Contribution
There was a Committee stage as well. The Green Party and I oppose the Bill, and I make no apology for situating it in the undeniable context of the extremely well-funded campaign, originating chiefly in America but felt around the world, against women’s right to reproductive healthcare. This is driven by disturbing anti-female ideology. As I said at the last Second Reading, this is a long-running campaign. The success of that campaign in the US has had awful impacts on the health of American women, as the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, outlined. Predictably, those who are subject to economic and social disadvantage suffer the most. The wealthy will always find a way to access abortion and, most usually, a safe method of abortion.
However, I want to be positive and note that this debate is happening in a context where we can celebrate real progress in the UK. Not only have we seen come into force a legal amendment that prevents women being criminalised for ending their own pregnancies, but it has also delivered pardons for about 150 women who were affected by that law. I note, however, that that law does not currently apply in Scotland. The Scottish Green Party is seeking to deliver in Scotland the same legal protection that women in England and Wales now have, as well as looking to a full decriminalisation of abortion so that it is treated like any other health procedure.
It is worth looking at the history of this. We are celebrating the end of something, so let us go back to the start. I credit the Guardian with reporting this. What has happened over the centuries? In 1862, just after the law that was often used against women having abortions came in, Fanny Worboys, a widow, was injured in a back-street abortion and then sentenced to three months in prison as a result. I tell that story as a way of saying, “Never again”. We have to keep moving forward, not backward as this Bill would take us. Just in the past week or so, we have seen some positive news in Hungary of significant potential improvements put forward by the Government to improve women’s access to reproductive healthcare.
This has been said before, but it always needs to be repeated: abortion is a very safe and effective procedure, and safer at all gestations than continuing a pregnancy to term. In one large-scale study in the US, the overall complication rate up to 24 weeks was 2.1% and major complications were at about 0.3%. This debate is also in the context of your Lordships’ House dealing with the Health Bill in some depth. I look forward to the comments of the noble Baroness, Lady Barker. She and I commented earlier this week about making sure that that Bill maintains and protects the crucial right to confidentiality and the long-standing right to anonymous sexual health treatment, including abortion. What this Bill asks for potentially threatens that. Sexual healthcare records should be accessible only with explicit opt-in consent on an episode-by-episode basis. As the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, said, this is particularly important as we are hearing quite regularly, I am afraid, reports of healthcare records being accessed in utterly inappropriate and very disturbing ways. Public confidence is absolutely crucial here: we want people to know that they have that right to privacy.
I will finally comment on the single patient record and how it interacts with this, which a number of noble Lords referred to. I declare an interest in that the Taiwanese Government funded this; I went to Taiwan, where we focused on health with the APPG on Taiwan. They have a single patient record in Taiwan, and they have a great deal of confidence in it. They were a bit surprised that we were so surprised. The way it works is that, if a medical professional is going to access your records, they essentially have to insert three cards into a machine: one is your healthcare card, one is the individual practitioner’s card and one is the institution’s card. The record cannot be accessed without those three cards. That shows one way in which a society has solved this problem. We have to solve this problem, but we have to keep confidentiality.