Contribution
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, for securing this debate. His timing, on the eve of the summit in Brussels, could hardly be better. I warmly congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, on an outstanding maiden speech. Her Remain credentials mean that any seating error will also be warmly welcomed on these Benches at any point in the future, should she lose her way in the Chamber. While we are swapping “Who met Nelson Mandela?” stories, I once had the honour. A really classy person such as Nelson Mandela will always find the most junior person in the room, and that of course was me. She has made her mark today, and I look forward to many more contributions from her.
It was an unexpected delight to hear from the noble Baroness, Lady Chapman of Darlington, the noble Lord, Lord O’Neill of Gatley, and, indeed, the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong, about the future opportunity of trade with Africa and all that Africa has to offer. It was a nice and refreshing diversion from some of the standard discussions.
The Motion asks us to look at international processes and approaches, and I am happy to do so. But given that other noble Lords have dwelt on the approach that this country took, I will start at home. In 2020, the last Government signed a trade agreement that put regulatory freedom ahead of trade without friction. We were promised the easiest deal in history, but the bill arrived in the farmyard, at the port and on the deli counter.
The NFU tells us that food exports to the EU have fallen by a third since Brexit, with eggs, chicken and potato products the worst hit. Fresh sausages, burgers, shellfish from our own waters and seed potatoes have been shut out of our nearest market altogether. The red lines negotiated at that time turned into reams and reams of endless red tape. Every consignment of animal products needs a £200 export health certificate. Small firms pay a vet to sign off every pallet. Jon Walsh of Bio&Me, a small company making yoghurt and granola, told the BBC that each pallet cost £140 in vets’ fees, so they lost money and stopped exporting. In his words:
“You just kind of give up”.
A haulier told a committee of the House of Commons that a lorry of frozen beef sat in Calais for 27 days because one certificate was wrong. I am delighted that the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, raised the issue of cheese. Small delis here can no longer buy a few wheels of cheese from France or Italy because the paperwork costs more than the cheese. To quote a former, briefly serving, Prime Minister: “that is a disgrace!”
That was not the only bad deal. The trade deal with Australia, which these Benches warned at the time sold out British farmers, was later described by a former Conservative Environment Minister as
“not actually a very good deal for the UK”.
He went on to say that we
“gave away far too much for far too little in return”.
Our farmers were asked to compete with producers on the other side of the world while losing easy access to customers on the other side of the channel. That is not taking back control; it is giving away a market.
When noble Lords describe this agreement as a “surrender”, I ask them to look at who is asking for it. The NFU supports it, the supermarkets support it and the British Chambers of Commerce says that business believes common rules are a “price worth paying” for lower costs, fewer delays and more access. The people who live with these checks every day are not asking for more sovereignty over paperwork; they are asking for the paperwork to go.
I turn now to the Motion. New Zealand’s agreement with the EU is often held up as the alternative. As I understand it, that agreement rests on equivalence, which reduces checks but does not remove them—certificates remain and inspections remain, albeit at a lower rate. The country that has removed veterinary checks at the EU border is Switzerland, and it did so in the same way this agreement proposes, by sharing the rules. If the aim is to remove checks rather than trim them, the international evidence points one way.
I turn now to gene editing, which has been presented in parts of this House and parts of the press as the great roadblock. I do not believe the facts bear that out. First, the EU is catching up with us, and that is a good thing. In June, the European Parliament gave final approval to new rules on gene-edited plants. Plants that could have been produced by conventional breeding came out of the old GMO regime. It is a two-tier system, broadly similar to the one Parliament put in place for England. Most of it applies from July 2028.
Secondly, the timetables meet. The SPS agreement is not now expected to take effect until early 2028. It has been reported, including in the home paper of the Benches next to me, the Daily Telegraph—not a newspaper famous for its enthusiasm for Brussels—that British gene-edited crops will have a temporary exemption until the EU regime is up and running.
Thirdly, we should listen to the scientists. I feel we are slightly missing them on the Cross Benches today. Professor Johnathan Napier of Rothamsted Research called the EU’s decision
“a seismic shift in how gene edited crops are regulated in Europe”.
That is the point. An English precision-bred wheat that can be sold freely to 450 million people is worth far more than one that stops at Dover. Indeed, today’s regime in England does not even reach Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland. There are differences. The EU limits the number of edits, it requires seed labelling and it is further behind on animals. Those need careful handling, but careful handling is not a roadblock.
From these Benches, we welcome this agreement and we want it to work for farmers as well as the fishing community. Tavish Scott, the chief executive of Salmon Scotland—Scottish salmon is the UK’s largest food export, with strong demand within the EU, the US and elsewhere—said that a new agreement would help cut the time taken to get products into the EU market. It requires a proper transition, and I ask the Minister to take note of Alistair Carmichael’s committee’s recommendations about the transition period.
While we are on international rules, like the noble Lords, Lord Hannay and Lord Carlile, I find it striking that the Benches beside me do not seem to object to Britain taking rules from elsewhere after all. They simply prefer the rules from Geneva rather than those from Brussels. Our farmers do not sell their lamb in Geneva; they sell it to wider markets.
Let us be honest about this agreement. As my colleague Al Pinkerton MP put it, as far as we are concerned, it is a patch, not a fix. Our exporters will still face customs declarations and VAT paperwork. The long-term answer is a customs union with the EU—which the House of Commons voted in favour of last December, with a little bit of help from the Labour Benches, for which many thanks to those people—and, in time, the single market.
I have just two questions for the Minister, and I am more than happy if she would prefer to write the answers, because it has been a long week for her. Will she confirm that the Government will keep England’s precision breeding regime in place until the EU’s is fully operational? Will she make sure that farmers get the transition time they require, particularly on plant protection products?
The Motion invites us to look abroad for answers. Having looked, I am more convinced than ever that the best approach for British farmers lies much closer to home—21 miles across the channel. We support this agreement; we only wish it would go further.