Contribution
My Lords, I apologise to noble Lords and to all my colleagues that, because of an unfortunate situation, I may have to leave slightly before the end.
The noble Lord, Lord Dodds, has set out clearly why this Bill should be supported. I am yet to hear—though perhaps we will from other speakers—why it should not be supported. I was not quite clear whether the noble Lord, Lord Bew, supports it or not, but that is obviously for us to think about.
I remind noble Lords that we had the same ballot paper as everywhere else in the rest of the United Kingdom when it came to leaving the European Union. The ballot paper asked whether we wished the United Kingdom to leave. It did not say in brackets, “but leave out Northern Ireland for lots of different aspects”. That is my first point.
I want to deal briefly with one of the real myths surrounding the entire discussion on the protocol and the Windsor Framework: that somehow, creating this “hard” border—a word which was used without anyone actually analysing what it meant—across the island of Ireland would be contrary to the Belfast/Good Friday agreement. That was repeated over and over again. Let us be clear: the land border exists, and, actually, the Good Friday agreement made it a much more recognised fact. On the one hand, the Republic of Ireland agreed to amend its constitution and drop its territorial claim on Northern Ireland; at the same time, the agreement was made that, if certain explicit conditions were met, there could be a poll on both sides of the border as to whether people wanted to stay part of the UK or move to be part of the Republic.
The reality is that the land border is a frontier. As has been pointed out by the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, it is a frontier at which the Republic of Ireland has different tax and excise rates, a different currency, and you go into kilometres as you go across the border. It has immigration controls, with people sometimes being stopped on the buses and trains. The Republic of Ireland is an independent country. Yes, it has got very special arrangements with the rest of the United Kingdom—we have the common travel area, and we obviously pay a lot of money to help defend the Republic of Ireland—but the spin that the Good Friday/Belfast agreement states that there can be no customs posts at the frontier is completely wrong. It says no such thing. It was referring to the military posts there, during the period when the armed IRA was coming across, preventing terrorists coming over to bomb and kill in Northern Ireland.
The Good Friday/Belfast agreement set up cross-border mechanisms for co-operation. If there was no border then there would be no need for those cross-border mechanisms. A land border with the EU was always going to have to be dealt with, as the EU would, rightly, want to protect its internal market and we would want to protect ours. Enda Kenny, who was Taoiseach around the time we were leaving, was very supportive of the development of smart border technology being operated, as is now contained in much of what the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, has said. Sadly, the new Government in the Republic stopped all discussion between civil servants on this. We ended up with the European Union, cleverly pushed by the Republic of Ireland, recognising that this was a good way of ensuring not only that the United Kingdom was punished for daring to leave but that Northern Ireland was left under EU rules in so many areas. It was also a bridge to getting the whole of the United Kingdom back, whenever such a Government came in and wanted it. Sadly, it looks like we have such a Government at the moment who want that.
I have been cheered up by the fact that there has been so much shift on this now. The Opposition seem to be clear that this is unsustainable and that something has to be done. The Reform party has made it quite clear that it supports mutual enforcement, and, if we had a Reform Peer here, they would be saying so. Danny Kruger has written an article today that makes it quite clear that Reform would want to change this, which I am very pleased about. That has cheered me up.
Will the Minister say why the Labour Government will not recognise that this is unsustainable and that it has to be changed? I apologise again if I am not here, but I will read carefully what he says. Bringing back our country into one United Kingdom should have been the first item in any reset with the European Union, making sure that the European Union does not control so much in our own country. When I read Hansard, I would like to find a real reason given that allows me to go away feeling even more cheerful that something might happen in the near future.