Contribution
My Lords, I draw the House’s attention to my interests in property and as a former chairman of three housing associations. I am not sure who to thank for winning a balloted debate like this; presumably, the democratic procedures of the House. I do thank them and I welcome this opportunity for a debate on social housing, although I am sorry to burden our Housing Minister when she is also coping with the Representation of the People Bill, but maybe she will be relieved to get back to social housing—a subject she knows well with her experience in Stevenage. On these Benches, we share her commitment. I am looking forward to the maiden speeches of the noble Lord, Lord Davey of Chalk Farm, and my noble friend Lord Petterson, and I wish them well. I thank all noble Lords for taking part in this debate.
I congratulate and thank the Government for all the initiatives they have been taking to build more social houses in difficult economic and financial circumstances. It takes time for new initiatives to show through and they deserve credit for starting them. Thanks to the Government’s new rules for investment expenditure, over £40 billion has been made available to the Social and Affordable Homes Programme 2026-36 to build 300,000 social and affordable homes with 180,000 for social rent. They have already awarded £9.6 billion, which should see over 70,000 social homes built.
The 10-year rent settlement gives financial strength to social housing providers to invest more securely. They have provided clarity for regulation after improvements in home standards and energy efficiency. We pay tribute to the Prime Minister’s initiative to end rough sleeping. We have been given a commitment through him for the biggest programme of social and council housebuilding since the post-war era. This should create a stable background and platform for the sustained growth of social housing over the next 10 years. Combined with the energy and new impetus of Homes England and the National Housing Bank across the country, we have the potential for progress and change in our housing supply.
As a nation, we have to make a significant inroad into reducing the numbers of single women and children, in particular, in temporary accommodation. The temporary accommodation bill to help 170,000 adults was £2.93 billion last year, an increase of 88% over the last five years. One in four councils is struggling to pay these bills. We know that increasing social housing will improve health and well-being for those who would otherwise be in insecure housing. It will help abate the growth of housing benefit, which grew from £21 billion a year to £39 billion under the last Government, as more people lacking social housing had to succumb to rising private sector rents. This investment in social housing should make a significant contribution to the nation’s economic growth. It will need strong cross-party support for success to be sustained and a fair economic wind, but it will deserve it, as this investment is long overdue.
Noble Lords might ask, if so much progress is being made, why have a debate at this time? There are four areas of concern that I wish to raise so that they do not become obstacles to what we need to achieve. There is the current dire state of the private housing market and the need for economic growth generally, and the important role social housing could now play in that. I am also concerned that we maintain a flexible and innovative approach to providing social housing and use what is working rather than resort to old formulas for the sake of it. There is also a need to address several long-term issues in the social housing sector now we are starting to build more social homes, and I hope to have time to get to those.
Let me start on the state of the housing market. We must be concerned about confidence in the housing market at the moment, which is dire and could get worse. I accept that government debt restrains freedom of action, and it is one reason why we want debt down, so we can respond better in a Keynesian way when times are tough. International uncertainty and the rise of interest rates have taken five-year mortgage rates back up to 5% from 1% just over five years ago. Rising construction costs over the past six years since Brexit are adding to the problem, with many development sites no longer viable as house prices fall. After a period of very low interest rates, which allowed asset prices to rise, some areas of the country are still expecting falls of 10% to 20% in house prices to come through in order to adapt to the high mortgage rates that are now likely to stay. This completely distorts the business model for developers, which have depended for too long on the rising value of their land holdings for their profitability.
National output in the last quarter grew by 0.9%, but the construction industry was down by 0.7%. Housing figures within those figures were even worse: private housing was down by 8.6% for the quarter and in September down by 12.9%, so the trend is getting worse. Savills is projecting that we will be building only 170,000 homes per year in the five years to 2029-30, on current trends. In reality, developers are becoming more risk averse and very selective about where they develop. Inevitably, this will slow the building of Section 106 social housing schemes. However, if growth in construction became positive, that would transform our national economic growth.
So what should the Government do? In the Budget, they added £1.5 billion to the social and affordable homes programme, but that is for council housing, so the impact will not be immediate. They also responded to building industry pressure and launched a £4.7 billion first home scheme to support 70,000 first-time buyers with equity loans. I admit to being very sceptical about those schemes, as they can simply increase house prices for first-time buyers while improving developers’ profits. The Government’s recent research is very patchy on the impact of past schemes, depending on local market conditions. Certainly, in London, it shows that they increase prices. So, despite the research, these schemes should be treated with caution.
It might therefore be more effective and timely for the Government to use their headroom for productive public sector investment to allow local authorities and housing associations to drive hard bargains with overextended housebuilders, such as Vistry, to buy homes for social rent to help them stay solvent and keep building. In the current climate, the Government need to encourage Homes England to allocate funds to social housing schemes that are shovel ready, to build the homes soonest and boost the construction sector.
From the recent £9.6 billion allocation in August, 73,617 social homes are envisaged, but there was scope for another 41,000 additional housing association homes if another £5 billion could be found. I have evidence from housing associations that were disappointed by the allocation. They had schemes with developers to start as soon as the funds were forthcoming. The construction sector desperately needs those schemes to help revive construction. With a construction downturn in play, addressing supply in a market where demand is strong for social housing must be the priority for any government contingency action until the private sector recovers.
There is some indication as well that Homes England held back funds on the recent August allocation to housing associations because it was waiting for councils to scale up for housing development. The capacity of councils to scale up is obviously a problem, as the Government are allocating special funds of over £40 million for them to do this. In my experience, it always takes longer for organisations to scale up, and there is not much benefit if they simply recruit personnel from housing associations. The quickest way for councils to make an impact is in direct partnership with housing associations, which have the proven capacity to build more now.
In 2025-26, housing associations built nearly 43,000 homes and their starts were 15% up. They are building nearly a quarter of all housing completions. Housing associations build 10 times more houses than councils currently do and, at their current rate of build, they could build more than 400,000 social homes over 10 years, surpassing the Government’s target of 300,000. The Government should be encouraging them to do even better and not hold them back. Every £1 in grants to housing associations is matched by £3 in private investment. It is less of a burden on public sector borrowing than council housing, and should be the focus in the short and medium term for pump-priming. Let us get the social housing built.
Before I conclude, I will refer briefly to several longer-term issues. To help create more funding for social housing, the Government must be prepared to use their new powers in the Planning and Infrastructure Act vigorously to free up land for social housing at much cheaper, low or no-hope value. Partnership working between councils, mayors, housing associations and developers will be crucial to scaling up regeneration work. Social housing must be a major component of housing supply. If we cannot achieve 1.5 million homes in this Parliament, which I accept, we can at least push to construct nearly 300,000 homes per annum after five years. Housing associations are not perfect. Building their capacity is as important as it is for councils; in reality, they are a long way ahead. They must not lose their local focus or social purpose. We must guard against large housing associations becoming remote from the communities they serve.
I end with three questions for the Minister. First, are the Government on top of contingency plans if the housing market worsens, and do they see social housing playing a major role in boosting the sector? Secondly, do the Government share the view that, although they want to boost council housing and building, the overriding objective is to deliver more social housing, from wherever it is sourced? Thirdly, do they recognise now the huge potential of housing associations to deliver more social housing than the government target is currently aiming for?