Contribution
My Lords, I also welcome the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, to her role here, and I hope she has a very enjoyable time over the next number of years.
Yesterday, the Minister for the Cabinet Office responded to a Written Parliamentary Question from the honourable Member for Harwich and North Essex about the UK-EU SPS agreement and said:
“Negotiations on the UK-EU SPS Agreement are on-going ahead of the UK-EU Summit on 20 November. We will publish the full treaty text once”
ratified. So, as is very plain, this is not just a summit; this is negotiating a proper SPS treaty with the European Union. In this context, having listened carefully to the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, I ask the Minister to explain exactly why we are negotiating a treaty with the European Union when the EU and the UK are both signatories to the World Trade Organization SPS treaty. Why do we need this, when we already have a treaty that allows both sides to recognise their standards?
The noble Lord quoted very carefully what the treaty says, so I will not repeat that. Our protections and all the ways we make sure we have the same standards are certainly as good as, and probably far better than, the European Union’s. If we look at the European Union map of animal diseases, we see that there is a far greater biosecurity risk from the EU, and the Minister must recognise this. Catherine McBride, the economist, has said
“the EU is full of animal diseases such as foot-and-mouth disease in cattle, African Swine Fever in pigs and wild boar, Peste des Petits Ruminants (PPR) in sheep and goats”—
I hope those of the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, have not been affected in France—
“and Lumpy Skin Disease … in cattle”.
Is it not ridiculous that while the EU is content to accept equivalence with a country on the other side of the world such as New Zealand, it does not want to do so in relation to a country which is very close? Nowhere in the WTO treaty does it say that you cannot accept the SPS standards of countries far away or that you cannot apply them to those located very closely.
The EU says that it is deeply committed to international law, but it seems it only cherry-picks the bits it wants to commit to and rejects those that it does not. That is precisely what it is doing now. The text of the treaty is very clear that:
“Members shall accept the sanitary or phytosanitary measures of other Members as equivalent, even if these measures differ from their own”.
As has been pointed out, ours do not differ. The text goes further. There is a very long passage which ends by saying that SPS measures
“shall not be applied in a manner which would constitute a disguised restriction on international trade”.
The National Farmers’ Union has priced GB compliance with the additional demands to which the EU is going to subject all farmers, not just those who are exporting to the European Union—over 130 pieces of EU legislation—at around £800 million. It is impossible to see this as anything less than a very poorly disguised restriction on trade. So I ask the Minister again why the Government are negotiating a new treaty with the EU that accommodates the EU’s failure to abide by its existing international obligations under the WTO SPS treaty.
Even prior to negotiating this treaty, the UK Government had already acquiesced with EU attempts to flout its existing SPS treaty obligations to an even greater extent, with the result that it is contravening even more fundamental obligations in international law. The EU’s refusal to respect SPS measures of other members as equivalent resulted in a sovereign state, the UK, being cut into two through an international SPS border separating Northern Ireland from Great Britain, in violation of the UN Declaration on Principles of International Law and not in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations, which states:
“Every State shall refrain from any action aimed at the partial or total disruption of the national unity and territorial integrity of any other State or country”.
By acting in this way, cutting the UK in two through the imposition of an international SPS border, the EU 27 have plainly disrupted the national unity and territorial integrity of the United Kingdom.
In this context, instead of accommodating the desire of the EU to cherry-pick international law, our Government should have this as the first item on any reset agenda, but we know that the failure to protect our own national unity is now acting as a key driver for the wider EU reset. On 9 March 2026, when the UK Government announced their intention to subject GB to over 70 EU SPS laws, Defra took the unusual step of issuing a press release targeted at Northern Ireland. It pointed out that extending EU SPS dynamic alignment from Northern Ireland to the rest of the UK would be of great benefit to Northern Ireland, because it would end the divergence between NI and the rest of the UK. In requiring Great Britain to dynamically align with over 130 pieces of EU legislation, this arrangement is, in effect, taking from Great Britain the ability to exercise self-determination in critical issues of SPS and biosecurity. Although the EU is seeking to dynamically align the whole UK with the SPS law, the mandate provided to the Commission by the Council of Ministers to negotiate with the UK refused to even minimally recognise the UK in the sense of allowing a deal that facilitates UK SPS law. Instead, it authorises negotiations only for a common SPS area specifically in respect of Great Britain. If the UK Government believe in the UK, in its territorial integrity and self-government, and in international law, which supports both, why are they acquiescing with the EU in its determination to undermine all three?
Finally, all the hype and the spin being launched that the reset will fix the Irish Sea border is just that, spin, and indeed not true. There is no attempt to tackle the central expression of the Irish Sea border—a customs frontier within the UK in the Irish Sea continues, even if there is an SPS agreement. Even this week, the Government have acknowledged this by refusing to pull the Stormont brake in relation to the application of the new custom border legislation the EU has introduced, which makes it plain to a far greater degree than the old legislation that Great Britain stands as a third country, which is referred to many times. We are even referred to as a foreign country in relation to Northern Ireland. We have to stop our kowtowing once again to a European diktat. When will this Government stand up for British interests and the United Kingdom as a whole?