Contribution
My Lords, it is a pleasure to support the Bill of the noble Lord, Lord Dodds. At the outset, I associate myself with his deepest condolences to my noble friend and colleague Lord Morrow on his tragic double loss this week.
In the stream of statutory instruments that we deal with in this House that have arisen from the protocol/Windsor Framework, a number of us have raised a range of concerns, from the damage to the constitutional integrity of the United Kingdom to the outrage around the democratic deficit of having laws imposed on us, over which no one ultimately has a say or control, to the level of economic damage that is being created to Northern Ireland, from being dislocated from our main market in Great Britain, from the reduction in consumer choice and from the barriers put in place for firms in Great Britain. We are in the very strange situation where, given the frictions of bringing goods to Northern Ireland, it is easier—there are fewer barriers—to bring them from Dubrovnik rather than Dundee, Nicosia rather than Newport or Malmö rather than Makerfield. That is the economic reality that we are faced with.
However justified our complaints and concerns are, today’s debate is about providing a positive solution to those problems. At times, in some of these debates, Government Ministers make sympathetic noises and state that they understand the problems that many of us face, but ask, in effect, “What is the alternative?”
The Bill offers a practical and better alternative. It genuinely defends the key cornerstone of the Belfast agreement: cross-community support. That has been uniquely abrogated under the protocol and is not central simply to the Good Friday agreement; it has been the cornerstone of policy for more than half a century that it is only with a buy-in from both unionists and nationalists that we can have proper balance within Northern Ireland.
Crucially, the Bill goes to the issue of respect, particularly self-respect. That we are in a situation where we have laws simply imposed upon us in over 300 areas of law is unacceptable. In recent statutory instruments, the Government have not even consulted on them. That is probably a reflection of reality. Consultation would be a façade, because no matter how many objections there are to the EU clause, nobody can do anything about them.
Famously and historically, the Germans facilitated Lenin on a sealed train from Zurich to Petrograd. No one could interfere with that train and contact Lenin, and it whizzed through Germany and neutral territory. Today, the train of EU laws, as regards Northern Ireland, is in a similar position. At Westminster and in the Assembly, we find ourselves standing at a station on that train’s route. We cannot interfere with its contents, stop the train or change its course of direction. That is not self-respect or mutual respect.
There are probably still some in this country, at one end of the scale, who would view the EU with the old headline: “Fog in Channel, continent isolated”. Still more, there are others who take the view that we will throw in the kitchen sink to get whatever concessions we can get off the EU. As we have seen with the current discussions, the danger of that is that we find ourselves in the bizarre situation where we appear potentially to be extending the situation in which laws are made, over which we have no control whatever, for the whole of the United Kingdom. It is not simply that: we actually pay a price to even have that position. That is not mutual respect. The sensible solutions of mutual enforcement that arise out of the Bill respect us and the EU—both sides—where regulations can be enforced in both jurisdictions. A proper relationship should not be one that is, in effect, subservient on either side but one in which there is mutual respect.
In conclusion, we face a choice between democracy and imposition, national integrity and constitutional division, cross-community votes and imposition, and, ultimately, between mutual respect and subjugation to laws. I know which one of those two paths we would be wisest to pick.