European Union (Withdrawal Arrangements) Bill [HL]
Friday, 20 November 2026
Contributions
Second Reading
Moved by
Lord Dodds of Duncairn
That the Bill be now read a second time.
Lord Dodds of Duncairn (DUP)
My Lords, before I begin, I express my heartfelt condolences—I am sure all of us in your Lordships’ House do this morning—to my noble friend Lord Morrow, who would have been with us today but who lost both his wife and daughter earlier this week. He and his family circle are in our thoughts and prayers today. The purpose of this Bill is to address one of the most important unresolved constitutional questions arising from the UK’s departure from the European Union: why should the people of Northern Ireland be denied the democratic rights enjoyed by fellow citizens elsewhere in the United Kingdom? The fundamental defects of the protocol and Windsor Framework have not been resolved. Some practical difficulties have been eased, but the underlying, undemocratic mess remains, in essence, intact. Northern Ireland remains subject to a substantial body of European law across approximately 300 areas of legislation—not 300 laws, but areas of legislation—which can be imposed without the consent of this Parliament or the Northern Ireland Assembly. Neither legislature can amend or repeal them. There is a continuing denial of democracy in Northern Ireland. Today, we will hear a lot about the reset and its benefits for Northern Ireland will no doubt be highlighted. However, a reset that does not remedy the core problems that Northern Ireland faces, whether democratic, constitutional or economic, cannot be regarded as a success. The proposed sanitary and phytosanitary arrangements may reduce certain trade frictions, but will not remove the underlying Irish Sea customs border or other damaging impositions. Indeed, Northern Ireland now faces the prospect of a new EU customs code, against which the Stormont brake was invoked just this week, but that was overruled by the Government, demonstrating the falsehoods of those who said it would be an effective way for Northern Ireland to stop damaging EU law applying, and showing the incoherence of a Government who say that the existence of a trade border across the English Channel is intolerable and fails the Makerfield test, yet apply it to Northern Ireland. To those who herald the approach being taken by the Government for greater alignment, are we being asked to accept that the solution to Northern Ireland’s democratic deficit is to extend that democratic deficit to the rest of the United Kingdom? The answer to the denial of democratic rights in one part of our country cannot be to dilute those rights in the rest of it; it is to restore them in Northern Ireland. As far as the Belfast agreement is concerned, the current arrangements actually breach that agreement, yet we are told they are necessary to protect it. The agreement established cross-community consent as a central safeguard in Northern Ireland’s political institutions. Yet, in December 2024, when the Assembly voted on continuing the application of EU law, the normal cross-community consent was uniquely set aside for this extremely important vote. Every unionist MLA who voted opposed continuation, but the arrangements were still approved. How can arrangements of such profound constitutional importance be considered sustainable when they lack the support of one of the communities in Northern Ireland? My Bill would restore the cross-community consent requirement, which is at the heart of the Belfast agreement. We are told that that agreement must be protected, but that must include the consent of both traditions and communities, and must include no change to Northern Ireland’s constitutional status without the agreement of its people. The economic consequences of the current arrangements remain very serious. Our overwhelmingly important trading relationship is with the rest of the country, obviously. It is not a commercial relationship between foreign countries but within the United Kingdom, yet the Irish Sea border has imposed customs procedures, regulatory requirements and additional costs on that trade. We hear much about green lanes and simplified procedures, but reducing the administrative consequences of a border is not the same as removing it. The recent report by Maureen O’Reilly, commissioned by the Northern Ireland Department for the Economy itself, identifies very large administrative and compliance difficulties for business, “reduced engagement from GB suppliers” regulatory divergence and particular challenges for smaller businesses. Those are not highlighted by the Government, of course; they pick on one or two bigger companies to illustrate what they want to prove. The Federation of Small Businesses found that 58% of surveyed businesses trading between Great Britain and Northern Ireland report moderate to significant challenges, while over a third reported ceasing trade rather than dealing with the new compliance arrangements. This must change. Northern Ireland’s right to participate fully in the United Kingdom’s internal market should not depend on temporary derogations, exemptions or concessions from Brussels; it should be a natural consequence of belonging to the United Kingdom. My Bill presents an alternative. The Bill before your Lordships seeks to replace the present arrangements with a framework which restores the integrity of the United Kingdom’s internal market by protecting legitimate trading interests on both sides of the border, and which removes the necessity for foreign jurisdiction over large swathes of our economy. Central to that approach is mutual enforcement. The principle is straightforward: each jurisdiction would take responsibility for ensuring that goods exported into the other’s market comply with the destination market’s requirements. It is an alternative that was developed by respected European legal and policy experts, and those within the Commission, at the outset of all the Brexit negotiations. Compliance could be enforced through obligations on exporters, electronic declarations, remote payment of duties and substantial penalties for breaches. Some still argue that removing the Irish Sea border between Great Britain and Northern Ireland inevitably means creating a hard border on the island of Ireland. That is clearly nonsense. The Bill provides a means of ensuring there is no hard border in any direction. The Belfast agreement does not require the United Kingdom and the Irish Republic to share customs or regulatory territory. The border already exists for legal, fiscal and administrative purposes. We have different currencies, for goodness’ sake, and different tax regimes, never mind the political differences. The challenge is to manage the border, as we do in all those other areas, without unnecessary physical infrastructure or disruption to everyday life, and it can be done. Mutual enforcement provides a serious alternative, worthy of proper examination. Of course there are practical challenges, as with any solution, but these are not a reason to abandon the search for a workable and politically acceptable solution across the board in Northern Ireland. The Government need to explain why these alternatives cannot be pursued, instead of treating the Windsor Framework/protocol as the only possible answer. If people refuse to countenance a solution that removes the friction on north-south trade and east-west trade and restores democracy over lawmaking to the Assembly and to Parliament, in the interests of both unionists and nationalists—because whether you are a unionist or nationalist Member of the Northern Ireland Assembly, you should want to have control over the laws that apply to the people of Northern Ireland—and if they will not address why that is unacceptable, their true motivations in persisting with the current set-up need to be called out. Some might argue that this Bill is incompatible with international law, but international law cannot be invoked selectively. Article 1 of the protocol expressly recognises the need to protect the Belfast agreement in all its dimensions, with the consent of both communities, to respect the essential state functions and territorial integrity of the United Kingdom. Article 16 recognises that serious economic difficulties and diversion of trade may require safeguards. The United Nations declaration on friendly relations recognises the importance of respecting the national unity and territorial integrity of states. That has clearly been breached by the Windsor Framework/protocol in respect of Northern Ireland. Clauses 1 and 17 of my Bill expressly address that principle. The Government must explain how the present arrangements can be reconciled with these fundamental commitments. A durable settlement must restore the principle that the people of Northern Ireland should enjoy the same democratic rights as their fellow citizens. The people of Northern Ireland are not asking for preferential treatment; they are asking for the same practical rights, protections and democratic entitlements enjoyed elsewhere in our country. It is called equal citizenship. The choice is clear: the Government will shortly bring forward their EU partnership Bill to dynamically align with EU law so as to manage the border problem by extending EU colony status in those areas to the rest of the UK. This Bill proposes a better solution. It would end Northern Ireland’s EU colony status, bring it into line with the rest of the country and thus bring Brexit to the whole of the UK. For those reasons, I beg to move.
Lord Lilley (Con)
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, on bringing forward this Bill, which would end a situation that no other country in the world would tolerate indefinitely. He proposes mutual enforcement, and I want first to examine whether that is a practical alternative to the present arrangements. It involves Britain making it illegal to export to the EU goods that would be illegal in the EU, and requiring those doing so to pay EU tariffs before doing so. Any checks to ensure that that was happening would be carried out at the point of dispatch or the point of delivery. The presumption of mutual enforcement is that the EU would reciprocate. In fact, that is not necessary. Throughout the withdrawal process, HMRC repeatedly told Select Committees of this House that there were no circumstances in which it would require border posts to police trade from the south to the north—it is desirable that the EU reciprocates but not necessary. Would it work? Well, it has worked. People forget that, prior to the introduction of the single market in 1992, there were border posts within Europe at the borders between France and Germany, Italy and Austria, and so on, where goods travelling between member countries, which operated different standards for SPS and other goods conditions, were checked. I was there; I saw it all happening. The European Commission did not like having border posts checking the transit of goods within the European Union, so it passed a directive saying that those border posts must go and that instead there would be mutual enforcement, and the enforcement would be carried out at the point of dispatch or the point of delivery. I have here a copy of the directive that enforced it—it is called Council Directive 89/662 of 11 December 1989, and it spells it all out. It worked. It is an EU piece of law. We can copy and paste it and use it in Northern Ireland. The second question is whether we can get there legally. The present arrangements are an intrinsically temporary provision. We know that because the EU told us that when it was negotiating the withdrawal agreement. We wanted to negotiate the future trade arrangements and the withdrawal arrangements in parallel, and the EU said, “No, you can’t do that. We can’t negotiate future permanent trade arrangements with the United Kingdom until it is no longer a member state”. European law did not allow that—so we said that we would go along with it, and negotiate the withdrawal agreement first and then the trade arrangements. But then the EU said, “Oh, but we must include in the withdrawal agreement the trading arrangements for the Northern Ireland border, because we don’t know what the situation will be at the point you leave, or whether there’ll be any kind of trade agreement between the United Kingdom and the EU, and we have to deal with that”. We said, “Fair enough”. But the EU said, “We can do that legally, as long as it’s temporary and transitional”. So the trade arrangements, including in the withdrawal agreement, are temporary and transitional in EU law; they have to come to an end in due course. I asked about this at the time in Parliament, and the Attorney-General said that yes, that is the case, and that if the EU tried to continue with these arrangements indefinitely, and someone in the EU took a case to the European Court to say that they were disadvantaged because the arrangements applying in Northern Ireland do not apply in Sicily or wherever, “they would win”—those were his words. It would be deemed to be a temporary and transitional arrangement. Now there are others who say that we cannot enforce that in the EU, as we have no rights to bring cases to the ECJ. What if the Europeans change their mind and say, “Well, we now think our legal judgment then was wrong, and what we’ve done is permanent and indefinite”? In that case, the EU was negotiating in bad faith. For the same reasons, we can bring an end to this arrangement, which is intolerable, when we wish, and we should do so. No self-respecting country would allow a division between parts of itself, leaving some of its citizens to have no say in its laws indefinitely. Would France allow a border between Corsica and the Hexagon? Would Italy allow a border between Sicily and mainland Italy? Would they allow their citizens in those separate islands and provinces to have no say in their laws, indefinitely? Maybe as a temporary and transitional arrangement they would, as we have done, but we should not allow it to go on permanently. We have the legal right to do so and the practical means of doing so in EU law.
Lord Bew (CB)
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, on securing this debate on a critical day, as it happens, in our relationship with the European Union. I am particularly glad to note the way in which the noble Lord framed the argument in relation to the withdrawal agreement and its relationship to the Good Friday agreement. One of my most unhappy moments when the original withdrawal agreement came forward in this House was to say that it was incompatible with the Good Friday/Belfast agreement. There was a strong sense that I was the only person in the House who had read that agreement. The withdrawal agreement was supposed to be compatible with, and to strengthen, the Good Friday/Belfast agreement. It is one of my most unhappy memories. The other key point—the constitutional garden of Eden referenced in the Bill from the noble Lord, Lord Dodds—is much less satisfactory. It is the Act of Union 1800 which he refers to as the golden reference point that we ought to be getting back to. That includes customs and excise between Ireland and Britain. If we applied it today, Irish whiskey from Northern Ireland would, to give a simple example, cost three times more in the UK market. When he was introducing the Act of Union, Pitt said he wanted free trade, but for practical reasons it could not be. Almost inevitably, a small part of the United Kingdom, at times, loses out in international agreements that the larger part of the United Kingdom thinks are necessary and desirable. It seems to me that that is political reality. That is essentially what has happened in this case. The Windsor Framework at least started from the point of view that you could not just walk willy-nilly over the Good Friday agreement and say that it was not a problem. It tried to mend, and did, at least some of the difficulties that we face in Northern Ireland, but by no means all. It is a fundamental point of political reality that a smaller part of the United Kingdom is likely to find itself locked into international agreements over time that are in the interests of a larger part. That, I am afraid, is the union. Overwhelmingly, it has been beneficial to Northern Ireland over 226 years; just in the indicator of average standards of living, there is no doubt that it has been overwhelmingly in the interests of Northern Ireland. But there are bad moments. It happened in 1938 with the Anglo-Irish trade agreement, which militated against Northern Irish interests, and only one senior politician in this Parliament stood up against it—Winston Churchill. It was done because Neville Chamberlain wanted to indicate to Nazi Germany: “We can do deals with our old enemies, so we can do a deal with you”. The actual details, to the amazement of the Irish side, favoured them enormously and disfavoured Northern Ireland. Again, that is what happens. It is the nature of the relationship in a union. My major difference with the Bill is in the way that the Act of Union is treated, unproblematically, as the source of reference. Today is a particular day. The Lords Select Committee report entitled Dynamic Alignment tells you all. As the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, has somewhat conceded, on the specific problem that Northern Ireland has of receiving laws and having no control over them, we are all now going to join it in that respect. There will be a new equality of citizenship across the two islands. I know that many will be shocked by this, and I was surprised to see gene editing included in the list, but, having said that, it means that equality of citizenship will return to a degree. I am surprised by how long the list is; having spoken on the SPS question in this House, I am surprised by how many other elements appear to be in the new deal, including gene editing. In the last cognate debate on this, the noble Lords, Lord Murphy and Lord Carlile, shared important reports on this moment in Northern Irish history and called for the Government to make sure, in the event of the recess, that the cognate changes which both of them advocated—the one-stop shop and so on—are put into effect. I say to the Minister, who was in his seat that night, that it is vital that the Government follow up on the report of the noble Lords, Lord Murphy and Lord Carlile. Otherwise, we will have what has tended to be the case with the Windsor Framework; some of the benefits promised to Northern Ireland have not ensued while some of the negative aspects are all that the Government come to the House with through these endless SIs. For example, the Windsor Framework has delivered a break with the idea of the island economy, but the Government do not actually say that. I call on the Minister to follow up on what the noble Lord, Lord Murphy, said.
Lord Frost (Non-Afl)
My Lords, it is a pleasure to support the Bill from the noble Lord, Lord Dodds. It is right that on the day of the summit in Brussels we should find ourselves discussing the Bill and the solutions that we ought to be getting, rather than the rather unfortunate sell-out that is happening in Brussels at this moment. Those two things, however, are not disconnected; they are all part of the same problem. To see why the Bill is necessary, one has to look back for a moment. There is a sequence. One thing leads to another, going right back to the joint report of 2017, the unfortunate 2018 agreement under the then Prime Minister, the noble Baroness, Lady May, and the somewhat improved protocol that we were able to bring back under pressure in 2019 from Brussels—arrangements that we never wanted, but which were forced on us by decisions taken here. We knew they would be difficult to work in practice and we expected that the protocol would end up being removed or overridden. We tried to achieve that first by negotiation, and then by the Northern Ireland Protocol Bill, which passed the Commons but was then withdrawn. Now we have the Windsor Framework, the latest thing in the sequence, which the Government are committed to defending rather than replacing. Our Government, Ireland’s Government, the EU, the nationalist community and their representatives in Northern Ireland are all united in maintaining an agreement that is, to varying degrees, unacceptable to unionism in Northern Ireland. One thing has led to another, and it is leading to another; the consequence is an incentive to align across Great Britain. We have been talking about this in the various SIs we have discussed in recent months. We have seen it in alignment in GB in areas such as cars and batteries. Of course, it is the main driver of today’s reset, whose sovereignty-destroying SPS and ETS agreements spread to the whole country the principle already enshrined in Northern Ireland: laws without votes and without representation. That is why it is so good that we have this Bill to discuss and why I am so glad to be able to support it. It shows that there is another way. It follows the logic of the earlier protocol Bill in replacing the existing arrangements with full UK law provisions in a way that is consistent with mutual enforcement or other possible arrangements at the border between Northern Ireland and Ireland. I do not need to labour the points because we have made them many times before in your Lordships’ House. I do not think the Windsor Framework can last; it is fundamentally unstable. Either it will do what people like me always feared and its proponents always hoped—drag the whole country back into an EU alignment arrangement like the May Government’s ill-fated deal, with national independence in many areas in name only, which is the direction in which the reset today is beginning to take us; or, alternatively, it will be seen for what it is—a monstrosity that is entirely incompatible with being a properly independent country. We had a little discussion on the international law aspect yesterday in our debate on the SPS reset. It was noted that the enthusiasm for breaking international law or legislating in contravention of it was not necessarily where you would expect to have found it. It is important to say that this Bill is incompatible with our international obligations, as set out in the withdrawal agreement and the Windsor Framework, and so be it; the British Parliament is sovereign. As President de Gaulle—who knew something about national sovereignty—said: “Les traités … ça dure ce que ça dure”. Treaties last as long as they last, by which he meant as long as the underlying national interests align. In this case, they did so only very briefly, as a temporary arrangement to deliver the referendum result and get us out of the EU. The withdrawal agreement is now an empty shell. The money is paid, most of the transitional arrangements are past and only the Windsor Framework remains, resting on international convenience and the fragile balance of interests in the Belfast/Good Friday agreement and in Northern Ireland more broadly. You do not make something that is already fragile less so by balancing something else on top of it; you make it more so. That is why the Windsor Framework must go and be replaced with something robust and consistent with Northern Ireland’s status as part of the UK. The Bill shows how it can be done, and that is why I am happy to support it.
Lord Moynihan of Chelsea (Con)
My Lords, I strongly support the excellent Bill from the noble Lord, Lord Dodds of Duncairn. We debate it, as other noble Lords have said, on the day the Prime Minister is in Brussels attempting to sign us up to dynamic alignment—submission to the EU’s laws without effective input across whole swathes of our economy. It is equality of subservience rather than, as the noble Lord, Lord Bew, put it, equality of citizenship. The lamentable Northern Ireland protocol and Windsor Framework all too easily conceded the canard that the Good Friday agreement was under threat unless we handed the economy of Northern Ireland to the European Union. This ploy, dreamed up by the EU and by collaborative UK remainers, brilliantly commenced a series of manoeuvres to reel the United Kingdom back inside its protectionist barriers, today’s summit being a further stage. The false premise needs finally to be rebutted if we want a Brexit that makes us sovereign over our laws, our money and our borders. The protocol and the framework were predicated on the, to me, preposterous claim that, unless we allowed EU laws to rule in Northern Ireland, a hard north-south border would have to be erected: a hard, fenced border of some 300 miles, cutting across the century-old common travel area and dividing closely-knit communities. No one ever told us who would build that hard border. We would not have done it; for sure, the Republic of Ireland would not have done it. Would the European Union have tried to force Ireland to do it? That would have been an interesting sight. The threat was a bluff, but our gullible leaders at least claimed, astonishingly, that they believed it, and this has damaged the union. According to the CSO, goods exports to Northern Ireland from the Republic have more than doubled since 2019, up from €2.5 billion to €5.4 billion, but British businesses are hindered by customs checks and compliance requirements. In 2024, HMRC recorded almost 1.5 million customer declarations on goods moving from Great Britain to Northern Ireland—customs declarations within our own country. The taxpayer has spent well over half a billion pounds on the Trader Support Service to help firms with the forms, and the Federation of Small Businesses found that fully one-third of small firms that used to trade across the Irish Sea have now simply stopped. In 2024 alone, Northern Ireland businesses bought 8.7% more from the Republic and 4.6% less from Great Britain. The people of Northern Ireland pay the price, with disrupted supply chains, less choice and higher prices. All that is diversion of trade. Article 16 of the framework entitles this country to take safeguard measures against that, but the Government do not seem disposed to. Yesterday, we heard how this sort of thing for UK SPS exporters to the EU necessitated this appalling reset, yet, apparently, exporters to Northern Ireland deserve no such consideration. The remedy is clearly mutual enforcement, compatible with WTO rules. Sensible people have advocated going this way for the best part of a decade. Each side would enforce the others’ rules on goods crossing from them to the other, with no checks on the north-south border and no border in the Irish Sea. Clauses 7 and 8 of this excellent Bill give Ministers the powers precisely to do this. Brussels already accepts the equivalence of New Zealand’s veterinary standards, from the other side of the world. It can surely extend the same good faith to a neighbour whose standards are all but identical to its own. Mutual enforcement is the only way to bring back Northern Ireland properly into a single United Kingdom. I end with two questions for the Minister. Do the Government believe in a United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, the paramount integrity of its internal market and the rule of its laws equally over all its people? If they do, why can we not agree this Bill, implement mutual enforcement and resolve this suppurating wound in our body politic?
Baroness Hoey (Non-Afl)
My Lords, I apologise to noble Lords and to all my colleagues that, because of an unfortunate situation, I may have to leave slightly before the end. The noble Lord, Lord Dodds, has set out clearly why this Bill should be supported. I am yet to hear—though perhaps we will from other speakers—why it should not be supported. I was not quite clear whether the noble Lord, Lord Bew, supports it or not, but that is obviously for us to think about. I remind noble Lords that we had the same ballot paper as everywhere else in the rest of the United Kingdom when it came to leaving the European Union. The ballot paper asked whether we wished the United Kingdom to leave. It did not say in brackets, “but leave out Northern Ireland for lots of different aspects”. That is my first point. I want to deal briefly with one of the real myths surrounding the entire discussion on the protocol and the Windsor Framework: that somehow, creating this “hard” border—a word which was used without anyone actually analysing what it meant—across the island of Ireland would be contrary to the Belfast/Good Friday agreement. That was repeated over and over again. Let us be clear: the land border exists, and, actually, the Good Friday agreement made it a much more recognised fact. On the one hand, the Republic of Ireland agreed to amend its constitution and drop its territorial claim on Northern Ireland; at the same time, the agreement was made that, if certain explicit conditions were met, there could be a poll on both sides of the border as to whether people wanted to stay part of the UK or move to be part of the Republic. The reality is that the land border is a frontier. As has been pointed out by the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, it is a frontier at which the Republic of Ireland has different tax and excise rates, a different currency, and you go into kilometres as you go across the border. It has immigration controls, with people sometimes being stopped on the buses and trains. The Republic of Ireland is an independent country. Yes, it has got very special arrangements with the rest of the United Kingdom—we have the common travel area, and we obviously pay a lot of money to help defend the Republic of Ireland—but the spin that the Good Friday/Belfast agreement states that there can be no customs posts at the frontier is completely wrong. It says no such thing. It was referring to the military posts there, during the period when the armed IRA was coming across, preventing terrorists coming over to bomb and kill in Northern Ireland. The Good Friday/Belfast agreement set up cross-border mechanisms for co-operation. If there was no border then there would be no need for those cross-border mechanisms. A land border with the EU was always going to have to be dealt with, as the EU would, rightly, want to protect its internal market and we would want to protect ours. Enda Kenny, who was Taoiseach around the time we were leaving, was very supportive of the development of smart border technology being operated, as is now contained in much of what the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, has said. Sadly, the new Government in the Republic stopped all discussion between civil servants on this. We ended up with the European Union, cleverly pushed by the Republic of Ireland, recognising that this was a good way of ensuring not only that the United Kingdom was punished for daring to leave but that Northern Ireland was left under EU rules in so many areas. It was also a bridge to getting the whole of the United Kingdom back, whenever such a Government came in and wanted it. Sadly, it looks like we have such a Government at the moment who want that. I have been cheered up by the fact that there has been so much shift on this now. The Opposition seem to be clear that this is unsustainable and that something has to be done. The Reform party has made it quite clear that it supports mutual enforcement, and, if we had a Reform Peer here, they would be saying so. Danny Kruger has written an article today that makes it quite clear that Reform would want to change this, which I am very pleased about. That has cheered me up. Will the Minister say why the Labour Government will not recognise that this is unsustainable and that it has to be changed? I apologise again if I am not here, but I will read carefully what he says. Bringing back our country into one United Kingdom should have been the first item in any reset with the European Union, making sure that the European Union does not control so much in our own country. When I read Hansard , I would like to find a real reason given that allows me to go away feeling even more cheerful that something might happen in the near future.
Lord Shinkwin (Con) [R]
My Lords, I support this Bill and I thank the noble Lord, Lord Dodds of Duncairn, for the service he does to the United Kingdom’s democracy by introducing it. It was because of my extreme discomfort with a measure which I feared would subvert democracy in a constituent part of the United Kingdom, Northern Ireland, that I was one of only two Conservative Members of your Lordships’ House to vote against the Whip on the Windsor Framework on 29 March 2023. Three and a half years later, the discomfort which led me, reluctantly, to break ranks with the then Government has turned to utter dismay. For far from being unjustified, the amendment to the Windsor Framework regulations tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Morrow, back in 2023 has instead been vindicated and the reassurances about a so-called Stormont brake revealed to be nothing more than semantic window dressing. Ursula von der Leyen would probably know that if someone referred to her dear Rishi’s reset—as opposed to Prime Minister Burnham’s—they meant the Windsor Framework. She would probably also know why some would say the framework supported Martin Selmayr’s alleged prediction that Northern Ireland would be the price of Brexit. I speak as someone with Irish Catholic blood coursing through my veins. So I am familiar with the appeal of a reunified Ireland, and I respect those who advance the case for it, just as I do those who believe that Northern Ireland’s future lies in the union. But we know that this is not what this is about. This is about democracy, specifically about democracy within a constituent part of the United Kingdom being subverted, to the detriment both of that part and of the whole, the wider body politic. That is my primary concern as we embark on this so-called reset. As Northern Ireland’s experience has shown following the enactment of the Windsor Framework, the EU does not negotiate; it only subjugates, as if we needed reminding that the words “EU Commission” and “EU concession” do not belong in the same sentence. In conclusion, we must not concede. This Bill would ensure that instead we learn from the misplaced trust underpinning the Windsor Framework and defend our democracy, which the framework, under the reset, undermines. This a matter of honour. My question to the Minister is: for as long as Northern Ireland remains a sovereign part of the United Kingdom, is it not the duty of any Government to do right by their people? That is what this Bill would enable, and it is why I support it.
Lord Weir of Ballyholme (DUP)
My Lords, it is a pleasure to support the Bill of the noble Lord, Lord Dodds. At the outset, I associate myself with his deepest condolences to my noble friend and colleague Lord Morrow on his tragic double loss this week. In the stream of statutory instruments that we deal with in this House that have arisen from the protocol/Windsor Framework, a number of us have raised a range of concerns, from the damage to the constitutional integrity of the United Kingdom to the outrage around the democratic deficit of having laws imposed on us, over which no one ultimately has a say or control, to the level of economic damage that is being created to Northern Ireland, from being dislocated from our main market in Great Britain, from the reduction in consumer choice and from the barriers put in place for firms in Great Britain. We are in the very strange situation where, given the frictions of bringing goods to Northern Ireland, it is easier—there are fewer barriers—to bring them from Dubrovnik rather than Dundee, Nicosia rather than Newport or Malmö rather than Makerfield. That is the economic reality that we are faced with. However justified our complaints and concerns are, today’s debate is about providing a positive solution to those problems. At times, in some of these debates, Government Ministers make sympathetic noises and state that they understand the problems that many of us face, but ask, in effect, “What is the alternative?” The Bill offers a practical and better alternative. It genuinely defends the key cornerstone of the Belfast agreement: cross-community support. That has been uniquely abrogated under the protocol and is not central simply to the Good Friday agreement; it has been the cornerstone of policy for more than half a century that it is only with a buy-in from both unionists and nationalists that we can have proper balance within Northern Ireland. Crucially, the Bill goes to the issue of respect, particularly self-respect. That we are in a situation where we have laws simply imposed upon us in over 300 areas of law is unacceptable. In recent statutory instruments, the Government have not even consulted on them. That is probably a reflection of reality. Consultation would be a façade, because no matter how many objections there are to the EU clause, nobody can do anything about them. Famously and historically, the Germans facilitated Lenin on a sealed train from Zurich to Petrograd. No one could interfere with that train and contact Lenin, and it whizzed through Germany and neutral territory. Today, the train of EU laws, as regards Northern Ireland, is in a similar position. At Westminster and in the Assembly, we find ourselves standing at a station on that train’s route. We cannot interfere with its contents, stop the train or change its course of direction. That is not self-respect or mutual respect. There are probably still some in this country, at one end of the scale, who would view the EU with the old headline: “Fog in Channel, continent isolated”. Still more, there are others who take the view that we will throw in the kitchen sink to get whatever concessions we can get off the EU. As we have seen with the current discussions, the danger of that is that we find ourselves in the bizarre situation where we appear potentially to be extending the situation in which laws are made, over which we have no control whatever, for the whole of the United Kingdom. It is not simply that: we actually pay a price to even have that position. That is not mutual respect. The sensible solutions of mutual enforcement that arise out of the Bill respect us and the EU—both sides—where regulations can be enforced in both jurisdictions. A proper relationship should not be one that is, in effect, subservient on either side but one in which there is mutual respect. In conclusion, we face a choice between democracy and imposition, national integrity and constitutional division, cross-community votes and imposition, and, ultimately, between mutual respect and subjugation to laws. I know which one of those two paths we would be wisest to pick.
Baroness Ludford (LD)
My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, knows that I do not agree with the Bill, which is a reiteration of other such Bills, including the Northern Ireland Protocol Bill, and involves unilateral derogation from treaty obligations. But I hope he also knows the regard and respect in which I hold him—I consider us friends, as fellow members of the Northern Ireland Scrutiny Committee of this House. I am very conscious of the gap in my knowledge and experience compared with those on our committee—and not on our committee—who come from Northern Ireland. I am conscious of the constitutional, political and practical issues raised by the Windsor Framework. Obviously, the noble Lord and others know that I would not start from here: it was clear that Brexit was going to have a major and damaging impact on Northern Ireland, and my view, for what it is worth, is that only return or rejoin could solve the problems of being a rule-taker without a vote. The noble Lord, Lord Bew, was understandably reproachful that the EU withdrawal arrangements failed to take account of the Good Friday/Belfast agreement. I can only concur with the words of our committee’s chairman, the noble Lord, Lord Carlile, in the debate that we had in May on the committee’s report on Northern Ireland a fter Brexit , who said that “the Windsor Framework is a complex amalgam of diplomacy, politics and sheer necessity, conjured from shakily designed foundations … it bears all the characteristics of having occurred, rather than having been designed. However, it is what Northern Ireland has to live with ”.—[ Official Report , 25/3/26; cols. GC 223-24.] However, as I said in that debate, my focus on the committee is not on rediscussing Brexit or the merits or demerits of the Windsor Framework, but on “how I can contribute to understanding and trying to resolve the practical challenges and difficulties for businesses, other organisations and consumers in Northern Ireland ”.—[ Official Report , 25/3/26; col. GC 258.] As we have heard, the reset and dynamic alignment are going to project some of these issues on to the whole of the UK, so at least there will be some heavier lifting coming into play on behalf of the UK Government, which should ease the pressure on Northern Ireland alone. I said in May’s debate that: “The fact that the Windsor Framework arrangements can be described to the committee as being of ‘labyrinthine complexity’ … is not only a poor service to the people of Northern Ireland, to put it mildly, but a poor omen for reception of the output from the reset ”.—[ Official Report , 25/3/26; col. GC 261.] The timely report from our Lords European Affairs Committee this week makes clear the challenges of dynamic alignment. It makes excellent proposals for maximising decision shaping—which can only be decision shaping; we have no vote—improving governmental machinery, including the resources of UKMis, the UK mission to the EU in Brussels, and increasing parliamentary scrutiny. In the meantime, reports from the Northern Ireland Scrutiny Committee and the review from the noble Lord, Lord Murphy, who is with us, as well as from elsewhere, have highlighted the practical steps that could and should be taken to make the conditions for Northern Ireland businesses and consumers less bureaucratic and UK-EU trade more free-flowing. These are issues such as: the one-stop shop; trusted trader status for the haulage industry; the office of the Northern Ireland Executive in Brussels to be properly staffed by people able to influence EU legislation at an early stage; better resourcing for the Democratic Scrutiny Committee of the Northern Ireland Assembly; and a database of emerging EU laws. I was pleased to see that the European Affairs Committee report on dynamic alignment devotes a whole page to this point, and we made it a point in the Northern Ireland Scrutiny Committee report. It is absolutely essential that there is a comprehensive source of knowledge about what is emerging from the EU and what exists. We need better co-operation from the Northern Ireland Executive with Westminster committees. The noble Lord, Lord Dodds, mentioned in our May debate how the First Minister of Northern Ireland vetoed the Deputy First Minister giving evidence to our committee, which is unhelpful, to say the least. We also have the important role of InterTrade UK, chaired by our committee colleague, the noble Baroness, Lady Foster. I accept that the reset and alignment do not remove the customs and VAT arrangements for Northern Ireland, and those issues remain. However, an all-UK effort and heft will help Northern Ireland in the immediate future, sharing the pain around, if you like. I am afraid that the Bill from the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, does not appeal to me. I like him a great deal better than I like his Bill.
Baroness Finn (Con)
My Lords, I too offer my condolences to the noble Lord, Lord Morrow, on the death of his daughter and wife last weekend. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Dodds of Duncairn, for bringing this Bill to the House. It touches on two fundamental issues: the relationship between the United Kingdom and the European Union, and the relationship between Great Britain and Northern Ireland. I will speak first to the status of Northern Ireland within the United Kingdom, before turning briefly to the wider question of the Government’s EU reset, which I have no doubt will be the main focus of public debate during the EU summit this weekend. The Windsor Framework, concluded by the previous Conservative Government, was a valiant attempt to address the issues with the old Northern Ireland protocol while protecting Northern Ireland’s access to the internal market and keeping Northern Ireland in the EU single market for goods. It also sought to avoid the need for a hard border in the Irish Sea while protecting the border settlement on the island of Ireland which was reached following the Good Friday agreement. The Official Opposition are committed to protecting Northern Ireland’s position within the United Kingdom. Although the Windsor Framework, taken alongside the subsequent Safeguarding the Union Command Paper, represented a significant improvement on the old protocol negotiated in 2019, we recognise that it was not a perfect document. I think there is some agreement between the Government and the Official Opposition on that point, and we will support the Government where they take steps to improve the position of Northern Ireland without making us rule-takers from the EU. We recognise that small businesses are still facing ongoing difficulties with the processes required to move goods from Great Britain to Northern Ireland. The Institute of Directors has called on the Government to improve business guidance for Great Britain firms to encourage more trade with Northern Ireland. What steps are Ministers taking to provide practical support to businesses in that context? As my honourable friend Alex Burghart said in the other place in December 2024, it is our view “that the Windsor framework with ‘Safeguarding the Union’ is a better solution than the Windsor framework was; that the Windsor framework was a better solution than the protocol; and that the protocol was a better option than the backstop. However, that does not mean that there are not better solutions available ”.—[ Official Report , Commons, 6/12/24; col. 630.] I say to the noble Lord, Lord Dodds of Duncairn, that we will always seek to work constructively with all the Northern Ireland parties to secure a brighter future for Northern Ireland within our United Kingdom. As some noble Lords have pointed out, the Windsor Framework has made some improvements to the defects in the original protocol, but as many noble Lords, such as the noble Lord, Lord Bew, have also mentioned, significant problems remain. As an Opposition, as my noble friend Lord Caine has previously said, we have never taken the view that the Windsor Framework was the final word in what is an evolving institution. We will look at constructive proposals for change, including some of the ones that have been raised by noble Lords today, consistent with the constitutional integrity of the United Kingdom and Northern Ireland’s position within it. Turning to the broader context of the Bill and the Prime Minister’s so-called EU reset, I hope that the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, and I will find ourselves united on this point. Of course, at a basic level, the reset is merely a distraction from a Prime Minister who is reticent to take the tough decisions on domestic policy, whether on welfare, the cost and burden of regulations that are holding business back or the NHS and social care. The Prime Minister has a penchant for the feel-good press release, but still we have not seen him commit to taking the difficult decisions that the Prime Minister’s role demands. We need only to look at the missed opportunity of the Budget to see evidence of that. We on these Benches are firmly opposed to any steps that make the United Kingdom subject to rules over which we have no say. Making the United Kingdom a rule-taker while paying for the privilege is unacceptable. Beyond that, the very premise of Brexit was to grant us the freedoms to carve out our own future in the world, allowing us to secure trade deals with Australia, New Zealand, Japan, India and Singapore, and set rules that promote our own high-growth sectors, such as agritech, digital and life sciences. Can the Minister say whether the Prime Minister’s EU reset will put our landmark trade deals with Australia and New Zealand at risk? What does it mean for the Government’s own trade deal with India? What concerns have his ministerial counterparts in Australia, New Zealand and India raised with the Government on this? It is not merely the risk of future harm that we should consider. The Prime Minister’s decision to set the United Kingdom on a path back toward ever-closer union has created uncertainty for businesses about the regulatory framework that will apply to the United Kingdom in future. Even commentators who support the proposed SPS deal with the EU recognise the difficult questions it raises. I quote: “Behind the positive headlines lie many difficult questions about pesticides, agricultural competitiveness, border inspections, food fraud, scientific independence and, perhaps most significantly, the future roles and responsibilities of the Food Standards Agency”. These are not my words but the words of Professor Chris Elliott, professor of food safety at Queen’s University Belfast. Uncertainty over an SPS agreement with the EU is extremely concerning to the UK precision breeding sector, an area where the UK has taken advantage of our new freedoms to diverge from the EU. The European Affairs Committee, chaired by the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, said in its recent forensic report on dynamic alignment: “Immediate and complete dynamic alignment in this area would therefore curtail the regime established in England” under the precision breeding Act, and recommended that the Government seek exemptions for the sector in any agreement with the EU. Can the Minister reassure the House that the Government will seek to protect our precision breeding sector from the EU’s more restrictive regulatory regime? As I have said, these Benches cannot accept any deal that makes the UK subject to EU rules without any say over what those rules look like. Yes, we want to see cheaper energy prices—something that can be achieved only by the Government abandoning their costly obsession with net zero. Yes, people want to see lower food prices—something that is not helped by covering the best and most versatile agricultural land with solar panels and endangering our trade deals with New Zealand and Australia. But no, the British people do not want to return to the uncertainty and acrimony of the years when these Benches fought tooth and nail to deliver the democratic instruction given by 17 million voters in the face of those who sought to overturn the mandate. I look forward to the Minister’s reply.
Lord in Waiting/Government Whip (Lord Katz) (Lab)
My Lords, before I turn to the substance of today’s debate, I know the whole House will wish to join me, the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, and the noble Baroness, Lady Finn, in extending our deepest, most heartfelt condolences to the noble Lord, Lord Morrow, and his family following the devastating loss of his wife Jennifer and his daughter Rachel on Sunday. May their memories be always a blessing. Our thoughts and prayers are with him, his friends and his family at this unimaginably difficult time. Let me also express my sincere thanks to all noble Lords who have contributed to today’s debate, and to the noble Lord, Lord Dodds of Duncairn, for introducing the Bill and outlining his views with his customary clarity and conviction. The Government are wholly committed to both the Windsor Framework and the United Kingdom internal market. It is precisely because of that commitment that the Government must express clear reservations regarding the noble Lord’s proposals in his Bill. Throughout the debate, a number of noble Lords, including the noble Lords, Lord Frost and Lord Lilley, have talked about the temporary nature of the Windsor Framework arrangements. Both the UK and the EU have repeatedly restated their commitment to these arrangements. This has taken place through the agreement of the Windsor Framework and subsequent decisions; indeed, the Northern Ireland Assembly voted for the arrangements to continue in 2024. While I fully respect the sincerity with which the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, advances his case, the Government have three fundamental concerns with the Bill, which I am sure will not come as a huge surprise to the noble Lord and his supporters. First, it cannot be reconciled with international law. Secondly, it does not adequately account for Northern Ireland’s unique circumstances following our exit from the European Union. Thirdly, it would reintroduce considerable uncertainty for businesses and traders over the rules that apply in Northern Ireland. In the Government’s view, these outcomes will be damaging for the United Kingdom, for our international standing and for Northern Ireland’s continued economic growth. At the same time, we should recognise the practical progress the Government have delivered by working constructively with the European Union since the Bill was introduced on 3 June. We have begun the operational rollout of the £16.6 million United Kingdom internal market package committed at the Autumn Budget in November 2025, delivering targeted support to help local traders navigate the Windsor Framework. Today, as many noble Lords mentioned, we will agree an SPS deal with the EU that, through its interplay with the Windsor Framework, will remove the vast majority of checks and paperwork on agri-food goods moving from Great Britain to Northern Ireland. This will promote consumer choice and generate new opportunities for businesses trading into Northern Ireland. I think the noble Lord, Lord Shinkwin, brought this up, and the interplay of the Windsor Framework and the SPS agreement will facilitate the smooth flow of agri-foods and plants, protect the UK’s internal market and reduce costs to businesses. They will save hours of time and money as this will remove swathes of paperwork, numerous health certificates and processes. Linking carbon markets will also bring significant benefits for UK businesses, including access to a larger, more liquid carbon market, fewer regulatory barriers and protection from new border taxes. We have also maintained the Trader Support Service to ensure that traders continue to receive free, expert digital assistance at no cost to business. We have ensured that the Windsor Framework facilitations are fully utilised to ensure the smooth flow of goods. Although I recognise that the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, and others may favour a different approach to our relationship with the European Union, I believe the evidence shows that this Government’s approach is delivering results. Major employers serving communities across Northern Ireland have been clear that negotiated practical solutions remove barriers on the ground. As Marks & Spencer noted in its evidence to Parliament, our sanitary and phytosanitary agreement “is a huge step forward. It is exactly the kind of pragmatic deal we have been hoping for, and … will remove … ‘Not for EU’ labelling” costs, speed up the flow of fresh produce and unlock new investment and jobs across Northern Ireland. Indeed, this sentiment is echoed across industry, from Asda and Morrisons to the British Poultry Council, Logistics UK and the Horticultural Trades Association. The Bill would inadvertently set aside that hard-won economic progress. Equally, the Bill does not take full account of the genuine progress that the Government have also made in delivering the commitments set out in Safeguarding the Union , from the switch-on of the UK internal market guarantee and significant strengthening of the UK internal market system to delivering UK-wide arrangements for the supply of both human and veterinary medicines. However, I fully recognise the sincere desire across the House, voiced by so many noble Lords, for further progress to be made by the Government. We have heard a range of contributions this morning, delivered with characteristic care, insight and eloquence. I now turn to the substance of the Bill and will reflect on the two primary reasons, as I have already stated, why the Government cannot support it today. First, the Bill cannot be reconciled with international law and would set aside the substantial progress that we are delivering with the European Union on a negotiated basis, of which we are seeing the fruit today. The Government are committed to the rule of law and to honouring the UK’s international obligations. Departing from those commitments would place in jeopardy the new and beneficial arrangements that we have announced with the European Union, including those being taken forward at the UK-EU summit in Brussels today. The resulting unilateralism and uncertainty would not serve the interests of business. Many noble Lords, such as the noble Lords, Lord Dodds, Lord Bew, Lord Frost and Lord Weir of Ballyholme, and the noble Baroness, Lady Finn, referred to the democratic deficit and were disparaging of the dynamic alignment that we are agreeing. This dynamic alignment means that, where required by agreements, the UK applies the same rules, at the same time, on an ongoing basis. The UK will have the ability to shape EU decision-making in these areas to ensure that UK views are taken into account. This is a sovereign choice by this Government to align in specific sectors where it is in our national interest to do so. Most British exporters are already de facto aligned with EU standards to keep selling their goods. As set out in the common understanding, the UK will have a decision-shaping role. The Commission will consult the UK in an early stage of policy-making so that the UK can contribute to the shaping of new rules as they are being developed. Parliament will rightly have a say in this process. The cost of not aligning is added bureaucracy to UK businesses, which would have to spend valuable time every day not looking after customers but completing onerous paperwork and exercises. All noble Lords would wish to avoid this. The noble Lords, Lord Dodds and Lord Bew, mentioned Article 1 and the constitutional status of the island of Ireland. The consent vote was created to ensure that the framework continues to operate on the basis of agreeing the support of elected representatives in Northern Ireland. It is a process unique to Northern Ireland that did not exist at the point of the Good Friday agreement, nor does it exist under devolution elsewhere. The vote is premised on cross-community support; it requires an independent review and means that the next vote is in four years rather than eight. The Supreme Court has already upheld that these arrangements are consistent with the Northern Ireland Act 1998. Ultimately, it is right that such a change of trading arrangements that address the unique circumstances in Northern Ireland should rely on a majority in the Assembly. I fully respect that the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, and others would prefer the United Kingdom to have a very different relationship with the EU. However, that is not the message we have heard from commerce and industry, with the Confederation of British Industry noting that a sanitary and phytosanitary agreement is a “significant win” for businesses in Northern Ireland, and the British Chambers of Commerce likewise expressing strong support. It would not serve those businesses well to depart from agreed rules in a way that disrupts the implementation of trading arrangements they themselves have sought and welcomed. Even where the noble Lord takes a different view of our relationship with the EU, I hope he shares our view that we must safeguard the United Kingdom’s credibility as a reliable partner that honours its commitments on the world stage. A unilateral approach would inevitably cause businesses and investors to question which rules will be respected in future, affecting our standing with a wide range of international partners. Secondly, the Bill does not offer a substantial resolution to Northern Ireland’s unique circumstances. While I understand and respect the strength of feeling on this issue, I gently suggest to the noble Lord that the Bill does not address the practical realities on the ground in a more stable or durable manner than the Windsor Framework. The fundamental challenge arising from our exit from the EU remains—a challenge left unanswered by the Bill. How do we preserve the integrity of the United Kingdom’s internal market, avoid a hard border on the island of Ireland and respect the legitimate interest of our European neighbours in protecting their single market, just as we protect ours? If straightforward alternatives to that challenge had been readily deliverable in practice, they would have been implemented long ago. Proposals such as technological solutions or mutual enforcement, referenced by the noble Lords, Lord Lilley, Lord Dodds and Lord Moynihan of Chelsea, are well intentioned but they do not fully account for the practical realities of physical infrastructure and border controls seen across international borders worldwide. The noble Lord, Lord Lilley, made reference to arrangements prior to the EU single market and the removal of border posts, but he ignores the reality that those EU countries were already following harmonised rules for certain products. The situation is not comparable to that of the island of Ireland. As for the comparison with New Zealand made by the noble Lord, Lord Moynihan of Chelsea, I gently suggest that trade with a small country on the other side of the planet is not entirely comparable to trade with our European partners and the situation on the island of Ireland. I recognise that, for some, avoiding a hard border on the island of Ireland was never viewed as the overriding priority. Yet across successive elections, it has remained a vital concern for the electorate—for good reason, given its impact on border communities, integrated cross-border businesses and, above all, the preservation of peace and stability in Northern Ireland. Even where noble Lords hold different perspectives, I hope they will recognise the clear democratic mandate given to successive Parliaments to avoid a hard border. This Bill would place existing facilitations in jeopardy, along with the extensive work undertaken with businesses to ensure that dual market access operates effectively. I acknowledge the many thoughtful points made by noble Lords on where further improvements can be made, and the Government will continue to engage constructively with your Lordships’ House and other stakeholders on those suggestions. However, the right response for businesses cannot be to dismantle the framework on which they currently rely and to return Northern Ireland to the prolonged uncertainty that preceded the Windsor Framework. Nor was such an outcome the wish of the Northern Ireland Assembly in December 2024. When given the democratic choice to discontinue these arrangements by a simple majority, the Assembly voted instead to retain them while commissioning an independent review from my noble friend Lord Murphy of Torfaen. The Government have responded to that review and work is actively under way to implement the commitments made in the Government’s response. The noble Lord, Lord Bew, mentioned those commitments. For the sake of time, I will not go into the long list that I have, but I will pick out one or two. For instance, we continue to take forward the delivery of the Northern Ireland business support service—the one-stop shop that provides a single accessible regulatory hub to help small and medium-sized enterprises navigate trading requirements smoothly. I am pleased to say that we remain on course to have the core service operational within this financial year. We have also ensured a reliable supply of veterinary medicines to Northern Ireland and taken forward the funding committed for Intertrade UK. There are more ways in which we have met the recommendations that my noble friend Lord Murphy made; we understand that these are important, and that is why we are acting on them. Just as it would not be right to overturn Northern Ireland’s dual market access lightly, it would not be proportionate to set aside the Assembly’s democratic vote and the findings of that independent review. Just as we must be candid about the consequences of this Bill, we must also recognise the tangible benefits of the Windsor Framework. Together, these arrangements affirm in domestic and international law Northern Ireland’s constitutional place in the union and its economic place in the UK’s internal market. I hope that that, as clearly as any other point in this speech, answers those who asked somewhat sarcastically whether this Government believe that Northern Ireland has a place in the United Kingdom. Of course we do. Time and again at this Dispatch Box, I and my noble friends on the Front Bench have made it very clear that Northern Ireland is an integral part of the United Kingdom. Are the arrangements durable under international law, accounting for Northern Ireland’s particular circumstances in a manner that avoids a hard border on the island of Ireland? Are they actively benefiting businesses, smoothing the flow of trade and reducing bureaucracy? More than 15,000 traders are now signed up to the UK internal market scheme, and more than 1,200 operators are registered for the Northern Ireland retail movement scheme and the Northern Ireland plant health label. The noble Lord, Lord Weir of Ballyholme, talked about the perception that Northern Ireland is second class within the UK. The Windsor Framework plainly ensures that Northern Ireland’s businesses have unfettered access to their most important market in Great Britain, while maintaining their privileged access to the whole of the EU market without customs duties or unnecessary checks.
Lord Weir of Ballyholme (DUP)
No one has ever suggested in any of the concerns that we have raised at different times that there is not a potential flow of goods going from Northern Ireland to Great Britain. The problem is the other way around; a range of firms in Great Britain find it so cumbersome that they cannot get their goods across or feel that it is not worth while. That is the level of disruption. It also impacts directly on Northern Ireland businesses if they rely on component parts from Great Britain, because there are restrictions on them coming in. That is where part of the market divergence happens, even if it is possible.
Lord Katz (Lab)
The deal that we will see agreed today on SPS will, to a large extent, remove some of the barriers of bureaucracy for trading in both directions for the sectors to which it relates. The Windsor Framework makes sure that the UK’s constitutional and trading arrangements accommodate the reality of the situation as a strength, not a weakness, of the union. Dual market access is delivering measurable economic results on the ground, contrary to the contribution of the noble Lord, Lord Moynihan. On the point from the noble Lord, Lord Weir, Northern Ireland purchases from Great Britain grew by 19.5% between 2020 and 2024, which is not indicative of major trade diversion. In the same period, Northern Ireland’s sales to Great Britain grew by 57%. Also, 61% of manufacturers in Northern Ireland say that reducing trade friction with the EU should be the key priority for the Government to support growth. In 2024, Northern Ireland’s external sales to Britain reached a record £20.1 billion, an increase of 14.2%, while exports to the European Union, including Ireland, grew by 23.5%, marking the fastest growth rate of any region in the United Kingdom. This is a success story, and we should not ignore it. Growth means jobs, investment and prosperity for families across Northern Ireland. It is also worth noting that the Independent Monitoring Panel’s most recent report found that 96% of goods moving between Great Britain and Northern Ireland were not at risk—that is, going through the green lane without EU customs procedures. The noble Baroness, Lady Finn, asked a specific question on precision breeding. We remain committed to regulating precision breeding in line with the UK’s farming interests. She also raised the impact on other trade deals. I say to her that the SPS deal is fully consistent with our existing international obligations. Recent FTAs that we have agreed and our membership of the CPTPP will not need to be renegotiated. I have taken a fair bit of time, so I will try to wrap up. I am very glad that the Government have been able to deliver meaningful progress on the Windsor Framework, and on our commitment to the UK internal market, since the Bill was introduced in June. Today’s debate has underlined the importance of swiftly taking forward the new and beneficial arrangements that we are agreeing with the EU today in Brussels to smooth the flows of agri-food within the UK internal market still further. It remains the Government’s view that this approach of working closely with our international partners is the one that is most likely to deliver the stability and certainty that businesses need to trade and the economic growth that we all want to see. While I respect the deeply held views of the noble Lord, Lord Dodds of Duncairn, and indeed noble Lords across the House, this Government will support only sustainable arrangements for Northern Ireland that work for businesses, protect the UK’s internal market, and uphold our international obligations. I regret that the Bill before the House today would place those objectives at risk. For those reasons, while respecting the conventions of this House at Second Reading, the Government cannot support the Bill and place their clear reservations on the record today.
Lord Dodds of Duncairn (DUP)
My Lords, I thank the Minister for his response. He had a lot to cram into the time that was available, which is not surprising, as this is a massive subject. The disenfranchisement of citizens of the United Kingdom and placing the law-making powers over the people of Northern Ireland in a foreign polity that is not accountable to the people of Northern Ireland and on which Parliament and the Northern Ireland Assembly cannot have any say will naturally evoke a lot of debate. If that were to happen to England, Scotland or Wales, people here would be outraged; they would not tolerate it for a minute. It is therefore right that we should debate these matters, and we will continue to do so until we get a sustainable solution. I am grateful to all noble Lords for their contributions. This is an extremely important subject, especially on this day with the reset. We will no doubt come back to these wider issues in this House and elsewhere. We recognise that changes have been made along the way and that practical improvements have been attempted. The work and report of the noble Lord, Lord Murphy, which the noble Baroness, Lady Ludford, referred to, and the work of the Select Committee, which I have the honour to sit on under the chairmanship of the noble Lord, Lord Carlile, have been invaluable in putting the spotlight on the problems being faced by businesses in Northern Ireland. It is important that that work continues. However, what I and other noble Lords are addressing through support for the Bill is that all the work that is going on can necessarily be only a patchwork of sticking plasters to deal with the fundamental problem. We must ultimately deal with that fundamental problem, which is the denial of democracy and the breach of the Belfast agreement. The Minister has put a lot of emphasis on the consent of the Northern Ireland Assembly and the vote but, on this one issue of the cross-community consent principle—which is at the heart of the Belfast agreement and of every vote of substance and significance in the Northern Ireland Assembly—it was set aside. For the first time in over 60 years, majoritarianism was introduced to Northern Ireland for this one vote to ensure that Northern Ireland would continue to be disenfranchised and not have the right to make its own laws in these areas. That is an issue that affects unionists, nationalists and people of no party at all. Everyone should want the people on whom laws are imposed to have representatives that they elect, not have things imposed upon them from afar. I am grateful to those noble Lords who have spoken in support of the Bill. I am also grateful for the contributions of those who opposed it. I utterly respect each and every one of them. The noble Lord, Lord Bew, for whom I have great respect, mentioned, as he has on previous occasions, the Act of Union 1801 and the customs union, but the customs union has evolved considerably and internal markets have evolved considerably since 1801, and we should not refer to that today as if it is still the model. The fact is that we do not have equality of citizenship under this reset, in the sense that all of the UK will now suffer in the same way as the people of Northern Ireland do, with dynamic alignment and no input into the laws that we make. It is an equality of subservience, as the noble Lord, Lord Moynihan, said, and that is not a solution. We need to find a solution that restores democracy, restores the constitutional position of Northern Ireland within the United Kingdom, and respects the Belfast agreement. Noble Lords have only to read the speeches of the late Lord Trimble, one of the main architects of the Belfast agreement. He was vehemently opposed to the protocol on the grounds that it breached the Belfast agreement. Noble Lords have only to listen to the people on the ground and small businesses in Northern Ireland. The Minister has referred a lot to businesses in support of the reset and the Windsor Framework. He mentioned the Trader Support Service. It costs over £500 million for civil servants to try to administer the paperwork. That is not mentioned. That is money that could be spent on hospitals and schools. The reality is that, as the Department for the Economy in Northern Ireland reported in its recent report, there is immense complexity, and problems, compliance issues and costs for businesses in Northern Ireland. For all these reasons, we will have to find a sustainable and workable solution. As the noble Lord, Lord Bew, knows well from his history and his work to bring about the Belfast agreement, if we do not get a situation that commands the support of unionists as well as nationalists, we will ultimately end up some day—I am not saying that it will happen or that I want it to happen—with a situation in Northern Ireland that becomes so unstable and fragile that the whole future of the Assembly and its institutions will be called into question. That is the reality, because you cannot continue to build upon this shaky foundation. With that, I commend the Bill to the House and I beg to move.
Bill read a second time and committed to a Committee of the Whole House.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5441637.