Lord Stevens of Birmingham (CB)

My Lords, I speak specifically against Amendment 771, which would require the Secretary of State to establish an assisted dying help service as part of the National Health Service. I believe that that is a conceptually misplaced proposition in that, if we cast our minds back to last Friday, it was completely evident that the sponsor of the Bill does not intend that only in cases of unbearable pain or suffering would a person be eligible for the assisted dying service. Instead, concerns about your finances or being a burden on your family would be defined as legitimate bases for making the choice to opt for an assisted death. It is not the proper function of a national health service to deal with financial burdens or pressures on people’s families in that way: that is a category mistake. Indeed, the founding charter for the NHS, the National Health Service Act 1946, is quite clear, and all successive health Acts have laid out the purpose of the NHS, which is “to promote the establishment … of a comprehensive health service designed to secure improvement in the physical and mental health of the people of England and Wales and the prevention, diagnosis and treatment of illness”. Assisted dying does not fall within the scope of that purpose. In fact, I think that must be evident indeed to the drafters of the Bill, because somewhat camouflaged at Clause 41(4) is the suggestion that, by regulations, that founding charter for the National Health Service could be amended to include assisted dying. They reference the fact that change is probably required to the most recent iteration, the 2006 Act, to bring that about. I do not think it can be said legitimately that this is a part of the purpose of the National Health Service, and it is unnecessary in practice, organisationally. Just because doctors, like lawyers and social workers, are proposed to be involved in this, it does not mean it is inherently part of the National Health Service. Doctors do DWP assessments, but that does not mean the National Health Service runs the benefits system. Doctors are involved in driving licence assessments, but that does not mean the National Health Service runs the DVLA. Doctors are involved in the criminal justice system as forensic medical examiners, but that does not mean the NHS needs to run the court system.