B

Baroness Morris of Yardley (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

State Schools: GCSE and A-level Arts Subjects

Contribution

My Lords, I, too, thank the noble Baroness, Lady Keeley, for introducing this debate and giving us an opportunity to discuss this. There is a strange contradiction at the centre of any debate about young people and the creative arts. Outside schools, we have a vibrant, excellent, growing and glowing group of young people with immense talent who are practising arts wherever they are. Inside school, there is a decline in the number of hours that it is taught and the number of people taking exams. I cannot think of any other subject for which that is the case. If they do not teach physics in school, they are not going around doing physics outside of school—and the same can be true for any other subject. You might argue, “If they are doing it without school, what is the problem? We are world-leading in the creative industries. It is not as though what does not happen in school feeds to a paucity of expertise outside school”. But exams matter in the mix of things that are part of this debate. They matter, first, because they are a key to some routes to the creative industries that would not be available if you do not have a GCSE or A-level. They are the key to higher education, the conservatoires and some aspects of the creative industries. They are also key to answering the problem raised by the noble Lord, Lord Hampton: getting more teachers. If you look at the different parts of the creative arts and how much they reach their target in initial teacher training and recruitment, art and design do best. If you look at the number of children studying arts subjects, more study art and design than any of the other creative subjects. There is a direct link between the number of teachers we train and the number of students who do A-levels and GCSEs, so it does matter. More than that, it is a sign of the value that society places on this subject. If we did not worry whether maths entries were going down, we know what message that would give to the wider world. The same is true of arts subjects. It is also a worry because, even in the number of people doing exams, it is not equal among those people attending schools and the areas or sections of society they come from. Some 54% of schools in the most deprived areas have no GCSE entries. You are 30% less likely to take GCSEs if you are from a deprived background than are your peers. This matters, because it closes doors at that stage to so many people and the opportunities that they have. So my one question to the Minister is: is this a big issue on the DfE agenda? How high up the list of priorities is it? If it is not, we will just continue to have more debates like this. Despite all that, I still go to many schools where teachers do wondrous things. There are art displays on the walls and there is good music, and there will be coming up to Christmas. They do that in spite of the system and support we give them, not because of it, and that cannot be right.

More from Baroness Morris of Yardley (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.