Baroness Blackstone (Lab)

I was not going to interrupt the noble Lord, but his last remark does lead me to interrupt him. I do not think there is anybody who backs the Bill because they think it is more expensive for people to continue to be treated. Nor do I think it is the case that those people who back the Bill are in some way unaware of the societal context in which people live and die. We are all aware of that. Moreover, some of the comments from those who oppose the Bill or are trying to introduce more amendments to it neglect the fact that most doctors—nobody is perfect, of course, but most doctors—are fully aware of their obligations as members of society and of a caring profession. They spend a lot of time trying to help and advise their patients not just about their immediate medical needs but their other needs. It is certainly the case that most general practitioners will help a patient who is suffering because of poverty. They will find ways in which they can access funding and support the patient in terms of their worries about being a burden. So I do not think anybody who supports this Bill suggests for one moment that we should accept that a patient who feels they are a burden should die just for that reason. The reason they do think they should die, if they want to, is that their suffering is intolerable. That is what lies behind those who back this Bill’s motivation. I hope the noble Lord will accept that and understand that there is nothing in what we are saying which suggests that we simply want people to be able to die because they need to be autonomous. We want them to have the choice to be able to die, if that is indeed their choice and if the circumstances which they are in are such that their suffering is enormous. Most of us who back the Bill have experienced this in our own lives and seen what happens in those circumstances. I have sometimes wondered, in listening—I have done a lot of listening and not much speaking on this Bill—that some of the people who raise all these amendments have not had the experience of seeing the terrible suffering of people who have already been diagnosed as terminally ill.