B

Baroness Ludford (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 November 2026

Debate

European Union (Withdrawal Arrangements) Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, knows that I do not agree with the Bill, which is a reiteration of other such Bills, including the Northern Ireland Protocol Bill, and involves unilateral derogation from treaty obligations. But I hope he also knows the regard and respect in which I hold him—I consider us friends, as fellow members of the Northern Ireland Scrutiny Committee of this House. I am very conscious of the gap in my knowledge and experience compared with those on our committee—and not on our committee—who come from Northern Ireland. I am conscious of the constitutional, political and practical issues raised by the Windsor Framework. Obviously, the noble Lord and others know that I would not start from here: it was clear that Brexit was going to have a major and damaging impact on Northern Ireland, and my view, for what it is worth, is that only return or rejoin could solve the problems of being a rule-taker without a vote. The noble Lord, Lord Bew, was understandably reproachful that the EU withdrawal arrangements failed to take account of the Good Friday/Belfast agreement. I can only concur with the words of our committee’s chairman, the noble Lord, Lord Carlile, in the debate that we had in May on the committee’s report on Northern Ireland after Brexit, who said that “the Windsor Framework is a complex amalgam of diplomacy, politics and sheer necessity, conjured from shakily designed foundations … it bears all the characteristics of having occurred, rather than having been designed. However, it is what Northern Ireland has to live with”.—[Official Report, 25/3/26; cols. GC 223-24.] However, as I said in that debate, my focus on the committee is not on rediscussing Brexit or the merits or demerits of the Windsor Framework, but on “how I can contribute to understanding and trying to resolve the practical challenges and difficulties for businesses, other organisations and consumers in Northern Ireland”.—[Official Report, 25/3/26; col. GC 258.] As we have heard, the reset and dynamic alignment are going to project some of these issues on to the whole of the UK, so at least there will be some heavier lifting coming into play on behalf of the UK Government, which should ease the pressure on Northern Ireland alone. I said in May’s debate that: “The fact that the Windsor Framework arrangements can be described to the committee as being of ‘labyrinthine complexity’ … is not only a poor service to the people of Northern Ireland, to put it mildly, but a poor omen for reception of the output from the reset”.—[Official Report, 25/3/26; col. GC 261.] The timely report from our Lords European Affairs Committee this week makes clear the challenges of dynamic alignment. It makes excellent proposals for maximising decision shaping—which can only be decision shaping; we have no vote—improving governmental machinery, including the resources of UKMis, the UK mission to the EU in Brussels, and increasing parliamentary scrutiny. In the meantime, reports from the Northern Ireland Scrutiny Committee and the review from the noble Lord, Lord Murphy, who is with us, as well as from elsewhere, have highlighted the practical steps that could and should be taken to make the conditions for Northern Ireland businesses and consumers less bureaucratic and UK-EU trade more free-flowing. These are issues such as: the one-stop shop; trusted trader status for the haulage industry; the office of the Northern Ireland Executive in Brussels to be properly staffed by people able to influence EU legislation at an early stage; better resourcing for the Democratic Scrutiny Committee of the Northern Ireland Assembly; and a database of emerging EU laws. I was pleased to see that the European Affairs Committee report on dynamic alignment devotes a whole page to this point, and we made it a point in the Northern Ireland Scrutiny Committee report. It is absolutely essential that there is a comprehensive source of knowledge about what is emerging from the EU and what exists. We need better co-operation from the Northern Ireland Executive with Westminster committees. The noble Lord, Lord Dodds, mentioned in our May debate how the First Minister of Northern Ireland vetoed the Deputy First Minister giving evidence to our committee, which is unhelpful, to say the least. We also have the important role of InterTrade UK, chaired by our committee colleague, the noble Baroness, Lady Foster. I accept that the reset and alignment do not remove the customs and VAT arrangements for Northern Ireland, and those issues remain. However, an all-UK effort and heft will help Northern Ireland in the immediate future, sharing the pain around, if you like. I am afraid that the Bill from the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, does not appeal to me. I like him a great deal better than I like his Bill.

More from Baroness Ludford (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.