Railways Bill
Wednesday, 18 November 2026
Contributions
Report (1st Day) (Continued)
Clause 16: Duty of Great British Railways and ORR to have regard to strategies etc
Amendment 27
Moved by
27: Clause 16, page 10, line 7, at end insert— “(c) the need to secure integration between railway passenger services and local passenger transport services, including bus, coach, light rail, tram and ferry services by improving connections and co-ordinating timetables, ticketing and passenger information.”
Lord Beith (LD)
My Lords, we discussed this issue in Committee at some length, but I was not confident then that a clear message had been delivered to the railway industry that transport integration matters and is crucial to increasing the use of the rail system as opposed to other forms of transport, particularly the private car. The objective of raising the matter again on Report is to get the Minister to express as clearly as he can what I know he thinks. I do not think there is any disagreement between us about this. This is an important matter, and real progress could be made. The procedures and processes that he described in Committee, which already exist—the integrated transport strategy and things like that—do not seem to be delivering. I do not think they will deliver in their present form, and I therefore think that more attention needs to be given to it. When you look at who is not using the train for journeys, various categories come to mind. One is people who live in a town that does not have a railway station and is not on the rail network and who therefore have to drive to some other place if they want to make use of the train. If there were a good bus connection on which they could rely, they would not need to use the car, pay a car parking fee and spend money on petrol, but rarely is that possibility available. Then there are people who commute on a daily basis, or two or three days a week, from an often busy station into central London or other urban centres, who again use the car to get to the train or decide that, since they have to get the car out, they might as well do the whole journey in the car and not use the train. When the industry is looking for people who could be induced to use the rail system, this is a very fruitful field and much more could be done. When it does not work, it is pretty distressing. If you arrive somewhere and there is supposed to be a bus to take you home the rest of the way, but no bus is there, you are in a hopeless position. If you arrive on a train five minutes later than the bus time and the bus has gone and has not waited for you, you are in an even more annoying position. Lots of people who have tried to use a supposedly partially integrated transport system are defeated by the inability of operators to work in conjunction. In my amendment, I have pointed to things that are necessary: improved connections, actual timed connections between trains and buses, trains and ferries and trains and light rail; improved timetables that show that the connection exists, and the devising of a timetable that builds in the connections; and passenger information. Passengers need to be told what is available and be able to rely on that information. I do not need to say much more about it to make the Minister realise why I think it is so important. When GBR begins its work, ceases to be a phantom body and becomes a real body, integration will be top of the agenda. However, it will not be this kind of integration. The integration that will be at the top of its agenda is to pull together the vastness of the British railway system and its many operators and participants. My fear is that that will crowd out any serious discussion of integration between different modes of transport. I ask the Minister to make it clear that this is not an optional extra for the railway industry. It is crucial to the expansion of rail use. It is not something that might be considered in a few years’ time; it needs to be built into the system now. If we are building up a new timetable system and new links between what were previously separate railway companies, this is the time at which we need to build in new links with other transport operators. I ask the Minister to make sure that this is a priority and that the industry knows it is a priority. I beg to move.
Lord Berkeley (Lab)
My Lords, before I speak to my amendment in this group, I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Beith, on his amendment because, on the very rare occasions when integrated transport has been mentioned, he has mentioned ferries. I live in the Isles of Scilly part of the time, and I got delayed for a whole week last week because there were no ferry services and no air services either. The co-ordination of timetables, ticketing and passenger information is important. I hope he will keep on pressing this issue, which is so simple but does not actually happen. I will speak to Amendments 28, 29, 30 and 31 in this group, which are to do with rail freight. I was very pleased to see in Clause 17 that the Government wish to introduce a target for growth in rail freight, which is something new. I congratulate my noble friend the Minister on getting this through—a lot of people would probably say that it cannot be done. What the target should contain is obviously of interest to noble Lords. I have put in a figure of a 100% increase until 2040, which seems a long way away, but it is not that far away. Other people would say that it should be a bit less. Amendment 29 includes the need for explanations. As to how that growth can be achieved, I tried to put in Amendment 30 some of the ideas that would need to be delivered for it to happen, including “reduced access charges” and “removal of penalty charges”, which we will come to later, as well as “improvements to rail infrastructure” to enable the trains to run faster, “improvements to junction capacity”, “reduced capacity delays” and some better electrification. We in this House have talked to my noble friend the Minister about some of these before. Small investments in, say, the line to London Gateway at Tilbury or in the line from Felixstowe at Ely would enable all these things to happen. The way that the infrastructure manager works at the moment is that if they have the money, they will do it, but if they do not, they will not do it. Either way, freight operators would not be charged —that is what is in my Amendment 30 at proposed new subsection (3B). Whatever percentage of growth is agreed, it is also important, as I put down in Amendment 31, that: “The ORR must monitor the growth of rail freight against the target and publish the results annually”. If it does not think that GBR is doing it properly, it must require further action and impose penalties. This is a very early attempt to put some flesh on the targets. I repeat that I am grateful to my noble friend the Minister for introducing them. I am sure that there will be many comments around the industry as to whether they are suitable, but I am still grateful that they are appearing at all. I hope we can take something forward on this.
Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb (GP)
My Lords, I have three amendments in this group—I will try to stick to time. Amendment 35 is about transport integration, which has been one of the biggest omissions from the Bill. It seems illogical that a Bill setting out the future of our railways says so little about how rail connects with the rest of the transport system. The existing Railways Act included duties to develop an integrated system of transport for passengers and goods, and to make it easier for passengers to complete journeys involving more than one operator. Those duties have disappeared with this Bill. This issue is important because very few people think about their journey in terms of individual transport operators; they just want to get to where they are going. The Department for Transport’s own impact assessment recognises the problem. Its figures show that half of public transport journeys in England in 2023 involved more than one transport mode. It also identifies poor co-ordination between different modes as a barrier to integration. For me, this is quite personal, because I take at least two train journeys a week and then I take bus journeys after that, and it is really not easy to get them integrated. But it is not just about convenience. Better integration means fewer unnecessary car journeys, better access to public transport for people who cannot drive, and a railway that serves communities rather than simply connecting major towns and cities. This amendment would restore a clear duty to support integrated transport. It would make sure that connecting journeys were considered as part of railway planning rather than left to individual operators or local authorities to sort out. My next two amendments, Amendments 37 and 32, are about growing passenger numbers and making the whole journey work—not just the bit on the train. We need to get more people using public transport and fewer people relying on private cars. Transport is the UK’s highest-emitting sector. We cannot seriously address climate change without changing how people travel. The railway has a major role in that, but it will not happen simply because we have a publicly owned railway. We need a clear commitment to making rail a more attractive alternative to driving. I personally think it is a much more attractive alternative—I would much rather take the train than drive—but I meet a lot of people who do not think like that. There is already recognition of this in Wales, where the Government have targets for increasing the proportion of journeys made by sustainable transport. Scotland has also maintained a policy commitment to reducing car use, although its previous target to reduce car kilometres by 20% by 2030 was abandoned after it concluded that it was not achievable. I think there is general recognition across the UK that we need to reduce our dependence on private cars, but the railway legislation does not give GBR a clear duty to contribute to that change. We obviously need to think about the whole system, not just individual rail services. Taken together, these amendments are about giving Great British Railways the tools and responsibilities to grow passenger numbers and deliver a better transport system. We cannot deal with any of these things in isolation. We cannot expect people to leave their cars at home if the train is too expensive, if the connecting bus does not turn up or if the journey simply is not practical. I really feel that these things should be central to the purpose of GBR.
Viscount Stansgate (Lab)
My Lords, I do not know what my noble friend the Minister is going to say about Amendment 27, but I hope he will stress how important it is to have integration. My noble friend Lord Berkeley talked about the problems of his commuting and the noble Baroness, Lady Jones, referred to her journeys. Like other Members, I commute to this House every day, and I cannot tell noble Lords how maddening it is to take a tram to a station for a connecting journey by train only to find that, as the tram pulls into the station, it waits before opening the doors and the train—literally as far away as my noble friend is on the Front Bench now—moves off and I miss the connection. This is a small practical example, but I hope that as a result of the Bill and the new era that we are going to enter, small things such as this can be addressed. It will make an enormous difference for people to feel that the transport network we have is truly integrated.
Baroness Pidgeon (LD)
My Lords, in Amendment 27 my noble friend Lord Beith rightly flags the importance of connectivity and integration between transport modes. Ensuring timetables work well together will ensure that passengers have confidence in using services. We have heard a number of examples from noble Lords of their own experiences. There is no point having an hourly train service arriving at a station to find only minutes later that the bus or the tram connecting passengers to the local area has left. The same applies, as we have heard, to ferries and other modes of transport. I hope the Minister will be able to assure my noble friend that he is committed to improving this connectivity. Indeed, I would like to see this in information at stations and the ability to purchase multimodal through tickets on apps, as I have seen and used in other countries. Training staff at stations will also be important to provide a more comprehensive passenger service and to show what this new Great British Railways is all about. What is the added value we are getting from this new public service? Building this in from the start is key, as my noble friend Lord Beith said.
My Amendment 84 in this group pushes the Government again to look at a passenger growth target. We on these Benches want to see as many people as possible using the railway, the railway growing and thriving, passengers choosing to travel by train and the growth of freight, which we have discussed throughout the Bill’s passage. There is a freight growth target in the Bill, and we think it would be beneficial to have a passenger growth target to focus minds at Great British Railways. I sense from the discussions in Committee that the Minister will not support this, but I would be grateful to have on record what he will commit to in terms of passenger growth. The amendments on rail freight from the noble Lord, Lord Berkeley, are clearly seeking greater clarity on how the Government will achieve the rail freight target and set out their commitment to this. I look forward to clarification on these matters from the Minister.
Lord Reay (Con)
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have participated in this debate. I will start by speaking to Amendment 84 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, which would place a duty on Great British Railways to exercise its statutory functions to increase passenger numbers. What we have heard from this Government is that they want a passenger-focused railway. We all want to see more people using our railways, but ultimately that will depend on providing passengers with good, reliable and affordable services. A competitive and efficient railway system that encourages innovation, investment and improvements in the quality of services will help achieve precisely that. The important question is how we ensure that Great British Railways delivers a railway that passengers actually want to use. I therefore look forward to hearing from the Minister how the Government intend to improve reliability, encourage competition and attract more passengers to the railway. The Government should have the objective of increasing passenger numbers, although whether a target is necessary is debatable, as are competing priorities on the railways such as an existing freight growth target. We welcome Amendments 28 to 31 from the noble Lord, Lord Berkeley. Amendment 28 would require rail freight to double by 2040. Amendment 29 would require explanations when the target is reviewed. Amendment 30 would require Great British Railways to set out how it intends to achieve the target, including through reduced access charges, improvements to infrastructure and increased capacity, while protecting freight operators from the associated costs. Amendment 31 would give the Office of Rail and Road powers to monitor progress annually and take enforcement action where the target is at risk of not being met. The Government have committed to increasing rail freight by 40% by 2040, with a longer-term target of 75% by 2050. However, 2040 is still 14 years away, and it is important that the Government demonstrate what they are doing now to achieve these ambitions. Just announcing a target is not enough; the industry needs certainty and confidence that the Government have a credible plan to deliver it, particularly when operators are making long-term investment decisions. These amendments therefore raise important questions about the practical steps the Government will take, how progress will be measured and what accountability there will be if the targets are not being met. I hope the Minister can provide some reassurance to the House on these matters.
The Minister of State, Department for Transport (Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill) (Lab)
My Lords, let me begin by turning to Amendments 27 and 35, which are both about the important issue of integrating rail passenger services with other public transport modes. As highlighted in Committee, I absolutely agree that passengers want a transport system that works as a whole. This is something the Government agree with and are already working towards. That is why we published Better Connected : a Strategy f or Integrated Transport in April of this year. The strategy brings together domestic transport across England into a single plan built around the principles of people, place and partnership. It includes eight priority areas focused on what people have told us they need, including simpler ticketing and reliable journeys. As part of the strategy, the Government have set out 40 commitments to be delivered within this Parliament to improve modal connectivity. This includes, for example, providing £6 million to support a rural integrated transport demonstrator programme in the Hope Valley and exploring further integration between train and bus services. They also committed to working with transport providers to ensure they open up access to high-quality data, in line with existing legislation, enabling better real-time information for passengers to plan. In addition, as set out in a discussion document published during Committee, the long-term rail strategy will set out expectations for GBR in relation to multimodal integration, which was identified as a key factor in achieving three of the Secretary of State’s five strategic objectives, including improving connectivity, meeting the needs of future passengers and supporting sustainability. To respond specifically to the noble Lord, Lord Beith, the noble Baronesses, Lady Jones and Lady Pidgeon, and my noble friend Lord Stansgate, GBR is mandated to have regard to both the long-term rail strategy, which I have just spoken about, and the local transport plans of strategic authorities. This sets a clear ambition that decisions should account for both national requirements and local multimodal needs. The Bill provides further mechanisms to ensure this happens, including enabling partnership arrangements between GBR and strategic authorities, which can only lead to a better understanding of what good local connectivity looks like, and therefore improved outcomes for passengers. The Bus Services Act, which this House passed some little time ago, deliberately allows greater control for local transport authorities, which will give more stability for bus services and enable the relationship that I just mentioned. In addition, the national integrated transport strategy says: “GBR will be responsible for the management of most stations, including developing interchange stations to support seamless connections to other forms of public transport, roads, and walking, wheeling and cycling. By working closely with local authorities and transport operators, with opportunities for devolved control, GBR will ensure stations and station precincts work well for passengers and the communities they serve”. On Amendment 37, I know that modal shift is important to the noble Baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb. As I confirmed in Committee, the long-term rail strategy will reference modal shift and connectivity between modes. Indeed, the discussion document I mentioned earlier outlines how encouraging modal shift by increasing the attractiveness of rail is key to the Government’s sustainability objective. The Bill supports this objective through the inclusion of the public interest duty at Clause 18, which explicitly includes the effect on the environment in its definition. This ensures that GBR is bound by this duty when making key decisions, and that it will respond to the LTRS ambitions specifically in its business plan, meaning that modal shift is actively considered throughout GBR’s governance and decision-making. I turn to Amendments 32 and 84, which both look to increase passenger numbers on the railway. I agree that we must increase the number of passengers on the railway. GBR will be expected to attract passengers by providing a reliable, efficient service in which passengers can have confidence. The long-term rail strategy discussion document outlines multiple ways in which we expect GBR to deliver passenger growth, whether through improving multimodal journeys or looking at how best to make use of the network. I agree with the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, that multimodal ticketing and perhaps a passenger loyalty scheme would help as well; we will discuss that on day two of Report. To support this, the Bill includes a passenger duty requiring GBR to promote the “interests of users and potential users of railway passenger services”, which requires GBR to consider how best to encourage new users on to the railways. I am happy to confirm that considering the interests of potential users will incentivise GBR to think about underutilised markets and their interests. For example, we know that older people travel less, on average, and to meet this duty I would expect GBR to be thinking about what it can do to attract these groups to use the railway. As I explained in Committee, I do not think we should have an additional or stronger passenger growth duty; it could push the duties out of balance and undermine the incentive for GBR to promote freight, for example. As GBR’s revenue already comes from passengers, there will naturally be pressure to increase this revenue, meaning there is already an inherent risk that GBR might seek to prioritise passengers to the detriment of freight. That is precisely why we have included two freight duties to sit alongside the passenger interest duty, which is designed to address passenger growth. I hope this reassures both noble Baronesses that passenger growth is actively supported by the Bill. I turn to Amendments 28 to 31 from my noble friend Lord Berkeley. I reassure him that we are aligned on our intentions for freight growth. This Government are committed to meaningful rail freight growth, so that the economic and environmental benefits can be fully realised. It is therefore as important to me as anyone that the target be ambitious but deliverable, in order to bring the freight sector out of its current stagnation and deliver the benefits we all agree on. Close collaboration with the freight industry has been key to developing these targets throughout. The targets reflect the desire of industry to balance ambition with a realistic and sustainable approach to driving freight growth. We have therefore ensured that the figures of 40% and 75% are supported by significant evidence and analysis, demonstrating that they can be achieved given the right support from GBR and the sector—for example, by modelling existing pipeline commitments and assumptions of future investment. To be clear, without significant new investment in rail and infrastructure enhancements, the target could not be reached. The target also requires significant investment from industry. This is therefore the most ambitious target that is still achievable for GBR on these timescales, and the sector agrees. Crucially, the freight sector has welcomed these targets and the ambition they demonstrate. For example, the Rail Freight Group highlighted that the target “sends a strong message about the benefits and potential of rail freight, which will encourage investment by industry and private businesses and attract more customers to move their goods by rail”. The support of the freight sector will be vital in ensuring that these targets can be achieved, and it reflects our expectation that GBR will work closely with the sector as part of this. I hope this explanation reassures my noble friend that this is a genuinely ambitious target that will not be achieved without significant investment, collaboration and focus, to which GBR will be held to account for delivering. I would expect any future Government to set out in similar terms their rationale for any future growth target, which I hope also satisfies my noble friend’s amendment on that front. On Amendments 30 and 31, my noble friend will be pleased to hear that we are absolutely aligned on ensuring that GBR is required to set out how it will meet the target, and on the important role of the ORR in monitoring its progress. That is exactly the process that the Bill provides for with GBR’s business plan. As part of the business planning process, GBR will be required to transparently set out how it plans to deliver the Government’s priorities, which will of course include the freight growth target. The Secretary of State will sign off this business plan and provide funding only once she is satisfied that what is included delivers on the long-term rail strategy and the freight growth target and reflects GBR’s duties. The ORR will provide expert advice to the Secretary of State on the deliverability and robustness of the plan as part of this, and it will continue to monitor GBR’s performance against the business plan once it is agreed. Should the ORR believe that GBR is failing to follow its agreed business plan or to meet its freight growth target, it can raise this directly with GBR and its board, publish information to name and shame GBR, or refer this to the Secretary of State for more direct enforcement. This process ensures that GBR must not only demonstrate how it plans to meet the freight growth target but actively demonstrate delivery. I hope this reassures my noble friend not only that the freight growth target we have chosen is evidenced, ambitious and deliverable but that the Bill already ensures GBR will be held to account for its delivery. I therefore ask noble Lords not to press their amendments.
Lord Beith (LD)
My Lords, I am grateful to all who have taken part in this short debate and emphasised the need to grow rail traffic, both freight and passenger, as an environmentally friendly form of transport. I still have this nightmare that Great British Railways will struggle to integrate itself and the many elements of the railway system that have been brought together, and that integration with other forms of transport could get pushed to one side as a result. The Minister has done his best to reassure me on that point and has cited things that should already be having the effect that we desire. There is no disagreement between us. I have no desire to press the amendment to a Division, because we do not disagree. I just want him to keep at it and continue to emphasise that there is an untapped market of people who would use rail if they could access it, assisted by other forms of public transport. With that, I beg leave to withdraw the amendment.
Amendment 27 withdrawn.
Clause 17: Rail freight target
Amendments 28 to 31 not moved.
Amendment 32 not moved.
Clause 18: General duties of Ministers, Great British Railways and ORR
Amendments 33 to 38 not moved.
Consideration on Report adjourned.
House adjourned at 9.02 pm.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5440395.