Contribution
My Lords, I begin with thanks to the British Society of Soil Science, the National Trust and the charity Buglife for their assistance in preparation for this debate. I also thank the noble Baroness, Lady Smith of Malvern, who gave me one starting point: her response yesterday to my Written Question about the current number of postgraduate soil science students. The Answer was that, in total, at UK HE providers, there are 45, of whom only 15 are on research courses—fifteen people. Two separate searches of UK job sites this year found more than 100 vacancies for soil scientists each time.
The other starting point was an event held last month by the British Society of Soil Science, an attempt to kick-start discussion about what can only be described as the collapse of soil science education and research in the UK. It was under Chatham House rules, so I cannot attribute this, but a sentence that stuck with me was, “We employed the last soil science PhD”. It is worth saying that many people’s work is focused on soils—I note particularly the work of academic geographers, anthropologists and regenerative farmers—but soil science brings particular understandings and approaches essential to all our futures in a particular way.
As the National Trust says, our understanding of soil, how it functions and the importance of its biology has changed significantly in the past 10 to 15 years. Nearly everything I was taught about soil science in an Australian agricultural science degree 40 years ago was wrong. We talk about it far more and have come to realise just how important soil is to food security, carbon storage and biodiversity. In fact, of course, it is biodiversity. A 2007 countryside survey estimated that just the top 8 cm of UK soil has 12.8 quadrillion invertebrates—before we even get to the fungi, bacteria, protozoa, algae and archaea. There are up to a billion organisms, maybe tens of thousands of species, in a healthy teaspoon of soil.
As Buglife explains, the technology has recently come a long way, particularly with eDNA monitoring tools, which could revolutionise the monitoring of soil fauna. However, that relies on good barcode libraries, which in turn depend on the collection and identification of species by experts. I could easily have made this debate instead about the collapse of biological taxonomy courses, which I was lamenting with the Royal Entomological Society this week.
We know that our soils are in a terrible state. If you want to count by pound value, one estimate suggests that the degradation of soils costs England and Wales £1.2 billion annually. Pesticides, veterinary medicines and intensive cultivation are all having significant impacts. Then add in the application of sewage sludge—which can introduce concentrated antibiotics and other pharmaceuticals, pesticides, PFAS, heavy metals and microplastics—and the impact of the climate emergency, including droughts, floods and storms.
What of the soil science university programmes that might be preparing students first to understand and then to tackle these pressing issues? Master’s programmes at Aberdeen, Cranfield and Edinburgh were recently closed or paused due to the university funding crisis. For undergraduates, only the BSc in plant and soil science at Aberdeen remains, although there were many courses at many universities only a few decades ago. The recent suspension of agriculture degree recruitment at the University of Nottingham further highlights the vulnerability of land-based education provision, reducing a key pathway through which graduates enter soil-related careers. This Government, like many Governments before them, are keen on apprenticeships. Cranfield organised a soil apprenticeship, but it was discontinued after one intake.
The state of research, unsurprisingly, reflects the state of funding. The Ag.Impact report, The State of Agricultural Research and Innovation, released just last month, found a halving in total UK funding in 2025 compared to the previous three years. Of UKRI-funded agricultural research, only 6% is focused on soils and water, with 42% for crops and 18% for livestock. Defra’s funding is also dominated by crops and livestock; “soils and water” gets just 9%. Yet farmers, growers and other land managers are crying out for more information, given that our understanding has so fundamentally transformed in the past couple of decades.
In January, I will again be at the Oxford Real Farming Conference, and I have no doubt that we will see many people coming down the road from the conference desperate for new insights, particularly into soils, and for sources of information that are not from people selling products. As the National Trust noted, the lacunae of unbiased research have created space for markets and products based on dubious or non-existent evidence. There are so many products—all too often backed by giant multinational companies—that are causing great harm to our soils, yet the only information available to farmers comes from the firms pushing those products.
I have focused up to now on higher education, because the collapse there is so obvious and deeply concerning, but we need the understanding of soils to be a basic, foundational part of everyone’s education. We need extensive practical further education about soils to equip our land-workers of the future. I included in the Question all levels of soil education, in the hope—which was not entirely successfully—of broadening participation. I suspect I know what the Minister has planned: a list saying that soils are mentioned in primary curriculums and in geography and science at secondary levels. However, I refer to the BSSS:
“Soil is rarely taught as a subject in its own right at primary or secondary level in England”.
According to the National Trust:
“Soil is only touched on lightly in GCSE and A-level Geology”.
Soil is what rocks turn into or what plants grow on, rather than the focus of attention; those subjects are not going to grab the attention of the next generation of soil scientists.
I also tabled a Written Question about the planned new natural history GCSE, which is an obvious opportunity to improve the teaching of soil science. The Answer I got was, in short: wait for the consultation. I hope to persuade the Government that they need to listen to submissions calling for a stand-alone soil science element, rather than the learning being spread across the study of habitats, ecosystems and environmental processes. After all, the whole aim of the course is—or should be—dirty boots, and understanding what is on those boots is foundational.
I circle back to where I started, to the answer from the noble Baroness, Lady Smith, to my Written Question. She concluded that the providers are autonomous, and provision and recruitment to those courses are matters for individual providers. The challenge I put to the Minister is that, simply and clearly, that is patently not good enough. We need far more people trained at all levels, including at postgraduate level, to tackle the challenges of our degraded, damaged and depleted soils, the foundations of our life.