Contribution
My Lords, it is a great privilege and highly opportune to have secured a debate on the SPS on the day before the UK-EU reset agreement is to be unveiled. I begin by declaring an interest as the owner of a smallholding in France, where I rear sheep and poultry and grow fruit. The trade and co-operation agreement which the UK reached with our continental neighbour and largest trading partner, the EU, is the closest, deepest and most comprehensive agreement the EU has with any country outside the European Economic Area. It is closer than the agreement between Canada and its continental neighbour, the USA. Even before Trump came along, no one in Canada ever suggested that it needed to align its laws with those of the US or enter a customs union to ensure growth.
Although the TCA is a very good deal, it is not perfect; nothing in this fallen world is incapable of improvement. However, the only specific criticism the Government have ever identified is the SPS checks, delays and costs imposed by the EU on our agri-food exports. The Government are right to want to get rid of these, although to suggest that this could somehow kick-start our economy is absurd. Agriculture accounts for only 0.6% of our GDP, and our agri-food exports to the EU are only 1/10th of our agricultural production, so even if successful, and I hope it will be, this will not have any measurable effect on the overall growth of the UK economy. Even so, every little helps, so we can all agree that it would be good to have an agreement with the EU to remove unnecessary checks, delays and costs of trade in agricultural products.
However, we already have such an agreement embracing the EU. It is called the WTO’s Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures. The agreement says that SPS measures
“shall not be applied in a manner which would constitute a disguised restriction on international trade”—
which is precisely how the EU uses them. Article 4 of the agreement says:
“Members shall accept the sanitary or phytosanitary measures of other Members as equivalent, even if these measures differ from their own … if … its measures achieve the importing Member’s appropriate level of sanitary or phytosanitary protection”.
Yet even though Britain’s regulations remain in large measure identical in most areas, including dairy, fish, eggs and red meat, the EU now subjects 100% of its imports of these products from Britain to paperwork checks, and 30% to physical checks at the border. By contrast, New Zealand reached a veterinary agreement with the EU, in conformity with the WTO SPS agreement, based on equivalence, not alignment. That agreement subjects only 2% of New Zealand’s animal product exports to the EU to physical inspection. Will the Minister explain why she and her colleagues never mention this agreement?
Ministers are normally fierce exponents of the importance of adherence to international law, even when it is not in the UK’s interests; why do they not do so when it is in the UK’s interests? Presumably because it would be an embarrassment, and because they know that the WTO appellate body is inoperable, since successive American presidents of both parties have refused to nominate judges to it, so we cannot refer the EU to the WTO. Even though the EU incurs more complaints about violating SPS rules than any other member of the WTO, it simply ignores them. Even when the appellate body was operational and the EU lost cases, the EU simply refused to comply.
In these circumstances, maybe it is reasonable simply to try pragmatically to achieve abolition of these illegal checks, delays and costs by negotiation. In theory, we have a very strong hand. The EU exports four or five times as many agri-foods to us as we do to it, so it is far more important for the EU to avoid the imposition of checks, delays and costs than it is for us. However, for the first four years after we left the EU, we did not impose on imports from the EU the checks it imposed on us. Why? I suspect because, initially, officials and Ministers opted for a quiet life, and because imposing those controls would have increased the cost of living, albeit only marginally. Indeed, when the Conservative Government decided to apply those checks belatedly, they claimed:
“Our robust analysis has shown”
that SPS checks on EU produce
“will have minimal impact … just a 0.2 percentage point increase on food prices over the next three years”.
Under pressure from the NFU, the last Government, in their last year, began to impose these controls. That would have put us in a strong negotiating position vis-à-vis the EU to reciprocally remove checks, delays and costs where our regulations are identical or equivalent. However, inexplicably, at the very point that the Labour Government needed this bargaining chip, they decided to dismantle these controls. Instead of seeking a New Zealand-style agreement based on equivalence, we left it to the EU to propose the terms for removing its checks and controls. Sensing the UK’s weakness, the EU demanded four things.
First, the EU refused to open negotiations on the reset unless and until the UK agreed unconditionally not to increase our share of our fish from our waters over the next 12 years. The Government supinely signed up to that demand, so we are now legally committed to it, even if all other aspects of the reset negotiations come to nothing. The fishing industry estimates that this concession alone will cost it £500 million per annum in lost earnings—£6 billion over the period.
Secondly, the EU insisted we must dynamically align with all EU SPS legislation. UK exports to the EU already conform to EU standards; they have to, just as exports to America have to conform to American standards. The impact of dynamic alignment will fall entirely on the more than 90% of farmers who do not export to the EU, but who will have to conform none the less to EU rules. It will also affect countless firms that process, package and market food within the UK.
Defra has already published a list of 42 EU regulations and 34 directives, covering 18 different areas, which it says are
“in scope of the agreement”.
It says:
“Businesses may need to take action to comply with these requirements”.
The Orwellian introduction to that document says:
“To cut red tape and costs for importing and exporting with the EU the UK will align with EU Sanitary and Phytosanitary (SPS) legislation; food and feed safety; and broader nutrition-related areas such as food supplements, fortified foods, food for specific groups, nutrition and health claims, and nutrition labelling; wider agri-food rules related to food labelling, organics, key agri-food marketing standards and compositional standards; as well as regulation of pesticides and biocides”.
That is some simplification.
Contrary to popular opinion, since we left, British rules have diverged from those of the EU and will have to be realigned. For example, we are now able to use the thousands of different combinations of plant protection products for plants in ways that are forbidden within the EU and will be forbidden here. These are products suitable for our warm, damp climate. According to the Andersen Consulting study, as a result, our growers will lose up to £810 million in revenue—a 7% to 11% hit to overall farm incomes.
Use of the bovine TB vaccine, which has completed field trials in the UK, is forbidden under EU Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2023/361. Bovine TB costs our farms some £150 million per annum and involved slaughtering 48,000 cattle in 2025-26.
Thanks to the freedoms given to us by Brexit, this Parliament, with the support of all major parties, legalised gene editing in this country. Since then, our agriscientists—not least those in Rothamsted Research, in my old constituency—have been developing crops that are resistant to insects and require less or no insecticide or herbicide, or less fertiliser, to the benefit of consumers, farmers and the environment. The Government hope that we will retain this freedom until the EU legislates to allow gene editing. Thereafter, we will be subject to whatever EU regulations are imposed in this area; they are always heavy-handed.
We should remember three things. It is the ECJ, not legislatures within the EU, which ruled that gene editing was illegal. We will be subject to rulings of the ECJ. The EU is changing its legislation only because we were able to forge ahead thanks to Brexit. Now it is forced to copy us. Should we decide, as I hope we will, to license safely gene-modified crops, it would still be forbidden if we dynamically aligned with EU law.
The fourth condition the EU imposed on us is that, having removed those costly checks and delays on trade in agricultural products across the channel, it must now apply all those checks on our food imports from the rest of the world. This is admitted deep in a government document which says:
“Checks on imports from the rest of the world will remain, and UK check rates will align with those applied by the EU”.
It gives the number of the relevant EU regulation. So precisely the costs which we are going to remove on our trade in food with the EU we are going to impose on our trade in food with the rest of the world. Will the Minister confirm that this is the case?
Everybody—apart from the Government—who has tried to cost this proposed SPS deal, let alone the additional costs of electricity, emissions trading schemes, carbon border tariffs, Erasmus, student loans and youth mobility, has concluded that it will have a large negative cost. The Growth Commission, for example, puts the SPS costs alone at more than £1,000 per person in this country up to 2036, and £74 billion off our GDP in this period.
How did the Government come to negotiate such a one-sided agreement? First, although I normally do not comment on the abilities of Ministers, there is no single Minister in the Cabinet who has ever negotiated anything, in business or in a trade union. Former Labour Governments had formidable negotiators who came up through the unions, but this Government do not have this.
Secondly, the Government have boxed themselves in by declaring that a deal—any deal, with no specifications—with the EU would be good for Britain and essential to boosting our growth. This means that they could not walk away from a deal. Thirdly, they failed to set out our asks and work out our red lines. They left it open to the EU to set the agenda, which it duly did in its own interests, for which one cannot blame them. Fourthly, the Government assumed that if we made unilateral concessions, such as giving up £6 billion-worth of fish, the EU would reciprocate. This is not how the world works—still less the EU.
Finally, the Government had no best alternative to no deal, yet, on their own calculations, the SPS checks and paperwork costs to our exporters have amounted to £210 million over three years—£70 million per annum. It would have been cheaper simply to have subvented that cost and avoided accepting costs amounting to billions of pounds per annum of the total reset package.
I am sorry that the noble Lord, Lord Kerr, is not taking part in this debate. No one is a more committed Europhile than he. The Government should have listened to his wise words. He said of the common understanding on which this negotiation is being completed tomorrow that the UK negotiators
“suffer from a degree of timidity in what we are putting forward, and the other side suffers from a bit of excessive ambition. I do not think we should be paying contributions into the EU budget … or that it is right to try to charge us for integration into the EU electricity market. These things are a common benefit—they suit both sides—so why should we pay?”—[Official Report, 26/2/26; col. 777.]
Perhaps the Minister could tell us why we should pay for getting nothing.