The Minister of State, Department for Work and Pensions (Baroness Sherlock) (Lab)

My Lords, it is a privilege to open the Second Reading of the Pension Schemes Bill. I am grateful to noble Lords for the engagement we have already had, and I look forward to working constructively together as the Bill progresses through this House. I also very much look forward to the maiden speech of the noble Baroness, Lady White of Tufnell Park. Pensions are really important, and the Bill will transform our pensions landscape for the better. It will play its part in delivering growth, as well as helping to raise living standards in every part of the UK. It will assist the pensioners of the future to feel more confident about the economy in general, as well as their own futures. Pensions are the promise we make to millions of people that their years of hard work will be rewarded with security and dignity in retirement. UK pension schemes invest hundreds of billions of pounds in our country. The reforms outlined in the Bill will make those pounds work harder for pensioners by making schemes more efficient—more money invested, and less on overheads and administration. The first Pensions Commission laid the groundwork for a new pensions landscape, with a simpler state pension and automatic enrolment into retirement savings. This transformed private pension saving in the UK. The Bill, along with the work of the pensions investment review, moves our private pensions system forward. Bigger, better pension schemes will drive better returns, as well as tackling inefficiencies in our system. The new Pensions Commission is looking at the issue of adequacy across the state and private pensions systems, with a clear objective of building a strong, fair and sustainable pension system. I look forward to this debate on the Bill, which is all about making every pound saved work harder for members, unlocking investment for our economy and restoring confidence in the promise of a decent retirement. I will now outline the main measures in the Bill. First, the Bill addresses the fragmentation of the Local Government Pension Scheme, which is currently spread across 87 funds in England and Wales. This fragmentation limits efficiency and scale. Through these reforms, all assets in the Local Government Pension Scheme, or LGPS, will be managed through FCA-regulated investment pools, ensuring professional oversight and better value for money. Administering authorities will set clear targets for local investment, working with strategic authorities to align with regional growth plans. Of course, LGPS members’ pensions and benefits are protected, as they are guaranteed in statute and are not affected by the performance of investments. These reforms are about the LGPS being well governed and well invested to deliver efficiency and value for money. Next, the Bill introduces powers to enable more trustees of well-funded defined benefit, or DB, schemes to share some of the £160 billion of surplus funds to benefit sponsoring employers and members. This will enable employers to drive growth through investment and higher purchasing power, but it will be subject to strict safeguards. The measure will allow trustees, working with employers, to decide how surplus can benefit both members and employers, while maintaining security for future pensions. The defined contribution, or DC, workplace pensions market prioritises competition on cost rather than on the overall value. The Bill introduces a value-for-money framework to enable a shift in focus away from cost towards a longer-term consideration of value. This new framework looks to standardise how value is assessed, in a transparent, consistent and comparable way. It will require schemes to disclose standardised metrics, undertake a holistic assessment of value, and take improvement actions where needed. Automatic enrolment has been a huge success, ensuring that millions more people are now saving for their retirement. However, frequent job changes mean that individuals are often enrolled into a new pension scheme by each employer, leaving them with multiple small pots over their working life, often with very small amounts saved. This has created a challenge across the workplace pensions market, with current estimates suggesting that within the system there are more than 13 million pots worth less than £1,000 each. This is hugely expensive for pension schemes to administer, with an estimated cost of £240 million a year, ultimately resulting in poorer value for members. Through the Bill, we are taking powers to introduce automatic consolidation of these dormant small pension pots through a multiple default consolidator model. Opportunity for member choice will be built in; members can choose a consolidator scheme or choose to opt out entirely if they wish. This will simplify the system, reduce costs and support members so they can better track their retirement savings. There is strong evidence that larger pension schemes mean better outcomes for members through efficiencies of scale, stronger governance and better investment opportunities at lower cost. The Bill will therefore drive scale by accelerating the consolidation of multi-employer DC schemes. From 2030, schemes used for auto-enrolment must reach at least £25 billion in assets in a single main scale default arrangement, or £10 billion on a transition pathway with a credible plan to reach £25 billion within five years. This is about harnessing the power of scale: larger schemes can negotiate better deals, access more diverse investments and deliver better outcomes for savers. On asset allocation, earlier this year, the Mansion House Accord was signed by 17 major pension providers, which, between them, manage about 90% of active savers’ DC pensions. This initiative was led by industry, and the signatories pledged to invest 10% of their main default funds in private assets, such as infrastructure, by 2030. The purpose of this voluntary commitment is, as the signatories put it, “to facilitate access for savers to the higher potential net returns that can arise from investment in private markets as part of a diversified portfolio, as well as boosting investment in the UK”. The Bill includes a backstop provision that would permit the Government, with Parliament’s approval, to require DC pension providers of auto-enrolment schemes to invest a fixed percentage of their default funds in specific asset classes. The Government do not anticipate exercising the power, unless they consider that the industry has not delivered the change on its own. There are also strong safeguards around it. All workplace pension schemes are required to have a default arrangement, where contributions are invested if members do not choose an investment option. Most members go into a default arrangement and remain there throughout their scheme membership. There are currently thousands of different default arrangements in pension schemes, creating fragmentation, inefficiency and poorer outcomes for members. The Bill introduces new requirements to review those default arrangements, with a power to make regulations as needed, following the review, to require default arrangements to be consolidated into a main scale default arrangement. There is also a power to make regulations for new default arrangements to be subject to regulatory approval. That will ensure that savers benefit from economies of scale and improved governance by reducing the fragmentation in the pensions market. Many pension schemes, especially legacy ones, are not delivering good outcomes for savers. As contract-based schemes rely on individual contracts between firms and members, firms usually need individual members’ consent to make any changes, even when the change would improve outcomes for members. Obtaining this consent is often difficult and costly, especially when members are disengaged, even when a scheme offers poor value. This leaves members stuck in poor-value schemes. To address that, the Government are introducing the contractual override power in the Bill. It will allow the providers of FCA-regulated DC workplace pensions to transfer members to a different pension arrangement, make a change which would otherwise require consent, or vary the terms of members’ contracts without the need for individual member consent, but only when the legal and regulatory requirements are met. That includes rigorous consumer safeguards such as the best interests test, which must be met and certified by an independent expert before a contractual override can take place. At retirement, DC scheme savers face complex financial decisions. They need to evaluate the different options to suit their own individual circumstances, assess risks and uncertainty in financial products, and factor in their own estimation of their life expectancy. We know that savers do not always use the support available: only 16% used a regulated source, such as Pension Wise or a professional financial adviser. The Bill puts new duties on trustees to develop and provide one or more default pension plans at retirement to help members access their savings without these complex decisions. These plans will provide a straightforward income solution for most members, with opt-out rights for those who prefer alternatives. Trustees must design plans based on member needs, communicate options clearly and publish a pension benefits strategy, which will be overseen by the Pensions Regulator. The Bill also requires the FCA to make rules that deliver default pension plans in relation to pension schemes regulated by the FCA, ensuring consistency and better outcomes for savers. Superfunds are commercial consolidators that offer a new route for employers to secure the legacy liabilities of closed DB schemes that cannot secure an insurance buyout. Building on the current interim regime, the Bill establishes a permanent legislative framework for superfunds. It introduces an authorisation and supervisory regime with robust governance, funding and continuity arrangements, so that members of those schemes can have the confidence that their pensions are properly protected. Superfunds may invest more productively because of their scale, expertise and buying power, so they are good for members, employers and the wider economy. Part 4 contains a range of important measures. Following the Virgin Media court case, certain DB pension benefit alterations could be treated as void if schemes cannot produce actuarial confirmation that they met the minimum standards in place at the time. This affects schemes that were contracted out between 1997 and 2016. The court judgment has the potential to cause pension schemes significant cost and uncertainty, even where the schemes did, in fact, meet the minimum standards required. To resolve that, the Bill allows schemes to ask their actuary to confirm that past benefit alterations would not have caused the scheme to fall below the relevant minimum standards. The Chancellor announced in the Budget that the Government will introduce pre-1997 indexation into the Pension Protection Fund and the Financial Assistance Scheme—the PPF and the FAS—to address the long-standing issue faced by members. As noble Lords will be aware, those are the compensation schemes that provide a safety net for members of DB schemes. Currently, payments in respect of service before 1997 are not uprated with inflation, and affected members have seen the real value of their compensation decrease significantly in recent years. The Bill will pave the way to introduce increases on PPF and FAS payments for pensions built up before 6 April 1997. These will be CPI-linked and capped at 2.5%, and will apply prospectively for members whose former schemes provided for these increases. That will help those members’ pensions keep pace with the cost of living. This is a step change that will make a meaningful difference to over 250,000 members. Incomes will be boosted by an average of around £400 for PPF members and £300 for FAS members after the first five years. Our changes strike an affordable balance of interests for all parties, including eligible members, levy payers, taxpayers and the PPF’s ability to manage future risk. The Bill makes some other changes to the PPF and the FAS that will benefit the members of these schemes and the levy payers supporting the PPF, including around terminal illness and the levies. Finally, some noble Lords may have seen that the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee published its report on the Bill last night. I emphasise that the Government recognise the importance of getting the right balance when taking delegated powers and using them appropriately. The pensions industry is highly technical and rapidly evolving, and there is a complex interaction between legislative requirements, regulatory oversight and changes in practice or innovation. In pensions legislation, it is common for a mix of requirements and principles to be set out in primary legislation, with finer detail, which is liable to frequent development, to be set out in secondary legislation. That allows for a quicker response to developments in the industry, including to protect scheme members. We think we have the right balance in the Bill, but I thank the committee for its report and will respond in due course. This Bill will initiate systemic changes to the pensions landscape, with the aim of building a pensions system that is fit for the future—one that is strong, fair and sustainable, and that delivers for savers, employers and the economy. At its core, the Bill is about making sure that people’s hard-earned savings work as hard for them as they have worked to save, while galvanising the untapped benefits that private pensions can offer the economy at large. I look forward to our discussions today. I beg to move.