L

Lord in Waiting/Government Whip (Lord Katz) (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 November 2026

Debate

European Union (Withdrawal Arrangements) Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, before I turn to the substance of today’s debate, I know the whole House will wish to join me, the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, and the noble Baroness, Lady Finn, in extending our deepest, most heartfelt condolences to the noble Lord, Lord Morrow, and his family following the devastating loss of his wife Jennifer and his daughter Rachel on Sunday. May their memories be always a blessing. Our thoughts and prayers are with him, his friends and his family at this unimaginably difficult time. Let me also express my sincere thanks to all noble Lords who have contributed to today’s debate, and to the noble Lord, Lord Dodds of Duncairn, for introducing the Bill and outlining his views with his customary clarity and conviction. The Government are wholly committed to both the Windsor Framework and the United Kingdom internal market. It is precisely because of that commitment that the Government must express clear reservations regarding the noble Lord’s proposals in his Bill. Throughout the debate, a number of noble Lords, including the noble Lords, Lord Frost and Lord Lilley, have talked about the temporary nature of the Windsor Framework arrangements. Both the UK and the EU have repeatedly restated their commitment to these arrangements. This has taken place through the agreement of the Windsor Framework and subsequent decisions; indeed, the Northern Ireland Assembly voted for the arrangements to continue in 2024. While I fully respect the sincerity with which the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, advances his case, the Government have three fundamental concerns with the Bill, which I am sure will not come as a huge surprise to the noble Lord and his supporters. First, it cannot be reconciled with international law. Secondly, it does not adequately account for Northern Ireland’s unique circumstances following our exit from the European Union. Thirdly, it would reintroduce considerable uncertainty for businesses and traders over the rules that apply in Northern Ireland. In the Government’s view, these outcomes will be damaging for the United Kingdom, for our international standing and for Northern Ireland’s continued economic growth. At the same time, we should recognise the practical progress the Government have delivered by working constructively with the European Union since the Bill was introduced on 3 June. We have begun the operational rollout of the £16.6 million United Kingdom internal market package committed at the Autumn Budget in November 2025, delivering targeted support to help local traders navigate the Windsor Framework. Today, as many noble Lords mentioned, we will agree an SPS deal with the EU that, through its interplay with the Windsor Framework, will remove the vast majority of checks and paperwork on agri-food goods moving from Great Britain to Northern Ireland. This will promote consumer choice and generate new opportunities for businesses trading into Northern Ireland. I think the noble Lord, Lord Shinkwin, brought this up, and the interplay of the Windsor Framework and the SPS agreement will facilitate the smooth flow of agri-foods and plants, protect the UK’s internal market and reduce costs to businesses. They will save hours of time and money as this will remove swathes of paperwork, numerous health certificates and processes. Linking carbon markets will also bring significant benefits for UK businesses, including access to a larger, more liquid carbon market, fewer regulatory barriers and protection from new border taxes. We have also maintained the Trader Support Service to ensure that traders continue to receive free, expert digital assistance at no cost to business. We have ensured that the Windsor Framework facilitations are fully utilised to ensure the smooth flow of goods. Although I recognise that the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, and others may favour a different approach to our relationship with the European Union, I believe the evidence shows that this Government’s approach is delivering results. Major employers serving communities across Northern Ireland have been clear that negotiated practical solutions remove barriers on the ground. As Marks & Spencer noted in its evidence to Parliament, our sanitary and phytosanitary agreement “is a huge step forward. It is exactly the kind of pragmatic deal we have been hoping for, and … will remove … ‘Not for EU’ labelling” costs, speed up the flow of fresh produce and unlock new investment and jobs across Northern Ireland. Indeed, this sentiment is echoed across industry, from Asda and Morrisons to the British Poultry Council, Logistics UK and the Horticultural Trades Association. The Bill would inadvertently set aside that hard-won economic progress. Equally, the Bill does not take full account of the genuine progress that the Government have also made in delivering the commitments set out in Safeguarding the Union, from the switch-on of the UK internal market guarantee and significant strengthening of the UK internal market system to delivering UK-wide arrangements for the supply of both human and veterinary medicines. However, I fully recognise the sincere desire across the House, voiced by so many noble Lords, for further progress to be made by the Government. We have heard a range of contributions this morning, delivered with characteristic care, insight and eloquence. I now turn to the substance of the Bill and will reflect on the two primary reasons, as I have already stated, why the Government cannot support it today. First, the Bill cannot be reconciled with international law and would set aside the substantial progress that we are delivering with the European Union on a negotiated basis, of which we are seeing the fruit today. The Government are committed to the rule of law and to honouring the UK’s international obligations. Departing from those commitments would place in jeopardy the new and beneficial arrangements that we have announced with the European Union, including those being taken forward at the UK-EU summit in Brussels today. The resulting unilateralism and uncertainty would not serve the interests of business. Many noble Lords, such as the noble Lords, Lord Dodds, Lord Bew, Lord Frost and Lord Weir of Ballyholme, and the noble Baroness, Lady Finn, referred to the democratic deficit and were disparaging of the dynamic alignment that we are agreeing. This dynamic alignment means that, where required by agreements, the UK applies the same rules, at the same time, on an ongoing basis. The UK will have the ability to shape EU decision-making in these areas to ensure that UK views are taken into account. This is a sovereign choice by this Government to align in specific sectors where it is in our national interest to do so. Most British exporters are already de facto aligned with EU standards to keep selling their goods. As set out in the common understanding, the UK will have a decision-shaping role. The Commission will consult the UK in an early stage of policy-making so that the UK can contribute to the shaping of new rules as they are being developed. Parliament will rightly have a say in this process. The cost of not aligning is added bureaucracy to UK businesses, which would have to spend valuable time every day not looking after customers but completing onerous paperwork and exercises. All noble Lords would wish to avoid this. The noble Lords, Lord Dodds and Lord Bew, mentioned Article 1 and the constitutional status of the island of Ireland. The consent vote was created to ensure that the framework continues to operate on the basis of agreeing the support of elected representatives in Northern Ireland. It is a process unique to Northern Ireland that did not exist at the point of the Good Friday agreement, nor does it exist under devolution elsewhere. The vote is premised on cross-community support; it requires an independent review and means that the next vote is in four years rather than eight. The Supreme Court has already upheld that these arrangements are consistent with the Northern Ireland Act 1998. Ultimately, it is right that such a change of trading arrangements that address the unique circumstances in Northern Ireland should rely on a majority in the Assembly. I fully respect that the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, and others would prefer the United Kingdom to have a very different relationship with the EU. However, that is not the message we have heard from commerce and industry, with the Confederation of British Industry noting that a sanitary and phytosanitary agreement is a “significant win” for businesses in Northern Ireland, and the British Chambers of Commerce likewise expressing strong support. It would not serve those businesses well to depart from agreed rules in a way that disrupts the implementation of trading arrangements they themselves have sought and welcomed. Even where the noble Lord takes a different view of our relationship with the EU, I hope he shares our view that we must safeguard the United Kingdom’s credibility as a reliable partner that honours its commitments on the world stage. A unilateral approach would inevitably cause businesses and investors to question which rules will be respected in future, affecting our standing with a wide range of international partners. Secondly, the Bill does not offer a substantial resolution to Northern Ireland’s unique circumstances. While I understand and respect the strength of feeling on this issue, I gently suggest to the noble Lord that the Bill does not address the practical realities on the ground in a more stable or durable manner than the Windsor Framework. The fundamental challenge arising from our exit from the EU remains—a challenge left unanswered by the Bill. How do we preserve the integrity of the United Kingdom’s internal market, avoid a hard border on the island of Ireland and respect the legitimate interest of our European neighbours in protecting their single market, just as we protect ours? If straightforward alternatives to that challenge had been readily deliverable in practice, they would have been implemented long ago. Proposals such as technological solutions or mutual enforcement, referenced by the noble Lords, Lord Lilley, Lord Dodds and Lord Moynihan of Chelsea, are well intentioned but they do not fully account for the practical realities of physical infrastructure and border controls seen across international borders worldwide. The noble Lord, Lord Lilley, made reference to arrangements prior to the EU single market and the removal of border posts, but he ignores the reality that those EU countries were already following harmonised rules for certain products. The situation is not comparable to that of the island of Ireland. As for the comparison with New Zealand made by the noble Lord, Lord Moynihan of Chelsea, I gently suggest that trade with a small country on the other side of the planet is not entirely comparable to trade with our European partners and the situation on the island of Ireland. I recognise that, for some, avoiding a hard border on the island of Ireland was never viewed as the overriding priority. Yet across successive elections, it has remained a vital concern for the electorate—for good reason, given its impact on border communities, integrated cross-border businesses and, above all, the preservation of peace and stability in Northern Ireland. Even where noble Lords hold different perspectives, I hope they will recognise the clear democratic mandate given to successive Parliaments to avoid a hard border. This Bill would place existing facilitations in jeopardy, along with the extensive work undertaken with businesses to ensure that dual market access operates effectively. I acknowledge the many thoughtful points made by noble Lords on where further improvements can be made, and the Government will continue to engage constructively with your Lordships’ House and other stakeholders on those suggestions. However, the right response for businesses cannot be to dismantle the framework on which they currently rely and to return Northern Ireland to the prolonged uncertainty that preceded the Windsor Framework. Nor was such an outcome the wish of the Northern Ireland Assembly in December 2024. When given the democratic choice to discontinue these arrangements by a simple majority, the Assembly voted instead to retain them while commissioning an independent review from my noble friend Lord Murphy of Torfaen. The Government have responded to that review and work is actively under way to implement the commitments made in the Government’s response. The noble Lord, Lord Bew, mentioned those commitments. For the sake of time, I will not go into the long list that I have, but I will pick out one or two. For instance, we continue to take forward the delivery of the Northern Ireland business support service—the one-stop shop that provides a single accessible regulatory hub to help small and medium-sized enterprises navigate trading requirements smoothly. I am pleased to say that we remain on course to have the core service operational within this financial year. We have also ensured a reliable supply of veterinary medicines to Northern Ireland and taken forward the funding committed for Intertrade UK. There are more ways in which we have met the recommendations that my noble friend Lord Murphy made; we understand that these are important, and that is why we are acting on them. Just as it would not be right to overturn Northern Ireland’s dual market access lightly, it would not be proportionate to set aside the Assembly’s democratic vote and the findings of that independent review. Just as we must be candid about the consequences of this Bill, we must also recognise the tangible benefits of the Windsor Framework. Together, these arrangements affirm in domestic and international law Northern Ireland’s constitutional place in the union and its economic place in the UK’s internal market. I hope that that, as clearly as any other point in this speech, answers those who asked somewhat sarcastically whether this Government believe that Northern Ireland has a place in the United Kingdom. Of course we do. Time and again at this Dispatch Box, I and my noble friends on the Front Bench have made it very clear that Northern Ireland is an integral part of the United Kingdom. Are the arrangements durable under international law, accounting for Northern Ireland’s particular circumstances in a manner that avoids a hard border on the island of Ireland? Are they actively benefiting businesses, smoothing the flow of trade and reducing bureaucracy? More than 15,000 traders are now signed up to the UK internal market scheme, and more than 1,200 operators are registered for the Northern Ireland retail movement scheme and the Northern Ireland plant health label. The noble Lord, Lord Weir of Ballyholme, talked about the perception that Northern Ireland is second class within the UK. The Windsor Framework plainly ensures that Northern Ireland’s businesses have unfettered access to their most important market in Great Britain, while maintaining their privileged access to the whole of the EU market without customs duties or unnecessary checks.

More from Lord in Waiting/Government Whip (Lord Katz) (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.