National Care Service
Tuesday, 20 October 2026
Contributions
Statement
The following Statement was made in the House of Commons on Thursday 15 October.
“With your permission, Madam Deputy Speaker, before I make a Statement on the creation of the national care service, I want to pay my own tribute to Sir David Amess and his family. We are all thinking of them today, and I am reflecting in particular on how much Sir David gave to this House.
It is in the news this week that Audrey Joughlin is celebrating almost 80 years of service in the NHS. This remarkable lady has been working in the NHS since the day it was founded in 1948, and today she is volunteering at the Royal Liverpool Hospital. I want to also wish a happy birthday to my constituent Vibeke Nicklin, who is turning 80, having spent 60 years as a nurse caring for patients.
When I read about these women, I feel nothing but pride; to know that they are from my home town in Merseyside just about makes my heart burst. These incredible women show what a wonderful thing it is that people are living longer—more grandparents are living to see their grandchildren as adults—but it also sets a test for our generation of politicians. When Audrey began her career, there were fewer than 6 million people aged over 65 in the UK; today, that figure is over 13 million. According to the Office for National Statistics, by 2050, 18 million people will be aged 65 and over; the number aged 75 and over will rise to more than 10 million; and the number aged 85 and over will have doubled. As the Prime Minister said yesterday, we cannot turn away from the question of social care. People who depend on care deserve better, and the dedicated staff deserve better, too.
This issue of social care has often been overlooked for two reasons. The first reason is who does most of the care. I can explain this simply in three words: working-class women. Working-class women never get a fair hearing in this country, but those in social care need to be heard right now. The second reason is what happens to people when they experience a failing care system. It is not that people do not like talking about getting old; too many people who go through our care system are traumatised by the experience, and it is too hard for them to talk about it. As the Prime Minister said at the Labour Party conference, social care workers often feel invisible. Who can blame them, when 80% of care workers working for independent providers receive within 10% of the minimum wage?
We are all looking forward to the findings of Baroness Casey’s important review, but the truth is that we cannot afford to wait for her to finish that work before getting on with the job. Ask any family who have gone through the nightmare of trying to sort out care for their loved ones—the status quo cannot be accepted. Beyond the immediate impact on families, the NHS is paying the price of our failure to get a grip; hospitals are dealing with 999 calls from a failing care system, and we have the appalling spectacle of corridor care in hospitals across the country. If we carry on like this, our broken social care system will break the NHS, too. We cannot let that happen.
We on the Government Benches remember that we were elected on a manifesto that said that we would build a national care service, improve the lives of the people who draw on care, and build a system that puts people before profit, and we are already working hard to deliver Baroness Casey’s early recommendations, whether on motor neurone disease, dementia or safeguarding. That is why the Prime Minister has taken the decision to build a national care service, with free personal care, adjusting the triple lock to make it possible. Baroness Casey will report next summer; meanwhile, we will prepare the ground now for the new service.
I am sick of people looking down their nose at social care staff, who do a highly skilled job that could provide the young people of this country with a great career. Yesterday, I spoke to our partners at Skills for Care about our workforce action plan. At the heart of this is a commitment not just to older generations who need care, but to younger generations who just need their chance in life. Being unemployed for any period can damage someone’s confidence, but doing a skilled job like social care can give people a sense of pride, and a pay packet they earn themselves. That is why we will offer thousands more academy places to help young jobseekers into good jobs in care, and are bringing in the first national collective pension scheme dedicated to care workers; and it is why we have already passed the Employment Rights Act 2025, which gave more than a million people—many of them care workers —access to sick pay, and raised the minimum wage. We will introduce the first fair pay agreement in adult social care, backed by half a billion pounds. It will put care workers under the protective umbrella of collective bargaining and give them the power that they deserve—not just as a one-off, but for ever.
For unpaid carers, we have announced the biggest expansion to the carer’s allowance since the 1970s. We will soon appoint the first unpaid carers’ champion to be a voice for people who provide unpaid care.
For too long, social care has been a Cinderella service, with care staff held back by not having the tools they need to look after people. Recently, however, we have been making good progress. Digital social care records are helping to reduce paperwork and improving the quality of information available to staff, which is vital for good care and saving precious time. Today, I can give the House the update that digital records are now used by 84% of care providers, compared with just 72% when this Government took office, and 92% of people who draw on care are now benefiting from that modernisation.
We are supporting the adoption of preventive technology that was the stuff of science fiction just 10 years ago—home monitoring kits to identify infections early, reminders to avoid missed medication, and specialised sensors to detect and prevent falls. If we can put the best technology in the hands of skilled and emotionally intelligent people, the result will be working-age adults with self-determination, choice and independence in life, and older people at home for longer, in better health, and with a much, much better chance of dying at home, in comfort and in dignity, when the time comes. As my right honourable friend the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions said on Tuesday:
‘A good retirement … is about more than income ’.—[ Official Report , Commons, 13/10/26; col. 198.]
There are those who say that we cannot afford the national care service; I say that they are asking the country to pay for the cost of failure. This issue is not going away. If our response to the test of an ageing population is simply to find an even larger bucket of sand to stick our heads in, the impact on the NHS—already plain for all to see—will only grow worse.
If the decade after 2010 taught me anything, it is that we do not save money by tearing chunks out of the fabric of our society and then making the NHS pick up the pieces. Most importantly, if we improve population health, people will have a much better quality of life. I do not pretend that it is easy, but our pensioners deserve security and peace of mind. Our national care service will be better for them, families and the NHS. It will ease the pressures we see today; failings in our social care system mean that many pensioners are kept in hospital for longer than they need or want to be, because social care beds are unavailable. The cost of inaction will only be more pressure on the NHS through more ambulance call-outs, more A&E admissions, more corridor care and more people stuck in hospital when they do not have to be there.
We are at a crossroads. Our choice is: either pay the financial and human cost of the failed system that we have now, or build the national care service, stabilise our public finances and enable people to live happier and healthier lives. I urge colleagues to think of not just the consequences of inaction, but what it means for our constituents if we get this right. In place of fear, the rising population of elderly people we represent can grow old in a good society. Instead of corridor care, we would have a thriving NHS, in which unnecessary admission was prevented and people who become unwell recovered quickly and enjoyed their life. Care workers would be recognised for their work, and all of us would gain peace of mind about what happens later in life.
When Audrey began her lifetime of service to our country, she was part of a generation that left the greatest legacy that anyone could hope to build. It meant that when a person falls ill, they never have to worry about the bill. Today we have the chance to carry her generation’s torch into the 21st century, and to leave to our children and grandchildren something as significant as the creation of the NHS. We are ripping off the plaster. I commend this Statement to the House”.
Lord Kamall (Con)
My Lords, I begin by thanking the Minister for allowing time for questions on this Statement. Let me begin by agreeing with the Minister that it is imperative for us all to address the issue of an ageing society, and to do so in an affordable and sustainable way, as I am sure many of us in this House will appreciate. In 2024, this Government committed themselves to the creation of a national care service. We are now being told that only the groundwork will be laid in this Parliament and that a national care service will be enacted after 2029. However, we have no details. Will it be a nationalised care service with no role for mutuals, co-operatives, friendly societies, charities, social enterprises, non-profits and family-run care providers? We have no details of any of that yet. We on these Benches recognise the extraordinary contribution made to social care by the millions of unpaid carers who provide indispensable support to their families and loved ones, as the noble Baroness, Lady Pitkeathley, often points out. They deserve our gratitude. As the Minister for Social Care and Mental Health, Alison McGovern, pointed out, there are now more than 13 million people aged over 65 in the United Kingdom and that is going to grow, reaching 18 million by 2050. So, it is essential that any reform commands public confidence, but that it can also endure beyond the lifetime of any one Government of any particular colour. I am concerned that the proposals the Government have set out so far do not meet that standard. In the other place, the Minister said that they could not force the recommendations made by the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, to suit what they have already announced as fundamental elements of the new social care system. That is welcome, but can the Minister confirm that if the noble Baroness’s conclusions challenge the Government’s proposals today, Ministers will alter their approach—or will it merely be too late? Such an independent review must be allowed to inform policy rather than endorse decisions that may have been taken already. While we welcome serious efforts to improve social care, the Prime Minister’s announcement of a national care service raises a number of questions about its scope, funding and practical delivery. Therefore, I will be asking for clarification on a few issues. The Government are committed to a national care service, providing free personal care. As my right honourable friend Damian Hinds has carefully highlighted for us, though, personal care and social care are not interchangeable terms. Residential accommodation, nursing provision and other essential support can represent a substantial proportion of the costs faced by individuals and families. Can the Minister explain precisely which services will be provided free of charge and which costs individuals will remain responsible for meeting? How will eligibility and assessment needs be determined? Will the arrangements also apply equally to working adults with care needs, and not just to the ageing? Those questions are important, because they relate directly to how families plan their finances in anticipation of old age. The Government have also placed considerable emphasis on improving the social care workforce. Obviously, we welcome that recognition, given the dedication and skill of care workers who, quite often, are undervalued when compared with healthcare workers. But commitments on pay, pensions and employment rights must be matched by a credible plan for recruitment, retention and funding. How will the proposed integration of the NHS and the national care service workforces operate when so much social care is delivered by independent and voluntary providers? Can the Minister also tell us the number of the expected workforce and what the cost of training and retraining might be? What reassurance can the Minister give that additional employment costs will not undermine the viability of those smaller care providers? This brings me to my final point. The Government suggested that these reforms will relieve the pressure on hospitals and reduce delayed discharges and corridor care. We have all known the mantra: you do not fix healthcare until you fix social care. That would be a desirable outcome, but it requires far more than funding requirements. The challenges facing social care are too important for political slogans or promises. What we need to hear is practical detail, because those who rely on care, the families who support them and the dedicated people who deliver that care deserve clarity, certainty and a genuinely sustainable settlement. We on these Benches will approach meaningful reform constructively and support the Government where they make a clear case, but the Government must demonstrate that their proposals are affordable, deliverable and fair to all generations. I hope that the Minister can provide the House with those detailed assurances that have, sadly, been too absent.
Baroness Pidgeon (LD)
My Lords, social care is one of the greatest unresolved challenges facing our country and every one of us will either need care ourselves or know someone who does. Yet too many people are left waiting, too many families are carrying unsustainable burdens and too many patients remain in hospital because the support they need in the community is simply not available. The consequences are felt across our country. Families face rapidly rising care costs, councils are struggling under mounting financial pressure and thousands of hospital beds are occupied by patients who are medically fit to leave, but cannot do so, because social care provision is not in place. As I raised earlier during Questions, this has knock-on impacts for our emergency departments and paramedics, and in the corridor care that we witness every day. Critically, we must remember the millions of unpaid family carers who quietly hold the system together. They save the state billions of pounds, often at great personal cost, yet many face financial hardship, exhaustion and inadequate support. Quite frankly, they have helped to save the care system from collapse. That is why any meaningful reform of social care should meet three fundamental tests. First, family carers must be placed at the heart of reform, with proper rights, support and respite. Secondly, there must be a universal safety net of care that guarantees dignity and independence, including access to free personal care. Thirdly, people must be protected from catastrophic care costs so that no family is forced to lose their savings or a home that they have worked for over a lifetime, simply because a loved one develops something like dementia or another long-term condition. For me, lost in this debate are those people who need long-term care throughout their life and not just in later years, which seems to be the framing of the current debate. This also needs addressing. The country has waited too long for a sustainable settlement on social care. The need for reform is urgent and delay carries a growing cost for families, the NHS and local government alike. I therefore ask the Minister three questions. When will the Government bring forward concrete proposals on social care reform? There is an opportunity for enabling legislation in the current Health Bill, which could help with the pace of change. Will the Government commit to putting unpaid family carers at the centre of their reforms, including improved financial support, greater access to respite care and stronger statutory rights? Will the Government introduce measures to protect individuals and families from those catastrophic care costs? I am really pleased that this issue is now up the Government’s agenda, but the time for reviews and promises has passed. What families, carers and those in need of care require now is action.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Health and Social Care (Baroness Merron) (Lab)
My Lords, I am most grateful to both Front Benches for their contributions and for coming in on what I think is a broad consensus that we seek to make, both politically and in relation to the public. That is why the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, is conducting the Big Conversation on Care, to ensure that the public come with us too. The noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, made the point, which is absolutely right, that adult social care has for a very long time been widely recognised as needing reform. The noble Lord, Lord Kamall, also spoke to that. We are seeking a lasting settlement—something, frankly, that has evaded previous Governments of all colours, for various reasons. We want to ensure that we find the way forward. That is why the Prime Minister set out a clear direction and instruction very early on towards a national care service. To highlight the main points, it will be person-centred, preventive and closely integrated with the NHS because, as we have discussed so many times in this Chamber, social care reform and healthcare reform are interchangeable and linked. I certainly accept that point. This will also include fully funded, free personal care for older people. It is only fair to acknowledge that this is a long-term commitment. The Prime Minister has already accelerated the work needed to turn that vision into a deliverable plan. I very much share the views of both noble Lords on wanting progress. We all know that we have to get progress accelerated, which is what the Prime Minister has done, but we have to make sure it is possible to do that. Therefore, the Government have asked the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, to bring forward the timetable for her independent commission. It will now report in the summer, which is considerably sooner. I want to make the point that we are already working in government to deliver the noble Baroness’s early recommendations, including developing a new pathway for those with motor neurone disease, progressing the recruitment of a dementia tsar, publishing the modern service framework for frailty and dementia later this year, and establishing a new national adult safeguarding board. So we are not waiting; it is important to emphasise that. We are also making over £4.6 billion of additional funding available for adult social care in 2028-29 compared to 2025-26. That will include £500 million to deliver the first ever fair pay agreement for care workers, which will be introduced in 2028. To refer to the points made by the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, we are indeed working in partnership with local government to put in place the foundations that we will need to build the national care service. I was grateful for the support that the noble Lord offered. A critical part of that will be how local authorities actually commission services. Through that practice, they will shape the local provider markets. As the noble Lord said, there will indeed be a role for family-run services and co-operatives. It is a mixed market, so to speak. It will be for local authorities to commission as they see fit, but also to create the circumstances for the services to be provided. As I mentioned, the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, will make recommendations next year for a national care service. The Government will consider these and will publish a response on how we will deliver a national care service shortly after the commission reports—I am sure that noble Lords will hold me to that. I say that in respect of the noble Lord’s question about the approach by Ministers. The noble Lord asked me to clarify the distinction between free personal care and social care. The national care service will provide fully funded free personal care for older people. I will define that: it includes support with activities such as eating, bathing and using the toilet. Existing council support for eligible individuals will remain. It will be for the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, to advise on exactly how and when free personal care should be introduced and how it will be built up in a sustainable way. On the subject of the workforce, we are legislating, as I mentioned, for a fair pay agreement, backed by £500 million. Most importantly, the Secretary of State recently announced a new workforce action plan—again, something that your Lordships’ House has pressed me on, and rightly so. That will support recruitment, retention and career development. It is important, and noble Lords have made this point: how we regard and support our workforce whom we rely on to provide care is crucial. Frankly, they have not had the deal they should have had. That is why we are looking at fair pay, but also at their broader conditions, including their training and the respect in which they are held. I know your Lordships’ House has great respect for them, and I certainly do, but that could be regarded as just words. Words are important, but we will continue, as I say, to support them as the professionals they are. There will also be the first national collective pension scheme dedicated to care workers, and an expansion of sector-based work academy programmes so that we can help more young people and job seekers find routes into care careers. We find that younger people are not well represented in providing care. We would like to harness their interest and their expertise. With regard to costs, as the Prime Minister has said, the provision of free personal care for older people will be fully funded through adjusting the triple lock from 2030. The Government will not borrow to pay for reform and will indeed continue to meet our fiscal rules. The noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, raised the point about unpaid carers. The Secretary of State recently announced a whole package of reforms, including plans to appoint the first unpaid carers champion. Again, I know that is something that noble Lords have been keen to see. In order to ensure care throughout life, not just later in life, I say to the noble Baroness that we absolutely recognise that working-age adults, who are high users of social care—that is often overlooked—have different ambitions, and it is right and proper that that includes participation in society and employment. Their needs are very different from those of older-age adults. The independent commission of the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, will consider reform for all those who need care, including working-age adults. I should also say that we are strengthening the join-up that I referred to, which I know noble Lords want to see, between health and social care services, so that people have more integrated and person-centred care by both developing neighbourhood services and reforming the Better Care Fund. We are enabling people to have more choice and control over their care, for instance by promoting the greater use of direct payments. I am grateful for the welcome for the work that we are doing. I completely agree about how long overdue this is—as I say, I know that view is shared on all sides of the House—but I hope that the commitment of the Prime Minister, along with the actions that we have already taken and will take, will reassure your Lordships’ House about the progress we intend to make.
Baroness Pitkeathley (Lab)
My Lords, for some of us—I would call us the usual suspects—who have been waiting for this for 40 years, these are happy days. But we have to remember that we are seeking a lasting settlement, and therefore the national care service is only part of this. Would my noble friend agree that one of the important things the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, is doing in her research and proposals is encouraging a national conversation? One of the major problems about social care is that nobody talks about it in their family. They do not make plans for what might happen or what will happen. We should encourage people to think about the future for their own family, including, of course, the huge contribution that unpaid carers make. Somebody suggested it was millions; it is of course £190 billion-plus. The conversation about what families plan will be of the utmost importance.
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I agree with my noble friend. I know she has not been patient for 40 years, and nor should she have been. She has pressed all Governments to take action. The public are important for a number of reasons, not least how this will be funded. It affects all of us, one way or another, at some point. The first phase of the big conversation on care that the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, started closed last month and the second phase will start soon. Some 125 people have also been randomly selected for a public panel on care to look at key reforms and give their views. So, yes, we need consensus politically and consensus publicly.
Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (CB)
My Lords, at the interface between health and social care needs—I must declare my role as president of Attend—the voluntary sector has a large number of people who can contribute very much. I would like confirmation from the Minister that the Government are considering clarifying the relationship between voluntary providers, both in the healthcare arena and out in social care, to define their accountability and shared objectives, to make sure that their relational insights are recognised and that they are able to maintain their independent identity as voluntary organisations, while also being recognised as being major contributors, to enable the whole passage to be smooth and to provide additional support to unpaid carers within families, as well as unpaid carers who are volunteers belonging to some of these organisations.
Baroness Merron (Lab)
The voluntary sector has always had, and will continue to have, a strong role. The noble Baroness makes very reasonable points. I go back to the point I made to the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, about what I described as a mixed economy of provision. The decisions on services will be down to local authorities and how they commission.
Lord Lansley (Con)
My Lords, we have a direction but not yet a road map: I look forward to it. One component of that was referred to in the report of 12 October from the King’s Fund—I hope the Minister has had a chance to look at it—on the future of social care reform. It said that an essential element would be a cap on care costs, as the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, referred to. Parliament legislated for this in the Care Act 2014. Will the Government now commence the relevant provisions?
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I am grateful to the King’s Fund for its thinking and its examination of this whole area. I take the noble Lord back to my point about the noble Baroness, Lady Casey. Through her independent commission, she is looking at a whole range of aspects, one of which the noble Lord referred to. That is important. She will make her recommendations, and the Government will consider them. I take the noble Lord’s point.
Lord Davies of Brixton (Lab)
I welcome the Statement and thank my noble friend the Minister. I particularly welcome the section, to which she referred, about a collective pension scheme for carers. That is a seriously good idea and I hope it can be introduced at pace. The Minister also referred to unpaid carers. Unpaid care is heavily gendered and one of the main reasons for the gender pensions gap. Is my noble friend prepared to consider a proposal whereby there could be support for unpaid carers through payments into this collective pension scheme on their behalf?
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I am glad that my noble friend welcomes the recent announcement. Like him, I think it is only right, fair and proper, and I am an enthusiast for this. On his specific point, the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, will consider various matters. I think our commitment is the first national collective pension scheme dedicated to care workers. I am not in a position to agree directly, but I am sure my noble friend will make sure that the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, is aware of his proposal, and I am sure she will take note of this debate.
Baroness Tyler of Enfield (LD)
My Lords, on a point of clarification, can the Minister confirm that the references made to free personal care for older people—I think she referred to that on a number of occasions—will also apply to working-age disabled adults? I do not think I heard her specifically say that. Working-age disabled adults may need long-term care throughout their lives, so I would be very grateful for clarification on that point. Separately, on the day that the Covid inquiry’s absolutely devastating report on the impact of the pandemic on care homes is published, I want to ask whether there will be an opportunity for this Chamber to debate that report.
Baroness Merron (Lab)
That will be a matter for the usual channels, and I will ensure that that request is brought to their attention. On the point about definition, personal care for older people will be free and will take the form that I have already described. We would not want to pre-empt the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, on her absolute definition of that. I re-emphasise—I think the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, referred to this—that existing council support for eligible people will remain. The noble Baroness, Lady Casey, will also advise on how free personal care should be introduced.
Baroness Manzoor (Con)
My Lords, I welcome the direction of travel. With the current passage of the Health Bill, there is a fantastic opportunity to integrate health and social care, if we are serious about doing so. One of the barriers to social care has been that budgets are held by local authorities and different budgets have created significant delays—for instance, even in getting basic equipment for people who are ready for discharge. Will the Government look into this and give it serious thought, as budgets are the biggest barrier? If we are to integrate the care and NHS workforces, this is a wonderful opportunity to do so.
Baroness Merron (Lab)
It is a wonderful opportunity, and it is very challenging. I certainly agree that NHS services and social care services have to work together through neighbourhood health and joined-up care. That is why over £9 billion will be committed to the better care fund, some of which will be provided to local authorities and some of which will be provided to integrated care boards. Further, we are acting now on workforce, commissioning, data and digital infrastructure while the independent commission develops its recommendations. The point that the noble Baroness makes is right: the Health Bill is a great opportunity. However, ultimately, greater integration will come in the wider changes that we make.
Lord Bradley (Lab)
My Lords, I apologise if the Minister has answered this already and I missed it, but when is the social care workforce plan intended to be published? Will it be published at the same time as the NHS workforce plan, to ensure that there is clear integration between the two proposals?
Baroness Merron (Lab)
My noble friend missed nothing, and I am happy to clarify. As he knows, we are committed to publishing the NHS workforce plan soon. We were keen to ensure that the views of the new Secretary of State were taken into account, so that we could be accurate. The simple answer is that it cannot be at the same time, because the NHS workforce plan will doubtless come before there is a social care workforce plan, on which more work needs to be done.
Baroness Uddin (Non-Afl)
My Lords, I pay tribute to my noble friend Lady Pitkeathley for decades of outstanding commitment and dedication to making carers’ lives better. I declare an interest: I have a son who lives with autism and a learning disability, so I really appreciated the comments about making sure that adults with special needs and other care needs are addressed in this wonderful new opportunity to get as much right as possible. Having said that, over the last three weeks, my whole family has experienced the care of our mother at hospital. I have shivers down my spine thinking about the incredible dedication of the staff there, caring for my mother as well as for all the other mothers and grandmothers and everyone in the hospital. The transition, however, is incredibly difficult—not for my mother, because she has an army of extended family and we will do everything we can when she arrives home—and there are many women lying in hospital beds simply because community care is not in place. The transition must be seamless or it will never work and we will continue debating this for another 30 or 40 years. Lastly, I will make a point I have raised on many occasions. Given the desperate nature of local authority funding, there must be something in our approach from now on to designate the funds—I have momentarily forgotten what this is called—
Baroness Pitkeathley (Lab)
Ring-fencing.
Baroness Uddin (Non-Afl)
Ring-fencing—I thank my noble friend. Will the Government consider this as part of the integrated care approach?
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I am sure the whole House shares the noble Baroness’s comments about my noble friend Lady Pitkeathley and the difference that she has made over the 40 years to which the noble Baroness referred. I thank the noble Baroness for bringing the personal experience of her family to the Chamber, on the point of discharge, which I think she was referring to. I am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, who asked me that Question earlier today. I will not repeat myself but will say that we are acting across the whole discharge pathway. Just this weekend—I will repeat this—we announced almost £140 million for 14 urgent care schemes, alongside 25 new or expanded sites due to open for winter, because we need additional urgent care capacity. We also need targeted support for the most challenged hospitals, as well as a whole range of other things, and that is exactly what we are providing.
Baroness Pinnock (LD)
My Lords, for 10 years now, council tax payers have had to pay an additional 2% on their council tax for the social care precept. This now adds up to around £300 for a band D property, although that clearly varies across the country. Is there hope for council tax payers that, in the brave new world of free personal care, which I hope will come, they will have a rebate?
Baroness Merron (Lab)
The noble Baroness tempts me to usurp the Treasury, but I will resist her invitation. I am sure her comments will be heard by the Chancellor.
Baroness Fraser of Craigmaddie (Con)
My Lords, I join others in welcoming a long-term, cross-party approach to tackling social care. I echo my noble friend Lord Kamall’s earlier comments that social care and free personal care are not necessarily the same thing. In Scotland, we have supposedly had free personal care for the elderly since 2002, and it was extended to anybody over 18 in 2019. Unfortunately, however, free is never free—somebody has to pay for it. In Scotland, we are finding that free personal care means that you have to be pretty desperate to get anything. The definition of what these terms are and who has responsibility for providing it are extremely important. As the Minister knows well, we have also toyed with the establishment of a free national care service in Scotland. Since 2022, the Scottish Government have spent over £44 million to achieve absolutely nothing. Can the Government look at Scotland as a caution rather than as a model? Can they reassure me that we are looking at it and learning for the whole of the UK, so that this benefits pensioners and working-age adults with disabilities who need care in Glasgow as well as in Gateshead, and that we will not all have to sacrifice the pension triple lock for nothing?
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I have had the opportunity to read the letter that the noble Baroness published in the media. As she knows, funding decisions on health and social care are of course devolved matters and that will not change. Scotland and the other devolved Governments receive funding via the Barnett formula as usual. I totally agree with her that not just definitions but practice are important; how we will make this long lasting is the stuff of the independent commission, and that is why we have acted already. When I talk about a national conversation about social care, that also means learning from each other across the UK, and the noble Baroness can define that however she wishes.
Baroness Gohir (CB)
My Lords, how will the Government ensure that everyone gets the same standard of care, particularly as there will be so many different service providers? For example, my mother-in-law came out of hospital and had two carers visiting her, and every time she asked them to do a task, they said: “We can’t use the equipment” or “We don’t have the training”. She turned around and said: “What on earth are they being paid for? I can do these tasks myself that they are unwilling to do”. She ended up cancelling her care.
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I am sorry to hear that. We have a whole suite of ways of seeking to maintain standards in the NHS, but it is important to note that this is a personalised care service and what is right for one will not be exactly the same for another; I know the noble Baroness understands that. She also reminds me to make the point that, in all of this, we have a great opportunity, which is already happening, to embrace technology, particularly in the home. While person-to-person care remains key, there is so much we can supplement now that we did not have before, such as home monitoring kits, reminders to avoid missed medications and sensors to detect and prevent falls. All of those, along with person-to-person care and the extra money we have put into making adjustments to people’s homes, are enabling people to live longer and healthier lives in their own homes.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5420645.