L

Lord Kamall (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

National Care Service

Contribution

My Lords, I begin by thanking the Minister for allowing time for questions on this Statement. Let me begin by agreeing with the Minister that it is imperative for us all to address the issue of an ageing society, and to do so in an affordable and sustainable way, as I am sure many of us in this House will appreciate. In 2024, this Government committed themselves to the creation of a national care service. We are now being told that only the groundwork will be laid in this Parliament and that a national care service will be enacted after 2029. However, we have no details. Will it be a nationalised care service with no role for mutuals, co-operatives, friendly societies, charities, social enterprises, non-profits and family-run care providers? We have no details of any of that yet. We on these Benches recognise the extraordinary contribution made to social care by the millions of unpaid carers who provide indispensable support to their families and loved ones, as the noble Baroness, Lady Pitkeathley, often points out. They deserve our gratitude. As the Minister for Social Care and Mental Health, Alison McGovern, pointed out, there are now more than 13 million people aged over 65 in the United Kingdom and that is going to grow, reaching 18 million by 2050. So, it is essential that any reform commands public confidence, but that it can also endure beyond the lifetime of any one Government of any particular colour. I am concerned that the proposals the Government have set out so far do not meet that standard. In the other place, the Minister said that they could not force the recommendations made by the noble Baroness, Lady Casey, to suit what they have already announced as fundamental elements of the new social care system. That is welcome, but can the Minister confirm that if the noble Baroness’s conclusions challenge the Government’s proposals today, Ministers will alter their approach—or will it merely be too late? Such an independent review must be allowed to inform policy rather than endorse decisions that may have been taken already. While we welcome serious efforts to improve social care, the Prime Minister’s announcement of a national care service raises a number of questions about its scope, funding and practical delivery. Therefore, I will be asking for clarification on a few issues. The Government are committed to a national care service, providing free personal care. As my right honourable friend Damian Hinds has carefully highlighted for us, though, personal care and social care are not interchangeable terms. Residential accommodation, nursing provision and other essential support can represent a substantial proportion of the costs faced by individuals and families. Can the Minister explain precisely which services will be provided free of charge and which costs individuals will remain responsible for meeting? How will eligibility and assessment needs be determined? Will the arrangements also apply equally to working adults with care needs, and not just to the ageing? Those questions are important, because they relate directly to how families plan their finances in anticipation of old age. The Government have also placed considerable emphasis on improving the social care workforce. Obviously, we welcome that recognition, given the dedication and skill of care workers who, quite often, are undervalued when compared with healthcare workers. But commitments on pay, pensions and employment rights must be matched by a credible plan for recruitment, retention and funding. How will the proposed integration of the NHS and the national care service workforces operate when so much social care is delivered by independent and voluntary providers? Can the Minister also tell us the number of the expected workforce and what the cost of training and retraining might be? What reassurance can the Minister give that additional employment costs will not undermine the viability of those smaller care providers? This brings me to my final point. The Government suggested that these reforms will relieve the pressure on hospitals and reduce delayed discharges and corridor care. We have all known the mantra: you do not fix healthcare until you fix social care. That would be a desirable outcome, but it requires far more than funding requirements. The challenges facing social care are too important for political slogans or promises. What we need to hear is practical detail, because those who rely on care, the families who support them and the dedicated people who deliver that care deserve clarity, certainty and a genuinely sustainable settlement. We on these Benches will approach meaningful reform constructively and support the Government where they make a clear case, but the Government must demonstrate that their proposals are affordable, deliverable and fair to all generations. I hope that the Minister can provide the House with those detailed assurances that have, sadly, been too absent.

More from Lord Kamall (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.