Contribution
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, on bringing forward this Bill, which would end a situation that no other country in the world would tolerate indefinitely. He proposes mutual enforcement, and I want first to examine whether that is a practical alternative to the present arrangements.
It involves Britain making it illegal to export to the EU goods that would be illegal in the EU, and requiring those doing so to pay EU tariffs before doing so. Any checks to ensure that that was happening would be carried out at the point of dispatch or the point of delivery. The presumption of mutual enforcement is that the EU would reciprocate. In fact, that is not necessary. Throughout the withdrawal process, HMRC repeatedly told Select Committees of this House that there were no circumstances in which it would require border posts to police trade from the south to the north—it is desirable that the EU reciprocates but not necessary.
Would it work? Well, it has worked. People forget that, prior to the introduction of the single market in 1992, there were border posts within Europe at the borders between France and Germany, Italy and Austria, and so on, where goods travelling between member countries, which operated different standards for SPS and other goods conditions, were checked. I was there; I saw it all happening. The European Commission did not like having border posts checking the transit of goods within the European Union, so it passed a directive saying that those border posts must go and that instead there would be mutual enforcement, and the enforcement would be carried out at the point of dispatch or the point of delivery. I have here a copy of the directive that enforced it—it is called Council Directive 89/662 of 11 December 1989, and it spells it all out. It worked. It is an EU piece of law. We can copy and paste it and use it in Northern Ireland.
The second question is whether we can get there legally. The present arrangements are an intrinsically temporary provision. We know that because the EU told us that when it was negotiating the withdrawal agreement. We wanted to negotiate the future trade arrangements and the withdrawal arrangements in parallel, and the EU said, “No, you can’t do that. We can’t negotiate future permanent trade arrangements with the United Kingdom until it is no longer a member state”. European law did not allow that—so we said that we would go along with it, and negotiate the withdrawal agreement first and then the trade arrangements. But then the EU said, “Oh, but we must include in the withdrawal agreement the trading arrangements for the Northern Ireland border, because we don’t know what the situation will be at the point you leave, or whether there’ll be any kind of trade agreement between the United Kingdom and the EU, and we have to deal with that”. We said, “Fair enough”. But the EU said, “We can do that legally, as long as it’s temporary and transitional”. So the trade arrangements, including in the withdrawal agreement, are temporary and transitional in EU law; they have to come to an end in due course.
I asked about this at the time in Parliament, and the Attorney-General said that yes, that is the case, and that if the EU tried to continue with these arrangements indefinitely, and someone in the EU took a case to the European Court to say that they were disadvantaged because the arrangements applying in Northern Ireland do not apply in Sicily or wherever, “they would win”—those were his words. It would be deemed to be a temporary and transitional arrangement.
Now there are others who say that we cannot enforce that in the EU, as we have no rights to bring cases to the ECJ. What if the Europeans change their mind and say, “Well, we now think our legal judgment then was wrong, and what we’ve done is permanent and indefinite”? In that case, the EU was negotiating in bad faith. For the same reasons, we can bring an end to this arrangement, which is intolerable, when we wish, and we should do so.
No self-respecting country would allow a division between parts of itself, leaving some of its citizens to have no say in its laws indefinitely. Would France allow a border between Corsica and the Hexagon? Would Italy allow a border between Sicily and mainland Italy? Would they allow their citizens in those separate islands and provinces to have no say in their laws, indefinitely? Maybe as a temporary and transitional arrangement they would, as we have done, but we should not allow it to go on permanently. We have the legal right to do so and the practical means of doing so in EU law.