Contribution
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, on securing this debate on a critical day, as it happens, in our relationship with the European Union.
I am particularly glad to note the way in which the noble Lord framed the argument in relation to the withdrawal agreement and its relationship to the Good Friday agreement. One of my most unhappy moments when the original withdrawal agreement came forward in this House was to say that it was incompatible with the Good Friday/Belfast agreement. There was a strong sense that I was the only person in the House who had read that agreement. The withdrawal agreement was supposed to be compatible with, and to strengthen, the Good Friday/Belfast agreement. It is one of my most unhappy memories.
The other key point—the constitutional garden of Eden referenced in the Bill from the noble Lord, Lord Dodds—is much less satisfactory. It is the Act of Union 1800 which he refers to as the golden reference point that we ought to be getting back to. That includes customs and excise between Ireland and Britain. If we applied it today, Irish whiskey from Northern Ireland would, to give a simple example, cost three times more in the UK market. When he was introducing the Act of Union, Pitt said he wanted free trade, but for practical reasons it could not be.
Almost inevitably, a small part of the United Kingdom, at times, loses out in international agreements that the larger part of the United Kingdom thinks are necessary and desirable. It seems to me that that is political reality. That is essentially what has happened in this case. The Windsor Framework at least started from the point of view that you could not just walk willy-nilly over the Good Friday agreement and say that it was not a problem. It tried to mend, and did, at least some of the difficulties that we face in Northern Ireland, but by no means all.
It is a fundamental point of political reality that a smaller part of the United Kingdom is likely to find itself locked into international agreements over time that are in the interests of a larger part. That, I am afraid, is the union. Overwhelmingly, it has been beneficial to Northern Ireland over 226 years; just in the indicator of average standards of living, there is no doubt that it has been overwhelmingly in the interests of Northern Ireland. But there are bad moments. It happened in 1938 with the Anglo-Irish trade agreement, which militated against Northern Irish interests, and only one senior politician in this Parliament stood up against it—Winston Churchill. It was done because Neville Chamberlain wanted to indicate to Nazi Germany: “We can do deals with our old enemies, so we can do a deal with you”. The actual details, to the amazement of the Irish side, favoured them enormously and disfavoured Northern Ireland. Again, that is what happens. It is the nature of the relationship in a union. My major difference with the Bill is in the way that the Act of Union is treated, unproblematically, as the source of reference.
Today is a particular day. The Lords Select Committee report entitled Dynamic Alignment tells you all. As the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, has somewhat conceded, on the specific problem that Northern Ireland has of receiving laws and having no control over them, we are all now going to join it in that respect. There will be a new equality of citizenship across the two islands. I know that many will be shocked by this, and I was surprised to see gene editing included in the list, but, having said that, it means that equality of citizenship will return to a degree. I am surprised by how long the list is; having spoken on the SPS question in this House, I am surprised by how many other elements appear to be in the new deal, including gene editing. In the last cognate debate on this, the noble Lords, Lord Murphy and Lord Carlile, shared important reports on this moment in Northern Irish history and called for the Government to make sure, in the event of the recess, that the cognate changes which both of them advocated—the one-stop shop and so on—are put into effect.
I say to the Minister, who was in his seat that night, that it is vital that the Government follow up on the report of the noble Lords, Lord Murphy and Lord Carlile. Otherwise, we will have what has tended to be the case with the Windsor Framework; some of the benefits promised to Northern Ireland have not ensued while some of the negative aspects are all that the Government come to the House with through these endless SIs. For example, the Windsor Framework has delivered a break with the idea of the island economy, but the Government do not actually say that. I call on the Minister to follow up on what the noble Lord, Lord Murphy, said.