Contribution
My Lords, I thank the Minister for his response. He had a lot to cram into the time that was available, which is not surprising, as this is a massive subject. The disenfranchisement of citizens of the United Kingdom and placing the law-making powers over the people of Northern Ireland in a foreign polity that is not accountable to the people of Northern Ireland and on which Parliament and the Northern Ireland Assembly cannot have any say will naturally evoke a lot of debate. If that were to happen to England, Scotland or Wales, people here would be outraged; they would not tolerate it for a minute. It is therefore right that we should debate these matters, and we will continue to do so until we get a sustainable solution. I am grateful to all noble Lords for their contributions. This is an extremely important subject, especially on this day with the reset. We will no doubt come back to these wider issues in this House and elsewhere.
We recognise that changes have been made along the way and that practical improvements have been attempted. The work and report of the noble Lord, Lord Murphy, which the noble Baroness, Lady Ludford, referred to, and the work of the Select Committee, which I have the honour to sit on under the chairmanship of the noble Lord, Lord Carlile, have been invaluable in putting the spotlight on the problems being faced by businesses in Northern Ireland. It is important that that work continues.
However, what I and other noble Lords are addressing through support for the Bill is that all the work that is going on can necessarily be only a patchwork of sticking plasters to deal with the fundamental problem. We must ultimately deal with that fundamental problem, which is the denial of democracy and the breach of the Belfast agreement. The Minister has put a lot of emphasis on the consent of the Northern Ireland Assembly and the vote but, on this one issue of the cross-community consent principle—which is at the heart of the Belfast agreement and of every vote of substance and significance in the Northern Ireland Assembly—it was set aside. For the first time in over 60 years, majoritarianism was introduced to Northern Ireland for this one vote to ensure that Northern Ireland would continue to be disenfranchised and not have the right to make its own laws in these areas. That is an issue that affects unionists, nationalists and people of no party at all. Everyone should want the people on whom laws are imposed to have representatives that they elect, not have things imposed upon them from afar.
I am grateful to those noble Lords who have spoken in support of the Bill. I am also grateful for the contributions of those who opposed it. I utterly respect each and every one of them. The noble Lord, Lord Bew, for whom I have great respect, mentioned, as he has on previous occasions, the Act of Union 1801 and the customs union, but the customs union has evolved considerably and internal markets have evolved considerably since 1801, and we should not refer to that today as if it is still the model.
The fact is that we do not have equality of citizenship under this reset, in the sense that all of the UK will now suffer in the same way as the people of Northern Ireland do, with dynamic alignment and no input into the laws that we make. It is an equality of subservience, as the noble Lord, Lord Moynihan, said, and that is not a solution. We need to find a solution that restores democracy, restores the constitutional position of Northern Ireland within the United Kingdom, and respects the Belfast agreement.
Noble Lords have only to read the speeches of the late Lord Trimble, one of the main architects of the Belfast agreement. He was vehemently opposed to the protocol on the grounds that it breached the Belfast agreement. Noble Lords have only to listen to the people on the ground and small businesses in Northern Ireland. The Minister has referred a lot to businesses in support of the reset and the Windsor Framework. He mentioned the Trader Support Service. It costs over £500 million for civil servants to try to administer the paperwork. That is not mentioned. That is money that could be spent on hospitals and schools.
The reality is that, as the Department for the Economy in Northern Ireland reported in its recent report, there is immense complexity, and problems, compliance issues and costs for businesses in Northern Ireland. For all these reasons, we will have to find a sustainable and workable solution. As the noble Lord, Lord Bew, knows well from his history and his work to bring about the Belfast agreement, if we do not get a situation that commands the support of unionists as well as nationalists, we will ultimately end up some day—I am not saying that it will happen or that I want it to happen—with a situation in Northern Ireland that becomes so unstable and fragile that the whole future of the Assembly and its institutions will be called into question. That is the reality, because you cannot continue to build upon this shaky foundation. With that, I commend the Bill to the House and I beg to move.