L

Lord Weir of Ballyholme (DUP)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 November 2026

Debate

Complications from Abortions (Annual Report) Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, I support the Bill from the noble Lord, Lord Moylan. Having heard the last few speakers, he may be glad that at least one person in the House supports his Bill. We know that the issue of abortion is highly controversial and particularly individual. I think everybody accepts that this is an incredibly sensitive topic. Given those sensitivities, it is right that we all take care over both language and tone in this debate, and I appreciate that all speakers so far have reflected this. It is also the case that there is a wide range of views on where abortion law should sit. Sometimes that is put into a very binary position of whether people are classified as being purely pro life or pro choice. However, it is more of a spectrum, because even those of us who are the most ardent pro-life supporters would certainly accept that there are a range of conditions and circumstances in which abortion is permitted and should be legally permitted. Similarly, I think the staunchest of pro-choice campaigners would accept that there should not simply be an unregulated system, and this should be about finding a legal balance between which circumstances are permissible and which are not. Some of us would take the view, particularly with recent changes, that the balance is not necessarily right, but the Bill does not change any of that. Similarly, that is the approach that we need to take in this country. We have always had this debate and, while it is a very passionate one, it has always been conducted in a civil and respectful manner. That contrasts with the position at times in the United States, where it has become a toxic issue that defines where politicians stand, sometimes even spilling over into those who would use violence to try to make their point. That is not a route that any of us want to go down. I always get slightly nervous when people start drawing comparisons and false analogies with any piece of legislation to suggest, however subtly, that this is some pathway down to where the United States is. We are a different people and a different country, and this is different legislation, and we need to bear that in mind. To that extent, therefore, we should be looking at where, within the context of this, we can find broad agreement. Surely all of us, irrespective of where we stand on the spectrum on abortion, believe it is right that women’s health and welfare should be put front and centre. At the heart of that is decision-making that is well informed. It is undoubtedly the case that events have changed rapidly over the last few years. The noble Lord, Lord Moylan, mentioned the shift from 48% to 85%. Statistics show that medications at home have risen from, I think, 34% to 72%. So we are seeing a rapidly shifting situation, and it is undoubtedly the case that the annual ANS statistics do not in and of themselves seem to reflect an entirely accurate position. Even when you exclude the issue of incomplete abortions, the HES statistics that were produced in 2023 would suggest a rate of complication 2.6 times higher than the ANS statistics. We are not suggesting that ANS statistics should be abandoned—it is right that those are continued—but this is something in a parallel track. It is also the case that it has sometimes been used by Ministers, of whatever persuasion, to say, “Well, these statistics cannot be produced, they’re impossible to produce, they’re impractical to produce”, and so on, but we know that these statistics can be produced because that is what happened in 2023. So that gives us a potential way forward. Lastly, for any of us who have ever been in government, the accusation is often thrown about that you are deciding policy and producing legislation on the basis of your own views or a party-political position, not something that is evidence driven. That does not mean that you do not sometimes have contrasting evidence, or indeed that sometimes a Minister cannot say, “For the greater good of society, despite the evidence, we believe this is the best way forward for our society”, but to deny any attempt at making that evidence more accurate and to keep that from public discourse and debate is the wrong course of action. We should therefore be striving to improve that information base and that evidence. I take on board the point that has been mentioned, that the level of complications is statistically very low. That may therefore be a level of reassurance to individuals rather than a deterrent to a particular course of action. But let us at least give policymakers and individuals making those decisions the best possible opportunity to decide for themselves on the basis of the most accurate information possible.

More from Lord Weir of Ballyholme (DUP)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.