Contribution
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, for introducing this important Bill to the House. He has made a compelling case to inform our discussion, and I am sure other noble Lords are grateful for that.
First, I want to acknowledge that there are different views on this topic, as we have heard so far in the debate. We have heard a number of speakers raise points against the Bill and I will try to address some of those points in my remarks. However, I support the Bill, because the system designed to record complications from what is a major health event in a woman’s life no longer reflects the reality of women’s lives today.
As the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, said, under the Abortion Regulations 1991, notification of an abortion via the statutory form requires medical practitioners to record complications occurring up until the time of discharge from the place of termination. However, we should be very clear that, in 1991, the vast majority of those terminations happened via surgical operations; figures indicate that these were 95% of the total at that time. Now the latest figures, from 2023, suggest that the situation has been almost entirely reversed; 87% of terminations are medical, which means after taking abortion pills, rather than by an operation. With operations, women remained under direct medical supervision until discharge, which allowed any immediate adverse effects to be observed, documented, reported and, crucially, treated in a timely manner.
This is important because it calls into question the value of the forms—we have heard about the HSA4 form and the ANS—as they currently stand. The 2023 statistics showed that 72% of those terminations involved taking both medications at home following a remote consultation. That is a marked increase from previous years: it compares to 34.3% in 2020 and 51.9% in 2021. For an at-home medical abortion, there is no meaningful concept of clinical discharge. If a woman experiences adverse symptoms, such as severe haemorrhaging, retained pregnancy tissue or infection, she is likely not to return to an independent abortion provider but to present to her local NHS A&E or perhaps call 111. Any abortion-related complications would then be captured in hospital episode statistics.
As the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, mentioned, the Office for Health Improvement and Disparities undertook a review which clearly showed that the hospital episode statistics identified an average complication rate 2.6 times higher than that derived from ANS data. In fact, when incomplete abortions are included—when the unpleasant-sounding products of conception remain—the complication rate is 11.9 times higher than was identified through the ANS data covering the same period. This is a significant disparity. That discrepancy has likely worsened, as the proportion of abortions that take place away from a clinical setting has increased since the publication of the data used by the OHID review. I was also concerned to read in that report that OHID found “no evidence” of abortion providers contacting the DHSC to ensure the data was updated when a woman had informed the abortion provider about a complication occurring after the form had been submitted.
I want to be clear that personal views on the subject of abortion in general, whatever they are, have no bearing on this Bill. Quite simply, there is a gap in our understanding that needs to be plugged. Continuing to rely solely on the existing system leaves us with only a partial grip on the reality for women undergoing termination of pregnancy and the complications that they may experience.
I note that the Minister indicated that there were possible concerns about technical difficulties when the Bill was in Committee. I accept that these are difficult systems to link up but, as the 2023 report shows, this is a surmountable problem. We should not accept that this is too difficult to do, as we are thinking about the safety of women. I am aware that work is being undertaken to digitise the process, so I look forward to hearing the Minister’s response. I hope the Government have reconsidered their position and will support the noble Lord’s quite modest proposal.