Contribution
My Lords, I am grateful to all noble Lords taking part this afternoon.
I want to begin with a scene that will play out in homes across this country tonight. It is 11 pm. A mother notices the light still on under her 14 year-old’s door. On his phone she finds a stranger threatening to send intimate images of her son to everyone he knows unless he pays up within the hour. She finds a feed telling her daughter how to hide her self-harm, or a chatbot that has spent weeks telling her child it is the only one who truly understands him or her. The mum does what she has been told to do. She reports it to the company on whose platform the harm presented. Back comes an automated response: “No violation found.” What does she do next? This is the question at the heart of this debate. Today, the honest answer is “very little”.
She is far from alone. A survey by Internet Matters of 3,000 children and parents found that 71% of children had experienced harm online, yet only around a third reported it. Of those who did, more than one in four heard nothing back at all. Some 82% of parents backed an independent route to complain. Parents are asking for somewhere to turn.
Ellen Roome knows that silence better than anyone. In April 2022, her son, Jools Sweeney, died at the age of 14. She wanted to understand what he had seen and done online before his death. The platforms would not help, so she became a campaigner. She gathered 126,000 signatures and brought her campaign to this Parliament. Jools’ law now means that a child’s data is preserved within five days of their death. In July, the High Court ordered a fresh inquest, more than four years on, after evidence Ellen herself uncovered. She is one of five British parents who have had to seek accountability in the courts of another country. Only last week, new duties came into force requiring platforms to explain how bereaved parents can request information about their child. I pay tribute to Ellen and every bereaved parent who has made that happen.
I ask noble Lords to notice what these hard-won reforms have in common. Every one of them has begun after a child has died. As Ellen says, data preservation is the first step; access and accountability must follow. My Question today is about what comes before: the hours when a child is in danger and a family is trying to stop the worst.
Let me be specific about what imminent harm looks like. I share this story with permission. Murray Dowey was 16 and lived in Dunblane. One evening in December 2023, he was contacted on Instagram by someone posing as a girl his own age. He was tricked into sharing an image and then blackmailed. His mother says he had been talking about going to the football the next day. He took his own life within hours. That is the speed of sextortion: from first message to crisis in a single evening. His parents are now suing Meta in Delaware, because there was nowhere here for them to go.
Then there is content that pushes children towards self-harm and suicide. Bereaved families spent months urging action against a pro-suicide forum linked to deaths here in the UK. In July, Ofcom concluded that the forum’s decision to block UK users was the fullest extent of what could be achieved under the Act, and yet young people in the UK were still accessing it. It took a fresh outcry from those families to push it further. If the regulator believes it has reached the limit of its powers, what chance does a terrified parent have?
There is a new frontier that we should be very concerned about. As the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron, reminded your Lordships’ House earlier this year, where a child is groomed or threatened by a chatbot, the police will not act,
“because there is no human perpetrator”.—[Official Report, 28/4/26; col. 1075.]
Where threats or self-harm fall below the criminal threshold, Ofcom has no role at all.
Let us be clear about what a parent or carer can do today. There is no individual right of action. The police will not act until a crime has been committed. Ofcom does not resolve individual complaints. The super-complaints regime cannot be used by individuals or about individual pieces of content. Only Ofcom can apply to a court to restrict a service. When harm is imminent, all a family can do is ask the platform, and hope.
Even organised families are turned away. Bereaved Families for Online Safety speaks for 28 parents. At an Ofcom lived-experience meeting, they were told their concerns would need to be raised through a charity or another organisation. If 28 bereaved parents acting together cannot find the door, what realistic hope does a single mother have at 11 pm?
A regime that takes children’s safety seriously needs three things. The first is injunctive relief: a fast, court-backed route to require a platform to act when a child faces imminent danger. We know that harm online moves in minutes. Our current remedies move in months, if they move at all.
The second is formal standing for parents, guardians and the organisations that act for them, so that families can speak for their own children rather than waiting for others to act. Rather than platforms simply responding with an automated “No violation found”, there should be urgent safeguarding reviews conducted by humans when parents report serious harm involving children.
The third is individual redress: an independent body for the family whose complaint to a platform has failed, so that parents can challenge those decisions, wherever possible, before it is too late. Underpinning all three, platforms should prioritise complaints involving children and publish standardised data on response times and outcomes. We know that what goes unmeasured cannot be held to account.
That brings me to an ombudsman, which many people before me in this place have argued for—for years—as did the Joint Committee on the Draft Online Safety Bill, in its unanimous report in December 2021. The Government’s reservation has been that individual complaints are complex and time-sensitive. I would gently say that this is precisely the case for a specialist body. The Financial Ombudsman Service has had statutory powers since 2001 and its decisions bind firms. In June, this Government confirmed that they will strengthen the Energy Ombudsman so that it can compel suppliers to pay compensation. If a customer in dispute over a gas bill deserves redress with teeth, a family whose child is in danger and facing harm deserves no less. In Australia, the eSafety Commissioner can order the removal of seriously harmful content targeting a child within 24 hours, and an ombudsman would help to do just that. Yet the Ofcom report on user redress, which could open the door to the establishment of an ombudsman, has been pushed back from 2028 to 2029. That is three more years of families asking the platforms, and hoping.
I ask my noble friend the Minister four questions. First, if a parent today finds that their child is in imminent danger online, to whom should they turn and what can that person do? Secondly, will the Government ensure that the statutory review of the Online Safety Act expressly considers injunctive relief, formal standing for families and individual redress? Thirdly, will they bring forward the work considering the creation of an ombudsman, rather than waiting until 2029? Fourthly, will they require platforms to publish how quickly they act on reports of harm involving children? I want us to stop any more children and young people dying from what happens online.