L

Lord Hannay of Chiswick (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

Sanitary and Phytosanitary Checks at EU Borders

Contribution

My Lords, it would be churlish to neglect to congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, on obtaining this timely debate. I do so congratulate him, even while recognising that the conclusions he and I draw in it are likely to be diametrically opposed. Before moving any further, I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, on a really remarkable maiden speech. I think all those who heard it will have benefited from it. I met Nelson Mandela at the United Nations, and it was a privilege to do so. If the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, is as successful in this House as she has been in her career before joining it, that will be a wonderful thing. This debate is timely, since tomorrow’s UK-EU meeting in Brussels will, I hope, put the seal on the negotiations between the two parties for a sanitary and phytosanitary agreement, which have been under way for several months. Such an agreement will be of clear benefit to both parties. There is no shadow of doubt that Brexit, and the lamentably skimpy trade and co-operation agreement that accompanied it, have inflicted serious damage on Britain’s agri-food industry, by piling bureaucracy and complex controls on a sector of our economy whose exports were growing steadily in the period before Brexit. The figures show that clearly enough. The markets in the rest of Europe are, by a very long way, our largest overseas market. This matters. British meat, fish, shellfish, cheese and many other agri-food projects have suffered grievously, and this agreement, if and when confirmed and implemented, will alleviate their position very considerably. Moreover—this is a point often overlooked by commentators—an SPS agreement will remove much of the bureaucracy still imposed on products moving to and from Northern Ireland, even after the Windsor Framework entered into force. Dislike of that framework seems to be blinding its critics to the benefits that this SPS agreement will bring to Northern Ireland. If you listen to the views of business, rather than to politicians, you will hear a rather different story. So, there is much for our exports; but there should also be benefits to British consumers from relieving continental European exporters from similar controls when exporting to the UK. A visit to any supermarket will show that that covers a multitude of products. Are there, then, no drawbacks? Well, the vociferous critics of a UK-EU SPS agreement—and they have been in full cry this morning—will dwell at length on the fact that the agreement means we will have to apply EU legislation, including changes to existing legislation, without having a full say in its shaping and adoption, in a process known as dynamic alignment. That will be the case. But those same critics were responsible in the first place for putting our agri-food industry in the damaging predicament it finds itself in. The assumption is that our diplomats and civil servants will supinely sit and watch changes being made to EU legislation that we would rather avoid. They will surely not do that, and this agreement seems to cover the ability to intervene in some of the shaping process. In the end, SPS, like many other policy areas, is a matter of making hard choices. Without an SPS agreement, such as we are debating, our agri-food industry will either have to accept the continuing damage to our largest export market, or they will have to adopt the bureaucracy and controls the EU imposes on imports from third countries themselves, which will impose costs on their own businesses: hardly a contribution to a sector that has the capacity to contribute to our future growth. The arguments I have referred to in my contribution to this debate make up, I suggest, a powerful case for going ahead with the agreement that will be on the table in Brussels tomorrow. I welcome the rather large number of new advocates for international law, who seem to have sprung up this morning in unlikely places, and from unlikely Members of the House. Long may they stay so when we next start talking about the European Convention on Human Rights. As for myself, I wish the Government well in this endeavour tomorrow to get an SPS agreement.

More from Lord Hannay of Chiswick (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.