B

Baroness Lawlor (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

Sanitary and Phytosanitary Checks at EU Borders

Contribution

My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, for securing this debate, and congratulate him. I also welcome the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong. She is not in her place at the moment, but I was very glad to hear her maiden speech. There are few in this House with the knowledge and experience of international trade of the former Secretary of State, the noble Lord, Lord Lilley. I have written about this myself, and I learn from the noble Lord each time I review what is happening in the world of international trade. He and other noble Lords have drawn our attention to the WTO rules and stipulations. Both we and the EU are members, and we have heard that the EU is constantly in breach of its SPS rules under the WTO. I would like to elaborate on some of the things that the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, pointed out. In applying the rules, as opposed to the rules themselves— Article 4— there must be a justification. SPS protections should be applied for no purpose other than ensuring food safety and be based, as far as possible, on an analysis of the scientific data. They should be consistent with international standards, whatever system we are applying; they should be able to adapt to local conditions, and they should choose the SPS measure which is least likely to depress the international trade purpose. All these conditions and stipulations on the application would be met were we to sign an equivalence-based SPS deal with the EU. In fact, none of them would be met by the current proposal, which looks as if it is going to go ahead tomorrow, to agree to put the UK under EU SPS law. I say this because, despite what the noble Baroness, Lady Chapman, said, the EU is itself in breach of international law. On that point, does the Minister agree that her Government are selective in their choice of which international treaties to break and which international treaties to follow? It is important that we know where the Labour Party—the Government—now stand. International treaties would be broken if we go ahead with this. It is not in the UK’s interests, and it cannot be justified for food safety measures on the basis of scientific data. Our existing international SPS agreements, with over 70 parties now since Brexit, are based on scientific evidence and conformity assessment, not on the code-based, unpredictive and untransparent basis of EU law, about which we know very little of what is coming down the line. There will be no security for our farming industry and agri-foods, because they will have no idea of what to expect next and how they will have to adapt. These laws on SPS do not adapt to local conditions as the WTO requires. The pesticides are not suitable for our climate conditions, which are often wetter in the UK and Ireland than in the EU. In the very wet parts of Normandy, you can get under-the-counter pesticides which are prohibited by EU law but are more suitable for combating pests in the damp and moist conditions in Normandy. Other countries break EU law because it is unsuitable, but I am afraid that this will not happen here. Nor is EU law transparent; we have heard about the 77 rules and regulations on Defra’s website, and we have heard—I was glad that the noble Lord mentioned it—that Defra officials said it would make the law transparent. Does the Minister, who has a farming background herself, think that our small farmers and small businesses will be in any position to understand the 77 laws that her department has published—including, to take one example, 191 pages of compliance regulations? This is an imposition on farming that cannot be justified by a Government who have the interests of our sector at stake. Finally, have the Government made a real costing of what these compliance burdens will be? Do they have any idea what taxpayers will be asked to pay just to support the farming industry, which has done so well under our own law? I draw the Minister’s and the House’s attention, not to the Anderson study for CropLife, but to the study by the fresh fruit importers. They are very concerned, because most of our fresh fruit is taken in from abroad. It is imported from non-EU countries, yet they will have to comply with EU laws. Have the Government taken account of the fact that this will raise prices in the supermarkets and may start restrictions, because those countries will feel it is not worthwhile to continue to sell their fresh fruit to the UK if they have to go through the whole paraphernalia of EU compliance law? It will be too expensive. Our customers, our buyers and our households may be short of goods. This is not consistent with the manifesto pledge. It goes far deeper than a mere veterinary agreement or the other two asks, neither of which was secured. This is a return to EU law. It puts our country in breach of international law, because we have signed treaties with other countries on the basis of the SPS deals we have made with them. I beg the noble Baroness to do what she can to mitigate this dreadful deal.

More from Baroness Lawlor (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.