B

Baroness Keeley (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

State Schools: GCSE and A-level Arts Subjects

Contribution

My Lords, since the first Labour Arts Minister, Jennie Lee, through to our current Culture Secretary, Lisa Nandy, there has been a driving passion that all our children should be given the kind of education that used to be the monopoly of the privileged few. That principle remains as important today as it was in 1965. However, due to the education policies of the Conservative-led Government since 2010, for too many young people in state schools, an arts-rich education exists only for those whose parents can pay for extracurricular tuition. Arts education is not just about preparing future artists; it helps young people to develop creativity, confidence, communication skills and critical thinking, whatever careers they eventually pursue. It is vital to the economic success of our country. The creative industries are one of the UK’s great success stories. They contribute almost £146 billion to our economy and employ 2.4 million people. They are globally competitive and increasingly important to the UK’s future prosperity. They also depend on a highly skilled workforce. Around two-thirds of creative workers hold degree-level qualifications, and Skills England predicts that most future growth in priority creative occupations will require qualifications at level 4 or above. Yet despite the demand for creative skills growing, the number of young people studying arts subjects has been through a marked decline. Since 2010, entries for arts subjects have declined dramatically. GCSE entries have fallen by 47%, while arts subjects’ share of A-level entries has fallen by more than a third. As the Campaign for the Arts reports, arts subjects now account for just one in 10 A-level entries—a record low. In 2010, that figure was close to one in six. Some of the steepest falls have been in subjects that were already in decline. Drama’s share of A-level entries has fallen by 58% since 2010. Music entries have more than halved, and they reached their lowest figure on record this year. Even art and design, the most popular arts subject, has fallen to its lowest ever share of A-level entries. These figures matter because they mean fewer opportunities for young people and, in future, a shrinking talent pipeline for one of our most successful sectors. What lies behind this decline? It reflects long-standing decisions about curriculum priorities, accountability measures and resource allocation. Since the introduction of the English baccalaureate alongside Progress 8, schools have been incentivised to prioritise subjects outside the arts. The Cultural Learning Alliance has described the result as a “denuded Arts education landscape”. Its annual scorecards have repeatedly highlighted the erosion of arts provision in state schools and argue that the narrowing of the curriculum options has contributed to the devaluation of creative subjects. But curriculum structure is not the only part of the problem. A recent report on creative subject choices from Cambridge University’s faculty of education found that many young people are actively discouraged from pursuing creative subjects. Students reported being steered away from creative options by teachers and parents, who viewed creative careers as risky or lacking credibility. As one young woman told the researchers: “I enjoyed things like art and media, but I did not choose them because I was advised to focus on subjects that were seen as more practical and better for future study and jobs”. The report concluded that, while interest in creative subjects is widely distributed and can be higher among disadvantaged groups, the resources, cultural capital and institutional support needed for young people to continue along creative pathways after the age of 16 are not equally available. Interest is not the barrier; opportunity is. It is wrong that a young person’s opportunities to study art, music or drama are narrowed because of their family circumstances, because they lack support or because they have been persuaded that creativity is somehow a less legitimate route to achievement than other forms of success. For meaningful choices to exist, schools must have the capacity for those subjects, and that brings me to teacher recruitment. Even where pupils want to study arts subjects, many schools increasingly struggle to provide them because of shortages of specialist teachers. We are facing a crisis in music teacher recruitment and broader shortages of specialist teachers across the arts. Research by Dr Anthony Anderson and Dr Adam Whittaker of Birmingham City University found that there were 280 vacancies for secondary arts teachers in 2024-25, compared with 110 vacancies in 2015-16. This increase in vacancies has occurred against a backdrop of almost half a million additional pupils in secondary schools. Dr Anderson and Dr Whittaker also found that, in the last 10 years, there has been a shift in what specialist arts teachers are teaching, away from key stages 4 and 5 and toward key stage 3. That means fewer opportunities for students to continue studying arts subjects at the point when they are choosing qualifications. In music alone, there are now nearly 900 fewer teachers at key stage 5 than there were 10 years ago, and the number of schools entering pupils for music qualifications has dropped from over 1,600 in 2012 to under 1,300 today. These workforce trends matter because they directly affect whether schools can offer arts qualifications at all. Young people clearly cannot choose subjects that their school no longer provides. There is an old argument that greater emphasis on the arts would somehow come at the expense of achievement in other subjects, but the evidence suggests the opposite. The Researching the Arts in Primary Schools report from the University of Nottingham concluded: “Commitment to the expressive arts does not come at the expense of other subject learning. The majority of the arts-rich schools we studied did at least as well as, if not better, than equivalent schools and schools in their local authority”. We have a world-leading creative sector that needs highly skilled workers. We have young people with an interest in studying the arts, but it has become harder for many of them to access an arts education. This matters for our economy, for opportunity and for fairness. I therefore want to end by asking my noble friend the Minister three questions. First, what steps are the Government taking to reverse the long-term decline in arts subjects being offered in state schools that I have outlined, and how can we persuade school leaders to ensure that creative subjects are valued alongside other disciplines? Secondly, what action are the Government taking to address the shortages of specialist arts and music teachers, particularly at key stages 4 and 5, where access to qualifications seems to be most at risk? Thirdly, how will the Government ensure that access to creative education is determined by interest and aspiration rather than by family circumstances, where the young people live or the school they attend?

More from Baroness Keeley (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.