B

Baroness Finn (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 November 2026

Debate

European Union (Withdrawal Arrangements) Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, I too offer my condolences to the noble Lord, Lord Morrow, on the death of his daughter and wife last weekend. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Dodds of Duncairn, for bringing this Bill to the House. It touches on two fundamental issues: the relationship between the United Kingdom and the European Union, and the relationship between Great Britain and Northern Ireland. I will speak first to the status of Northern Ireland within the United Kingdom, before turning briefly to the wider question of the Government’s EU reset, which I have no doubt will be the main focus of public debate during the EU summit this weekend. The Windsor Framework, concluded by the previous Conservative Government, was a valiant attempt to address the issues with the old Northern Ireland protocol while protecting Northern Ireland’s access to the internal market and keeping Northern Ireland in the EU single market for goods. It also sought to avoid the need for a hard border in the Irish Sea while protecting the border settlement on the island of Ireland which was reached following the Good Friday agreement. The Official Opposition are committed to protecting Northern Ireland’s position within the United Kingdom. Although the Windsor Framework, taken alongside the subsequent Safeguarding the Union Command Paper, represented a significant improvement on the old protocol negotiated in 2019, we recognise that it was not a perfect document. I think there is some agreement between the Government and the Official Opposition on that point, and we will support the Government where they take steps to improve the position of Northern Ireland without making us rule-takers from the EU. We recognise that small businesses are still facing ongoing difficulties with the processes required to move goods from Great Britain to Northern Ireland. The Institute of Directors has called on the Government to improve business guidance for Great Britain firms to encourage more trade with Northern Ireland. What steps are Ministers taking to provide practical support to businesses in that context? As my honourable friend Alex Burghart said in the other place in December 2024, it is our view “that the Windsor framework with ‘Safeguarding the Union’ is a better solution than the Windsor framework was; that the Windsor framework was a better solution than the protocol; and that the protocol was a better option than the backstop. However, that does not mean that there are not better solutions available”.—[Official Report, Commons, 6/12/24; col. 630.] I say to the noble Lord, Lord Dodds of Duncairn, that we will always seek to work constructively with all the Northern Ireland parties to secure a brighter future for Northern Ireland within our United Kingdom. As some noble Lords have pointed out, the Windsor Framework has made some improvements to the defects in the original protocol, but as many noble Lords, such as the noble Lord, Lord Bew, have also mentioned, significant problems remain. As an Opposition, as my noble friend Lord Caine has previously said, we have never taken the view that the Windsor Framework was the final word in what is an evolving institution. We will look at constructive proposals for change, including some of the ones that have been raised by noble Lords today, consistent with the constitutional integrity of the United Kingdom and Northern Ireland’s position within it. Turning to the broader context of the Bill and the Prime Minister’s so-called EU reset, I hope that the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, and I will find ourselves united on this point. Of course, at a basic level, the reset is merely a distraction from a Prime Minister who is reticent to take the tough decisions on domestic policy, whether on welfare, the cost and burden of regulations that are holding business back or the NHS and social care. The Prime Minister has a penchant for the feel-good press release, but still we have not seen him commit to taking the difficult decisions that the Prime Minister’s role demands. We need only to look at the missed opportunity of the Budget to see evidence of that. We on these Benches are firmly opposed to any steps that make the United Kingdom subject to rules over which we have no say. Making the United Kingdom a rule-taker while paying for the privilege is unacceptable. Beyond that, the very premise of Brexit was to grant us the freedoms to carve out our own future in the world, allowing us to secure trade deals with Australia, New Zealand, Japan, India and Singapore, and set rules that promote our own high-growth sectors, such as agritech, digital and life sciences. Can the Minister say whether the Prime Minister’s EU reset will put our landmark trade deals with Australia and New Zealand at risk? What does it mean for the Government’s own trade deal with India? What concerns have his ministerial counterparts in Australia, New Zealand and India raised with the Government on this? It is not merely the risk of future harm that we should consider. The Prime Minister’s decision to set the United Kingdom on a path back toward ever-closer union has created uncertainty for businesses about the regulatory framework that will apply to the United Kingdom in future. Even commentators who support the proposed SPS deal with the EU recognise the difficult questions it raises. I quote: “Behind the positive headlines lie many difficult questions about pesticides, agricultural competitiveness, border inspections, food fraud, scientific independence and, perhaps most significantly, the future roles and responsibilities of the Food Standards Agency”. These are not my words but the words of Professor Chris Elliott, professor of food safety at Queen’s University Belfast. Uncertainty over an SPS agreement with the EU is extremely concerning to the UK precision breeding sector, an area where the UK has taken advantage of our new freedoms to diverge from the EU. The European Affairs Committee, chaired by the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, said in its recent forensic report on dynamic alignment: “Immediate and complete dynamic alignment in this area would therefore curtail the regime established in England” under the precision breeding Act, and recommended that the Government seek exemptions for the sector in any agreement with the EU. Can the Minister reassure the House that the Government will seek to protect our precision breeding sector from the EU’s more restrictive regulatory regime? As I have said, these Benches cannot accept any deal that makes the UK subject to EU rules without any say over what those rules look like. Yes, we want to see cheaper energy prices—something that can be achieved only by the Government abandoning their costly obsession with net zero. Yes, people want to see lower food prices—something that is not helped by covering the best and most versatile agricultural land with solar panels and endangering our trade deals with New Zealand and Australia. But no, the British people do not want to return to the uncertainty and acrimony of the years when these Benches fought tooth and nail to deliver the democratic instruction given by 17 million voters in the face of those who sought to overturn the mandate. I look forward to the Minister’s reply.

More from Baroness Finn (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.