. If we did not worry whether maths entries were going down, we know what message that would give to the wider world. The same is true of arts subjects. It is also a worry because, even in the number of people doing exams, it is not equal among those people attending schools and the areas or sections of society they come from. Some 54% of schools in the most deprived areas have no GCSE entries. You are 30% less likely to take GCSEs if you are from a deprived background than are your peers. This matters, because it closes doors at that stage to so many people and the opportunities that they have. So my one question to the Minister is: is this a big issue on the DfE agenda? How high up the list of priorities is it? If it is not, we will just continue to have more debates like this. Despite all that, I still go to many schools where teachers do wondrous things. There are art displays on the walls and there is good music, and there will be coming up to Christmas. They do that in spite of the system and support we give them, not because of it, and that cannot be right.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. Lord Isaac (Lab)

    My Lords, I declare an interest as chair of the University of the Arts London. The pipeline into the university through schools is hugely important. I am not alone in suggesting that the decline in arts education in our state schools is deeply concerning. We have heard from my noble friend Lady Keeley about the significant decline in numbers over many years. It is a sad fact that many schools no longer offer GCSEs and A-levels in key creative subjects. Most troublingly, schools in our most deprived areas are the least likely to offer these opportunities. While recruitment to arts teaching has improved recently, as I understand it, too many pupils are still taught by non-specialist teachers. Every child, regardless of background, deserves access to a broad and balanced education in which creativity plays a central role. Creative education should not be an optional extra. I therefore urge the Government, when they publish their revised national curriculum, to take four steps: first, guarantee an entitlement to creative arts education through to at least key stage 3, but ideally to key stage 4, with opportunities to pursue creative subjects throughout a young person’s education; secondly, invest in recruiting and retaining specialist arts teachers, restore training bursaries for creative subjects and provide sustained multiyear funding, as the importance of resources mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Hampton, evidences; thirdly, ensure that teacher training and school leadership programmes recognise and reflect the evidence of the benefits of creative education; and fourthly, make tackling inequality of access a priority so that children from disadvantaged backgrounds are not denied the opportunities enjoyed by their more affluent peers. The new National Centre for Arts Education offers a valuable opportunity to reverse this decline. We must seize that opportunity. Creativity should be the right of every child, not a privilege determined by their postcode or family income. Creative education should be embedded in the national curriculum.

    View contribution permalink →

  10. Lord Doyle (Non-Afl)

    My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Keeley, for securing this debate. My starting point is that I believe all children and young people will benefit from school time spent on the arts, film, music and drama, regardless of whether they go on to make it one of their exam picks, let alone choose it as a career. Creative subjects should be for all in the same way in which we believe all children benefit from PE without expecting them to go on and do an exam in it. However, this debate is about how we get more young people not just enjoying the benefits of a creative education but selecting it as a GCSE and/or A-level. We have heard many sensible questions raised but I want to look at this from the perspective of the young person themselves. My core argument today is that we cannot expect young people to aspire to careers they have never encountered. When we talk about careers in the arts, inevitably it is the stars people think of first, and it is absolutely right to dream of that BAFTA or BRIT award. But go backstage at the Royal Opera House and you discover an extraordinary industrial operation. Yet, how many young people know these sorts of careers exist? How many teenagers interested in engineering, construction or technology would imagine that a theatre might be the place to offer them that future? That is why I welcome the work our cultural institutions are doing. Some of us were lucky enough to be at a presentation by the Royal Shakespeare Company here yesterday. The RSC and Dame Harriet Walter recently took “Julius Caesar” into secondary schools, combining professional performances with workshops going through all the roles behind production. Hearing from the young advocates of the scheme yesterday was moving. Sky Up Academy Studios introduces young people to the technical skills behind television, and the National Theatre has just launched a new nationwide programme, partnering with regional theatres, with the aim of reaching more than 100,000 young people through productions, workshops and roadshows. That is a good start, but my challenge to government is that every child, before choosing their GCSEs, should have the opportunity to encounter the creative industries first hand, regardless of where they live or what their family’s income is. What makes a 14 year-old excited enough to choose art, music or drama in the first place? We need to make the creative subjects feel relevant, exciting, aspirational and connected to real opportunities, so let us bring creative professionals into every secondary school. Give every pupil the chance to make something—a performance, recording, film or exhibition. That should be a national entitlement, delivered through regional partnerships between schools, cultural organisations and employers. Let us also engage parents, demonstrating that creative subjects can lead to serious careers where there are established apprenticeships and paid routes into creative employment. My ask of the Government is very simple: how can we ensure that we are showing that choosing creative subjects is rewarding for our young people, not just at school but for their futures?

    View contribution permalink →

  11. Baroness Bi (Lab)

    My Lords, I congratulate my noble friend on securing this debate in the week when we have had two iconic examples of British creative power, with the announcement of the new James Bond and the release of Grand Theft Auto VI. These are two examples of the global power of our creative industries, built on the imagination and, as others have said, resulting in a sector that is worth £146 billion and growing at a fast rate each year. I have never agreed with a utilitarian view of education which is focused purely on what jobs it should lead to, and which has led to a focus for decades purely on STEM subjects. I think we have underfocused on the human need for children to use their imagination and develop their maturity. However, with the advent of AI, it is become absolutely clear that knowing and processing information is no longer sufficient; what is needed is judgment, original thought and the ability to engage with people, and the arts help to foster that, whatever career you choose to take. I was struck by Professor Carl Benedikt Frey of Oxford University saying that highly talented people in the creative industries will be the irreplaceable superstars of the future while those who are in the middle will become squeezed by AI. Speaking as a lawyer, I can say that we are seeing that first hand. The Dickens approach to scriveners charging by the word has folded into the chargeable hour that we have relied on, but that is being completely challenged now, and what is becoming increasingly important is the trusted adviser. Some noble Lords will have seen reports in the press of rainmaker partners being lured away to other firms at salaries that some footballers would be envious of. Sadly, we have seen that resulting in the collapse of a once great firm just in the last couple of weeks. We need our future lawyers to be creative, understand nuance, have good judgment and be able to influence and engage with people. That means we have to treat the arts, which help to develop those skills, with the same respect and seriousness that we once reserved for STEM subjects. I am glad that the Government are committed to revitalising arts education through the forthcoming curriculum reforms. I hope the Minister appreciates that the number of people participating in the debate today shows how important this subject is and that it is necessary, not just for the well-being of our children but for the future health and prosperity of our nation.

    View contribution permalink →

  12. Lord Berkeley of Knighton (CB)

    My Lords, it is extremely worrying that A-level entries for certain arts subjects between 2022 and 2026 declined so dramatically. However, the problem, and we have heard this elsewhere, begins at an earlier stage. Most children are not going to suddenly switch to music and the arts if they only encounter them as teenagers. I am often asked about the perceived “difficulty” of modern music, and I point out that the answer lies in the exact opposite of the old adage, “familiarity breeds contempt”. Familiarity breeds love across the arts. Exposure to the arts needs to begin at primary school at assembly, where children should experience different music every day, and in communal singing. But here, as with later stages of education, there is an imbalance between the state system and the independent sector, despite the fact that around 93% of children attend state schools. There, they are likely to get a fraction of the music tuition available in the independent sector, so disadvantaged students are 39% less likely to take GCSE music. As both this and the last Government have acknowledged, this situation is partially due to a lack of teachers, so I wonder how the Minister can justify the slashing of music trainee bursaries when compared to those available for other subjects. In fact, these tables are really shocking in the way they appear to discriminate against music. The Government have talked about creating a centre of excellence, but this, I am afraid, is a bit like sticking a two-inch plaster on a gaping wound. Where will it be? How will it help areas disadvantaged by geography and poverty? Perhaps the Minister could enlighten us. Why does all this matter to us as a society? Music and the arts allow young people, at often turbulent moments in their development, an outlet, a means of creative expression. Secondly, our children are the next generation who will, one hopes, contribute to the creative industries and the acknowledged wealth, both cultural and financial, that they bring to our society and economy. In answer to the noble Baroness, Lady Morris, the mother of Sheku Kanneh-Mason told me that if her children were in the system now, they would not be where they are as musicians. That is a shocking statement.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. Lord John of Southwark (Lab)

    My Lords, in a world increasingly dominated by the current and future capabilities of artificial intelligence, we are sometimes reminded of its frailties—for example, with last week’s Microsoft outage, which left many of us quite pleased and relieved that we had a few hours where we did not have to constantly refresh our email inboxes. It should also serve as a reminder to us that nothing beats the wonder of actual human creativity, a live performance of a play or music, or seeing art, design or an object that has been created by the human imagination and skill. I strongly believe that the creative and artistic sector will not be a nice add-on for our future economy but will be central to that economy and to the growth of our human community. That is why I am delighted to be a trustee of the Old Vic Theatre, which I declare, and was pleased to attend, along with others, the joyful reception here yesterday organised by the Royal Shakespeare Company, where the Question in this timely debate brought by my noble friend Lady Keeley seemed to have such relevance, and where the brilliant actor Dame Harriet Walter made much the same point about the importance of human interaction. It is right that we should applaud the work of leading arts organisations such as the RSC and the Old Vic for their philanthropic work. They go above and beyond their remits of producing theatres to work and inspire children and young people about the possibilities of drama and careers in the arts, as well as giving those skills for life. But their work cruelly exposes the inadequacies of arts education within our current curriculum. We should not have to rely on the voluntary or third sector for our arts education. It cannot be right that, with individual budgets of nearly £8,500 per pupil, many schools are spending just £2 per year on arts materials and resources. If, as I firmly believe, the arts and creativity are to be the real area of growth for employment and our economy, our school system needs to place much greater priority on proper funding for these subjects. I congratulate the Government on establishing the National Centre for Arts Education, to which my noble friend Lord Isaac referred. I look forward with him to the forthcoming changes to the national curriculum and hope that the Government give culture and the arts the prominence they deserve. In closing, I ask the Minister to give us some reassurance in this regard.

    View contribution permalink →

  14. Baroness Caine of Kentish Town (Lab)

    My Lords, I, too, congratulate my noble friend Lady Keeley on securing another debate and her indefatigable leadership in pursuing opportunities to discuss this area. The national curriculum review was tasked with addressing the skills and aptitudes needed for young people’s futures in this fast-paced changing world, one where they consume, produce and watch content on screens constantly. However, the philosophical position informing the review—of evolution, not revolution—was taken literally and only those subject areas already delivered within the curriculum were addressed. Leading institutions wanting to prosecute the case for including film, media and TV studies were advised not to do so, because it would mean that another art subject would have to be taken out. As a result, film, media and TV studies at GCSE and A-level are available but have always stayed outside the curriculum and performance management measures, and remain so, despite being vital for media literacy, creative education and the skills that our future economy needs, not just for the creative industries but right across the economy. There are innumerable creative roles right across different sectors. There was no contextual assessment of their importance and no deep dive looking at the existing qualifications, and they are not included in the National Centre for Arts Education. In other words, they are in the weakest position of all, yet at the same time as a country we are seen as a global leader in all of those art forms. Some 50% of state schools deliver A-levels in these subjects across England, a figure which has come down by 36% since 2010. GCSEs are delivered in 27.6% of state-funded schools, but since 2010 entries have halved—it is only 5% at key stage 4. As others have noted, particularly in this area there is significant regional and local variation in coverage, with multiple postcodes right across the country with no access at all. There is a slightly better position for of level 3 technical qualifications, as 61% of state-funded secondary schools and 55% of all FE colleges deliver them. But—this is a really big “but”—with the introduction of one T-level in broadcast and digital media, which currently only has hundreds studying it, all current funding for the delivery of level 3 qualifications for screen is timetabled to be completely cut in 2027. It is welcome news that Minister Gould has announced the intent to launch a GCSE in creative media. However, does the Minister agree with me that the time is now right to take stock and review all the qualifications in this area within a strategic context, including the critical links to media literacy?

    View contribution permalink →

  15. The Earl of Clancarty (CB)

    My Lords, I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Keeley, on introducing this debate so well. If everything were rosy in the arts education garden, we would not have had the delivery last week of the open letter by Arts and Minds, which represents so many experts, to the Department for Education, asking for the Government to fulfil their commitment to restore the value of the arts in schools. As I said in the recent debate of the noble Baroness, Lady Featherstone, after years of the arts being diminished in schools, there will inevitably be an institutional bias—which the noble Baroness, Lady Keeley, touched on—alongside the practical obstacles that will take a lot to shift. The Government have a huge role to play in doing so. The recent Teacher Tapp surveys confirm the extent of the challenge. Only 7% of schools expect to increase time spent on creative subjects over the next two years. Meanwhile, 92% say a lack of funding has negatively affected arts provision, including facilities, and 45% of schools in the most deprived areas cannot offer even one art subject at GCSE or BTEC level because of the shortage of teachers. Bursaries for all art subjects need to be reintroduced. The previous Government introduced accountability measures with the express goal of cementing the status of academic subjects at the expense of the arts. The EBacc has gone but Progress 8—currently in limbo—and Attainment 8 are still with us; as they stand, they both give undue weight to the sciences. When will the Government report back on the future of these measures? I sincerely hope they have no future. Following comments made in the previous debate today on soil science, I note that PISA scores in England, and therefore the UK, do not look at performance in creative subjects. A whole area of our education is ignored through these scores. Young people with neurodivergent conditions are central to the Milburn review, although the current emphasis on NEETs and work is on retail and hospitality, and the emphasis on education only on technical education. The Government could usefully carry out their own research specifically into the potentially strong connections between NEETs with such conditions and aptitude for work in the creative sector, alongside the importance of arts education in enabling these opportunities. I look forward to hearing the Minister’s views on this. It is important that we do not forget the significant role of the arts pipeline in this respect, as well as for the wider creative employee and freelancer landscape.

    View contribution permalink →

  16. Lord Forbes of Newcastle (Lab)

    My Lords, I congratulate my noble friend Lady Keeley on securing such an important debate. Let me add a further statistic to the many remarkable statistics that noble Lords have shared so far: the proportion of students studying AS-levels in all subjects who qualify for free school meals is currently 16%, but for music AS-level it is 3.7%. That is another marked inequality, using the measure of free school meals, which highlights differential access to arts education in different schools in different parts of the country. The challenge is not simply to persuade more students to study arts and music; it is to introduce structural incentives that should encourage schools to prioritise subjects that would be counted within Progress 8, the English baccalaureate and performance measures. Therefore, in the spirit of constructive endeavour, I will suggest a number of effective ideas to improve participation without diluting academic excellence or creating significant additional costs. The Government could consider introducing an arts premium linked to school accountability measures. This would be a measurable creative performance score; schools could get recognition and funding for the proportion of students studying GCSE music, arts, drama, dance or design. They could get recognition for the proportion of students participating in ensembles, choirs or productions. This could also be considered a progress measure into post-16 education. We know that schools respond strongly to what is measured, and music entries for GCSE and A-level have fallen because incentives have directed endeavours elsewhere. Therefore, creating participation in published metrics is essential in changing the course. Secondly, the Government could consider creative school zones, particularly in disadvantaged areas. This would be a way of targeting areas with low cultural levels of participation and high levels of deprivation, recognising that talent is everywhere but opportunity is not. This could provide modest funding for schools in, for example, instruments, lessons, studio facilities, visiting artists and creative partnerships. Thirdly, I suggest the Government seriously consider introducing tax relief for cultural organisations, similar to theatre and orchestral tax reliefs, to support and incentivise outreach and schools’ participation in cultural professional artist programmes. We know that arts qualifications are symbolic of wider interest and participation in arts and culture. It is not just about the performers of the future but about the audiences of the future. Investment now will be rewarded by decades of growth in such an important sector for us. Culturally, arts and music, with all the associated personal and social benefits that they bring, would surely be a national endeavour worth fighting for.

    View contribution permalink →

  17. Lord Addington (LD)

    My Lords, as I listened to this debate, I was astounded by the degree of harmony that had broken out and by the fact that every original point I had has been picked off one by one. I will give just a few thoughts. When I look at GCSEs and A-levels, I am not that bothered by the figures, but I am particularly interested in the skills that come with the person who teaches them. If you are going to encourage people even to do this as a hobby, we need to remember what we have learned from sports—I think the noble Lord, Lord Doyle, mentioned this—which is that anybody who partakes in sports generally has better results in education. The same is true of anything else that gives them that degree of positiveness and that reassurance that opens them up to learning. It is about the fact that you can get somebody in there who knows what they are doing, even if it is only at the introductory level. That first step of any journey and the most difficult part—why not go to another cliché?—which is getting an introduction, means they will be open to taking it further. There are other points. I received the UK Music brief. If we are looking at music, teach people to play guitars first, not violins. It is culturally available to them. Drums are there. Make sure you have these things which talk to them properly. Many people get into sports—even other sports—from kicking a football around first. Make sure those steps are available and the transitions onwards are there. That will really help. You will get the positive feedback and a way forward. Make sure there is a way forward where you make it relevant to the lives of the people we are talking about. All noble Lords have said that, if you come from a better socioeconomic background, you are much more likely to do these things. You have to adapt this to where people are, not where you would like them to be. I hope that when the Minister responds—let us face it, I do not think that many in this debate will be bemoaning the decline in Progress 8 or the English baccalaureate, apart from possibly one—she will say how we make sure that people are enthused in these subjects and get the social benefits from them. That is the important bit. The exams come with it, and the people capable of doing that teaching are essential, but it is about making sure that people can have access. We have lots of new exams here, with V-levels and T-levels; I am waiting for the O-level to make a comeback. How are we going to make sure that these new exams are designed to get people enthused and working onwards? There are real economic benefits to be taken from this approach.

    View contribution permalink →

  18. Baroness Spielman (Con)

    My Lords, this is a valuable debate but time is brief. Arts and creative subjects are building blocks of individual fulfilment, economic success and civilisation itself, so it is right that in compulsory schooling every child should have a broad and rich curriculum, including in arts and creative subjects. Your Lordships can find me on record on this over many years. I have checked the source data. The good news is that art is in rude health in schools. GCSE entries dipped between 2000 and 2010, but they recovered and in 2026 were as strong as in 2000. I see art rooms everywhere in constant use, and we should celebrate that. Elsewhere, the picture is more mixed—by the way, some of the same trends are also visible in Scotland and Wales. In music and drama, factoring in the shift from GCSEs and A-levels into BTECs and similar programmes, the decline is smaller than many believe but still very real. It is design and technology that has really been hammered. In 2000, around two-thirds of students took it at GCSE; now it is under 15%. Despite what is so often asserted, most of that drop happened before the EBacc measure, not after it. This reflects serious errors made by the Labour Government back in 2004. They made both performance tables and inspection entirely blind to curriculum choices beyond English and maths. All subjects were deemed equal and no curriculum strand had any protection. Quality of curriculum and teaching did not matter, only the grades that students achieved. Creative subjects lost ground, mostly not to languages and humanities but to BTECs and similar, in subjects such as health and social care, sports science, business and enterprise. Key stage 3 was often cut right back, so students might never discover creative interests and strengths. It was not just arts and creative subjects that suffered; so too did science, humanities and languages, and children were the losers. In the intervening years, important improvements were made. Progress 8 and inspection changes surfaced the damage and improved the incentives. Qualifications were recalibrated against international benchmarks, bringing in real ambition for our children. But with the current Government’s headlong dash to reorient education towards early vocational specialisation, I am once again fearful for creative subjects and for the whole broad and balanced education that should be and is protected by the current national curriculum. So I ask the Minister to confirm four things: that there will be no dilution of curriculum expectations to age 18 in arts and creative subjects, or in any other subject specification to GCSE or A-level; that there will be no reduction in teaching time for core academic or creative subjects up to age 16; that the Government accept Professor Francis’s recommendation that Progress 8 already reflects an appropriate curriculum balance and should not be changed; and that, if the Government intend to change performance measures, they will publish their evidence to show that this will not harm the academic and other foundations on which all technical education and skills are built.

    View contribution permalink →

  19. Baroness in Waiting/Government Whip (Baroness Ramsey of Wall Heath) (Lab)

    My Lords, I seem to have made more notes than what is actually in my speech, so please bear with me and I will do my very best. I am grateful to my noble friend Lady Keeley for securing this debate and to all noble Lords who have contributed. I took a long-standing personal interest in arts education as a Back-Bencher, and I have a daughter who was fortunate enough to go to the BRIT School, mentioned by the noble Baroness, Lady Bottomley. As I have been involved in so many debates, it is a pleasure to see all the noble Lords in the Room, with their particular interests and areas of profound and deep expertise. Every young person, regardless of background, should have the opportunity to study and succeed in creative subjects, including GCSEs and A-levels. The arts enrich lives, develop confidence and communication, and nurture the talent on which our creative industries depend. Those industries contribute approximately £145 billion to the economy and have grown four times faster than the wider economy since 2010. The Government recognise concerns about arts provision and progression, and we are listening to teachers, school leaders and education providers in the creative sector as we build clearer, stronger qualifications and widen opportunity. The noble Baroness, Lady Featherstone, mentioned the curriculum. We are making important changes to the national curriculum in music, art and design, drama, and dance, so that more pupils are ready and inspired to continue studying these subjects. Our response to the Curriculum and Assessment Review committed to revitalising arts education, maintaining high standards in knowledge and skills, and recognising the value of creativity. A broad, balanced and ambitious education must combine strong foundations in literacy and numeracy with meaningful opportunities in the arts. This is not an either/or choice. We will shortly publish the draft national curriculum for consultation, with a final version next year and first teaching from September 2028. All academy-status schools will be required to teach the new national curriculum, strengthening the entitlement to arts education across state-funded schools. Consultation on the first tranche of GCSEs for teaching from September 2029 will follow shortly. Plans for subsequent GCSEs and A-levels will be set out in due course. On the point made by the noble Baroness, Lady Caine, the Government have not ruled out reform of GCSE and A-levels in film studies and media studies. The curriculum review focused on GCSEs and A-levels that are subjects in the curriculum. On school accountability, which was mentioned, in addition to our reforms to school performance measures, as part of Ofsted school inspections, inspectors expect schools to provide a broad, balanced and ambitious curriculum for pupils. Inspectors will also look to see that pupils are provided with a wide range of opportunities that broaden their experience and enable them to develop their talents and interests in areas such as the arts, music and sport. We have removed the EBacc performance measures mentioned by the noble Baroness, Lady Keeley, and others, which unnecessarily constrained subject choice. We will soon publish our response on changes to Progress 8 and Attainment 8, mentioned by my noble friend Lady Caine and the noble Baroness, Lady Spielman. A-levels remain a respected academic route into higher education and the creative industries. They offer opportunities in art and design, dance, drama and theatre, music, music technology, design and technology, and film studies. Uptake varies, but entries in art and design and in media and film have grown since 2019. The review found that A-levels generally work well and did not recommend significant reform. Our approach is evolution, not revolution, with updates where necessary to maintain coherence with revised GCSEs, with changes to AS-levels and A-levels in national curriculum subjects planned for first teaching in 2031 and 2032. Alongside A-levels and T-levels, we are developing V-levels to offer a clearer vocational pathway. I will write to the noble Lord, Lord Doyle, on the detail around backstage, as I do not have time in this speech. Some students know where they wish to specialise; others want to combine academic and vocational study or build their foundations at level 2 before progressing. We want a rigorous, coherent system that supports both choices. The review recommended a revised third pathway at level 3 alongside A-levels and T-levels. Our reforms will seek to provide breadth, clarity and strong progression into further study, training and opportunity. On school funding, mentioned by my noble friend Lord John and others, we are making significant investment in the core schools budget in the financial year 2026-27, with an extra £2.3 billion for schools. The funding that schools receive is not ring-fenced for any specific form of expenditure and it is for each school to determine how this money will be best used to support their individual circumstances. On teacher recruitment, we should also recognise the contribution of teachers. None of these ambitions can be realised without a skilled and motivated workforce, as mentioned by my noble friends Lady Morris and Lady Keeley and the noble Lord, Lord Hampton. Supporting teacher recruitment, retention and professional development within arts disciplines must remain an important priority if we are to secure long-term growth in participation and attainment. That is why we have committed to recruiting an additional 6,500 new expert teachers in secondary and special schools and in our colleges over the course of this Parliament. I will give specific answers in writing to the questions asked by the noble Lords, Lord Hampton and Lord Berkeley, about the detail of that. I turn to the National Centre for Arts Education, mentioned by my noble friends Lord Isaac and Lady Keeley. Curriculum reform must be matched by practical support. The newly established National Centre for Arts Education will improve the quality and equity of arts education across England, helping every child achieve and thrive. It will work nationally with a broad expert network across the country, rather than being centred on a single physical location. Its focus is art and design, music, drama and dance for pupils aged five to 16. Access to excellent teaching, a rich curriculum and meaningful enrichment should not depend on where a child lives or their family circumstances, as a number of noble Lords said. The National Centre for Arts Education is designed to address that problem. Through professional development, training and practical resources, the centre will support teachers and strengthen partnerships between schools and cultural organisations. It will also promote opportunities and careers to schools, families and young people, helping those with fewer opportunities to discover and pursue their talents. That goes to the point about fairness mentioned by a number of noble Lords, including the noble Baroness, Lady Featherstone. Arts education extends beyond qualifications. The enrichment framework published in June provides benchmarks, case studies and resources to help schools and colleges develop their offer. It draws on the work of organisations such as Arts Council England, the Royal Ballet and Opera and Into Film, recognising the contribution of cultural partners across the country. We are also investing £22.5 million over three years through the enrichment expansion programme to support up to 400 schools in areas facing the greatest disadvantage to develop youth-led, tailored provision. Our ambition is not simply to give pupils a chance to experience the arts but to inspire more of them to continue studying, achieve highly and see clear routes into further learning, training and rewarding careers—which so many noble Lords have said is important. My noble friend Lord Forbes asked about the Arts and Minds campaign. Many of its recommendations are already reflected in the Government’s commitment to revitalise arts in schools, including reviewing Progress 8. I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Bottomley, for mentioning the BRIT School. My youngest daughter had the great privilege of attending and is now at drama school—lucky her. I will give the noble Baroness some more details about BRIT School North, which has not been cancelled. We share the goal of enabling young people to develop their talents and pursue their ambitions. We recognise the strength of feeling about protecting high-quality progression routes, and will continue working closely with the sector as we take these reforms forward. I hope that noble Lords whose names I have not mentioned will recognise that I have answered their particular issues in my main speech. On anything else that was omitted, I will write to noble Lords. Through curriculum reform, clearer qualifications and practical support for teaching and enrichment, we are laying stronger foundations for creative opportunity. I thank again my noble friend Lady Keeley and all noble Lords who participated today for their contributions and their consistent advocacy for arts education, both in the House and outside it, and I look forward to continuing that dialogue.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5441479.