L

Lord Sharpe of Epsom (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 November 2026

Debate

Corporate Waste Responsibility Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, for introducing this debate on the Bill and the Bill itself. We are also grateful to the committee for its extensive work in diagnosing the scale of the problem, which is undeniably acute. Unfortunately, we have a problem with the proposed solution. There is no disagreement that tackling illegal waste disposal and fly-tipping is of the utmost importance, but we have concerns about the additional regulatory burdens that this Bill will impose on business. Businesses have endured more than two years of increasing costs and regulatory pressures under this Government. From the increase in employers’ national insurance contributions—the jobs tax—to the Employment Rights Act and the business rates regime, businesses have faced cost after cost. At a time when many are struggling to afford to recruit new employees, invest and expand, the last thing they need is yet another set of regulatory requirements. Clause 1 would require every qualifying large company to appoint a named director responsible for waste compliance, regardless of whether that business operates in the waste industry. While the Bill allows an existing director to assume that responsibility, it would nevertheless impose additional compliance, reporting and record-keeping obligations on businesses. Companies would also have to maintain records for at least six years and notify regulators of suspected waste-related criminal activity in their supply chains. These requirements would disproportionately burden the responsible businesses already doing the right thing, while doing little to tackle the rogue operators deliberately engaging in illegal waste disposal. It would impose further costs on legitimate businesses without addressing the underlying failures in enforcement. I declare my interests as a company director as set out in the register, but any individual accepting these responsibilities would have to be borderline insane. It is welcome that the Government finally recognised the need to reduce some of these burdens when, in January 2026, they abandoned their proposed audit reform and corporate governance Bill, acknowledging that further corporate governance measures would increase costs for businesses. They are therefore right to reject the recommendations of the Environment and Climate Change Committee. Conservatives set out in our 2026 “Alternative King’s Speech” and wider economic programme that we believe the Government should be reducing unnecessary regulation rather than continually adding to it. Our proposals include scrapping mandatory sustainability and climate-related ESG reporting requirements and removing diversity and inclusion reporting requirements for financial services businesses. The Government need to examine the cumulative burden of existing reporting and compliance requirements, and whether the time and resources currently devoted to unnecessary paperwork could be better directed towards productive investment, employment and ensuring that waste is disposed of responsibly. Businesses are already subject to a statutory waste duty of care under Section 34 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990. During the passage of the Crime and Policing Bill, the Conservatives successfully amended the legislation to give police officers explicit powers to seize vehicles used by fly-tippers. Despite being defeated in the House of Lords, the Government rejected that amendment in the other place, ultimately agreeing only to strengthen statutory guidance on the use of existing powers. Rather than imposing further regulatory burdens on responsible businesses, the Government should focus instead on ensuring that those committing waste offences face effective enforcement and punishment. The answer to fly-tipping cannot be simply to impose further regulatory costs on every large qualifying business in the country. If the Government are serious about encouraging growth, attracting private investment and making Britain a more competitive place to do business, they should be looking to reduce the cumulative burden of regulation, not add to it. For those reasons, I oppose the Bill.

More from Lord Sharpe of Epsom (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.