B

Baroness Spielman (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

State Schools: GCSE and A-level Arts Subjects

Contribution

My Lords, this is a valuable debate but time is brief. Arts and creative subjects are building blocks of individual fulfilment, economic success and civilisation itself, so it is right that in compulsory schooling every child should have a broad and rich curriculum, including in arts and creative subjects. Your Lordships can find me on record on this over many years. I have checked the source data. The good news is that art is in rude health in schools. GCSE entries dipped between 2000 and 2010, but they recovered and in 2026 were as strong as in 2000. I see art rooms everywhere in constant use, and we should celebrate that. Elsewhere, the picture is more mixed—by the way, some of the same trends are also visible in Scotland and Wales. In music and drama, factoring in the shift from GCSEs and A-levels into BTECs and similar programmes, the decline is smaller than many believe but still very real. It is design and technology that has really been hammered. In 2000, around two-thirds of students took it at GCSE; now it is under 15%. Despite what is so often asserted, most of that drop happened before the EBacc measure, not after it. This reflects serious errors made by the Labour Government back in 2004. They made both performance tables and inspection entirely blind to curriculum choices beyond English and maths. All subjects were deemed equal and no curriculum strand had any protection. Quality of curriculum and teaching did not matter, only the grades that students achieved. Creative subjects lost ground, mostly not to languages and humanities but to BTECs and similar, in subjects such as health and social care, sports science, business and enterprise. Key stage 3 was often cut right back, so students might never discover creative interests and strengths. It was not just arts and creative subjects that suffered; so too did science, humanities and languages, and children were the losers. In the intervening years, important improvements were made. Progress 8 and inspection changes surfaced the damage and improved the incentives. Qualifications were recalibrated against international benchmarks, bringing in real ambition for our children. But with the current Government’s headlong dash to reorient education towards early vocational specialisation, I am once again fearful for creative subjects and for the whole broad and balanced education that should be and is protected by the current national curriculum. So I ask the Minister to confirm four things: that there will be no dilution of curriculum expectations to age 18 in arts and creative subjects, or in any other subject specification to GCSE or A-level; that there will be no reduction in teaching time for core academic or creative subjects up to age 16; that the Government accept Professor Francis’s recommendation that Progress 8 already reflects an appropriate curriculum balance and should not be changed; and that, if the Government intend to change performance measures, they will publish their evidence to show that this will not harm the academic and other foundations on which all technical education and skills are built.

More from Baroness Spielman (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.