Hansard·Lords Chamber·Vol. 861

Sanitary and Phytosanitary Checks at EU Borders

Thursday, 19 November 2026

26 contributions17 members

Contributions

  1. Motion to Take Note

    View contribution permalink →

  2. Moved by

    View contribution permalink →

  3. Lord Lilley

    That this House takes note of international approaches to removing sanitary and phytosanitary checks at EU borders.

    View contribution permalink →

  4. Lord Lilley (Con)

    My Lords, it is a great privilege and highly opportune to have secured a debate on the SPS on the day before the UK-EU reset agreement is to be unveiled. I begin by declaring an interest as the owner of a smallholding in France, where I rear sheep and poultry and grow fruit. The trade and co-operation agreement which the UK reached with our continental neighbour and largest trading partner, the EU, is the closest, deepest and most comprehensive agreement the EU has with any country outside the European Economic Area. It is closer than the agreement between Canada and its continental neighbour, the USA. Even before Trump came along, no one in Canada ever suggested that it needed to align its laws with those of the US or enter a customs union to ensure growth. Although the TCA is a very good deal, it is not perfect; nothing in this fallen world is incapable of improvement. However, the only specific criticism the Government have ever identified is the SPS checks, delays and costs imposed by the EU on our agri-food exports. The Government are right to want to get rid of these, although to suggest that this could somehow kick-start our economy is absurd. Agriculture accounts for only 0.6% of our GDP, and our agri-food exports to the EU are only 1/10th of our agricultural production, so even if successful, and I hope it will be, this will not have any measurable effect on the overall growth of the UK economy. Even so, every little helps, so we can all agree that it would be good to have an agreement with the EU to remove unnecessary checks, delays and costs of trade in agricultural products. However, we already have such an agreement embracing the EU. It is called the WTO’s Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures. The agreement says that SPS measures “shall not be applied in a manner which would constitute a disguised restriction on international trade”— which is precisely how the EU uses them. Article 4 of the agreement says: “Members shall accept the sanitary or phytosanitary measures of other Members as equivalent, even if these measures differ from their own … if … its measures achieve the importing Member’s appropriate level of sanitary or phytosanitary protection”. Yet even though Britain’s regulations remain in large measure identical in most areas, including dairy, fish, eggs and red meat, the EU now subjects 100% of its imports of these products from Britain to paperwork checks, and 30% to physical checks at the border. By contrast, New Zealand reached a veterinary agreement with the EU, in conformity with the WTO SPS agreement, based on equivalence, not alignment. That agreement subjects only 2% of New Zealand’s animal product exports to the EU to physical inspection. Will the Minister explain why she and her colleagues never mention this agreement? Ministers are normally fierce exponents of the importance of adherence to international law, even when it is not in the UK’s interests; why do they not do so when it is in the UK’s interests? Presumably because it would be an embarrassment, and because they know that the WTO appellate body is inoperable, since successive American presidents of both parties have refused to nominate judges to it, so we cannot refer the EU to the WTO. Even though the EU incurs more complaints about violating SPS rules than any other member of the WTO, it simply ignores them. Even when the appellate body was operational and the EU lost cases, the EU simply refused to comply. In these circumstances, maybe it is reasonable simply to try pragmatically to achieve abolition of these illegal checks, delays and costs by negotiation. In theory, we have a very strong hand. The EU exports four or five times as many agri-foods to us as we do to it, so it is far more important for the EU to avoid the imposition of checks, delays and costs than it is for us. However, for the first four years after we left the EU, we did not impose on imports from the EU the checks it imposed on us. Why? I suspect because, initially, officials and Ministers opted for a quiet life, and because imposing those controls would have increased the cost of living, albeit only marginally. Indeed, when the Conservative Government decided to apply those checks belatedly, they claimed: “Our robust analysis has shown” that SPS checks on EU produce “will have minimal impact … just a 0.2 percentage point increase on food prices over the next three years”. Under pressure from the NFU, the last Government, in their last year, began to impose these controls. That would have put us in a strong negotiating position vis-à-vis the EU to reciprocally remove checks, delays and costs where our regulations are identical or equivalent. However, inexplicably, at the very point that the Labour Government needed this bargaining chip, they decided to dismantle these controls. Instead of seeking a New Zealand-style agreement based on equivalence, we left it to the EU to propose the terms for removing its checks and controls. Sensing the UK’s weakness, the EU demanded four things. First, the EU refused to open negotiations on the reset unless and until the UK agreed unconditionally not to increase our share of our fish from our waters over the next 12 years. The Government supinely signed up to that demand, so we are now legally committed to it, even if all other aspects of the reset negotiations come to nothing. The fishing industry estimates that this concession alone will cost it £500 million per annum in lost earnings—£6 billion over the period. Secondly, the EU insisted we must dynamically align with all EU SPS legislation. UK exports to the EU already conform to EU standards; they have to, just as exports to America have to conform to American standards. The impact of dynamic alignment will fall entirely on the more than 90% of farmers who do not export to the EU, but who will have to conform none the less to EU rules. It will also affect countless firms that process, package and market food within the UK. Defra has already published a list of 42 EU regulations and 34 directives, covering 18 different areas, which it says are “in scope of the agreement”. It says: “Businesses may need to take action to comply with these requirements”. The Orwellian introduction to that document says: “To cut red tape and costs for importing and exporting with the EU the UK will align with EU Sanitary and Phytosanitary (SPS) legislation; food and feed safety; and broader nutrition-related areas such as food supplements, fortified foods, food for specific groups, nutrition and health claims, and nutrition labelling; wider agri-food rules related to food labelling, organics, key agri-food marketing standards and compositional standards; as well as regulation of pesticides and biocides”. That is some simplification. Contrary to popular opinion, since we left, British rules have diverged from those of the EU and will have to be realigned. For example, we are now able to use the thousands of different combinations of plant protection products for plants in ways that are forbidden within the EU and will be forbidden here. These are products suitable for our warm, damp climate. According to the Andersen Consulting study, as a result, our growers will lose up to £810 million in revenue—a 7% to 11% hit to overall farm incomes. Use of the bovine TB vaccine, which has completed field trials in the UK, is forbidden under EU Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2023/361. Bovine TB costs our farms some £150 million per annum and involved slaughtering 48,000 cattle in 2025-26. Thanks to the freedoms given to us by Brexit, this Parliament, with the support of all major parties, legalised gene editing in this country. Since then, our agriscientists—not least those in Rothamsted Research, in my old constituency—have been developing crops that are resistant to insects and require less or no insecticide or herbicide, or less fertiliser, to the benefit of consumers, farmers and the environment. The Government hope that we will retain this freedom until the EU legislates to allow gene editing. Thereafter, we will be subject to whatever EU regulations are imposed in this area; they are always heavy-handed. We should remember three things. It is the ECJ, not legislatures within the EU, which ruled that gene editing was illegal. We will be subject to rulings of the ECJ. The EU is changing its legislation only because we were able to forge ahead thanks to Brexit. Now it is forced to copy us. Should we decide, as I hope we will, to license safely gene-modified crops, it would still be forbidden if we dynamically aligned with EU law. The fourth condition the EU imposed on us is that, having removed those costly checks and delays on trade in agricultural products across the channel, it must now apply all those checks on our food imports from the rest of the world. This is admitted deep in a government document which says: “Checks on imports from the rest of the world will remain, and UK check rates will align with those applied by the EU”. It gives the number of the relevant EU regulation. So precisely the costs which we are going to remove on our trade in food with the EU we are going to impose on our trade in food with the rest of the world. Will the Minister confirm that this is the case? Everybody—apart from the Government—who has tried to cost this proposed SPS deal, let alone the additional costs of electricity, emissions trading schemes, carbon border tariffs, Erasmus, student loans and youth mobility, has concluded that it will have a large negative cost. The Growth Commission, for example, puts the SPS costs alone at more than £1,000 per person in this country up to 2036, and £74 billion off our GDP in this period. How did the Government come to negotiate such a one-sided agreement? First, although I normally do not comment on the abilities of Ministers, there is no single Minister in the Cabinet who has ever negotiated anything, in business or in a trade union. Former Labour Governments had formidable negotiators who came up through the unions, but this Government do not have this. Secondly, the Government have boxed themselves in by declaring that a deal—any deal, with no specifications—with the EU would be good for Britain and essential to boosting our growth. This means that they could not walk away from a deal. Thirdly, they failed to set out our asks and work out our red lines. They left it open to the EU to set the agenda, which it duly did in its own interests, for which one cannot blame them. Fourthly, the Government assumed that if we made unilateral concessions, such as giving up £6 billion-worth of fish, the EU would reciprocate. This is not how the world works—still less the EU. Finally, the Government had no best alternative to no deal, yet, on their own calculations, the SPS checks and paperwork costs to our exporters have amounted to £210 million over three years—£70 million per annum. It would have been cheaper simply to have subvented that cost and avoided accepting costs amounting to billions of pounds per annum of the total reset package. I am sorry that the noble Lord, Lord Kerr, is not taking part in this debate. No one is a more committed Europhile than he. The Government should have listened to his wise words. He said of the common understanding on which this negotiation is being completed tomorrow that the UK negotiators “suffer from a degree of timidity in what we are putting forward, and the other side suffers from a bit of excessive ambition. I do not think we should be paying contributions into the EU budget … or that it is right to try to charge us for integration into the EU electricity market. These things are a common benefit—they suit both sides—so why should we pay? ”—[ Official Report , 26/2/26; col. 777.] Perhaps the Minister could tell us why we should pay for getting nothing.

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Baroness Sarpong (Lab) (Maiden Speech)

    My Lords, I am truly honoured to address noble Lords and noble Baronesses across the House for the first time. I thank all the staff for all their care in looking after me since I have been here. I give special thanks to the doorkeepers, clerks, catering staff, librarians, Black Rod, Garter Principal King of Arms and anyone else whom I might have missed. They have all treated me with such kindness, care and, most of all, patience. I thank my supporters, the noble Baroness, Lady Amos, and the noble Lord, Lord Alli—two long-standing Members of this House who have been my friends and mentors for more than two decades. I also thank my noble friend Lady Smith of Basildon, the Leader of the House, and my noble friend Lord Kennedy of Southwark, the Chief Whip, for making me feel so valued on these Labour Benches. Speaking of Benches, I have always been a bridge-builder, so much so that, in my second week, I accidentally sat with the Cross-Benchers. I must say that they were very friendly indeed. In fact, I thank my noble friends—I mean, noble Lords—for so warmly welcoming me into their ranks two weeks after I had become a Labour Peer. I can reassure my actual noble friends that I have no plans to defect. I also congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, on securing this important debate. First, I will say a little about how I come to stand here after almost 30 years in broadcast media, advocacy, campaigning, and now as an author and entrepreneur. My story began in the East End of London—in Walthamstow, to be precise. An internship at Kiss FM at the age of 16 changed my life. Walthamstow to Westminster might sound like a straightforward Tube ride but, in terms of life’s predictable social mobility outcomes, to borrow Barack Obama’s saying, it is indeed an improbable journey. That is why social mobility matters so deeply to me. It is personal. Throughout my career, I have championed disadvantaged talent and worked to tackle discrimination. I have worked alongside organisations such as the SHINE charity of the noble Lord, Lord O’Neill, the Social Mobility Commission alongside Alan Milburn, the King’s Trust, the Amos Bursary, founded by the noble Baroness, Lady Amos, and many others. The task has always been to ensure that where somebody starts does not determine where they finish. From radio, I moved to TV, fronting Channel 4’s flagship youth show “T4”. I persuaded my bosses at the time that young people deserved politics and social issues with their entertainment. Some of my biggest highlights include hosting Nelson Mandela’s Make Poverty History launch in Trafalgar Square and his 90th birthday concert in Hyde Park. Both were reminders of how a platform can serve a purpose. Alongside all this, in the background, I was always campaigning for my beloved Labour Party. I was therefore humbled to learn from Garter that the last noble Lord to hold the Walthamstow title was my political idol, Clement Attlee, whose Government built the post-war social contract that still underpins fairness in Britain today. Throughout my political career, I was fortunate enough to be mentored by Baroness Margaret McDonagh, a friend whose passing is as much a personal loss to me as I believe it is to your Lordships’ House. Let me turn to the subject of the debate. I am sure that the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, will be delighted to learn that I served on the board of the remain campaign. I believe that Britain does best when we work closely with our European neighbours. While I of course accept the referendum result, aligning with EU food standards is in both our and the EU’s interests. Tomorrow, at the second UK-EU summit, the Government hope to conclude the SPS agreement. Dynamic alignment will cut red tape and costs for our SMEs, saving them around £200 on every shipment. The Government also estimate that the agreement could add up to £5.1 billion a year to our economy in the long run. Perhaps most importantly, it will help to keep the food on British plates safe. I return to where I started: the privilege of being a Member of this House. In 2019, the noble Lord, Lord Hall, appointed me as the BBC’s first ever global director of creative diversity, making me the first Black woman to sit on the institution’s executive committee. I hope that this, my five years on the board of the British Fashion Council and now also a Tate trustee will enable me to add my expertise to debates on the contribution of the creative industry to Britain’s GDP. The connection between creativity and commerce brings me to Africa, a continent that will be central to my work here. Tomorrow is the UN Africa Industrialisation Day. I am sure that noble Lords will be pleased to know that I am wearing British-Sierra Leonean brand LABRUM London, a firm favourite of His Majesty the King and the rapper Little Simz, who I am sure noble Lords are all big fans of. Africa is rising. According to UN population data, by 2030, over 40% of the world’s youth will be African. Are we sufficiently engaged with this opportunity? I fear not—but our competitors certainly are. Both Russia and China are investing heavily across the continent and building important alliances. We must boldly see Africa through the possibilities of the future without turning away from the challenges of the past. That is why I welcome the comments of former Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and, more recently, Prime Minister Burnham and His Majesty on this painful history. Reparatory justice requires serious engagement, especially if we wish Britain to retain its moral leadership on the world stage. However, while that debate goes on, the one thing we can all agree on is that trade builds trust. Africa’s industrial century has begun, and missing out could be one of the UK’s costliest mistakes. Before I close, I do not take this moment lightly. As I stand here, I am reminded of a photograph I have of my grandmother on the first day she arrived here in the UK in the late 1950s. In that picture, she is standing alone somewhere in London, still dressed for the Ghanaian sun and awkwardly trying to adjust to the British cold. My grandmother was a trailblazer and achieved many things at a time when not much was expected from women like her. Even so, I doubt very much that she could have ever imagined a moment like this. When I think of my grandmother, I am also reminded of one of my favourite poems, “Our Grandmothers”, by the late, great Dr Maya Angelou, who I had the pleasure of knowing while she was alive. In that poem, she writes: “I come as one, but I stand as 10,000”. That powerful line pays homage to the ancestors, to those who came before, those whose shoulders we stand on, and those whom I will think of every day that I am in this House. I love this country, and I know that your Lordships do too. I know we are committed to doing what is best for Britain. We might not always agree on how we get there—in fact, most of the time, we will not even agree on what that is—but in the days, weeks, months and years to come, I look forward to trying. Thank you.

    View contribution permalink →

  6. Baroness Chapman of Darlington (Lab)

    My Lords, it is a real delight to follow such an incredible, inspiring maiden speech from my new noble friend Lady Sarpong. You are so welcome here. We are thrilled that you are joining us on these Benches and we really cannot wait to hear your contributions because, if that speech is anything to go by, they are going to be magnificent. When I knew that I would be following my new noble friend, I had a little look at what she had done previously. When she was being introduced, I was in the Chamber and I thought, “I know that face. I’ve seen that woman before. Is she from local government?” Then I remembered that you had been at the Hay Festival a couple of years ago. You have written several books, which you modestly did not talk about. I went to see you because you had written a book about Una Marson. I was the Minister for the Caribbean at the time. Una was a trailblazing creative TV executive from Jamaica. At the time, we were just appointing a new head of mission in Jamaica, Alicia Herbert, who is the first woman of Caribbean heritage to take up that post. I bought her a copy of your book and gave it to her. It is now with her in Kingston. So, I remembered you and I was very pleased to see that you were joining our Benches here. The second little bit of common ground I noticed was the connection with Alan Milburn. I have known Alan Milburn since I was 15 years old—he would not thank me for noting that. I worked with him from 1997 for about 10 years. You cannot get away from the guy at the moment. He is absolutely everywhere. He has done a fantastic piece of work. I was very pleased to see that you have that connection too—I know that I should not be saying “you”; I apologise to noble Lords, but my new friend is sitting right in front of me. On my noble friend Lady Sarpong’s comments about Africa, I could not agree more. Africa is a place of opportunity, creativity, vibrancy, youth and dynamism. It is a place where we ought to be encouraging far more investment from this country. The growth in African economies is something that investors here in Europe and in America are not sufficiently taking advantage of. It is good that the Government are trying to do what they can to enable that to happen at greater scale. That is what will really make the difference in opportunities, health and education, particularly for women and girls, in many countries across Africa. It is wonderful that that experience is being brought to this place. Obviously, I have never met Maya Angelou or Nelson Mandela and have never been a presenter on a very trendy Channel 4 kids’ programme, or any of those things. I certainly have not had the honour of this one thing that my noble friend Lady Sarpong was treated to, which I saw on Wikipedia: namely, Elton John rewriting the words to “Your Song”. I think it was a shared joke, or maybe it was a particular event, I do not know; I would love to know the story behind it. He rewrote the words to say: “I can tell everybody I am June Sarpong”. Obviously, he sang it far better than I just did. She is incredibly welcome, and I really cannot wait to hear more from my new noble friend. I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, for enabling us to have all this out again. We have had these discussions on topics of peppers, tomatoes, washing machines, seed potatoes and various other things over the years. This is a chance to have these discussions in the round. My noble friend Lady Sarpong will have to use all those bridge-building skills that she referred to if she is going to try to bring us all together. This is a good time to have the debate, as the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, said, because we have the agreement tomorrow and I think there is a well-developed understanding of what will be in it. There is a point of tension that we always come back to when we talk about these things. On the one hand, there are noble Lords who are very concerned about sovereignty and the UK’s ability to make its own rules—I completely understand and respect that, and I know that that is felt keenly and strongly. On the other hand, there is the need to practically get on with it and make life easier for exporters. Where you sit on that line varies across the House. We are getting to a place now where the Government are just getting on with it and making some decisions and coming to agreements, which may be further to one side of that equation than some noble Lords would like to see, but I think that is the right thing to do and I will explain why. The critiques that we hear are quite familiar to us now, and I am not going to repeat them. The noble Lord, Lord Lilley, made his case incredibly well. I do not see this at all as any kind of surrender of sovereignty; I see it as exercising our ability to make a choice in the interests of UK exporters. Farmers and exporters do not all agree, and farmers who do not make produce for export will feel that they now have an additional set of considerations to bear in mind. That is true. There are always some things that are better than others for different people in these situations, but on balance it is the right thing. Many of them have been completely clear that they are not happy with the existing arrangements because of the time it takes and the regulatory burden. I completely accept that it would be great if the EU just said, “You know what? We don’t need to do all this”, but it is its right to insist on the measures that it wants on goods that are imported into its economic area. That is what these things are all about.

    View contribution permalink →

  7. Lord Lilley (Con)

    Is the noble Baroness saying that it is the EU’s right to breach an agreement that it entered into—the WTO SPS agreement?

    View contribution permalink →

  8. Baroness Chapman of Darlington (Lab)

    The EU has the right to determine what checks it wishes to have on its border. The noble Lord may not think it is right to want to do that, but it has that ability, and the proof that it has that ability is that it is exercising it right now. We might prefer that the EU took a different choice, but that is the choice it has taken, and we have to deal with reality. We cannot deal with the world as we wish it to be; we have to deal with the situation that we, and more importantly our producers and exporters, are in. There are delays, it is taking time and it is an administrative burden on their businesses. Veterinary checks are £200 a go, and it is not the right, responsible thing for a Government to allow that to continue without attempting to improve the situation. Since Brexit, services have done quite well. There is lots of evidence, particularly on financial services, that things are going much better. But this issue with goods and SPS is something that, from recollection, we had in our manifesto that we would attempt to get an agreement on. Most people would agree that a fix of some sort is needed. Critics always say that there are better options. Usually, they are referring to countries a very long way away or with much smaller flows, such as New Zealand, Canada and the US—places that really are not comparable. We have a land border with the EU where we do not want posts, guns and checks and all the things that you have on the US-Canada border. Those of us who have been to see the checks they impose would not want to see those sorts of things on our soil. The truth is that exporters are already following EU rules because they have to. The only difference now is that they will not have to pay with their time and their money for the privilege of doing so. In a sense, we are achieving what the EU told us we must not do, which is cherry picking. We have an agreement on something that we feel is in our best interests, after the EU spent a long time telling previous Governments that that was not going to be possible. This is all about us having the freedom to choose; it is a rational exercise of our sovereignty. Why would we want to maintain a separate, duplicate set of standards and rules that are 99% identical to Europe’s anyway, if it results in border checks, costs and delays? I hear the point about gene editing. I think I heard the Minister call this the ability to shape decisions, although we would not be at the table because we left. We will not be there to have the votes and vetoes that we may have had in the past, but we have the ability to shape decisions. The EU will have to consider the impact on the entirety of the market area, which will include the United Kingdom, for these goods, when it makes decisions in the future. There will be benefits and disadvantages at that point, and we will be able to use our influence. I have some confidence in our Diplomatic Service’s ability to do that. The bigger picture here is that we are in a volatile world, supply chains are fragile, food security is national security and trading seamlessly with our nearest neighbours strengthens our security and our resilience against global shocks—that is where we are in reality. Much as I respect, understand and have heard many times arguments from the noble Lord and others to the contrary, I am very pleased that the Government have got on with it. It is a choice that any proud, independent nation should be very glad to make.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. Lord O'Neill of Gatley (CB)

    My Lords, what a wonderful honour it is for me also to respond to the noble Baroness’s maiden speech. Needless to say, June, you did yourself, your gazillion friends and followers and, of course, your beloved grandmother proud. We met by chance on a delayed Heathrow flight back in 2003, when we happened to be sitting next to each other on a plane stuck on the tarmac due to the fog. In those days, people used to fly to Manchester because the trains were so bad. The delay was quite long, and I kept wondering who this larger-than-life character next to me was, chattering away endlessly to her colleague. It seemed like they might have been involved in music or media or something a bit glamorous. At the time, I was deep into my rather duller life as a partner and chief economist at Goldman Sachs, and this was a somewhat welcome distraction. After a while, I plucked up the courage to ask them what they did. I confess that I had never heard of June or T4, but I recall the noble Baroness suggesting that perhaps I should mention our meeting to my kids when I landed at Ringway, which I did, and they were truly excited. I immediately thought of an opportunity for the children’s educational charity, Shine, which I had co-founded just under three years earlier, and boldly asked June to consider becoming a patron. Luckily for us, she did, and I am delighted to say that she remains so some 23 years later. I remember fondly those earliest days when June would happily give up some of her Saturdays to go into some of the most challenging schools in London to chat to the kids from our programmes. The excitement among them was palpable. Who would have dreamed that, 23 years later, the two of us would be in this place? It is a delight for me and all noble Lords, as the noble Baroness has already heard, to have her enlighten this place with her brightness and wisdom. We welcome the noble Baroness. I am not going to address the direct issue of the EU regulations and our relationship; I apologise, and I will try to be brief. Having had the fortune of having a sneak preview of the noble Baroness’s maiden speech, I wanted, in that spirit, to also talk a bit about Africa and its potential. Later that year when we first met was the first projection that I ever saw with my colleagues of what the world might look like in 2050. This was less than two years after I had first written a paper entitled Building Better Global Economic BRICs —the “s” being a small “s” for the plural and not for South Africa, which, of course, became a member of the political club later that decade. A week on Monday, 30 November to be precise, is the 25th anniversary of that day. In the build-up to it, earlier this year I jointly set up a policy platform to try to use this moment to push for a recovery in smart, genuinely global governance and problem solving and get it back on a positive track. Many still do not realise that that was the topic of my initial paper—it had nothing to do with investment themes—along with the need to bring in rising emerging nations and give them a more representative voice. This is what bricsplusthinking.org, a not-for-profit organisation, is all about. We operate by publishing short policy papers from leading academics around the world. In addition, we are also going to publish our own proprietary 2050-style projections for the world, and these will come very shortly. The reason I say all this is that, not surprisingly given the rising demographics of so many African countries, some of them are going to feature. Long-term economic growth is driven by two simple forces: the growth of a nation’s labour force and its productivity. In those African countries with large and rapidly rising labour forces, if they can harness better policies to boost productivity, including—but not only—more inter-African trade itself, better governance institutions and stable economic policy, by 2050 some of them will be rather significant in global economic matters. I highlight Egypt, Ethiopia and of course Nigeria, which has 20% of the continent’s population, as being at the core of them. Maybe the noble Baroness’s beloved Ghana will be there as well. The noble Baroness is right to suggest we need to do whatever we can to boost our trade and other ties with these nations. I welcome the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, to the House.

    View contribution permalink →

  10. Lord Redwood (Con)

    My Lords, I too welcome the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, to this House and wish her every happiness here. Perhaps now we can get back to the real topic of this debate, which is the future of our fish and farming industries and our food production, and our relationship with the EU and whether this is going to damage further these important matters. As we heard in an excellent fact-filled speech from my noble friend Lord Lilley, we had many of the cards for a good negotiation, but this Government decided to play none of them. We are the customer, primarily. The EU is primarily the producer. There is no need for us to pay to play. If anybody should be paying, it should be paying us for access to the treasure island of the British market, whereas it sees every EU negotiation as an opportunity to take more of our money and control more of our laws. We have a great Minister here who is a strong advocate of British farms, British farming and British food, and I want to back her in that. She can do a great deal to help our agricultural industries, but it will not be through the EU reset we are likely to be served up tomorrow. Indeed, it requires the opposite of that. Let us look at the state of our fishing industry. It was decimated by years in the common fisheries policy. We had a wonderful opportunity with Brexit to take control of our fishing grounds, increase the quotas for British vessels and offer some grant support to rebuild a British fishing industry. We would then get a lot of onshore fish processing by landing more of the fish here. Instead, this Government wantonly gave away 12 years more of our fish on an excessive scale so that those fish can be landed on the continent of Europe and processed there, with all the revenues and jobs that that will generate on the continent, confining us once again to being the customer and not the producer. Let us look at the issue of farming. Over our many years in the common agricultural policy, we saw a long, protracted and big decline in the amount of temperate food we grow for our home market. That was not coincidental or bad luck. It was the result of bad EU policies. Does the Minister remember that generous grants were given by the EU to grub up orchards in the United Kingdom so that we would import more fruit from the continent, which is what we now do? Does she remember that our dairy industry was not allowed to grow and produce enough milk to meet even our own value-added requirements in the production of cheese and other value-added items? We were the only country in the system that was not allowed to have enough quota for our own needs and to grow the industry. Does she remember how, when our beef industry was badly afflicted by BSE—which obviously required remedial action—the EU’s remedial action was too severe for too long, crippling the industry, meaning that we turned out to be much more of a beef importer? These are the things that need to be reversed, but instead we are going to be offered a deal which says those very EU laws and controls which so harmed our market share of our home production during all those years in the EU, have to be reimposed and intensified. As my noble friend pointed out, those who export to the continent already obey all the rules, just as you need to. There are lots of different rules all around the world and, if you want to be an exporter, you have to conform to the different rules for the different markets. What you normally do, and what we are doing with other countries around the world now we are free to choose our own trade arrangements, is trade with trusted friends and partners on the basis of mutual recognition. This is clearly the way forward and should be the way put forward in the EU reset for our trade with the EU. It should be quite easy to achieve it because we are the importers more than we are the exporters. If there is mutual recognition, we enforce our standards on our companies and it enforces its standards on its companies. Those goods are made freely available in each other’s markets, with appropriate labelling, and the customers in those different markets make a decision about whose product, and to which standards, they like best. All the food items that we produce are edible; they are not going to harm people. Why on earth does the EU suddenly have to have a hissy fit and decide that everything we send to it has to have extra costs imposed on it? It is not a friendly or sensible act, and if we retaliated by imposing some restrictions on its exports to us, I am sure it would soon see sense and we would make some progress. The total cost of this deal is going to be very large indeed. I have seen figures of up to as much as £15 billion a year. Can the Minister tell us what provisions will be made in Budgets for all the extra money we are going to send to the EU? Why do we have to send a solidarity payment? Why do we have to join Erasmus on penal terms? Worst of all is the youth opportunity scheme. Why on earth are we going to invite in 100,000 young people who will want homes and jobs when we are chronically short of those homes and jobs for our own people? The Government have at last recognised that one of their main missions must be to turn round the worklessness, and some of the homelessness, of the young people already legally settled in our country. Minister, please go back to your colleagues and say that the EU reset is a dreadful cost and burden, importing laws we do not want and charging us taxes we do not wish to pay. To add insult to injury, it will mean dearer energy through the energy provisions that we are not invited to debate at this time. My final point is that EU code law is much more damaging to business than our own statute and common law. It is the countries in the world with common-law systems, led by the United States of America, that grow faster, do better, reward the innovators and allow change to take place. Code law ossifies, damages, restricts, slows growth and throws people out of work.

    View contribution permalink →

  11. Baroness Hoey (Non-Afl)

    My Lords, I also welcome the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, to her role here, and I hope she has a very enjoyable time over the next number of years. Yesterday, the Minister for the Cabinet Office responded to a Written Parliamentary Question from the honourable Member for Harwich and North Essex about the UK-EU SPS agreement and said: “Negotiations on the UK-EU SPS Agreement are on-going ahead of the UK-EU Summit on 20 November. We will publish the full treaty text once” ratified. So, as is very plain, this is not just a summit; this is negotiating a proper SPS treaty with the European Union. In this context, having listened carefully to the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, I ask the Minister to explain exactly why we are negotiating a treaty with the European Union when the EU and the UK are both signatories to the World Trade Organization SPS treaty. Why do we need this, when we already have a treaty that allows both sides to recognise their standards? The noble Lord quoted very carefully what the treaty says, so I will not repeat that. Our protections and all the ways we make sure we have the same standards are certainly as good as, and probably far better than, the European Union’s. If we look at the European Union map of animal diseases, we see that there is a far greater biosecurity risk from the EU, and the Minister must recognise this. Catherine McBride, the economist, has said “the EU is full of animal diseases such as foot-and-mouth disease in cattle, African Swine Fever in pigs and wild boar, Peste des Petits Ruminants (PPR) in sheep and goats”— I hope those of the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, have not been affected in France— “and Lumpy Skin Disease … in cattle”. Is it not ridiculous that while the EU is content to accept equivalence with a country on the other side of the world such as New Zealand, it does not want to do so in relation to a country which is very close? Nowhere in the WTO treaty does it say that you cannot accept the SPS standards of countries far away or that you cannot apply them to those located very closely. The EU says that it is deeply committed to international law, but it seems it only cherry-picks the bits it wants to commit to and rejects those that it does not. That is precisely what it is doing now. The text of the treaty is very clear that: “Members shall accept the sanitary or phytosanitary measures of other Members as equivalent, even if these measures differ from their own”. As has been pointed out, ours do not differ. The text goes further. There is a very long passage which ends by saying that SPS measures “shall not be applied in a manner which would constitute a disguised restriction on international trade”. The National Farmers’ Union has priced GB compliance with the additional demands to which the EU is going to subject all farmers, not just those who are exporting to the European Union—over 130 pieces of EU legislation—at around £800 million. It is impossible to see this as anything less than a very poorly disguised restriction on trade. So I ask the Minister again why the Government are negotiating a new treaty with the EU that accommodates the EU’s failure to abide by its existing international obligations under the WTO SPS treaty. Even prior to negotiating this treaty, the UK Government had already acquiesced with EU attempts to flout its existing SPS treaty obligations to an even greater extent, with the result that it is contravening even more fundamental obligations in international law. The EU’s refusal to respect SPS measures of other members as equivalent resulted in a sovereign state, the UK, being cut into two through an international SPS border separating Northern Ireland from Great Britain, in violation of the UN Declaration on Principles of International Law and not in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations, which states: “Every State shall refrain from any action aimed at the partial or total disruption of the national unity and territorial integrity of any other State or country”. By acting in this way, cutting the UK in two through the imposition of an international SPS border, the EU 27 have plainly disrupted the national unity and territorial integrity of the United Kingdom. In this context, instead of accommodating the desire of the EU to cherry-pick international law, our Government should have this as the first item on any reset agenda, but we know that the failure to protect our own national unity is now acting as a key driver for the wider EU reset. On 9 March 2026, when the UK Government announced their intention to subject GB to over 70 EU SPS laws, Defra took the unusual step of issuing a press release targeted at Northern Ireland. It pointed out that extending EU SPS dynamic alignment from Northern Ireland to the rest of the UK would be of great benefit to Northern Ireland, because it would end the divergence between NI and the rest of the UK. In requiring Great Britain to dynamically align with over 130 pieces of EU legislation, this arrangement is, in effect, taking from Great Britain the ability to exercise self-determination in critical issues of SPS and biosecurity. Although the EU is seeking to dynamically align the whole UK with the SPS law, the mandate provided to the Commission by the Council of Ministers to negotiate with the UK refused to even minimally recognise the UK in the sense of allowing a deal that facilitates UK SPS law. Instead, it authorises negotiations only for a common SPS area specifically in respect of Great Britain. If the UK Government believe in the UK, in its territorial integrity and self-government, and in international law, which supports both, why are they acquiescing with the EU in its determination to undermine all three? Finally, all the hype and the spin being launched that the reset will fix the Irish Sea border is just that, spin, and indeed not true. There is no attempt to tackle the central expression of the Irish Sea border—a customs frontier within the UK in the Irish Sea continues, even if there is an SPS agreement. Even this week, the Government have acknowledged this by refusing to pull the Stormont brake in relation to the application of the new custom border legislation the EU has introduced, which makes it plain to a far greater degree than the old legislation that Great Britain stands as a third country, which is referred to many times. We are even referred to as a foreign country in relation to Northern Ireland. We have to stop our kowtowing once again to a European diktat. When will this Government stand up for British interests and the United Kingdom as a whole?

    View contribution permalink →

  12. Baroness Lawlor (Con)

    My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, for securing this debate, and congratulate him. I also welcome the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong. She is not in her place at the moment, but I was very glad to hear her maiden speech. There are few in this House with the knowledge and experience of international trade of the former Secretary of State, the noble Lord, Lord Lilley. I have written about this myself, and I learn from the noble Lord each time I review what is happening in the world of international trade. He and other noble Lords have drawn our attention to the WTO rules and stipulations. Both we and the EU are members, and we have heard that the EU is constantly in breach of its SPS rules under the WTO. I would like to elaborate on some of the things that the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, pointed out. In applying the rules, as opposed to the rules themselves— Article 4— there must be a justification. SPS protections should be applied for no purpose other than ensuring food safety and be based, as far as possible, on an analysis of the scientific data. They should be consistent with international standards, whatever system we are applying; they should be able to adapt to local conditions, and they should choose the SPS measure which is least likely to depress the international trade purpose. All these conditions and stipulations on the application would be met were we to sign an equivalence-based SPS deal with the EU. In fact, none of them would be met by the current proposal, which looks as if it is going to go ahead tomorrow, to agree to put the UK under EU SPS law. I say this because, despite what the noble Baroness, Lady Chapman, said, the EU is itself in breach of international law. On that point, does the Minister agree that her Government are selective in their choice of which international treaties to break and which international treaties to follow? It is important that we know where the Labour Party—the Government—now stand. International treaties would be broken if we go ahead with this. It is not in the UK’s interests, and it cannot be justified for food safety measures on the basis of scientific data. Our existing international SPS agreements, with over 70 parties now since Brexit, are based on scientific evidence and conformity assessment, not on the code-based, unpredictive and untransparent basis of EU law, about which we know very little of what is coming down the line. There will be no security for our farming industry and agri-foods, because they will have no idea of what to expect next and how they will have to adapt. These laws on SPS do not adapt to local conditions as the WTO requires. The pesticides are not suitable for our climate conditions, which are often wetter in the UK and Ireland than in the EU. In the very wet parts of Normandy, you can get under-the-counter pesticides which are prohibited by EU law but are more suitable for combating pests in the damp and moist conditions in Normandy. Other countries break EU law because it is unsuitable, but I am afraid that this will not happen here. Nor is EU law transparent; we have heard about the 77 rules and regulations on Defra’s website, and we have heard—I was glad that the noble Lord mentioned it—that Defra officials said it would make the law transparent. Does the Minister, who has a farming background herself, think that our small farmers and small businesses will be in any position to understand the 77 laws that her department has published—including, to take one example, 191 pages of compliance regulations? This is an imposition on farming that cannot be justified by a Government who have the interests of our sector at stake. Finally, have the Government made a real costing of what these compliance burdens will be? Do they have any idea what taxpayers will be asked to pay just to support the farming industry, which has done so well under our own law? I draw the Minister’s and the House’s attention, not to the Anderson study for CropLife, but to the study by the fresh fruit importers. They are very concerned, because most of our fresh fruit is taken in from abroad. It is imported from non-EU countries, yet they will have to comply with EU laws. Have the Government taken account of the fact that this will raise prices in the supermarkets and may start restrictions, because those countries will feel it is not worthwhile to continue to sell their fresh fruit to the UK if they have to go through the whole paraphernalia of EU compliance law? It will be too expensive. Our customers, our buyers and our households may be short of goods. This is not consistent with the manifesto pledge. It goes far deeper than a mere veterinary agreement or the other two asks, neither of which was secured. This is a return to EU law. It puts our country in breach of international law, because we have signed treaties with other countries on the basis of the SPS deals we have made with them. I beg the noble Baroness to do what she can to mitigate this dreadful deal.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. Lord Hannay of Chiswick (CB)

    My Lords, it would be churlish to neglect to congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, on obtaining this timely debate. I do so congratulate him, even while recognising that the conclusions he and I draw in it are likely to be diametrically opposed. Before moving any further, I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, on a really remarkable maiden speech. I think all those who heard it will have benefited from it. I met Nelson Mandela at the United Nations, and it was a privilege to do so. If the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, is as successful in this House as she has been in her career before joining it, that will be a wonderful thing. This debate is timely, since tomorrow’s UK-EU meeting in Brussels will, I hope, put the seal on the negotiations between the two parties for a sanitary and phytosanitary agreement, which have been under way for several months. Such an agreement will be of clear benefit to both parties. There is no shadow of doubt that Brexit, and the lamentably skimpy trade and co-operation agreement that accompanied it, have inflicted serious damage on Britain’s agri-food industry, by piling bureaucracy and complex controls on a sector of our economy whose exports were growing steadily in the period before Brexit. The figures show that clearly enough. The markets in the rest of Europe are, by a very long way, our largest overseas market. This matters. British meat, fish, shellfish, cheese and many other agri-food projects have suffered grievously, and this agreement, if and when confirmed and implemented, will alleviate their position very considerably. Moreover—this is a point often overlooked by commentators—an SPS agreement will remove much of the bureaucracy still imposed on products moving to and from Northern Ireland, even after the Windsor Framework entered into force. Dislike of that framework seems to be blinding its critics to the benefits that this SPS agreement will bring to Northern Ireland. If you listen to the views of business, rather than to politicians, you will hear a rather different story. So, there is much for our exports; but there should also be benefits to British consumers from relieving continental European exporters from similar controls when exporting to the UK. A visit to any supermarket will show that that covers a multitude of products. Are there, then, no drawbacks? Well, the vociferous critics of a UK-EU SPS agreement—and they have been in full cry this morning—will dwell at length on the fact that the agreement means we will have to apply EU legislation, including changes to existing legislation, without having a full say in its shaping and adoption, in a process known as dynamic alignment. That will be the case. But those same critics were responsible in the first place for putting our agri-food industry in the damaging predicament it finds itself in. The assumption is that our diplomats and civil servants will supinely sit and watch changes being made to EU legislation that we would rather avoid. They will surely not do that, and this agreement seems to cover the ability to intervene in some of the shaping process. In the end, SPS, like many other policy areas, is a matter of making hard choices. Without an SPS agreement, such as we are debating, our agri-food industry will either have to accept the continuing damage to our largest export market, or they will have to adopt the bureaucracy and controls the EU imposes on imports from third countries themselves, which will impose costs on their own businesses: hardly a contribution to a sector that has the capacity to contribute to our future growth. The arguments I have referred to in my contribution to this debate make up, I suggest, a powerful case for going ahead with the agreement that will be on the table in Brussels tomorrow. I welcome the rather large number of new advocates for international law, who seem to have sprung up this morning in unlikely places, and from unlikely Members of the House. Long may they stay so when we next start talking about the European Convention on Human Rights. As for myself, I wish the Government well in this endeavour tomorrow to get an SPS agreement.

    View contribution permalink →

  14. Lord Frost (Non-Afl)

    My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, for, as always, a very informative and eloquent opening speech on this important subject. When the SPS reset is announced tomorrow, we will be told, and expected to believe, that abandoning the right to make our own laws on food and agriculture constitutes some sort of benefit for this country. That puzzles me, and I admit that I am a bit confused by the Government’s negotiating strategy in this reset more generally. In my experience, most negotiations involve giving something that benefits the other side in return for something that benefits you. This negotiation has involved asking for things that benefit the EU in return for conceding things that benefit the EU. It is a novel approach to negotiations. One must spare a thought for Maroš Šefčovič, my old sparring partner, who must have been a bit flummoxed by this. He has, after all, spent a career negotiating with people who actually wanted to get something from him. He was not in his current job between 2016 and 2018, so he will not have been familiar with British negotiators with this unique negotiating style. But he has adjusted, and was no doubt delighted to discover that the EU single market for food and agriculture could be enlarged without going through any of the inconvenience of giving Britain any say in it. Maroš Šefčovič certainly seemed pretty delighted on Monday, when he spoke at the UK-EU Parliamentary Partnership Assembly of his “intense” “dating schedule” with our negotiator, the Minister, Mr Falconer, who, for his part, said that his role had “felt like a honeymoon”, and that although they were not married, “the relationship is indeed very close”. If I may bring a colloquial term into your Lordships’ House, this kind of thing slightly gives me the ick. Our relationship with the EU is not a marriage. We just went through a long and unnecessarily painful divorce, but the remainer/rejoin establishment, so well represented on the Benches opposite, are still turning up at the ex’s house and desperately trying to bestow gifts in the hope that there will one day be another chance. That is the context in which we must see this SPS deal. Let us be clear about the problem the Government tried to solve here. British traders face costs at the border, as they do at all kinds of borders and always have. Some of those costs are imposed unnecessarily by our own Government and the others are real, but even Mr Falconer himself claims these are only some tens of millions of pounds per year. If the aim was to reduce that number, why not just reduce or subsidise those costs? Instead, Labour’s way of cutting the paperwork at the border has been to agree that Brussels should write all the paperwork everywhere else and that we should pay it to do so. Dynamic alignment sounds so much better than doing what you are told. We already have to accept EU food rules in order to sell food in Europe. This agreement is not about that; it is about accepting the rules and transactions which have nothing to do with the European Union. Food and animal exports to the EU are under 1% of this economy. Most British food production never goes anywhere near the EU and only 6% of it goes abroad at all. For most British producers, the effect of the SPS deal will be to remove a barrier between them and a European customer they do not have anyway and to put a new cost between them and a British customer they do have. It has achieved something remarkable and truly innovative: imposing the expense and inconvenience of the EU single market without even having to sell into it. In all this, we get no say. Of course, British diplomats can turn up and say what they think, but they are then kicked out of the room and the EU gets on with it, and, whatever is agreed, we have to put up with it. In Andy Burnham’s British food restaurant, there is no menu; the waiter just tells you that you have to have whatever the chef decides. And if you want to leave, apparently you have to pay for that, too. The Government tell us it is all worth it to get some growth—0.14%, to be precise—in 2040. The DBT methodology note of 22 May last year admits: “This analysis is not a full cost-benefit analysis of an SPS agreement”. Too right it is not, for it covers only the benefits and not the costs: the inability to import cheaper food from outside the EU and the inability to reform our own rules and promote innovation. This week, the more serious estimate we had from the Growth Commission says that, over 10 years, there will be about 1% of benefits and 3% of costs—a loss of 2% of GDP and, in 10 years’ time, some £2,400 per household. The savings from less red tape for exporters are going to be dwarfed by higher prices for everyone else. My question to the Minister is this: are we tomorrow, or in the near future, going to get a new and more thorough economic analysis, one that includes a proper methodology of all the facts and that can be critiqued and discussed by outsiders? It is very necessary in this discussion. In 2018, some of the EU’s negotiators were filmed joking that Britain had become the EU’s first colony. Unfortunately, eight years on, it seems that we have a British Government who do not think that that was a joke. The old Colonial Office used to send young men abroad to govern people who had not asked for it. The Government have reversed the arrangements—they send young negotiators abroad to ask Brussels to govern us. Think about it for a moment. This agreement gives Emmanuel Macron and Friedrich Merz more say over British food and agriculture than the British Prime Minister. How can that be right? Under no pressure at all, the Government have needlessly, gratuitously and unnecessarily chosen to give away this Parliament’s rights to an institution in which we are not represented. They should be ashamed of themselves.

    View contribution permalink →

  15. Lord Murphy of Torfaen (Lab)

    My Lords, it seems that I am always called in these debates after the noble Lord, Lord Frost. In doing so, I realise that I increasingly disagree with him and what he is saying. He was a member of the Government who produced the Northern Ireland protocol—they then denounced it. They produced the Windsor Framework—they went on to denounce that as well. There is no question in my mind that there is a huge issue here, which affects all the people of the United Kingdom, especially the people in Northern Ireland, and that this is an extremely important debate. Before I comment on that, I make reference to my new noble friend Lady Sarpong, who gave a wonderful maiden speech. It was one of the best speeches I have heard in the 40 years I have been in Parliament. It was an absolutely brilliant speech, and we look forward to her time in this place. I welcome tomorrow’s summit, which, generally speaking, will be of great benefit to our people. I pay tribute to those who negotiated it, especially my right honourable friend Nick Thomas-Symonds, the Member for Torfaen—who, as it happens, is my successor in the constituency in Wales—and the right honourable Hamish Falconer, who succeeded him as the Minister responsible for EU relations. They have done a brilliant job. What about the reset so far as the United Kingdom is concerned and the SPS deal in particular? It will reduce bureaucracy, remove border checks and mean that there are no more inspection fees. It will bring approximately £5 billion to our national income as a consequence of what will happen. I refer specifically to Northern Ireland, as it has been referred to by the noble Baroness, Lady Hoey, and others. Last year, I was asked by His Majesty’s Government to conduct a review into the Windsor Framework. I made 17 recommendations, all of which were accepted by the Government, including recommendations regarding SPS checks. I spent six or seven months going all over Northern Ireland, talking to businesses, politicians, and people from the private and public sectors. When I talked to businesses—small and large, especially those concerned with food and drink—there was no question in my mind that they were seriously worried about the effect on Northern Ireland of the checks which were then in force between Great Britain and Northern Ireland. They urged me, time after time, to ask my colleagues in government to negotiate a new SPS deal with Brussels. That is what the Government have done, and tomorrow we will see what the details are. There is no question that the Windsor Framework itself has been simplified over the last couple of years, with the green lanes, red lanes and other improvements that have been made. However, so far as SPS, food and drink, and the agricultural industries were concerned, people in Northern Ireland were hugely dissatisfied with it.

    View contribution permalink →

  16. Baroness Hoey (Non-Afl)

    The noble Lord has had many years of experience in dealing with Northern Ireland. However, does he accept that, whether this SPS agreement goes through or not, the customs border is still there and will affect many businesses on both sides of the border?

    View contribution permalink →

  17. Lord Murphy of Torfaen (Lab)

    Yes, I do accept that. I accept that there are still many things to address with the Windsor Framework. Some of my recommendations covered that: for example, on the democratic deficit in Northern Ireland. However, today we are dealing with the SPS. That is likely to be the most important thing tomorrow in the negotiations. A number of noble Lords have called this a “dreadful deal”, a “dreadful burden” and “one of the worst things that has happened to us in the last number of years”. I ask noble Lords to remember that the people who are going to deal with this are the businesses that sell food and import food and drink, and those people who are going to consume them, particularly in Northern Ireland. The purveyors of gloom, doom and misery should listen to those people. In Northern Ireland, as I explained to noble Lords, many businesses and associations have asked me to ask the Government to have an SPS agreement in the way we are going to deal with tomorrow. Asda, Iceland, Marks & Spencer, the Horticultural Trades Association, the Federation of Small Businesses, the CBI, the Northern Ireland Retail Consortium, Logistics UK, the Ulster Farmers’ Union and the British Poultry Council are just some of the hundreds of people that I and the Government talk to who are urging us to do what is coming tomorrow. Far from this being a dreadful deal, it is a good deal for the United Kingdom and an especially good deal for Northern Ireland.

    View contribution permalink →

  18. Lord Moynihan of Chelsea (Con)

    My Lords, tomorrow, the Prime Minister goes to Brussels to conclude a treaty. Its full content is unknown. It will bind every farm, abattoir, GM research company and food factory in Great Britain to rules made in Brussels on which we will have no vote. Last week’s report from your Lordships’ European Affairs Committee, which I commend as evening reading, made it absolutely clear that we will have little to no input to the shaping of those rules. This rebuts the assertion by the noble Baroness, Lady Chapman of Darlington, and the Government, that we will have influence. The EU likely sees the deal as a further step in its plan to edge the UK back into full, disastrous membership. The Financial Times today called this “a true crossing of the Brexit Rubicon”. The Government, echoed by credulous sock puppets in the BBC and elsewhere, including in this Chamber, claim that this deal is just about easing paperwork for those in the UK who are exporting SPS goods to the EU. I find it amazing that they can say that with a straight face. The whole of SPS in the UK will have to be brought over to the EU’s SPS rules. The entire UK now has to follow those rules: the EU’s rules, not ours. That includes all SPS goods exported from the UK to the rest of the world. Even worse, for all SPS goods that we import from the rest of the world, the EU’s protectionist wall will be erected: for Morocco, Japan, Egypt, Thailand, Turkey and many others, including those countries that the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, whom I welcome to this place, mentioned. It is a pity that she and the noble Lord, Lord O’Neill, did not remain in their places to hear this. The barriers will all be erected by us, under EU compulsion, to all those countries. Many who currently export to us will no longer bother as much—and when they do it will be at a higher price. The gap will be filled by—guess who?—exporters from the EU to the UK. Another captured market is brought into line by the EU, a success for it. Industry figures estimate a past cost of roughly £60 million a year from vet-signed export health certificates. That is the only hard benefit figure that we have for this deal. What about the cost of the deal, which the Government are so silent about? The pesticide manufacturers’ analysis says that an immediate switch to EU pesticide rules would cost arable, horticulture and sugar growers between £500 million and £800 million in year 1. The Fresh Produce Consortium estimates more than £300 million a year in extra costs from applying EU-style checks to fruit and vegetables that are coming into the UK from the rest of the world: food that will never go near the EU. For all these munificent benefits, we are told that we will pay a financial contribution to Brussels, the size of which the Government have so far failed to disclose but which alone will likely dwarf any possible financial benefits to this small economic subsector of ours. England, ahead of Europe, has successfully legislated in ever-improving regimes for gene-edited crops. Without a permanent carve-out, not just one that lapses in July 2028, that flourishing industry in this country will die as the rest of the world—America, China, Brazil, even Argentina—will take it away from us. Our farmers will lose access to treatments, chemicals and technologies that the EU will not approve. Many will be banned by the EU on the ludicrous “precautionary principle” basis, and we will just have to take it. Our trading partners will be unhappy, and that will cost us. The US trade representative said in a Financial Times interview last week that our planned alignment with EU rules is now a “problem” for expanding our trade deal with it. Within the CPTPP, the SPS chapter is enforceable through state-to-state disputes. Australia and Canada have already raised concerns. Every EU rule we must adopt but cannot defend on the science—and there will be plenty of those, because the EU is anything but scientific—is a case waiting to be brought against us. The Government assert a headline benefit of £5.1 billion a year by 2040 and then admit, as other noble Lords have said, that they have not done a full cost-benefit analysis. So how do they know? The only hard figure is that £60 million-a-year saving and, as we have seen, the pesticide cost to us alone is some 10 times that. Our exporters to the EU correctly complain that the EU imposes unreasonable inspections on incoming goods from the UK, sending loads back for trivial paperwork errors. The EU is wrong, petty and confrontational to do that. However, there is a way of responding, as my noble friends have already said: fight back until the EU behaves better, while in the meantime financially and administratively helping our exporters. The EU and the UK have equivalent levels of SPS standards. WTO rules state that these should be recognised once demonstrated, just as the EU has agreed with New Zealand. Mutual recognition of equivalent systems—the model that the NFU argued for and that many of us on the Conservative side have been advocating since the Brexit vote—would cut physical inspections to a fraction of today’s level and simplify the paperwork without surrendering control of our rules. It would also solve the Northern Ireland problem. So will the Government publish a full impact assessment, including the cost to growers, importers and exporters to the rest of the world, before signature? Will they secure binding exemptions for precision breeding and plant protection products? Will they tell the House what the full financial contribution will be? Will they promise that Parliament will have a vote on each new EU rule before it becomes our law? I finish by saying that we left to make our own rules. Three-quarters of the people of Makerfield said in an opinion poll last week that they want to continue making our food laws solely in this country. Why would the Prime Minister betray his own constituents’ views in this way?

    View contribution permalink →

  19. Lord Verdirame (Non-Afl)

    My Lords, I too congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, on securing this important and timely debate. It is a pleasure to follow so many excellent speeches, particularly, as others have noted, the magnificent maiden speech by the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong. As others have pointed out, there are two main approaches to removing SPS checks in international trade law. The first is based on equivalence and mutual recognition. It is true that that is the approach the WTO promotes in Article 4 of the SPS agreement, but it is fair to say that the SPS agreement has not been a huge success, for various reasons. It is too complicated to get into them, but there has been very little litigation under Article 4 of the agreement, even during the time when the dispute settlement system was up and running. Perhaps more importantly for present purposes, equivalence and mutual recognition is what we have signed up to in the CPTPP. The alternative approach, as we have heard, is based on regulatory harmonisation and alignment, which is the EU’s model. At its heart is a single rulebook which applies to all the countries within the bloc. It is fair to say that, within the bloc, the results can be quite impressive: with a single rulebook and no trade checks, trade grows. But it is also the case that the single rulebook that enables the growth of trade within the bloc acts as a protectionist wall vis-à-vis those who are outside. It is possible, as we have heard, for countries that have agreed to harmonise to choose to trade with third countries on the basis of mutual recognition and equivalence. To some extent, this is what happened between the EU and New Zealand. We are going to do something different: we are going to trade with the EU on the basis of dynamic alignment. We will do so not as a member of the bloc but as a third country, and, quite importantly, one that is now obliged under other agreements to trade on the basis of equivalence and recognition with other states. Paragraph 28 of the common understanding from last December promised that the SPS agreement would include some exceptions to dynamic alignment. I believe a crucial test for the treaty will be the scope and content of these exceptions. In the common understanding, there was no indication that the exceptions were going to be temporary, but we will have to see tomorrow whether that has been maintained. The main trade policy question for the Government is this: once we have signed up to dynamic alignment with the EU, how will we manage the tension between dynamic alignment and equivalence and mutual recognition, to which we are committed under other agreements? Article 7.9 of the CPTPP requires state parties to proceed on the basis of objective scientific evidence. Under the CPTPP, the precautionary principle is far more limited than under even the WTO, and certainly than under EU law. Under Article 7.8 of the CPTPP, another party may ask us to conduct an equivalence assessment. When that happens, we are obliged to “recognise the equivalence of a sanitary or phytosanitary measure if the exporting Party objectively demonstrates to the importing Party that the exporting Party’s measure … achieves the same level of protection as the importing Party’s measure”. We may choose not to recognise, even in that case—that is allowed under the CPTPP—but we must provide the requesting party with a rationale for our decision. If the real decision is that our agreement with the EU does not allow us to accept their import, notwithstanding equivalence of protection, that is not going to be an acceptable rationale under the CPTPP. We would, in effect, be saying that our obligations under another treaty must trump our obligations under that treaty. Simply in terms of treaty law, that cannot work. What could happen next is that we might be sued under the CPTPP. It has rather complex dispute settlement provisions, but there would be a pathway for litigation. If we are found to be not compliant, there could be trade sanctions. I have a few follow-up questions for the Minister, based on this matter and this interaction. First, how many equivalence determination requests have we received under the CPTPP or other agreements, including the WTO or our bilateral agreements with Australia and New Zealand, and with what outcomes? Secondly, if the United Kingdom finds a CPTPP partner’s measures to be equivalent but cannot permit the import because of our SPS obligations to the EU, how will the Government handle that situation and the potential conflict of obligations between those two treaties? Finally, have the Government assessed whether dynamic alignment under the UK-EU SPS agreement is, in general terms, compatible with our equivalence obligations under these other treaties? If so, will the Government share that assessment with Parliament?

    View contribution permalink →

  20. Lord Carlile of Berriew (CB)

    My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow my noble friend Lord Verdirame, who has given us a notable tutorial on international law in the last few minutes. I hope that the Government will be able, at least in due course, to answer the important questions he has raised. It was, of course, memorable to be here for the fabulous maiden speech by the new noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, and I look forward to hearing her again in the future. I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, for initiating this debate. He is a wonderful parliamentarian, and, if he will take this as a compliment—I hope he will—he is, in my view, a most agreeable colleague with whom to agree to disagree in your Lordships’ House. Returning—if I dare, after my noble friend’s speech—to a bit of international law that I would suggest is applicable here, WTO agreements allow countries to make their own domestic regulatory choices. By the way, I was very impressed, as was my noble friend Lord Hannay, by the enthusiasm shown by a number of noble Members opposite for international law—something we do not usually hear them repeating in unison and chorus in your Lordships’ House. WTO agreements allow countries to make their own domestic regulatory choices through mechanisms such as regulatory autonomy, Article 4 equivalents in the SPS agreement itself, and bilateral mutual recognition. Countries are explicitly permitted under international law to set their own appropriate level of health protection and, most importantly, to enter into bilateral deals to reduce border friction. The WTO agreement has not been universally successful, as my noble friend Lord Verdirame said. As a result, a number of countries have entered into bilateral agreements, including New Zealand; Switzerland, with its deep regulatory alignment with the EU for agricultural and animal products; Canada, under its Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement with the EU; Chile; South Korea; and the European Union—it is not one country but a very large number of countries. In my view, saying that the alleged breach of the WTO agreement is a serious matter is, I am afraid, deeply misleading when one analyses the international law. I particularly want to say something based on my experience so far as chair of your Lordships’ Northern Ireland Scrutiny Committee. The SPS has featured very strongly in our discussions in the committee. The position was not good; it is better now than it was. Many of the most acute difficulties experienced in the early stages of the protocol have been mitigated, and tomorrow’s announcements are anticipated with optimism—by me, at least. However, it would be complacent to say that everything is now going to be well in Northern Ireland in relation to these issues. As our report last year and the superb report by the noble Lord, Lord Murphy of Torfaen, last year demonstrated, a striking feature of the evidence received by the noble Lord and our committee has been the continuing and sometimes stultifyingly complex arrangement: even very sophisticated businesses struggle to understand which rules apply, how future changes affect them and, particularly, how their concerns can be communicated effectively to decision-makers in companies. The noble Lord, Lord Murphy of Torfaen, suggested, and our committee supported, the creation of a one-stop shop to deal with these inquiries by interested parties. The Government have taken that one-stop shop on board, but it is coming very slowly—a step at a time. I would be very grateful to hear from the Minister, who is always extremely helpful to your Lordships’ House, how that process can be accelerated, because it is really needed. There is nothing particularly mysterious about SPS controls. Around the world, the level of SPS checking is broadly proportionate to the degree of regulatory divergence between nations, often neighbouring nations. When jurisdictions choose to maintain closely aligned SPS regimes, border interventions and bureaucracy tend to be limited. Where they choose divergent neighbouring regulatory frameworks, checks and certification requirements inevitably increase. As far as businesses are concerned, most of them are interested in neither constitutional theory nor institutional architecture—that is boring and not practical. They simply wish to be able to move their goods efficiently and at a reasonable cost. I turn to three questions that I would like to put to the Minister. First, what formal mechanisms do the Government envisage for consulting Northern Ireland stakeholders during the development of new SPS arrangements? Secondly, how will Parliament and, of course, the Northern Ireland Assembly be enabled to scrutinise those arrangements before they are brought into effect, so that creases are ironed out before they are there in black and white? Thirdly, what further steps will be taken to provide businesses with clear and accessible information about the rules under which they are expected to operate in the future? These are not abstract questions. They go directly to the success or failure of the Windsor Framework in the years ahead. If a deeper SPS partnership with Europe can reduce friction, support Northern Ireland’s large agri-food sector and provide greater certainty for businesses, it should be welcomed. But it will command lasting confidence only if accompanied by effective and continuous scrutiny and by a stronger voice for those in Northern Ireland who must live with its consequences.

    View contribution permalink →

  21. Lord Kerr of Kinlochard (CB)

    My Lords, I had not intended to intervene in this debate, but I feel I must in order not to disappoint the noble Lord, Lord Lilley. I was very grateful for his kind words, but I was a little puzzled, I have to admit, by his argument that the Government had thrown away a valuable negotiating chip by not exercising the right to set up UK border controls—a right that they acquired in the agreement negotiated by the noble Lord, Lord Frost. As an ex-negotiator, I am rather sceptical about the bargaining-chip value of a right never exercised and never likely to be exercised because exercising it would be costly both to administer and in its effect. The EU did of course exercise the reciprocal right that the noble Lord, Lord Frost, gave it, no doubt because he believed in a doctrine of deliberate distancing. If a deal concluded tomorrow dismantles the border checks that have so damaged our producers and farmers, that seems to me to be worth a welcome less churlish than that given by him and the noble Lord, Lord Lilley.

    View contribution permalink →

  22. Baroness Grender (LD)

    My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, for securing this debate. His timing, on the eve of the summit in Brussels, could hardly be better. I warmly congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, on an outstanding maiden speech. Her Remain credentials mean that any seating error will also be warmly welcomed on these Benches at any point in the future, should she lose her way in the Chamber. While we are swapping “Who met Nelson Mandela?” stories, I once had the honour. A really classy person such as Nelson Mandela will always find the most junior person in the room, and that of course was me. She has made her mark today, and I look forward to many more contributions from her. It was an unexpected delight to hear from the noble Baroness, Lady Chapman of Darlington, the noble Lord, Lord O’Neill of Gatley, and, indeed, the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, about the future opportunity of trade with Africa and all that Africa has to offer. It was a nice and refreshing diversion from some of the standard discussions. The Motion asks us to look at international processes and approaches, and I am happy to do so. But given that other noble Lords have dwelt on the approach that this country took, I will start at home. In 2020, the last Government signed a trade agreement that put regulatory freedom ahead of trade without friction. We were promised the easiest deal in history, but the bill arrived in the farmyard, at the port and on the deli counter. The NFU tells us that food exports to the EU have fallen by a third since Brexit, with eggs, chicken and potato products the worst hit. Fresh sausages, burgers, shellfish from our own waters and seed potatoes have been shut out of our nearest market altogether. The red lines negotiated at that time turned into reams and reams of endless red tape. Every consignment of animal products needs a £200 export health certificate. Small firms pay a vet to sign off every pallet. Jon Walsh of Bio&Me, a small company making yoghurt and granola, told the BBC that each pallet cost £140 in vets’ fees, so they lost money and stopped exporting. In his words: “You just kind of give up”. A haulier told a committee of the House of Commons that a lorry of frozen beef sat in Calais for 27 days because one certificate was wrong. I am delighted that the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, raised the issue of cheese. Small delis here can no longer buy a few wheels of cheese from France or Italy because the paperwork costs more than the cheese. To quote a former, briefly serving, Prime Minister: “that is a disgrace!” That was not the only bad deal. The trade deal with Australia, which these Benches warned at the time sold out British farmers, was later described by a former Conservative Environment Minister as “not actually a very good deal for the UK”. He went on to say that we “gave away far too much for far too little in return”. Our farmers were asked to compete with producers on the other side of the world while losing easy access to customers on the other side of the channel. That is not taking back control; it is giving away a market. When noble Lords describe this agreement as a “surrender”, I ask them to look at who is asking for it. The NFU supports it, the supermarkets support it and the British Chambers of Commerce says that business believes common rules are a “price worth paying” for lower costs, fewer delays and more access. The people who live with these checks every day are not asking for more sovereignty over paperwork; they are asking for the paperwork to go. I turn now to the Motion. New Zealand’s agreement with the EU is often held up as the alternative. As I understand it, that agreement rests on equivalence, which reduces checks but does not remove them—certificates remain and inspections remain, albeit at a lower rate. The country that has removed veterinary checks at the EU border is Switzerland, and it did so in the same way this agreement proposes, by sharing the rules. If the aim is to remove checks rather than trim them, the international evidence points one way. I turn now to gene editing, which has been presented in parts of this House and parts of the press as the great roadblock. I do not believe the facts bear that out. First, the EU is catching up with us, and that is a good thing. In June, the European Parliament gave final approval to new rules on gene-edited plants. Plants that could have been produced by conventional breeding came out of the old GMO regime. It is a two-tier system, broadly similar to the one Parliament put in place for England. Most of it applies from July 2028. Secondly, the timetables meet. The SPS agreement is not now expected to take effect until early 2028. It has been reported, including in the home paper of the Benches next to me, the Daily Telegraph —not a newspaper famous for its enthusiasm for Brussels—that British gene-edited crops will have a temporary exemption until the EU regime is up and running. Thirdly, we should listen to the scientists. I feel we are slightly missing them on the Cross Benches today. Professor Johnathan Napier of Rothamsted Research called the EU’s decision “a seismic shift in how gene edited crops are regulated in Europe”. That is the point. An English precision-bred wheat that can be sold freely to 450 million people is worth far more than one that stops at Dover. Indeed, today’s regime in England does not even reach Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland. There are differences. The EU limits the number of edits, it requires seed labelling and it is further behind on animals. Those need careful handling, but careful handling is not a roadblock. From these Benches, we welcome this agreement and we want it to work for farmers as well as the fishing community. Tavish Scott, the chief executive of Salmon Scotland—Scottish salmon is the UK’s largest food export, with strong demand within the EU, the US and elsewhere—said that a new agreement would help cut the time taken to get products into the EU market. It requires a proper transition, and I ask the Minister to take note of Alistair Carmichael’s committee’s recommendations about the transition period. While we are on international rules, like the noble Lords, Lord Hannay and Lord Carlile, I find it striking that the Benches beside me do not seem to object to Britain taking rules from elsewhere after all. They simply prefer the rules from Geneva rather than those from Brussels. Our farmers do not sell their lamb in Geneva; they sell it to wider markets. Let us be honest about this agreement. As my colleague Al Pinkerton MP put it, as far as we are concerned, it is a patch, not a fix. Our exporters will still face customs declarations and VAT paperwork. The long-term answer is a customs union with the EU—which the House of Commons voted in favour of last December, with a little bit of help from the Labour Benches, for which many thanks to those people—and, in time, the single market. I have just two questions for the Minister, and I am more than happy if she would prefer to write the answers, because it has been a long week for her. Will she confirm that the Government will keep England’s precision breeding regime in place until the EU’s is fully operational? Will she make sure that farmers get the transition time they require, particularly on plant protection products? The Motion invites us to look abroad for answers. Having looked, I am more convinced than ever that the best approach for British farmers lies much closer to home—21 miles across the channel. We support this agreement; we only wish it would go further.

    View contribution permalink →

  23. Lord Roborough (Con)

    My Lords, I thank my noble friend Lord Lilley for this important and timely debate, and for his comprehensive remarks and expertise in this area. It was also a great pleasure to hear the maiden contribution from the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong. I think all Benches are looking forward to future interventions. Before I begin, I refer the House to my register of interests, including as a forester, farmer and agricultural landlord. My comments primarily address how we can best support our farmers and food producers today and in the future, while protecting food and biosecurity and delivering high-quality, affordable food to consumers. Dynamic alignment is not just about aligning certain standards with those of the EU. There are cases where that is sensible, evidence-based and beneficial. Alternatively, some countries, such as New Zealand, keep different rules but recognise others as providing an equivalent level of food safety. In these cases, it has meant that all physical checks can be removed. Dynamic alignment, however, and the SPS agreement that is expected to be finalised at the summit tomorrow, are the British Government giving the EU control of our food and biosecurity. We do not have representation in the EU Parliament or a veto over the EU Commission, so why would we voluntarily sign up to future laws without having a formal seat at the table? It is more accurate to call this automatic alignment rather than dynamic alignment. Nor are we just picking up from where we left off when the UK left the EU in 2020. It will not surprise noble Lords to hear that the EU has continued to legislate since then. We on these Benches are committed to reducing red tape and costs for British businesses. Signing up to the EU SPS means vast new regulation on our farming and food sector. There are more than 400 pieces of primary EU SPS legislation, 76 core directives and regulations, and countless other standards, some of which have changed since 2020. We will be taking on more laws and regulations, not cutting them. Many businesses already align their practices with those approved by the EU without the need for government intervention, but this agreement would force all businesses to comply, even if they do not export to the EU. In fact, approximately 90% of our farms do not. This Government have said that an SPS deal could be worth up to £5.1 billion per annum by 2040. This estimate is far enough away to be tenuous at best. Independent assessments put the reality as ranging from no impact to as much as a negative £15 billion per annum. The Minister for Intergovernmental and European Relations today said in the other place that the Government find the impact on farmers to be “quite difficult to quantify”—that is not exactly reassuring. CropLife UK estimates that dynamic alignment could cost UK farming up to £810 million in the first year. The Growth Commission estimates that the agreement could cost the UK £15 billion. We have previously been told that negotiations are ongoing and therefore Ministers cannot comment on the detail, but the 200-page text has been agreed, and if they can promote the supposed economic benefits, they should be up front about how they are calculated and what the costs might be. Can the Minister provide us with a timeline and breakdown of how the £5.1 billion figure was calculated? Can she confirm that the £6 billion figure for the surrender of our fisheries over the next 12 years is included in that calculation? If it is not included, what particular benefit did that gift bring to our country from the EU, since the defence deal that was dangled in front of the last Prime Minister disappeared after we gave away our fisheries? It was a successful bit of bait and switch, although we do not quite know what it has been switched for yet. We import £47 billion of food, feed and drink products from the EU and export only £15 billion, of which one-third goes to Ireland. That is 23% of EU food exports coming to our country. This is why my noble friend Lord Redwood called us the “treasure island” for the European food industry. The benefits for the EU of an SPS deal appear meaningfully larger for it than for us. Our exports to the EU are focused on notable successes such as cheese, horticulture, whisky, farmed and wild fish, and lamb. Those fell by 16% post Brexit as the EU chose to apply full SPS checks on UK exports from the beginning of 2021, while we began our own checks only in 2024. The prize for British farming and food production overall from an SPS deal is small and likely concentrated within those particular sectors, while the threat from increased imports of EU food is very high. Since Brexit, government payments to our farming industry have fallen by 30% in real terms and the funds farmers now receive are wholly for environmental goods and services, to which significant costs are attached. Across the EU, the average subsidy to farmers stands at €376 per hectare, with little or no cost attached. That equates to roughly three times the net value of UK farm receipts from government per hectare. We have been asking our farmers to compete with a heavily subsidised farming sector in the EU. That is not working and will not work., and making it easier to trade with the EU exposes our farmers to even greater unfair competition. How does the SPS increase our domestic food security if our farmers are exposed to more cost and greater subsidised competition? For them, this is a major administrative task, even if more generous transition periods are negotiated. As we have warned previously, growers have already made their production decisions for food sold beyond mid-2027, when this agreement is expected to come into force. Can the Minister confirm the expected implementation date of this agreement? Smaller businesses in particular will be affected by these burdens, risking a further increase to the cost of living. The Food and Drink Federation has said that this will not bring food prices down. We in the UK have moved on as well since leaving the EU SPS and have made significant progress in several areas. As others have mentioned, the UK now leads the world in precision breeding following the Genetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Act 2023, passed by our last Government. Will the SPS deal protect our precision breeding sector across both crops and livestock, without any imposition of protectionist measures such as labelling the output? The Government’s bovine TB strategy makes much of the development of a bovine TB vaccine for cows, crucially supported by the DIVA test allowing for the distinction between vaccinated and infected cattle. Will the UK be able to continue with the planned rollout of bovine TB vaccinations and tests, as laid out in the Government’s bovine TB strategy? What ability will the UK have to take geographic advantage in protecting ourselves against biosecurity risks? Will we be able to apply tailored, risk-based safeguards against animal and plant disease and pest threats? There are 17 active substances available to our farmers but not in the EU. Will our farmers be able to continue to use those? In particular, will our farmers be able to continue to use glyphosate as a pre-harvest desiccant? Our other international trading partners expect us to continue with our current science-based approach. We are concerned that the new SPS agreement will not be compatible with the UK’s membership of the CPTPP and cause litigation and sanction risks from our other trading partners. I have previously asked Written Questions on this subject and did not feel reassured by the replies, so can the Minister guarantee that this will not be the case? This would affect not only food but potentially pharmaceuticals and other key sectors. Are our trading partners elsewhere in the world aware of the obligations we take on with an SPS deal and how they relate to our existing agreements? Many countries share the opinion of my noble friend Lord Lilley that the SPS structure in the EU is protectionist in nature. Trade with Africa has been mentioned several times in this debate and I cannot believe that signing up to the SPS will make that easier. As I have said, this is not just about the principle of sovereignty over our own laws, fundamental though that is. There are pragmatic reasons as to why we have not aligned with all of the EU’s regulations and legitimate concerns as to what this new agreement will mean for our trade with other partners, for domestic businesses, and for the cost of living. The Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee reported earlier this year: “The realities and implications of dynamic alignment have not been well explained to the public. There is a need for a fuller debate”. I therefore thank my noble friend Lord Lilley for this essential debate ahead of tomorrow’s summit and I look forward to hearing the Minister’s responses.

    View contribution permalink →

  24. The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Baroness Hayman of Ullock) (Lab)

    My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, for bringing this debate in front of us today and for giving me the opportunity to respond for the Government on this matter. I also thank all noble Lords from all sides of the House for their thoughtful and constructive contributions to today’s debate, which has come the day before the second UK-EU summit. I welcome especially my noble friend Lady Sarpong to the Labour Benches and thank her for her words in support of the SPS agreement today. She talked about cutting red tape, the benefits for SMEs and growth. I also echo her comments on the great loss to the House of Baroness Margaret McDonagh. My noble friend Lady Sarpong and the noble Lord, Lord O’Neill, raised some important points on Africa and trade. Defra has two agricultural attachés based in Africa, with the important aim of increasing market access and providing insights and support, so that exporters can enter and expand into the African market. Having said that, the Government are committed to building a closer, more ambitious relationship with Europe. Our relationship with the EU is fundamental to delivering our domestic economic agenda and delivering growth to every postcode. It is clear that leaving the EU has done more harm than good, as between 2018 and 2025 agri-food trade exports to the EU fell by 24%. The trade and co-operation agreement introduced barriers impacting over 1,500 products, with 61% of those accounting for agri-food. This does not need to be the case with our closest trading partner. Behind every barrier is a real person whose livelihood has been held back by the bureaucracy of current trading arrangements—the cheesemaker in Somerset whose export business is hard, the farmer in Scotland who can no longer sell seed potatoes to customers they have supplied for decades, the shellfish trader in Wales who has had to turn down orders because their catch is not fresh by the time they have completed their paperwork, and the grocery shop in Northern Ireland which faces unnecessary bureaucracy when receiving goods from Great Britain. The noble Baroness, Lady Hoey, asked why this agreement is needed. The summit tomorrow is an important milestone in resetting our relationship with the EU and delivering practical benefits for British businesses and consumers. Our focus is on translating this strengthened partnership into tangible economic benefits, removing costly bureaucracy and making trade both easier and cheaper. The Government have been negotiating an ambitious but pragmatic SPS agreement with the EU to cut red tape, boost British exports, strengthen supply chains, open opportunities for British food and drink businesses, and drive economic growth. The agreement will reduce costs associated with non-tariff measures applicable to exports of agri-food, plant, fish and seafood products from Great Britain to the EU. It will remove export health certificates, which is expected to save businesses up to £200 per certificate. The agreement as a whole could increase the volume of UK exports of major agricultural commodities to the EU by around 16%. British goods such as dairy, fish, eggs and red meat are currently subject to 100% paperwork checks and up to 30% physical checks. This agreement will remove these entirely. Trade in products such as fresh sausages, burgers, seed potatoes and some live bivalve molluscs from class B waters will be able to resume, and that will reopen the UK market for those goods. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Hannay, and my noble friend Lord Murphy for recognising these benefits. Of course, until the summit takes place tomorrow, I cannot comment on the contents of the agreement in detail, but engagement with Parliament will be central to taking it forward. Members across both Houses bring considerable expertise, and their scrutiny of what will be agreed and how it is implemented will be invaluable. We will continue to engage closely with parliamentary colleagues and will update the relevant Select Committees following the summit, along with publishing guidance on our website to help businesses prepare. To answer the question from the noble Lord, Lord Roborough, the expected date for this entering into force is spring 2028. The Government’s goal is to bring down as many trade barriers with our nearest and largest trading partner as possible. To that end, the agreement is based on the model of dynamic alignment, which is in the best interest of all four nations of the United Kingdom because it delivers this prize for as many British agri-food exporters as possible by reducing the costs of certification checks at the border. Many British agri-food exporters already follow EU requirements in practice to keep selling their goods, and, once the agreement is implemented, they will continue to do so with less bureaucracy, saving valuable time on onerous paperwork. The noble Lord, Lord Lilley, and others correctly identified that there are other trade agreements based on equivalence provisions, with particular reference to arrangements between New Zealand and the EU. While this simplifies checks for a limited selection of goods, it does not remove the need for all paperwork or documentary checks at the border. New Zealand is not part of a shared SPS area of the EU. I also note that the volume of trade between the EU and New Zealand is substantially lower than our trade with the EU, and that New Zealand is, of course, geographically much further away. It is important to point out that New Zealand cannot export goods such as fresh minced red meat, and many goods such as live animals, fish, dairy and composite products still require documentary and identity checks, and, in some cases, still need physical checks. I highlight to the House that ensuring that Northern Ireland benefits from this agreement has been at the heart of the negotiations. Dynamic alignment in the areas covered by the agreement will allow benefits to extend across the United Kingdom, subject to agreed exceptions, and through the agreement’s interaction with the Windsor Framework. Nearly all friction arising from SPS requirements on movements from Great Britain to Northern Ireland will be removed by eliminating the vast majority of checks, certification and labelling requirements for goods in scope. It is important to add that dynamic alignment does not mean every UK rule will automatically mirror the EU’s. The Government have been pursuing specific exceptions where it is important for the UK to retain its own rules. More details will become available after the summit. The Government are making a pragmatic choice to pursue common rules in defined areas where that removes costly barriers to trade and supports growth. We will be able to engage early on relevant future EU measures, and to raise evidence and concerns where UK interests may be affected. I assure the House that facilitating a safe trade in agri-food is a priority for this Government. Defra has already begun work to make sure our border is ready for the new agreement while continuing to protect our biosecurity. Our strong protections and risk-based measures will continue to safeguard the United Kingdom’s biosecurity for the future. In fact, they will strengthen co-operation on biosecurity, including through access to EU agencies, systems and databases and greater sharing of data, science and evidence. The UK will play a key role alongside EU member states in protecting the shared UK-EU SPS area from external biosecurity and public health risks. Importantly, we will still be able to take targeted action where threats arise, in the same way as EU member states do, including national measures in response to specific threats. I now come to some specific questions. I will do my best in the time I have but there are a lot to get through, so I will write to any noble Lords whose questions I have missed. Obviously, there will be many opportunities to discuss this in more detail in the coming weeks. The noble Lord, Lord Lilley, asked whether this would make food from non-EU countries more expensive and undermine other trade deals. We remain an independent trading nation, free to negotiate and conclude trade deals worldwide. The agreement may change checks on some non-EU imports, but many major imports will face no additional checks. Our priority is to keep costs down. Removing barriers with our largest agri-food trading partner will cut costs and delays for businesses. We will have smoother trade with the EU, while still maintaining strong global trading partnerships. The WTO rules were mentioned by a number of noble Lords, including the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, my noble friend Lady Chapman and the noble Lord, Lord Carlile. While there is obviously a World Trade Organization SPS agreement that sets the baseline rules, a core tenet of that agreement is that members have the right to set their appropriate level of SPS protection. In this context, the UK-EU SPS agreement benefits the UK by establishing a common SPS area within the EU, but it is for the EU to speak to its view of its World Trade Organization SPS agreement obligations. However, it makes it very clear that World Trade Organization members can determine their own appropriate level of protection. A UK-EU SPS agreement based on deep integration works best for UK biosecurity, and the deal provides access to EU agency systems and databases. The noble Baroness, Lady Lawlor, suggested that we were breaking international agreements. It is usual practice for WTO members to apply SPS controls to each other. This is not, in principle, a breach of WTO obligations. While we will always advocate for British exports, we also recognise that the EU has a right to currently apply SPS controls to trade from the UK, in line with its WTO and TCA obligations. The noble Lord, Lord Redwood, and the noble Baroness, Lady Lawlor, talked about the importance of supporting farmers. Absolutely; we have been working closely with the farming industry as we go through the negotiations, including with the NFU. It has been involved with Defra throughout SPS agreement negotiations. We will continue to talk to and engage with it as we prepare for the operation of the agreement. The noble Lord also asked about the budget. Clearly, I cannot comment on a budget that is months away. The noble Lord, Lord Redwood, also asked about EU payments. Payments are subject to negotiations and we will discuss making proportionate payments for access to the systems and databases that we need as part of the agreement. Northern Ireland was mentioned by a number of noble Lords. My noble friend Lord Murphy has done a huge amount of work in this area. The Windsor Framework will, of course, continue to apply in Northern Ireland. However, once the SPS agreement has been implemented, its benefits will extend to Northern Ireland through the interplay with the Windsor Framework, creating opportunities to further smooth trade within the UK internal market system. This means the vast majority of goods moving from Great Britain to Northern Ireland will no longer need certificates or agri-food checks. Additionally, the vast majority of goods will no longer require “Not for EU” labelling. This will change the need for Windsor Framework schemes such as the Northern Ireland plant health label scheme, which will close. The noble Baroness, Lady Hoey, suggested that removing border controls could undermine biosecurity. The SPS agreement will not remove our biosecurity protections; strong protections and risk-based measures will continue to safeguard UK biosecurity and maintain our high standards. Importantly, as I have just mentioned, it will strengthen co-operation on biosecurity, including through access to EU agencies, systems and databases and greater sharing of data, science and evidence. The UK will play a key role alongside EU member states in protecting the shared UK-EU SPS area from external biosecurity and public health risks. Importantly, the agreement does not mean an end to border controls. Border control posts and control points will continue to be required for relevant rest-of-world imports and some high-risk commodities from the EU, including live animals, germinal products and some plants, which will still require documentation and/or inspection at destination premises. It is worth pointing out that I am in fact going to Northern Ireland next week. I will have two days in Belfast meeting businesses and Ministers to discuss the best way to work with Northern Ireland as we move towards implementation. As my noble friend Lord Murphy said, businesses there are very welcoming of this agreement; I have worked for a long time with businesses in Northern Ireland. It removes routine SPS checks for the vast majority of goods—something for which those businesses in Northern Ireland have been asking me for two years. The noble Lord, Lord Carlile, asked about business support and business readiness. We absolutely understand that businesses need clarity on forthcoming changes, implementation timelines and legislative requirements to plan effectively. We have been learning from the mistakes made during Brexit, when there were too many changes and businesses did not have clarity. They have been very clear that that is what they need for this. Businesses will receive an explanation of the agreement, updated GOV.UK information and a forward look setting out what they should do now, what further information will be provided, and when. It is an absolute priority for this Government and for Defra to deliver clear and timely information, and we will publish what we can as negotiations proceed. On the way in which businesses are consulted, Defra ran a call for information in spring 2026 to hear from them directly about what they need, and a summary of responses was published on GOV.UK. The call for information found strong anticipated benefits: 68% of respondents expect reduced compliance costs, around half anticipate improved market access and reduced import costs, and half expect increased exports. Businesses currently trading with the EU were particularly positive, highlighting the prospect of reduced paperwork, fewer border checks and lower certification costs as meaningful near-term gains. We have also established an SPS agreement business advisory council, which I personally chair, alongside other sector subgroups, to ensure that businesses and government are working in partnership to implement the new agreement. I thank the businesses and trade associations for taking part in that close partnership working. This feedback has helped shape our policy development and the practical guidance and support we provide. We have extensive practical guidance ready, and businesses of all sizes will benefit from day one. I reassure the noble Lord, Lord Carlile, that this includes Northern Ireland and that Northern Ireland Members are involved in those discussions. The guidance will also include particular tools and implementation support as the delivery arrangements mature. The idea is that it should be very hands-on, which is why we are working with trade associations and businesses to ensure that the guidance reflects what they need to know, and that it reaches businesses throughout the entire supply chain, supporting them in understanding the practical information. This will ensure that they can properly prepare for implementation. The noble Lord, Lord Carlile, asked about the one-stop shop. We are making good progress on the design and development of the enhanced one-stop service; I know it is frustrating that we are not there yet. We expect it to be live this financial year, and we are grateful to businesses and stakeholders for supporting us in developing it. Fishing was mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, and the noble Baroness, Lady Grender. The Government have secured a deal that ensures returns to our fishing community. We are looking to scrap red tape and restore shellfish exports to the EU, which is particularly important for Wales, protecting the significant quota uplift that came with the Brexit deal and maintaining regulatory autonomy for UK waters. We understand that UK fisheries need long-term certainty, and we are committed to the long-term prosperity and sustainability of our fishing industry. The noble Lord, Lord Hannay, asked about sovereignty and decision-shaping. We are obviously not seeking a vote on EU legislation, but the UK will have a very meaningful role in shaping decisions affecting the common SPS area. As I said before, we need to bring people together. UK science, regulation and industry expertise needs to be in the development of the relevant rules, and the impact and value of that should not be understated. Our objective is to influence upstream while policy is being developed, rather than simply responding. On precision breeding, I cannot comment on the detail before tomorrow’s summit, but we have been absolutely clear about the importance of being able to support the use of new and innovative technologies, and we remain committed to moving forward with the Genetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Act 2023. The noble Baroness, Lady Grender, and the noble Lord, Lord Roborough, mentioned pesticides. We are aware of concerns, and we have been absolutely clear with the EU on the need to agree appropriate transition arrangements. On future legislative changes, we intend to take powers through the European partnership Bill, which will be laid shortly after the signing of the agreement to fulfil the treaty obligations in the agreements with the EU, which will enable the domestic implementation of relevant commitments. I assure noble Lords that Parliament will have the opportunity to scrutinise these powers and their associated scrutiny mechanisms once the Bill is introduced. The noble Lords, Lord Frost and Lord Roborough, and others, said that the Government’s figures are misleading. We previously published modelling that estimated the agreement could increase UK GDP by up to 0.14% annually in the long run—equivalent to £5.1 billion a year. That figure is the Government’s upper estimate of the long-run annual increase in UK GDP from the SPS agreement, compared with the scenario of no agreement. The year 2040 is used as the “long run” to reflect the economy once all the shorter-run transitions have been worked through, which is typically assumed to take around 10 to 15 years following the agreement, based on established economic modelling and the best available evidence. Of course, this cannot be a precise forecast but rather an assessment, and we will continue to assess as we go forward. The noble Lord, Lord Frost, asked about costs. We will assess the impact as part of the normal regulatory process, which will be developed alongside the secondary legislation required for the agreement. The noble Lords, Lord Verdirame and Lord Roborough, asked a number of quite complex questions around the CPTPP and other areas. I am going to run out of time. As the topics are quite detailed, I will write to the noble Lord, Lord Verdirame, and ensure that other noble Lords who have taken part are copied in. In the last five seconds, I thank everybody for taking part in this important debate. I look forward to future debates on the EU partnership agreement.

    View contribution permalink →

  25. Lord Lilley (Con)

    My Lords, I am grateful to everybody who took part, and to the Minister for her response. I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, on a superb, brilliant and charming speech—so charming that I am quite prepared to forgive her for upstaging my own speech and nearly hijacking the debate into one about industrialisation in Africa. My first career was working in Africa on industrial development projects, so perhaps we will find ourselves working together on that—not least in the APPG on Trade out of Poverty, which I set up to try to get the EU to reduce its SPS rules to allow Africa and other countries to export to it, and to stop using those rules as a disguised restriction on international trade. I am astonished at the reaction to the WTO agreement, which was largely snide. People said, “How can you make that point?” I believe in recognising and adhering to agreements that we belong to, which is why I do not want to enter into agreements that are not in our interest. The Minister has not explained why the EU has a right to act in disagreement with Article 4 of the WTO SPS agreement. I wait to hear from her on that. There has been no explanation from the Government as to why the NFU, which was very strongly in favour of remain, has now been very critical about this agreement—so much so that, in the briefing the NFU sent to us, it says in bold that Parliament must “retain the sovereign right to withhold consent … in exceptional and significant circumstances”. That would be absolutely incompatible with the agreement that has been reached and will be announced tomorrow. The NFU is therefore at loggerheads with the Government. The noble Lord, Lord Verdirame, quite rightly pointed out that we are led to understand that the SPS arrangements will almost certainly conflict with CPTPP provisions and with those of other free trade agreements we have entered into, which will prevent us reaching free trade agreements with other countries. None of this can be good. We are going to debate Northern Ireland tomorrow which is why I did not discuss it today. In relation to bovine TB, I would mention that, of the 48,000 cattle which we had to exterminate last year, 18,000 were in Northern Ireland. If they retain EU law and we do not, they will not be able to use bovine tuberculosis vaccines. This will be of great disadvantage to them. The noble Lord, Lord Kerr, illustrated all that is wrong with the Foreign Office by saying that the EU could exercise its negotiating capacity of having controls, but it would be of no use to us to have that negotiating right. This must explain why Mrs Thatcher described the Foreign Office as an office which acted in the interests of foreigners. I beg to move.

    View contribution permalink →

  26. Motion agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5441471.