L

Lord Stevenson of Balmacara (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

Online Harm: Legal Remedies

Contribution

My Lords, I congratulate my noble friend on securing this debate and her speech, which was excellent, as indeed was the one we have just heard. Taken together, they make the case almost irresistibly for action to be taken this day, and moving forward, in ways that are surely the right things for this Government to take on. We know, as brought out from the figures in the Library report, that the internet has become central to most children’s lives. Some 88% of children aged three to seven, and almost 99% of all children aged eight to 17, go online. This includes playing online games, listening to music and using social media. While children’s engagement with the technologies is central to their social lives, the evidence suggests that they are being exposed to a wide range of harms, including cyber bullying, online sexual harms, sexual exploitation and online radicalisation. The results are completely awful and unacceptable for a society such as ours. The question of how users should be able to complain about online services was debated at length by the Joint Committee on the Online Safety Bill. The unanimous decision, as we have heard, was that there was need for an ombudsman to help individuals, and in particular, children, with complaints and obtaining redress. However, when the Bill reached us from the other place, the wording was far from satisfactory, as it simply asserted that parents and children must be provided with, “clear and accessible ways to report problems online to the service provider”. During Committee and Report stages in the Lords, we put considerable pressure on the Government to strengthen this approach and pushed strongly for an ombudsman service or similar. As we have heard, the Government resisted this approach. There is a case for the argument they were running, although to leave us with nothing was not the right result. In the event, during Report we struck a deal—or thought we had— with the then Government, so that in addition to ensuring that there would be strongly enforceable legal duties placed on Part 3 services to offer accessible, transparent and easy to use complaints procedures, and to provide for appropriate action to be taken in response to complaints, the Act’s provisions in this area would be the subject of a report to be published by Ofcom within two years of commencement, which, by my reckoning must be about now. When he comes to respond to the debate, I would be grateful if my noble friend the Minister could confirm my understanding of the situation, which is as follows. First, Ofcom will shortly be undertaking a report about Part 3 services’ reporting and complaints procedures, assessing the measures in use by providers of Part 3 services to report content and make complaints. Secondly, I hope he will confirm that this Ofcom report will take into account users’ and others’ experiences of those procedures, including how easy they are to use and how clear they are for reporting content and making complaints, as we have heard evidence that they are not working. Thirdly, can my noble friend please confirm that, in this report, Ofcom has a duty to provide advice to the Secretary of State about whether she should use the powers provided in the Act now to make regulations imposing an alternative dispute resolution duty on category 1 services, and that Ofcom may make wider recommendations about how the complaints and user redress provisions can be strengthened, and how users’ experiences with regard to complaints can be improved more broadly? From the arguments already made today by earlier speakers, which are irresistible, I suggest the time has come to introduce the alternative dispute resolution scheme in this area, and to do it quickly. I look forward to hearing from my noble friend.

More from Lord Stevenson of Balmacara (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.