B

Baroness Chapman of Darlington (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

Sanitary and Phytosanitary Checks at EU Borders

Contribution

The EU has the right to determine what checks it wishes to have on its border. The noble Lord may not think it is right to want to do that, but it has that ability, and the proof that it has that ability is that it is exercising it right now. We might prefer that the EU took a different choice, but that is the choice it has taken, and we have to deal with reality. We cannot deal with the world as we wish it to be; we have to deal with the situation that we, and more importantly our producers and exporters, are in. There are delays, it is taking time and it is an administrative burden on their businesses. Veterinary checks are £200 a go, and it is not the right, responsible thing for a Government to allow that to continue without attempting to improve the situation. Since Brexit, services have done quite well. There is lots of evidence, particularly on financial services, that things are going much better. But this issue with goods and SPS is something that, from recollection, we had in our manifesto that we would attempt to get an agreement on. Most people would agree that a fix of some sort is needed. Critics always say that there are better options. Usually, they are referring to countries a very long way away or with much smaller flows, such as New Zealand, Canada and the US—places that really are not comparable. We have a land border with the EU where we do not want posts, guns and checks and all the things that you have on the US-Canada border. Those of us who have been to see the checks they impose would not want to see those sorts of things on our soil. The truth is that exporters are already following EU rules because they have to. The only difference now is that they will not have to pay with their time and their money for the privilege of doing so. In a sense, we are achieving what the EU told us we must not do, which is cherry picking. We have an agreement on something that we feel is in our best interests, after the EU spent a long time telling previous Governments that that was not going to be possible. This is all about us having the freedom to choose; it is a rational exercise of our sovereignty. Why would we want to maintain a separate, duplicate set of standards and rules that are 99% identical to Europe’s anyway, if it results in border checks, costs and delays? I hear the point about gene editing. I think I heard the Minister call this the ability to shape decisions, although we would not be at the table because we left. We will not be there to have the votes and vetoes that we may have had in the past, but we have the ability to shape decisions. The EU will have to consider the impact on the entirety of the market area, which will include the United Kingdom, for these goods, when it makes decisions in the future. There will be benefits and disadvantages at that point, and we will be able to use our influence. I have some confidence in our Diplomatic Service’s ability to do that. The bigger picture here is that we are in a volatile world, supply chains are fragile, food security is national security and trading seamlessly with our nearest neighbours strengthens our security and our resilience against global shocks—that is where we are in reality. Much as I respect, understand and have heard many times arguments from the noble Lord and others to the contrary, I am very pleased that the Government have got on with it. It is a choice that any proud, independent nation should be very glad to make.

More from Baroness Chapman of Darlington (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.