L

Lord Roborough (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

Sanitary and Phytosanitary Checks at EU Borders

Contribution

My Lords, I thank my noble friend Lord Lilley for this important and timely debate, and for his comprehensive remarks and expertise in this area. It was also a great pleasure to hear the maiden contribution from the noble Baroness, Lady Sarpong. I think all Benches are looking forward to future interventions. Before I begin, I refer the House to my register of interests, including as a forester, farmer and agricultural landlord. My comments primarily address how we can best support our farmers and food producers today and in the future, while protecting food and biosecurity and delivering high-quality, affordable food to consumers. Dynamic alignment is not just about aligning certain standards with those of the EU. There are cases where that is sensible, evidence-based and beneficial. Alternatively, some countries, such as New Zealand, keep different rules but recognise others as providing an equivalent level of food safety. In these cases, it has meant that all physical checks can be removed. Dynamic alignment, however, and the SPS agreement that is expected to be finalised at the summit tomorrow, are the British Government giving the EU control of our food and biosecurity. We do not have representation in the EU Parliament or a veto over the EU Commission, so why would we voluntarily sign up to future laws without having a formal seat at the table? It is more accurate to call this automatic alignment rather than dynamic alignment. Nor are we just picking up from where we left off when the UK left the EU in 2020. It will not surprise noble Lords to hear that the EU has continued to legislate since then. We on these Benches are committed to reducing red tape and costs for British businesses. Signing up to the EU SPS means vast new regulation on our farming and food sector. There are more than 400 pieces of primary EU SPS legislation, 76 core directives and regulations, and countless other standards, some of which have changed since 2020. We will be taking on more laws and regulations, not cutting them. Many businesses already align their practices with those approved by the EU without the need for government intervention, but this agreement would force all businesses to comply, even if they do not export to the EU. In fact, approximately 90% of our farms do not. This Government have said that an SPS deal could be worth up to £5.1 billion per annum by 2040. This estimate is far enough away to be tenuous at best. Independent assessments put the reality as ranging from no impact to as much as a negative £15 billion per annum. The Minister for Intergovernmental and European Relations today said in the other place that the Government find the impact on farmers to be “quite difficult to quantify”—that is not exactly reassuring. CropLife UK estimates that dynamic alignment could cost UK farming up to £810 million in the first year. The Growth Commission estimates that the agreement could cost the UK £15 billion. We have previously been told that negotiations are ongoing and therefore Ministers cannot comment on the detail, but the 200-page text has been agreed, and if they can promote the supposed economic benefits, they should be up front about how they are calculated and what the costs might be. Can the Minister provide us with a timeline and breakdown of how the £5.1 billion figure was calculated? Can she confirm that the £6 billion figure for the surrender of our fisheries over the next 12 years is included in that calculation? If it is not included, what particular benefit did that gift bring to our country from the EU, since the defence deal that was dangled in front of the last Prime Minister disappeared after we gave away our fisheries? It was a successful bit of bait and switch, although we do not quite know what it has been switched for yet. We import £47 billion of food, feed and drink products from the EU and export only £15 billion, of which one-third goes to Ireland. That is 23% of EU food exports coming to our country. This is why my noble friend Lord Redwood called us the “treasure island” for the European food industry. The benefits for the EU of an SPS deal appear meaningfully larger for it than for us. Our exports to the EU are focused on notable successes such as cheese, horticulture, whisky, farmed and wild fish, and lamb. Those fell by 16% post Brexit as the EU chose to apply full SPS checks on UK exports from the beginning of 2021, while we began our own checks only in 2024. The prize for British farming and food production overall from an SPS deal is small and likely concentrated within those particular sectors, while the threat from increased imports of EU food is very high. Since Brexit, government payments to our farming industry have fallen by 30% in real terms and the funds farmers now receive are wholly for environmental goods and services, to which significant costs are attached. Across the EU, the average subsidy to farmers stands at €376 per hectare, with little or no cost attached. That equates to roughly three times the net value of UK farm receipts from government per hectare. We have been asking our farmers to compete with a heavily subsidised farming sector in the EU. That is not working and will not work., and making it easier to trade with the EU exposes our farmers to even greater unfair competition. How does the SPS increase our domestic food security if our farmers are exposed to more cost and greater subsidised competition? For them, this is a major administrative task, even if more generous transition periods are negotiated. As we have warned previously, growers have already made their production decisions for food sold beyond mid-2027, when this agreement is expected to come into force. Can the Minister confirm the expected implementation date of this agreement? Smaller businesses in particular will be affected by these burdens, risking a further increase to the cost of living. The Food and Drink Federation has said that this will not bring food prices down. We in the UK have moved on as well since leaving the EU SPS and have made significant progress in several areas. As others have mentioned, the UK now leads the world in precision breeding following the Genetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Act 2023, passed by our last Government. Will the SPS deal protect our precision breeding sector across both crops and livestock, without any imposition of protectionist measures such as labelling the output? The Government’s bovine TB strategy makes much of the development of a bovine TB vaccine for cows, crucially supported by the DIVA test allowing for the distinction between vaccinated and infected cattle. Will the UK be able to continue with the planned rollout of bovine TB vaccinations and tests, as laid out in the Government’s bovine TB strategy? What ability will the UK have to take geographic advantage in protecting ourselves against biosecurity risks? Will we be able to apply tailored, risk-based safeguards against animal and plant disease and pest threats? There are 17 active substances available to our farmers but not in the EU. Will our farmers be able to continue to use those? In particular, will our farmers be able to continue to use glyphosate as a pre-harvest desiccant? Our other international trading partners expect us to continue with our current science-based approach. We are concerned that the new SPS agreement will not be compatible with the UK’s membership of the CPTPP and cause litigation and sanction risks from our other trading partners. I have previously asked Written Questions on this subject and did not feel reassured by the replies, so can the Minister guarantee that this will not be the case? This would affect not only food but potentially pharmaceuticals and other key sectors. Are our trading partners elsewhere in the world aware of the obligations we take on with an SPS deal and how they relate to our existing agreements? Many countries share the opinion of my noble friend Lord Lilley that the SPS structure in the EU is protectionist in nature. Trade with Africa has been mentioned several times in this debate and I cannot believe that signing up to the SPS will make that easier. As I have said, this is not just about the principle of sovereignty over our own laws, fundamental though that is. There are pragmatic reasons as to why we have not aligned with all of the EU’s regulations and legitimate concerns as to what this new agreement will mean for our trade with other partners, for domestic businesses, and for the cost of living. The Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee reported earlier this year: “The realities and implications of dynamic alignment have not been well explained to the public. There is a need for a fuller debate”. I therefore thank my noble friend Lord Lilley for this essential debate ahead of tomorrow’s summit and I look forward to hearing the Minister’s responses.

More from Lord Roborough (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.