Contribution
My Lords, it is a pleasure to support the Bill from the noble Lord, Lord Dodds. It is right that on the day of the summit in Brussels we should find ourselves discussing the Bill and the solutions that we ought to be getting, rather than the rather unfortunate sell-out that is happening in Brussels at this moment. Those two things, however, are not disconnected; they are all part of the same problem.
To see why the Bill is necessary, one has to look back for a moment. There is a sequence. One thing leads to another, going right back to the joint report of 2017, the unfortunate 2018 agreement under the then Prime Minister, the noble Baroness, Lady May, and the somewhat improved protocol that we were able to bring back under pressure in 2019 from Brussels—arrangements that we never wanted, but which were forced on us by decisions taken here. We knew they would be difficult to work in practice and we expected that the protocol would end up being removed or overridden. We tried to achieve that first by negotiation, and then by the Northern Ireland Protocol Bill, which passed the Commons but was then withdrawn. Now we have the Windsor Framework, the latest thing in the sequence, which the Government are committed to defending rather than replacing.
Our Government, Ireland’s Government, the EU, the nationalist community and their representatives in Northern Ireland are all united in maintaining an agreement that is, to varying degrees, unacceptable to unionism in Northern Ireland. One thing has led to another, and it is leading to another; the consequence is an incentive to align across Great Britain. We have been talking about this in the various SIs we have discussed in recent months. We have seen it in alignment in GB in areas such as cars and batteries. Of course, it is the main driver of today’s reset, whose sovereignty-destroying SPS and ETS agreements spread to the whole country the principle already enshrined in Northern Ireland: laws without votes and without representation.
That is why it is so good that we have this Bill to discuss and why I am so glad to be able to support it. It shows that there is another way. It follows the logic of the earlier protocol Bill in replacing the existing arrangements with full UK law provisions in a way that is consistent with mutual enforcement or other possible arrangements at the border between Northern Ireland and Ireland.
I do not need to labour the points because we have made them many times before in your Lordships’ House. I do not think the Windsor Framework can last; it is fundamentally unstable. Either it will do what people like me always feared and its proponents always hoped—drag the whole country back into an EU alignment arrangement like the May Government’s ill-fated deal, with national independence in many areas in name only, which is the direction in which the reset today is beginning to take us; or, alternatively, it will be seen for what it is—a monstrosity that is entirely incompatible with being a properly independent country.
We had a little discussion on the international law aspect yesterday in our debate on the SPS reset. It was noted that the enthusiasm for breaking international law or legislating in contravention of it was not necessarily where you would expect to have found it. It is important to say that this Bill is incompatible with our international obligations, as set out in the withdrawal agreement and the Windsor Framework, and so be it; the British Parliament is sovereign. As President de Gaulle—who knew something about national sovereignty—said:
“Les traités … ça dure ce que ça dure”.
Treaties last as long as they last, by which he meant as long as the underlying national interests align. In this case, they did so only very briefly, as a temporary arrangement to deliver the referendum result and get us out of the EU.
The withdrawal agreement is now an empty shell. The money is paid, most of the transitional arrangements are past and only the Windsor Framework remains, resting on international convenience and the fragile balance of interests in the Belfast/Good Friday agreement and in Northern Ireland more broadly. You do not make something that is already fragile less so by balancing something else on top of it; you make it more so. That is why the Windsor Framework must go and be replaced with something robust and consistent with Northern Ireland’s status as part of the UK. The Bill shows how it can be done, and that is why I am happy to support it.