Contribution
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, on introducing this highly topical and important Bill, and I thank her for her excellent chairmanship of the Environment and Climate Change Committee, of which I have the privilege of being a member. I also thank the noble Earl, Lord Russell, who first encouraged the committee to inquire into waste crime. Without his initial impetus, we might not have uncovered the issues that we have already heard about, which are so damaging to many communities and our environment.
Our inquiry showed that waste crime is low-risk, high-reward and an excellent career choice for the aspiring young criminal. It is often run by international organised crime gangs, and, as the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, said, it is linked to other types of crime, such as people smuggling, drugs and money laundering. Of course, waste crime is not cost-free: the costs are borne by taxpayers, landowners, local authorities and farmers. It blights the lives of people living nearby and damages the environment. As the noble Lord, Lord Grantchester, said, we all have our own favourite waste site near where we live. I live in Oxford and mine happens to be in Kidlington. As we have already heard, the Kidlington site contained 21,000 tonnes of illegal waste and is costing £7 million to clean up. Does the Minister have any information about the question of pollution into the nearby River Cherwell from the Kidlington waste dump?
We have already heard from the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, about Philip Duffy, the chief executive of the Environment Agency, who gave evidence last week to the Environment and Climate Change Committee. I thought his comments were a succinct and cogent summary of why the Bill is needed. He welcomed the additional resources and effort being put into tackling waste crime in the field, as well as the 10-point plan. However, he said that this is tackling the symptoms rather than the cause; it is an end-of-pipe solution. Tackling the end of the pipeline by prosecuting those caught dumping illegal waste will never be effective enough because the courts are too slow, the chances of being caught are too low, and, if you are caught, the fines are too low. He might also have added that the people caught are generally the small fry. Mr Big is quite possibly living in the Cayman Islands or a Mediterranean villa—think “McMafia”.
Philip Duffy went on to say that we need to go further upstream and tackle the problem at source. This is precisely what the Bill aims to do. It places responsibility on the producer of waste to ensure that it is disposed of legally. We heard from the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe of Epsom, that this will impose an unnecessary burden on many businesses, but, as the Environmental Services Association says, any business that is already behaving legally and is compliant will not feel extra costs; the impact of regulation will be felt by those who are irresponsible.
We will also no doubt hear the question of whether the Bill is necessary, because there is an existing duty of care under Section 34 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990. But the fact that waste crime is such a big problem perhaps suggests that this duty of care is not enough. The Bill will strengthen the regulatory controls by having a named director, improved governance, clearer audit trails and financial liability.
Finally, I will mention the fact that Ministers are obliged by the Environment Act 2021 to have due regard to the five environmental principles in any area of legislation. At least three of the principles are embedded in this Bill. The “polluter pays” principle, the “rectification at source” principle of addressing damage where it originates rather than downstream, and the “prevention” principle of stopping harm proactively before it occurs.
Therefore, I urge the Government to show their commitment to these principles by accepting the Bill. It will be popular with communities, it will be popular with farmers—we are told by the NFU that 29% have experienced illegal waste dumping and 12% have been threatened—and it will be popular with the environmental movement. So what is not to like? I very much hope that the Minister will tell us that the Government accept the Bill.