L

Lord Moynihan of Chelsea (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 November 2026

Debate

European Union (Withdrawal Arrangements) Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, I strongly support the excellent Bill from the noble Lord, Lord Dodds of Duncairn. We debate it, as other noble Lords have said, on the day the Prime Minister is in Brussels attempting to sign us up to dynamic alignment—submission to the EU’s laws without effective input across whole swathes of our economy. It is equality of subservience rather than, as the noble Lord, Lord Bew, put it, equality of citizenship. The lamentable Northern Ireland protocol and Windsor Framework all too easily conceded the canard that the Good Friday agreement was under threat unless we handed the economy of Northern Ireland to the European Union. This ploy, dreamed up by the EU and by collaborative UK remainers, brilliantly commenced a series of manoeuvres to reel the United Kingdom back inside its protectionist barriers, today’s summit being a further stage. The false premise needs finally to be rebutted if we want a Brexit that makes us sovereign over our laws, our money and our borders. The protocol and the framework were predicated on the, to me, preposterous claim that, unless we allowed EU laws to rule in Northern Ireland, a hard north-south border would have to be erected: a hard, fenced border of some 300 miles, cutting across the century-old common travel area and dividing closely-knit communities. No one ever told us who would build that hard border. We would not have done it; for sure, the Republic of Ireland would not have done it. Would the European Union have tried to force Ireland to do it? That would have been an interesting sight. The threat was a bluff, but our gullible leaders at least claimed, astonishingly, that they believed it, and this has damaged the union. According to the CSO, goods exports to Northern Ireland from the Republic have more than doubled since 2019, up from €2.5 billion to €5.4 billion, but British businesses are hindered by customs checks and compliance requirements. In 2024, HMRC recorded almost 1.5 million customer declarations on goods moving from Great Britain to Northern Ireland—customs declarations within our own country. The taxpayer has spent well over half a billion pounds on the Trader Support Service to help firms with the forms, and the Federation of Small Businesses found that fully one-third of small firms that used to trade across the Irish Sea have now simply stopped. In 2024 alone, Northern Ireland businesses bought 8.7% more from the Republic and 4.6% less from Great Britain. The people of Northern Ireland pay the price, with disrupted supply chains, less choice and higher prices. All that is diversion of trade. Article 16 of the framework entitles this country to take safeguard measures against that, but the Government do not seem disposed to. Yesterday, we heard how this sort of thing for UK SPS exporters to the EU necessitated this appalling reset, yet, apparently, exporters to Northern Ireland deserve no such consideration. The remedy is clearly mutual enforcement, compatible with WTO rules. Sensible people have advocated going this way for the best part of a decade. Each side would enforce the others’ rules on goods crossing from them to the other, with no checks on the north-south border and no border in the Irish Sea. Clauses 7 and 8 of this excellent Bill give Ministers the powers precisely to do this. Brussels already accepts the equivalence of New Zealand’s veterinary standards, from the other side of the world. It can surely extend the same good faith to a neighbour whose standards are all but identical to its own. Mutual enforcement is the only way to bring back Northern Ireland properly into a single United Kingdom. I end with two questions for the Minister. Do the Government believe in a United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, the paramount integrity of its internal market and the rule of its laws equally over all its people? If they do, why can we not agree this Bill, implement mutual enforcement and resolve this suppurating wound in our body politic?

More from Lord Moynihan of Chelsea (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.