Contribution
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Berger, for her advocacy and powerful words. Nearly six years ago, I brought together a group of bereaved families who would later become the Bereaved Families for Online Safety. One evening, during the passage of the Online Safety Bill, following a meeting with the then Secretary of State, we went to a nearby restaurant, as many of the parents were meeting for the first time. I was gutted when I looked around the table and realised I was the only one present who had not lost a child. It was, as one parent put it, a club that no one wants to be a member of.
What those families had in common was not simply that they had lost a child; each of them had tried to raise the alarm. Between them, they had gone to tech companies, the police, the regulator and their children’s schools while their children were still alive. It was only after their children had died that they came to me. Time and again, in matters of online safety, those who identify the harm and know what needs to be done cannot get those with the power to act to do so.
It happened with Judy and Andy Thomas, who came to me after their daughter Frankie took her own life following exposure to suicide content on a school tablet. Their attempts to speak to someone at Instagram were repeatedly met with an automated message offering a memorial page, and they could not get a meeting with an Education Minister. I got Instagram to talk to them, and we saw a revolving door of Ministers, but the DfE is only now consulting to create filtering and monitoring standards, eight years after Frankie’s death.
It happened, as we have heard, with Ellen Roome, who called for coroner data preservation notices to be made automatic. This House successfully secured preservation powers two years earlier, but they were not being used. Recently, she told me that coroners are still not using the provisions as intended, a fact underlined by a call I had yesterday with a newly bereaved parent.
It happened to academics, who discovered that sexual predators were using Google Maps reviews of orphanages and children’s homes to identify and traffic children, but could not get the practice stopped. Incandescent with rage, I raised that issue directly with senior Google executives, and earlier this year they disabled those reviews worldwide.
It is happening now with AI chatbots. Earlier this year, I spoke to a parent whose son was being groomed by a chatbot, yet when she reported it to the police, they said they could not act without a human predator. When I phoned Ofcom, I got a letter back the following week that said, “We are not empowered to adjudicate on individual consumer concerns”. I have told Ofcom’s leadership that its response was wholly inadequate in purely human terms, but it is right in the letter of the law: they are not empowered to help individuals.
It should not be the unofficial work of an independent Peer to help parents in crisis; it should be a function of the state. While I do my best, help should come from someone who has appropriate legal standing and the resources to act on their behalf, not someone who can only cajole, threaten and plead. Those bereaved parents raised the alarm while there was still time to act, but they found that no one heeded their call. The same is true for teachers, health professionals and even children themselves. This is an emergency. As the noble Baroness, Lady Berger, eloquently set out, parents must have access to a legal remedy, not only after the event but in time to prevent it.
At the time of the Online Safety Bill, I advocated for an e-safety commissioner, and this year, during the passage of the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill and the Crime and Policing Bill, I tabled amendments that would have brought forward injunctive relief and a private right of action. The Minister will recall that he responded to one of those amendments by saying that
“the intention is understandable, but the amendment raises key practical and legal concerns”.—[Official Report, 18/3/26; col. 935.]
However, he did not set out what those concerns were, nor have the Government answered the desperate need of those caught in a trap of unresponsive companies and nowhere to go. Australia has an e-safety commissioner, the US has a private right of action, Ireland has both, and Canada is introducing both as we speak. I find it hard to believe that what they can do the UK cannot.
In her opening speech, the noble Baroness, Lady Berger, called for companies to publish information about their response to reports of harms to children. In supporting that call, I wish to tell the House a short story. Some years ago, I was asked by activist shareholders to present a motion at Meta’s annual shareholder meeting. The motion was that Meta publish the harms to children in its annual report—not do anything about them but simply publish the harms. Unexpectedly, the motion won the support of a little over 51% of independent shareholder votes, and, for a very short time—a matter of minutes—we were jubilant. However, Mark Zuckerberg’s preferential voting rights mean that he has control of over 60% of the votes, meaning that the wishes of other shareholders can be overridden. Moments later, the vote was washed away. At the time, Meta was in contact with approximately 3.2 billion people across the globe. One man had the ability to determine the rules of engagement for a vast proportion of the world’s population. It is against that concentration of power that we are expecting individual parents to protect their children.
An e-safety commissioner would be a permanent presence and a key advocate for citizens at all times. They could keep the regulator on their toes, see early signs of emerging harms, and combine front-line experience with briefing Ministers and officials. They would be a visible figure who is neither reshuffled nor replaced, and whose job is not to juggle the economic interests of the state with the safety and privacy of citizens. That evening, when I had pizza with the bereaved families, they told the Secretary of State that they had sought help while their children were still alive. All these years later, a parent in the same circumstances still has nowhere to turn.
This is not a series of tragedies; it is, and has been for many years, a failure of successive Governments, including the present one, to curb the excesses of a sector that has shown cynical disregard for the safety of children. I doubt that the Minister will announce a major policy initiative in response to a QSD, though I hope he will commit to taking the substance of the debate to the Secretary of State. However, in the absence of such an announcement, I challenge the Minister to tell the House what his Government are going to do today, right now, for parents who need somewhere to turn before their child is murdered, groomed, perpetrates an act of violence or commits suicide as a result of online activities. What advice would his Government have us give to the next parent whose child is in imminent danger when they call?