L

Lord Carlile of Berriew (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

Sanitary and Phytosanitary Checks at EU Borders

Contribution

My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow my noble friend Lord Verdirame, who has given us a notable tutorial on international law in the last few minutes. I hope that the Government will be able, at least in due course, to answer the important questions he has raised. It was, of course, memorable to be here for the fabulous maiden speech by the new noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, and I look forward to hearing her again in the future. I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, for initiating this debate. He is a wonderful parliamentarian, and, if he will take this as a compliment—I hope he will—he is, in my view, a most agreeable colleague with whom to agree to disagree in your Lordships’ House. Returning—if I dare, after my noble friend’s speech—to a bit of international law that I would suggest is applicable here, WTO agreements allow countries to make their own domestic regulatory choices. By the way, I was very impressed, as was my noble friend Lord Hannay, by the enthusiasm shown by a number of noble Members opposite for international law—something we do not usually hear them repeating in unison and chorus in your Lordships’ House. WTO agreements allow countries to make their own domestic regulatory choices through mechanisms such as regulatory autonomy, Article 4 equivalents in the SPS agreement itself, and bilateral mutual recognition. Countries are explicitly permitted under international law to set their own appropriate level of health protection and, most importantly, to enter into bilateral deals to reduce border friction. The WTO agreement has not been universally successful, as my noble friend Lord Verdirame said. As a result, a number of countries have entered into bilateral agreements, including New Zealand; Switzerland, with its deep regulatory alignment with the EU for agricultural and animal products; Canada, under its Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement with the EU; Chile; South Korea; and the European Union—it is not one country but a very large number of countries. In my view, saying that the alleged breach of the WTO agreement is a serious matter is, I am afraid, deeply misleading when one analyses the international law. I particularly want to say something based on my experience so far as chair of your Lordships’ Northern Ireland Scrutiny Committee. The SPS has featured very strongly in our discussions in the committee. The position was not good; it is better now than it was. Many of the most acute difficulties experienced in the early stages of the protocol have been mitigated, and tomorrow’s announcements are anticipated with optimism—by me, at least. However, it would be complacent to say that everything is now going to be well in Northern Ireland in relation to these issues. As our report last year and the superb report by the noble Lord, Lord Murphy of Torfaen, last year demonstrated, a striking feature of the evidence received by the noble Lord and our committee has been the continuing and sometimes stultifyingly complex arrangement: even very sophisticated businesses struggle to understand which rules apply, how future changes affect them and, particularly, how their concerns can be communicated effectively to decision-makers in companies. The noble Lord, Lord Murphy of Torfaen, suggested, and our committee supported, the creation of a one-stop shop to deal with these inquiries by interested parties. The Government have taken that one-stop shop on board, but it is coming very slowly—a step at a time. I would be very grateful to hear from the Minister, who is always extremely helpful to your Lordships’ House, how that process can be accelerated, because it is really needed. There is nothing particularly mysterious about SPS controls. Around the world, the level of SPS checking is broadly proportionate to the degree of regulatory divergence between nations, often neighbouring nations. When jurisdictions choose to maintain closely aligned SPS regimes, border interventions and bureaucracy tend to be limited. Where they choose divergent neighbouring regulatory frameworks, checks and certification requirements inevitably increase. As far as businesses are concerned, most of them are interested in neither constitutional theory nor institutional architecture—that is boring and not practical. They simply wish to be able to move their goods efficiently and at a reasonable cost. I turn to three questions that I would like to put to the Minister. First, what formal mechanisms do the Government envisage for consulting Northern Ireland stakeholders during the development of new SPS arrangements? Secondly, how will Parliament and, of course, the Northern Ireland Assembly be enabled to scrutinise those arrangements before they are brought into effect, so that creases are ironed out before they are there in black and white? Thirdly, what further steps will be taken to provide businesses with clear and accessible information about the rules under which they are expected to operate in the future? These are not abstract questions. They go directly to the success or failure of the Windsor Framework in the years ahead. If a deeper SPS partnership with Europe can reduce friction, support Northern Ireland’s large agri-food sector and provide greater certainty for businesses, it should be welcomed. But it will command lasting confidence only if accompanied by effective and continuous scrutiny and by a stronger voice for those in Northern Ireland who must live with its consequences.

More from Lord Carlile of Berriew (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.