Contribution
My Lords, tomorrow, the Prime Minister goes to Brussels to conclude a treaty. Its full content is unknown. It will bind every farm, abattoir, GM research company and food factory in Great Britain to rules made in Brussels on which we will have no vote. Last week’s report from your Lordships’ European Affairs Committee, which I commend as evening reading, made it absolutely clear that we will have little to no input to the shaping of those rules. This rebuts the assertion by the noble Baroness, Lady Chapman of Darlington, and the Government, that we will have influence. The EU likely sees the deal as a further step in its plan to edge the UK back into full, disastrous membership. The Financial Times today called this
“a true crossing of the Brexit Rubicon”.
The Government, echoed by credulous sock puppets in the BBC and elsewhere, including in this Chamber, claim that this deal is just about easing paperwork for those in the UK who are exporting SPS goods to the EU. I find it amazing that they can say that with a straight face. The whole of SPS in the UK will have to be brought over to the EU’s SPS rules. The entire UK now has to follow those rules: the EU’s rules, not ours. That includes all SPS goods exported from the UK to the rest of the world. Even worse, for all SPS goods that we import from the rest of the world, the EU’s protectionist wall will be erected: for Morocco, Japan, Egypt, Thailand, Turkey and many others, including those countries that the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, whom I welcome to this place, mentioned. It is a pity that she and the noble Lord, Lord O’Neill, did not remain in their places to hear this. The barriers will all be erected by us, under EU compulsion, to all those countries.
Many who currently export to us will no longer bother as much—and when they do it will be at a higher price. The gap will be filled by—guess who?—exporters from the EU to the UK. Another captured market is brought into line by the EU, a success for it. Industry figures estimate a past cost of roughly £60 million a year from vet-signed export health certificates. That is the only hard benefit figure that we have for this deal.
What about the cost of the deal, which the Government are so silent about? The pesticide manufacturers’ analysis says that an immediate switch to EU pesticide rules would cost arable, horticulture and sugar growers between £500 million and £800 million in year 1. The Fresh Produce Consortium estimates more than £300 million a year in extra costs from applying EU-style checks to fruit and vegetables that are coming into the UK from the rest of the world: food that will never go near the EU.
For all these munificent benefits, we are told that we will pay a financial contribution to Brussels, the size of which the Government have so far failed to disclose but which alone will likely dwarf any possible financial benefits to this small economic subsector of ours. England, ahead of Europe, has successfully legislated in ever-improving regimes for gene-edited crops. Without a permanent carve-out, not just one that lapses in July 2028, that flourishing industry in this country will die as the rest of the world—America, China, Brazil, even Argentina—will take it away from us. Our farmers will lose access to treatments, chemicals and technologies that the EU will not approve. Many will be banned by the EU on the ludicrous “precautionary principle” basis, and we will just have to take it.
Our trading partners will be unhappy, and that will cost us. The US trade representative said in a Financial Times interview last week that our planned alignment with EU rules is now a “problem” for expanding our trade deal with it. Within the CPTPP, the SPS chapter is enforceable through state-to-state disputes. Australia and Canada have already raised concerns. Every EU rule we must adopt but cannot defend on the science—and there will be plenty of those, because the EU is anything but scientific—is a case waiting to be brought against us.
The Government assert a headline benefit of £5.1 billion a year by 2040 and then admit, as other noble Lords have said, that they have not done a full cost-benefit analysis. So how do they know? The only hard figure is that £60 million-a-year saving and, as we have seen, the pesticide cost to us alone is some 10 times that. Our exporters to the EU correctly complain that the EU imposes unreasonable inspections on incoming goods from the UK, sending loads back for trivial paperwork errors. The EU is wrong, petty and confrontational to do that. However, there is a way of responding, as my noble friends have already said: fight back until the EU behaves better, while in the meantime financially and administratively helping our exporters.
The EU and the UK have equivalent levels of SPS standards. WTO rules state that these should be recognised once demonstrated, just as the EU has agreed with New Zealand. Mutual recognition of equivalent systems—the model that the NFU argued for and that many of us on the Conservative side have been advocating since the Brexit vote—would cut physical inspections to a fraction of today’s level and simplify the paperwork without surrendering control of our rules. It would also solve the Northern Ireland problem.
So will the Government publish a full impact assessment, including the cost to growers, importers and exporters to the rest of the world, before signature? Will they secure binding exemptions for precision breeding and plant protection products? Will they tell the House what the full financial contribution will be? Will they promise that Parliament will have a vote on each new EU rule before it becomes our law?
I finish by saying that we left to make our own rules. Three-quarters of the people of Makerfield said in an opinion poll last week that they want to continue making our food laws solely in this country. Why would the Prime Minister betray his own constituents’ views in this way?