Contribution
My Lords, I, too, am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Berger, both for organising this short debate and for her powerful speech.
This is a very important debate at a time when the Online Safety Act is being reevaluated. When the legislation was passing through this House, enormous efforts were made by noble Lords, some of whom are present in the Chamber now, to limit children’s exposure to harms. However, as technology moves on, and as gaps are appearing in the tech platforms’ ability to limit children’s exposure to harms, it is becoming clearer that a meaningful complaints mechanism needs to be incorporated into the Act. There needs to be a mandatory framework for users to be able to report complaints, a time limit for platforms to respond to the complaints and an appeals process for users who feel that their complaints have not been dealt with adequately.
New research has highlighted the concern of children and their parents about their ability to report harms they encounter on platforms. The most common types of harm relate to contact with strangers, encountering hate and coming across hateful speech. Part of the problem is that 47% of the children who encountered online harm thought that the complaints procedure was unclear, while others said there were too many steps to creating a report. Certainly, a full complaint to Meta can take up to nine clicks, including selecting from 17 categories of illegal content. Meta has said that a simple complaint can be made in only three steps. Nevertheless, pressure should be brought on it and other platforms to ensure that a full and effective complaints procedure is available for all users of all ages.
Besides the difficulty of reporting harms, many children say that they do not make reports because they do not know what happens after they report content or interference from other users. This reveals a lack of confidence that platforms will act on reports, and my noble friend Lady Kidron has given us a whole series of awful examples of complaints not being acted on. Users therefore feel that there is no point in following through with their complaint.
The research has also shown that children and their parents would like an explanation from the platform about how it made the decision when it responded to the complaint. Obviously, parents play an important role in helping children with their complaints. However, many still want the process to be made easier, including being able to complain on the child’s behalf. As the noble Baroness, Lady Berger, just said, there is currently no mechanism for doing that.
The Online Safety Act has a great lacuna in it, which other noble Lords have mentioned. Not only are users worried about reporting to the platforms but there needs to be an ultimate backstop for them to be able to complain directly to Ofcom or to an ombudsman if they feel they have had an unsatisfactory response to their complaint. Noble Lords have already brought attention to the Australian example of the eSafety Commissioner. In Australia, parents and guardians can take individual cases of serious cyber bullying to the eSafety Commissioner. If the material meets the legal threshold and is still online 48 hours after the report, the commissioner can issue a notice for the platform to remove the content.
During the debate on the Online Safety Act in this House, noble Lords ensured that, in Section 160, there was a provision for Ofcom to assess how many platforms handle reports and other complaints about the harms users were exposed to online. Once it is commenced, Ofcom has up to two years to report, and the Secretary of State has three months to respond. However, Section 160 is still awaiting commencement. When do the Government plan to put this provision into effect, and when will the Minister respond on plans to set up an independent backstop to ensure that users who feel their complaints are not addressed can report their concerns?
This debate is about complaints, but I will also raise a very worrying issue on the possibility of future harms. The Government are making huge progresses in amending the Online Safety Act to stop children being exposed to online harms, and their proposed social media ban could be very beneficial to so many families and children. However, its implementation must be carefully carried out to ensure that it does not create more harm to children.
An area of concern for so many campaigners and parents is ensuring that children are not exposed to unmediated livestreaming. Com groups—a collection of bad actors across the internet—move between platforms and continuously avoid detection through their rapid changes of platform. They have been responsible for the most horrific images and videos imaginable, livestreamed to an audience. This includes a sickening suicide, which was livestreamed to users across the world, and there are other instances of victims being encouraged to self-harm, watched by a live audience of all ages across the globe.
Many people, both inside and outside Parliament, have campaigned to ensure that this hideous functionality is very heavily regulated and that friction is built into the system. These controls were not in the first children’s code issued by Ofcom in 2025. Campaigners subsequently called for the introduction of these measures to mitigate online harms to children. One proposal was that live streaming for children should require an adult moderator to be present to supervise any livestreaming event. This is an eminently sensible safeguard to keep our children safe. There was hope that the measures would be included in Ofcom’s additional safety measures online, which have been long awaited, but when they were published on Monday, any measures to mitigate live streaming had been dropped. The reasoning was that the planned ban on social media for under-16s would stop all livestreaming to children, so the functionality would not need to be controlled.
That might be a sensible decision, as long as the ban on social media will affect 100% of under-16. However, that is not what happened in Australia. When the ban first came into effect, 60% of Australian children were getting around it. Now, the percentage of evaders has risen to 80%. We are told that this huge increase is because Australia does not have an effective age assurance system, so children can easily get around the ban by lying about their age to open an online account.
We are told that, in the UK, much more impressive age verification technologies, which have been rolled out across the country, will stop children getting onto social media sites once the ban is introduced. However, it is self-evident that nobody wants to have something they value taken away from them, especially teenagers, for whom social media is the main form of information and social interaction. They will move heaven and earth to get an older friend, older siblings or parents to help them evade the ban. When that happens, they will be exposed to unregulated livestreaming. I call on the Minister not only to limit the harms children are exposed to; we owe it to a generation of young people to protect them as effectively as we can from the horrors of the internet.