L

Lord Forbes of Newcastle (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

State Schools: GCSE and A-level Arts Subjects

Contribution

My Lords, I congratulate my noble friend Lady Keeley on securing such an important debate. Let me add a further statistic to the many remarkable statistics that noble Lords have shared so far: the proportion of students studying AS-levels in all subjects who qualify for free school meals is currently 16%, but for music AS-level it is 3.7%. That is another marked inequality, using the measure of free school meals, which highlights differential access to arts education in different schools in different parts of the country. The challenge is not simply to persuade more students to study arts and music; it is to introduce structural incentives that should encourage schools to prioritise subjects that would be counted within Progress 8, the English baccalaureate and performance measures. Therefore, in the spirit of constructive endeavour, I will suggest a number of effective ideas to improve participation without diluting academic excellence or creating significant additional costs. The Government could consider introducing an arts premium linked to school accountability measures. This would be a measurable creative performance score; schools could get recognition and funding for the proportion of students studying GCSE music, arts, drama, dance or design. They could get recognition for the proportion of students participating in ensembles, choirs or productions. This could also be considered a progress measure into post-16 education. We know that schools respond strongly to what is measured, and music entries for GCSE and A-level have fallen because incentives have directed endeavours elsewhere. Therefore, creating participation in published metrics is essential in changing the course. Secondly, the Government could consider creative school zones, particularly in disadvantaged areas. This would be a way of targeting areas with low cultural levels of participation and high levels of deprivation, recognising that talent is everywhere but opportunity is not. This could provide modest funding for schools in, for example, instruments, lessons, studio facilities, visiting artists and creative partnerships. Thirdly, I suggest the Government seriously consider introducing tax relief for cultural organisations, similar to theatre and orchestral tax reliefs, to support and incentivise outreach and schools’ participation in cultural professional artist programmes. We know that arts qualifications are symbolic of wider interest and participation in arts and culture. It is not just about the performers of the future but about the audiences of the future. Investment now will be rewarded by decades of growth in such an important sector for us. Culturally, arts and music, with all the associated personal and social benefits that they bring, would surely be a national endeavour worth fighting for.

More from Lord Forbes of Newcastle (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.