B

Baroness Lawlor (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 November 2026

Debate

Complications from Abortions (Annual Report) Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, few can cavil with the aim of the Bill from the noble Lord, Lord Moylan. Even fewer would disagree that, in general, up-to-date information should be available to patients in deciding treatment that is available under the NHS. People should know about the complications and side-effects, and the information and statistical data should be available. I disagree that this should be kept, as some noble Lords have suggested, within the medical profession or the patients. It is a question of the wider availability of data on the possible health outcomes of treatment, particularly in cases where it is being publicly funded. I am delighted about the progress on patient records, but it is important that we have accessible data such as exists for many treatments. Whether it is osteoarthritis, lupus or the medication available, we should know, whether we are a patient, a doctor or a member of the public who wants to get briefed on what is available. Just to go back to the Private Member’s Bill from the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, he told us that a great deal of data exists at the moment, at least until 2023. We know about the HSA4 forms, which are compiled on the basis of ANS data, but those forms have their limitations; they have to be submitted within a fortnight and therefore they may not pick up treatments which have complications after a fortnight or which are reported elsewhere. Indeed, the DHSC itself has highlighted that these statistics should be treated with caution in view of some of the changes, including, of course, the change that medication can be taken entirely at home and therefore complications are likely to occur at home. The hospital episode statistics record data only for those admitted to hospitals and not those who are seen in A&E, ring 111 or may be in the out-patient department’s clinics. Therefore, the HES statistics are also limited. In fact, as with the ANS data, they do not record complications for which GPs are responsible, and neither does the 111 service. Clearly, however, both sets of data matter. We heard from the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, that the 2023 one-off report was very useful in putting the data together, so we understood that different sorts of complications were recorded in different sorts of data. This matters if you are trying to get to the bottom of many statistics which are available today. To conclude, it has been objected that this measure would exceptionalise abortion. The noble Lord, Lord Moylan, pointed out the requirements for reporting under the Act, and I add that abortion is an exceptional treatment. It has very different characteristics legally from other medical or quasi-medical procedures, and only the most hardened misanthrope could describe it as a treatment for illness, because it is not necessarily an illness for which one is being treated. One is being treated in line with a view or a choice which is made. I do not want to get into the abortion debate. However, it is important that women who opt for that treatment should have access to all the data, just as that is important for women who opt for any other treatment. In a proper parliamentary democracy, the report to Parliament is important. We should not restrict statistics and data on publicly funded activities provided on behalf of our Government. We should not have reports which are circulated privately to the profession of one group or another; they should be available to all in the interests of transparency and democracy.

More from Baroness Lawlor (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.