Contribution
My Lords, before I begin, I express my heartfelt condolences—I am sure all of us in your Lordships’ House do this morning—to my noble friend Lord Morrow, who would have been with us today but who lost both his wife and daughter earlier this week. He and his family circle are in our thoughts and prayers today.
The purpose of this Bill is to address one of the most important unresolved constitutional questions arising from the UK’s departure from the European Union: why should the people of Northern Ireland be denied the democratic rights enjoyed by fellow citizens elsewhere in the United Kingdom? The fundamental defects of the protocol and Windsor Framework have not been resolved. Some practical difficulties have been eased, but the underlying, undemocratic mess remains, in essence, intact. Northern Ireland remains subject to a substantial body of European law across approximately 300 areas of legislation—not 300 laws, but areas of legislation—which can be imposed without the consent of this Parliament or the Northern Ireland Assembly. Neither legislature can amend or repeal them. There is a continuing denial of democracy in Northern Ireland.
Today, we will hear a lot about the reset and its benefits for Northern Ireland will no doubt be highlighted. However, a reset that does not remedy the core problems that Northern Ireland faces, whether democratic, constitutional or economic, cannot be regarded as a success. The proposed sanitary and phytosanitary arrangements may reduce certain trade frictions, but will not remove the underlying Irish Sea customs border or other damaging impositions. Indeed, Northern Ireland now faces the prospect of a new EU customs code, against which the Stormont brake was invoked just this week, but that was overruled by the Government, demonstrating the falsehoods of those who said it would be an effective way for Northern Ireland to stop damaging EU law applying, and showing the incoherence of a Government who say that the existence of a trade border across the English Channel is intolerable and fails the Makerfield test, yet apply it to Northern Ireland.
To those who herald the approach being taken by the Government for greater alignment, are we being asked to accept that the solution to Northern Ireland’s democratic deficit is to extend that democratic deficit to the rest of the United Kingdom? The answer to the denial of democratic rights in one part of our country cannot be to dilute those rights in the rest of it; it is to restore them in Northern Ireland.
As far as the Belfast agreement is concerned, the current arrangements actually breach that agreement, yet we are told they are necessary to protect it. The agreement established cross-community consent as a central safeguard in Northern Ireland’s political institutions. Yet, in December 2024, when the Assembly voted on continuing the application of EU law, the normal cross-community consent was uniquely set aside for this extremely important vote. Every unionist MLA who voted opposed continuation, but the arrangements were still approved. How can arrangements of such profound constitutional importance be considered sustainable when they lack the support of one of the communities in Northern Ireland? My Bill would restore the cross-community consent requirement, which is at the heart of the Belfast agreement. We are told that that agreement must be protected, but that must include the consent of both traditions and communities, and must include no change to Northern Ireland’s constitutional status without the agreement of its people.
The economic consequences of the current arrangements remain very serious. Our overwhelmingly important trading relationship is with the rest of the country, obviously. It is not a commercial relationship between foreign countries but within the United Kingdom, yet the Irish Sea border has imposed customs procedures, regulatory requirements and additional costs on that trade. We hear much about green lanes and simplified procedures, but reducing the administrative consequences of a border is not the same as removing it.
The recent report by Maureen O’Reilly, commissioned by the Northern Ireland Department for the Economy itself, identifies very large administrative and compliance difficulties for business,
“reduced engagement from GB suppliers”
regulatory divergence and particular challenges for smaller businesses. Those are not highlighted by the Government, of course; they pick on one or two bigger companies to illustrate what they want to prove. The Federation of Small Businesses found that 58% of surveyed businesses trading between Great Britain and Northern Ireland report moderate to significant challenges, while over a third reported ceasing trade rather than dealing with the new compliance arrangements. This must change. Northern Ireland’s right to participate fully in the United Kingdom’s internal market should not depend on temporary derogations, exemptions or concessions from Brussels; it should be a natural consequence of belonging to the United Kingdom.
My Bill presents an alternative. The Bill before your Lordships seeks to replace the present arrangements with a framework which restores the integrity of the United Kingdom’s internal market by protecting legitimate trading interests on both sides of the border, and which removes the necessity for foreign jurisdiction over large swathes of our economy. Central to that approach is mutual enforcement. The principle is straightforward: each jurisdiction would take responsibility for ensuring that goods exported into the other’s market comply with the destination market’s requirements. It is an alternative that was developed by respected European legal and policy experts, and those within the Commission, at the outset of all the Brexit negotiations. Compliance could be enforced through obligations on exporters, electronic declarations, remote payment of duties and substantial penalties for breaches.
Some still argue that removing the Irish Sea border between Great Britain and Northern Ireland inevitably means creating a hard border on the island of Ireland. That is clearly nonsense. The Bill provides a means of ensuring there is no hard border in any direction. The Belfast agreement does not require the United Kingdom and the Irish Republic to share customs or regulatory territory. The border already exists for legal, fiscal and administrative purposes. We have different currencies, for goodness’ sake, and different tax regimes, never mind the political differences.
The challenge is to manage the border, as we do in all those other areas, without unnecessary physical infrastructure or disruption to everyday life, and it can be done. Mutual enforcement provides a serious alternative, worthy of proper examination. Of course there are practical challenges, as with any solution, but these are not a reason to abandon the search for a workable and politically acceptable solution across the board in Northern Ireland.
The Government need to explain why these alternatives cannot be pursued, instead of treating the Windsor Framework/protocol as the only possible answer. If people refuse to countenance a solution that removes the friction on north-south trade and east-west trade and restores democracy over lawmaking to the Assembly and to Parliament, in the interests of both unionists and nationalists—because whether you are a unionist or nationalist Member of the Northern Ireland Assembly, you should want to have control over the laws that apply to the people of Northern Ireland—and if they will not address why that is unacceptable, their true motivations in persisting with the current set-up need to be called out.
Some might argue that this Bill is incompatible with international law, but international law cannot be invoked selectively. Article 1 of the protocol expressly recognises the need to protect the Belfast agreement in all its dimensions, with the consent of both communities, to respect the essential state functions and territorial integrity of the United Kingdom. Article 16 recognises that serious economic difficulties and diversion of trade may require safeguards. The United Nations declaration on friendly relations recognises the importance of respecting the national unity and territorial integrity of states. That has clearly been breached by the Windsor Framework/protocol in respect of Northern Ireland. Clauses 1 and 17 of my Bill expressly address that principle. The Government must explain how the present arrangements can be reconciled with these fundamental commitments.
A durable settlement must restore the principle that the people of Northern Ireland should enjoy the same democratic rights as their fellow citizens. The people of Northern Ireland are not asking for preferential treatment; they are asking for the same practical rights, protections and democratic entitlements enjoyed elsewhere in our country. It is called equal citizenship. The choice is clear: the Government will shortly bring forward their EU partnership Bill to dynamically align with EU law so as to manage the border problem by extending EU colony status in those areas to the rest of the UK. This Bill proposes a better solution. It would end Northern Ireland’s EU colony status, bring it into line with the rest of the country and thus bring Brexit to the whole of the UK. For those reasons, I beg to move.