Milburn Review: Final Report
Wednesday, 18 November 2026
Contributions
Statement
The following Statement was made in the House of Commons on Tuesday 16 November.
“With permission, Mr Speaker, I would like to make a Statement on the Milburn review into young people and work. I begin by echoing you in thanking the House officials for all their help.
This morning, Alan Milburn published a landmark report setting out a radical blueprint for a new settlement with young people. I thank Mr Milburn and his team for their outstanding work. Sometimes a review deals with an issue so fundamental that it alters what we see as the contract between government and society, and I believe this is one such report, because 1 million young people not in education, employment or training creates a human cost that no country should ask its young people to bear. It robs them of the thing that is most important to their lives: the prospect of a good future. It demands a response that is much more than a conventional departmental response. It has to be one that goes from education to health, to employment and more.
There is a narrative out there that describes young people as snowflakes and shirkers. We reject that entirely. The fault does not lie with the young people themselves. They want to work, they want to learn, and it is for us to make sure that they have a chance to do so. So our message to young people—the message from me, from the Prime Minister and from the whole Cabinet—is that we value you, we believe in you, and we want you to have a future.
When the Cabinet met this morning to discuss the report, the Prime Minister and the whole Cabinet endorsed the need for a whole new system for young people that puts work and opportunity at its heart, with earlier intervention, stronger support, more devolution and clear expectations to take part—a system that changes the question the state asks to a much deeper and more fundamental one: how do we help people to live the fullest life?
Today, I want to set out what Alan Milburn has proposed and the next steps that the Government will take. His report is clear that this has been a long time coming. He states:
‘The NEET crisis is not new. The NEET rate has barely been below 10 per cent in 25 years. It has become a fact of life’.
That is what we must change. In the future, we should judge the success of the welfare state not just by a snapshot of people’s monthly incomes but by the story of people’s lives and by their ability to achieve their full potential. That is why we need a new settlement for young people, just as we announced a new settlement for older people at our party conference, with a reformed triple lock and a new national care service.
This new settlement must give people the best chance of higher living standards for the whole of their lives. It must change the equation that sees us spend £25 on the consequences of inactivity for every pound that we spend on opportunity. That work has already begun, with our £2.5 billion youth guarantee, fully funded apprenticeships for the under-25s, more work experience places, hiring incentives for employers, youth hubs in every community and, for the long-term unemployed, a guaranteed fully funded six-month job.
But we must do more. Alan Milburn is right to argue for a new system that is more personalised, more devolved and focused on participation first. Instead of asking a young person to prove what they cannot do, the system should begin by asking what they need to build a future. His first key recommendation is for a new opportunity and support guarantee, backed by legislation, so that every young person who is not earning or learning has a credible route into education, training, an apprenticeship, high-quality work experience or a job. We support that recommendation.
Alan Milburn’s second recommendation is for a more personalised system that treats people as human beings, not as departmental clients, with employment, education, skills, health and wider support brought together around the person; and, crucially, he recommends that this be delivered locally. The Government also accept that second recommendation, which will mean more local delivery, with proper standards and accountability for outcomes. This is common in other countries with significantly lower rates of youth inactivity, because local leaders have the knowledge, the relationships and the networks to connect young people with the support and opportunities that make sense for them.
Every eligible young person who falls out of education or work should have one place to turn, one trusted person responsible for helping them, and one plan bringing together the support that they need. In this new system, opportunity must be matched by responsibility, so when someone can participate, they should be expected to take up the support available.
The report recommends a youth allowance, which people will receive while they receive help from the youth opportunity service, with extra support for care leavers and those outside the family home. It says that young people whose disabilities or health conditions create significant, enduring additional costs—including people with conditions that fluctuate—should continue to receive help with those costs, and that support should not be put at risk if they start work. Because people should not always have to wait for a national assessment for short-term help, it proposes a dedicated locally held fund to help with one-off costs, or temporary cash support.
For those with the most severe and lifelong conditions, for whom work is not a realistic prospect, Alan Milburn recommends a stronger safety net, providing dignity and security, and an end to unnecessary reassessments. The report points out that in some cases extra cash may not always be the right way to support a young person, because when participation is realistic, the right priority should be earlier and more intensive support with their health, education and employment, to help them build a better future; and to help change the current situation in which a 20 year-old who signs on for long-term sickness benefits is more likely to mark their 30th birthday and still be on those benefits than to have had a steady job in any of the intervening 10 years.
As the Prime Minister said to the Cabinet this morning, delivering this new settlement will require a genuinely cross-government effort, which is why the Government are today committing to the creation of a new youth opportunities unit, which will report directly to the Prime Minister. We will also work with the devolved Governments to ensure that the benefits of local delivery and personalised support are available to young people throughout the United Kingdom. These are significant commitments to begin building the new settlement.
There is a further step that we can take immediately for young people who have already spent too long out of work. The jobs guarantee that I launched earlier this year provides for a fully funded, six-month job matched to a young person’s skills. Alan Milburn recommends making it available after 12 months on universal credit, rather than 18. I agree, and we will do that. I am also hugely grateful to businesses in the retail, hospitality and tourism sectors for announcing recently that they will hire a total of 250,000 young people not in education, employment or training over the next few years.
In the weeks ahead, the work of change will continue. I am already working with colleagues from the Department of Health and Social Care and the Department for Education, and others across government, to put in place a better support offer from now. The Timms review will report soon, and in the new year the Government will publish a White Paper and, following that, legislation. The House will then decide whether to continue with the current system—the system that we inherited from the Conservatives, which far too readily signs people off and writes them off—or to introduce a new settlement for young people that puts opportunity, participation and work at the heart of the welfare system, and at the heart of the wider challenges that young people are facing.
I put forward this response today not because it is a tough decision but because it is the right decision. Carrying on as we are has too high a human cost—too many wasted lives and too much spent on failure, rather than opportunity. As the party of work, we believe that people from all backgrounds and all parts of the country should fulfil their full potential. That is what will change lives for the better, and that is what will bring more hope. I commend this Statement to the House”.
Baroness Stedman-Scott (Con)
My Lords, I thank the Minister for the Statement made in the other place and Alan Milburn and his team for their work on this review. It has been excellent. There is a great deal in this review that all sides of your Lordships’ House can get behind, and I suspect many noble Lords will read parts of it and think, “I have been saying that for months, if not years”. But publishing a review is only step one. The real test begins now. Can the Government carry their own Benches, particularly in the other place? Mr Milburn recommends savings—not enough of them, in our view, but savings all the same. Reforming welfare means hard choices, getting spending under control and setting a clear expectation to work. The question is whether the Government have the political will to see it through. If they do, there is a bigger question still: where are the jobs? Yesterday’s figures from the Office for National Statistics tell the story. Payrolled employees fell by 34,000 in October and by 95,000 over the year. Among the smallest businesses, those with between one and nine staff, vacancies have fallen to 73,000. Outside the pandemic, that is the lowest since 2012. The ONS’s own evidence suggests why: smaller firms are holding back on hiring because of labour costs. For young people, the picture is starker. Youth unemployment is 15.6%. There is one starter vacancy for every three young people who are NEET, and graduate vacancies have fallen by 43% in a single year. A welfare system can prepare a young person for work and a programme can build their skills, but neither can give them a job. Only an employer can offer that first chance, that first wage and that first rung on the ladder. The Government need not take my word for it; they need only read their own review. It says plainly that Britain cannot fix this by making more young people work-ready while demand for young workers keeps falling. Mr Milburn himself writes: “There is nothing progressive about pricing young people out of work”— my goodness, he is right. He warns that “government cannot be indifferent to the cumulative effect of the costs and obligations it places on the decision to hire”, yet indifference is exactly what we have had, Budget after Budget. Employers do not feel government policy one measure at a time. As the review says, they feel it all at once, as “cost, complexity and risk”. National insurance, energy bills, business rates, wage rules and employment regulation all lead up to the same simple question: “Can I afford to take on one more person?” Let us start with the jobs tax. The review finds that the Government’s 2025 national insurance changes added around £800 a year to the cost of a full-time worker on the living wage. Add the rise in the national living wage itself and the cost of employing that worker has gone up by £3,414 in just two years—between 2024 and 2026. For the youngest workers, it is starker still. As the review says: “Wage costs for young people aged 18 to 20 on the minimum wage have increased by 65 per cent over the last 5 years”. The Government taxed jobs, knocked confidence, and then commissioned a review into why opportunities for young people were disappearing. The review has now supplied the answer. I may not be a renowned economist, and I never will be, but I know this much: if you tax something, you get less of it—fewer jobs, fewer chances and fewer first steps. Mr Milburn’s answer is to double the threshold for 21 to 24 year-olds in retail and hospitality, but only when fiscal conditions allow, giving the Government every chance to put it on the never-never. We would act now. We would halve employer national insurance for 21 to 24 year-olds, saving a business around £1,500 a year for every young person it takes on. We would cut business rates for 250,000 high street shops, pubs and hospitality businesses, and we would create 100,000 more apprenticeships a year, paid for by the £36 billion of welfare savings we have identified. Alongside that, we would deliver “get to work” for young people on universal credit without a strong work record. Instead of sitting at home losing confidence, they would be expected to turn up every day, engaging with meaningful support in return for their benefit. That is tough love, but the alternative is a generation watching their skills fade and their hopes drain away. Then there is the Employment Rights Act. The review put its cost to business at around £1 billion a year. More than a third of employers were planning to cut permanent hiring because of it. On guaranteed hours, Mr Milburn warns of the unintended consequences, adding: “I believe this is likely to be the case”. I ask the Minister three simple questions. Will the Government accept Mr Milburn’s recommendation and today commit not to increase the cost of employing young people any further? Will they cut the jobs tax on young workers now? Will they think again about guaranteed hours, where they threaten seasonal work, temporary work and the Saturday job? The Government will not bring down the cost of hiring; their answer is to subsidise it instead. But a subsidy should be a bridge to a real job, not a permanent substitution for one. That is the circularity here: the Government raise the cost of employing young people, then spend taxpayers’ money subsidising placements with the very employers who might otherwise have created those jobs themselves. Does the Minister not see the absurdity of that? If the subsidy is the answer, it has to lead somewhere. Can the Minister tell the House what proportion of young people on the jobs guarantee the Government expect to be in unsubsidised work six to 12 months later, after the subsidy ends? Then there are the savings. The review expects a net saving of around £200 million by 2036-37. Is that it? The OBR expects working-age welfare spending to pass £200 billion by the end of this decade. That is a saving of less than £1 in every £1,000. Then there is the target itself. The review aims for a NEET rate of around 5% by 2036, but its own modelling gets to only 6.8%. It says that closing the gap depends on higher growth and “new momentum in the youth labour market”. In other words, the review’s policies do not meet the review’s own target. What is missing is a thriving labour market and employers with the confidence to hire. On both, the Government are falling short. We need answers. Which recommendations do the Government accept in full and which do they reject? Will existing claimants be reassessed? Will benefits be withdrawn from those who persistently refuse a reasonable offer? When will we see reform for over-25s, which the review says is urgent? In the meantime, what will happen to all those who are already out of work? The restart scheme has stopped taking referrals and its last participants finish next August. Can the Minister tell the House whether the restart scheme will be extended? If not, what support will long-term unemployed people receive at its end and after the implementation of the review? Although the Statement made no mention of savings, will the Government take forward the changes to the sickness benefit that Mr Milburn proposes? We have set five tests for this review. First, will it cut costs on business, so that it creates real jobs rather than taxpayer-subsidised jobs? Secondly, will benefits be cut for those who refuse to work or take part? Thirdly, will it reduce the number of young people dependent on the state? Fourthly, will cash benefits be kept for the seriously disabled, with support rather than cash for milder conditions? Fifthly, will it bring the working-age welfare bill down overall? Yesterday evening, I welcomed a group of young people into Parliament to talk about the review. We sat down and they spoke passionately about their experiences. They all had one thing in common: each of them had applied for hundreds of jobs. Some had been fortunate enough to get a chance, some are still waiting to hear, and some had yet to land a single opportunity. That is why there are fewer vacancies. Will the Government listen to this report and set out clearly when they will stop adding to the cost of hiring and admit that their policies have made it harder, not easier, for young people to get their first job?
Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)
My Lords, I thank the ministerial team for bringing the Statement here for debate, and I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott, for speaking at length about the Conservative’s view on this. I thank the Government for this 278-page report. We do not say anything simply—it is 278 pages. Could the Minister say where and how the trained personnel will be found to implement these reforms? I have some more questions, and I will limit myself purely to questions. First, Alan Milburn is explicit that his reforms require an upfront investment of £500 million in 2027-28. Will the Government commit that £500 million for 2027-28, and where will these reprioritisations come from exactly? Secondly, what assessment have the Government made of the report’s modelling that its proposed policies would reduce the youth NEET rate from 13.4% to 6.8% by 2036-37, particularly given that its NEET zero target is 5% and the lowest NEET rate on record was, sadly, 9.7% in June 2021? Thirdly, will the Government set out a timeline for the phasing in of the reduction of NICs? On that, I agree with the noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott. Will the Government commit to beginning its implementation in the next Budget? Will they consider cutting employers’ NICs beyond hospitality and retail to undo more of the damage caused by the jobs tax? Fourthly, the youth opportunity service is tasked with delivering statutory opportunity and support guarantees across England by 2029, including mental health navigation, vocational rehabilitation, community work and health teams, and a local health and disability fund. Can the Minister say how much funding and staffing resource the Government will allocate to the youth opportunity service? The review proposes a statutory duty to require benefit claimants not to refuse “reasonable offers without good cause”, backed, ultimately, by reductions in the youth allowance. What statutory criteria will define “reasonable offers” and “good cause”? It is very vague. The Milburn review proposes three new support categories: a local health and disability fund, an additional cost allowance, and a severe and complex needs allowance. What is the Government’s assessment of how many young people will move into each category? The review also stresses that existing claimants should move to the new system following a personalised, time-limited transition. Can the Government set out the timeline for this proposed vague change? PIP is a passport benefit for other benefits such as carer’s allowance, yet carer’s allowance does not seem to feature anywhere in the Milburn report. Perhaps I missed it—in the 278-odd pages. How will the Government ensure that carers do not lose access to their carer’s allowance off the back of these changes? How exactly will the Government decide where the line is drawn for the different types of support? The DWP has around 2 million overdue work capability assessments for universal credit health support. The Government want to merge these with the PIP assessment. How will the Government ensure that this process is workable? Will they commit to doing more assessments face to face so that claimants are better and correctly supported? What changes does the department intend to make to the implementation of the curriculum and assessment review in light of the Young pe ople and work: interim report recommendations? Alan Milburn explicitly warns Ministers against taking months to review his report. He calls for a legislative and funding timetable within the first 100 days. Will the Government commit to that 100-day deadline and publish a clear timetable showing which policies they accept, which they reject and when each will take effect? One would have thought that, in light of a 278-page report, I would not have had to ask so many questions. I look forward to the answers.
The Minister of State, Department for Education and Department for Work and Pensions (Baroness Smith of Malvern) (Lab)
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness and the noble Lord for their contributions. In the time I have available, I will do my best to respond to at least some of their questions. Alan Milburn’s review is clear that the challenge it confronts has deep roots going back many years. Some of what the noble Baroness said made it sound as if this was a problem that has newly emerged. Let us be clear: the biggest increase in the numbers of young people not earning or learning was the 250,000 increase that occurred between the pandemic and this Government coming to power. As Alan Milburn himself says, no unfunded, unaffordable decrease in national insurance contributions will be a magic bullet that solves this problem. When it comes to the Employment Rights Act, having jobs with guaranteed hours and security is much more likely to keep young people in the workplace than the sort of uncertain work that the party opposite would want to dump them in. The issue that Alan Milburn has done such an important piece of work on is damaging the life chances of 1 million young people who are not in education, work or training. This is a moral failure and an economic catastrophe, and we are determined to do something about it—in a way previous Governments did not. A challenge of this scale calls for a response that reaches far beyond one government department. The whole system must change. Young people need a new settlement, and Alan’s report sets out a blueprint for that. We have to move away from a system that all too easily signs off and writes off young people and build a new system that believes in and values their generation, with earlier intervention, stronger support, more devolution and clear expectations to take part. That is why we have already started. We have started with a £2.5 billion youth guarantee. The Milburn review makes further proposals for how we put work and opportunity at the heart of the system, because it should give young people the best chance of higher living standards throughout their lives. It should start by asking what they need to build a good future. That is why we have already said that we support Alan Milburn’s recommendation for a new opportunity and support guarantee, backed by legislation, so that every young person who is not earning or learning has a credible route forward. We have also said that we will support and implement his recommendation for a more personalised system that brings together the support and opportunities that young people need at a local level, making the most of local connections and expertise. When a young person needs help to get back on track, they should have one place to turn to, with a clear point of contact and one plan; and yes, we will ensure that the £500 million is available as a budget for the youth opportunity service next year. In this new system, opportunity must be matched by responsibility—on which we have rightly been challenged. Where somebody can participate, with the right support, they should be expected to take up that support. Because building this system requires a joint effort across government and society, we have also committed to creating a new youth opportunities unit, reporting directly to the Prime Minister, to co-ordinate this. Today, my right honourable friend the Secretary of State for Education announced that we will guarantee a funded college place for every 16 to 18 year-old who wants one, giving those who have disengaged a fresh start. That is four significant commitments, ahead of our full response next year. The noble Baroness suggested that there are no jobs out there for young people. I am enormously grateful for the progress we have seen in recent weeks, with the retail, hospitality and tourism sectors stepping forward with an offer of 250,000 jobs over the coming years for young people who are not currently earning or learning. We know that employers are keen to support this mission, and we will support them in helping us with that. Our work to change the system continues. As the Secretary of State has announced, we are expanding eligibility for the jobs guarantee, bringing that subsidised six-month job back to the point where a young person has been out of work for a year, rather than the current 18 months. The Timms review of personal independence payments will report shortly. When we have that review, we will bring it together with Alan’s work to enable us to respond fully on the points about benefits that Alan makes in his report, and that noble Lords have made this evening. We will respond fully in the new year with a White Paper, followed by legislation. On savings, let me be clear: we do want to spend less money on young people sitting out of the jobs and the learning that will create their future. However, we know from experience that the only way to do that successfully is to put the support in place first to enable those young people to get their place in work and in learning. We have learned what happens when you make abrupt cuts: it simply forces spending into the health system, into housing and into the criminal justice system. We are determined not only to make savings, but in a way that enables young people to have the chance of the future that this report is all about. Together, this is our chance to reshape the system into one that invests in success, rather than paying the costs of failure; one that offers young people a new settlement, so that, whoever they are and wherever they are from, they can fulfil their potential—and so can our country.
Captain of the King’s Bodyguard of the Yeomen of the Guard and Deputy Chief Whip (Baroness Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent) (Lab)
My Lords, we have 20 minutes for questions. We will start with the Labour Benches and then work our way around the Chamber. The second question will come from the Conservative Benches.
Lord Stace (Lab)
My Lords, as a former chief executive of the Prince’s Trust, now the King’s Trust, I urge all of us to show young people that we understand the seriousness of this situation and that we will do whatever it takes to give them the best chance in life. Can my noble friend ensure that the centrepiece for action, the youth opportunity service, is designed with charities, employers, colleges and mayors, so that we create a system that works for the long term?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
My noble friend is absolutely right, and that is certainly our intention. Not only will that service operate at a local level, where it will make the most difference in bringing together the services that young people need, but it will do that with the sorts of partners that my noble friend identified. There is a crucial job for employers and a vital job for local authorities, but the voluntary sector, in particular the organisation that my noble friend cited, has an enormously important role to play in providing that support and future for young people, and it will be part of this project.
Baroness Coffey (Con)
My Lords, I was Secretary of State when we had the lowest ever NEETs level and youth unemployment on record, whether measured in percentages, actual numbers, seasonally adjusted totals or real people. The point is that this is about real people. The Milburn review is a mixture of gold and pyrite. I wonder whether the Labour Government and the Prime Minister will understand that chapter 5, on the NHS, is the gold; the risk is that the rest is the pyrite. I desperately want to see more young people in jobs, but Alan Milburn has asked for £500 million. What is going to be cut? As one good example, next year £570 million will be spent on quite a small number of young people on Erasmus. Would it not be better to put that money into making sure that young people get going and have the youth opportunities that they deserve and merit, rather than choosing something to do with Erasmus?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
The Prime Minister is clear that we need to find the funding from across government to support the youth opportunity service. As I said to the noble Lord, we will ensure that that budget is in place for the youth opportunity service next year. The noble Baroness also made an important point about the contribution of health. That is why this is a cross-government effort and why the youth opportunity unit will play that important role in ensuring that all parts of government are contributing to the future that young people need.
Lord McCobb (LD)
My Lords, the Statement points towards giving mayors a greater role in skills and employment. In Hull and east Yorkshire, months of delays to the launch of Connect to Work prompted local MPs to write to the mayor to express concern that millions of pounds of support could have been lost in the delay. In handing mayors more responsibility for this critical area of work, how will the Government make sure that they and their authorities have the ability and the capacity to deliver it?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
The noble Lord makes an important point. We believe that the sorts of services that exist at local level, such as the youth opportunity service, can be co-ordinated at that level, commissioned by mayoral authorities but, in many cases, as I said to my noble friend, delivered by the voluntary sector, local authorities and the local health service. Those services are best organised around a young person at that level. The test will be the change that it makes for young people and the ability to deliver the opportunity and support guarantee that we have also committed to as part of our response to this report.
Lord Cameron of Dillington (CB)
My Lords, I am hugely supportive of this new deal for our young. It is a vision that simply must be made to work for all our young. That is what I wish to highlight, because nowhere does this report address the specific problems of the rural young. How do they get from home to the local technology college, which is probably 12, 13 or 14 miles away—every day there and back? How do they get to their first job? It is possibly only seven or eight miles away, but even so, how do they get there and back every day without any transport? I would love to talk to the Minister and her team about the rural solutions to all the rural NEET problems. Believe me, NEET problems in rural areas are considerable, certainly where I come from in Cornwall. They really need considering in depth on their own, so I hope there is going to be serious consideration of the problems of a rural rollout of this review.
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
The noble Lord makes an important point, and of course makes the case for a locally designed youth opportunity service. What it is necessary to provide for young people in Cornwall to be able to access those opportunities may well be different from what it is necessary to provide in a city. Transport will obviously be one of those areas of support that we will need to put in place for young people to be able to access the jobs or college places that will be made available to them.
Baroness MacLeod of Camusdarach (Lab)
My Lords, the aims and aspirations of this report should be celebrated, but I have a serious question to ask my noble friend: how confident is she that these changes will be rolled out throughout the United Kingdom, particularly in Scotland?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
My noble friend makes a really important point, not least given the levels of young people not earning or learning in Scotland. While elements of this report will be delivered on the basis of powers that exist only in England, we will certainly want to work extremely closely with Governments in Scotland and Wales to ensure that the new system and the support that Alan Milburn has proposed in this report are available for everybody across the whole of the United Kingdom.
Lord Baker of Dorking (Con)
My Lords, I would like to ask a question about youth unemployment, as that is what the committee was set up for. There are 981,000 16 to 24 year-olds unemployed in our country today. That is unacceptable and a disgrace to the fifth-richest country in the world. It is because both Conservative and Labour Governments have failed to provide 18 year-olds with employable skills. That is why I set up new technical schools—university technical colleges—and Alan Milburn refers to them in his report. He says that we want to expand, but no new schools will be built for seven years in Britain because of falling school rolls. His review states: “The UTC model should also be expanded. There are currently 44 UTCs … representing around 1% of state-funded secondary schools. A recent analysis found that UTC leavers were more likely to enter apprenticeships and more likely to be employed. Mainstream secondary schools are already beginning to build on the model by adopting the ‘UTC Sleeve’ approach” for 14 to 16 year-olds in bog-standard comprehensives and existing secondary schools. Two opened last week, in Barrow-in-Furness and in Darwen. The review states: “It … should become over time a mainstream part of the school landscape”. So my question is: should the UTC model be expanded and become, in time, a mainstream part of the school system?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
From the sound of it, the noble Lord has done as good a job of lobbying Alan Milburn as he does of lobbying me on UTC sleeves. The key point, which he has been arguing for many years, is the ability of young people to have that exposure from the age of 14 to a technical education that can show them the routes into work. That is precisely why the Prime Minister has already started us down a route of developing those technical routes from 14 to 16. It is why we are already reforming qualifications post 16 in order to ensure that those routes are available. The UTC sleeve is an important way in which that can happen, and we will certainly consider that as part of our response to developing those better routes to technical education for young people.
Lord Addington (LD)
My Lords, can the Minister give us a little guide to which department will be the ultimate lead here? We have been told that it will report to the Prime Minister. We all know what happens: it is the new, shiny project of a Minister or a Prime Minister, but the money has got to come out of a budget. Which Secretary of State will be responsible for this, or is this a new model that will depend on the enthusiasm of the Prime Minister of the day?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
In my experience in government, when you face a very big challenge such as this, it is absolutely fundamental to have not just the enthusiasm but the support and commitment of the Prime Minister. He has quite clearly demonstrated that here. It is also, of course, the case that when something needs input from across government, you need a way to co-ordinate that. That is the reasoning behind the Government’s proposal to set up the youth opportunities unit in the centre of government, reporting to the Prime Minister, with the job of co-ordinating those departments to ensure that everything necessary is there to deliver not only the service but the response that will be necessary to ensure that young people have the future they want. That machinery of government approach and the absolute commitment of the Prime Minister are what are likely to make this a success and bring government together to deliver it.
Baroness Lister of Burtersett (Lab)
My Lords, Alan Milburn’s very welcome report emphasises: “Poverty and inequality are at the core of the NEET crisis”. In the long term, the hope is that his new settlement will reduce poverty. It is worth noting the big reduction in child poverty that has just been announced because of the abolition of the two-child limit. What assessment have the Government made of the impact on poverty in the shorter term? There are fears among disability groups not just that cuts to benefits for some disabled young people will cause more hardship but that that increased hardship will itself make it harder for them to take up the work or educational opportunities that are being opened up for them.
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
I do not think there is anything more likely to make somebody poor throughout their lives than, at the point at which they should be entering the workforce, being put on benefits that provide them with no question of what they are able to do and no support to enable them to do it. We are determined to turn the system around to get that support in place, not simply to leave young people on benefits without that future. My noble friend makes an important point about the detail of benefit changes. That is why, as I have said, when the Timms review reports in the near future, we will bring together the really important work that has been led by that group, alongside Alan’s proposals, and come forward with detailed proposals about proposed benefit changes, which everybody will be able to scrutinise. She is right that an important test will be how all the changes we are making help to reduce poverty and provide young people with the chance of a fruitful life. That will certainly be a yardstick that we will use to determine our proposals.
Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)
My Lords—
Lord Harper (Con)
My Lords—
Baroness in Waiting/Government Whip (Baroness Antrobus) (Lab)
We will hear from the Greens first.
Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)
My Lords, Wales is now starting the Nature Service, delivering part of what the green new deal movement, nature charities and campaign groups have been calling for across these islands—a national nature service. It will have work outside in green spaces, in active jobs that are ideal for many. Yet “nature” appears only four times in the 278-page report and there is nothing referring to the natural world, despite its desperate need for repair for labour. Are the Government at least prepared to consider a significant investment in a national nature service? That is something that could provide good jobs and would be for the public good, rather than what is suggested here of subsidising existing employers, which will largely be giant multinational companies—subsidising their profits rather than working for the public good.
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
I think it is fair to say that Alan Milburn’s report, as others have mentioned, is pretty wide-ranging. It feels a little unfair to criticise it on the basis that it did not take up that particular point about a nature service. Where I agree with the noble Baroness is that we have to find a range of opportunities for young people, through work experience, work and training, to experience what it is like to work in a way that enthuses them and makes them want to carry on working. It may well be, for some of them, that that type of activity outside would be the way to do it, but I am afraid I am not in a position to answer her specific questions about the nature service as part of this Statement.
Lord Harper (Con)
If the Government conclude in the next month or so, when they are considering both the Milburn report and the Tims review, that it is the right thing to do to reduce national insurance contributions for young people, will they be brave enough to make that decision and execute it now, or will they wait a year until the next Budget, when they could have a year’s worth of that lower-cost employment taking effect and giving those young people an opportunity to get into work?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
First, I started off by explaining why all the evidence about how long this problem has existed for, and at which points it increased considerably, suggests that national insurance contributions are not the determining factor here. Secondly, the noble Lord knows that decisions about taxes and national insurance contributions will be made at the point of a Budget and will be made by the Chancellor of the Exchequer.
Lord Pitkeathley of Camden Town (Lab)
My Lords, I refer the House to my registered interests representing two business communities in north London. Can my noble friend the Minister say a little more about how the businesses that provide the jobs, pay the taxes and bring life to our high streets will experience the government support implied in yesterday’s report as they help to tackle this national challenge?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
My noble friend is right: businesses, in my experience, are very keen to help us to tackle this challenge. We know that they are under pressure and we want to make it easier for them to hire young people. We are already providing substantial support to reduce the cost of employing young people. There has been a lot of talk about national insurance contributions. Of course, it is the case that if you employ somebody aged under 21, you pay no national insurance contributions. If they are an apprentice then you pay no national insurance contributions up to the age of 25, saving up to £6,790 per eligible employee. One of the Prime Minister’s first announcements in office was to cut business rates for pubs. At the Budget, the Chancellor extended business rates cuts for thousands of retail, hospitality and leisure businesses—sectors that are particularly important in giving young people their first step back into work. Through the youth guarantee, the growth and skills levy and our apprenticeship work, we are providing incentives to employers to take on young people who are neither earning nor learning. My noble friend is right that we need to work alongside business to ensure that those jobs are there, but that is work that we have already started.
Lord Bailey of Paddington (Con)
My Lords, can the Minister tell the House what work is being done to give small firms better access to the apprenticeship levy? Does she agree that young people do not want endless training schemes? They want actual work. What measures will the Government be taking to ensure that young people end up in permanent full-time work?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
This Government, in reforming the growth and skills levy, have already increased incentives for small businesses to take on apprentices, are now fully funding the cost of an apprenticeship for small businesses and, through the funding made available for local apprenticeship services, will enable small businesses to get the advice and links to young people who want to be apprentices who I know those businesses are keen to get. In all those ways, we are ensuring that young people are getting the type of training, alongside a job, that supports not only them but the employer to bring on an enthusiastic young person for their business.
Baroness O’Grady of Upper Holloway (Lab)
My Lords, does my noble friend the Minister agree that, as well as concern about the scarring impacts of unemployment on the young, we must also take account of the scarring impacts of insecure, low-paid work? Young people are twice as likely to be trapped in that revolving door of low-paid, insecure work as older workers. Does she agree that ensuring we have well-paid, quality employment opportunities for young people is as important as ensuring that they get off unemployment?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
My noble friend is absolutely right and, of course, the two are linked. We make no apology, therefore, as I said, for wanting young people to start their working lives in decent, secure jobs. Young people are among those who stand to benefit most from stronger employment rights, because they are, as my noble friend says, disproportionately represented in low-paid, insecure work. Giving people greater certainty over their hours and income can make work more attractive and give young people the confidence and stability they need to stay in work. Our employment rights legislation is not only morally but economically right.
Lord Sharpe of Epsom (Con)
My Lords, following on from the question from the noble Baroness, Lady O’Grady, on page 66, paragraph 307, Mr Milburn says that “when considering the responses to the recent consultation” on zero-hours contracts, “the goal should be to ensure that the potential impact on youth employment should be a primary consideration, and a cautionary principle should be adopted”. It does not sound like the Minister agrees with Mr Milburn. Am I wrong?
Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
Not only do I agree with him, but that is what we are doing. We want the reforms that we are putting in place to work for employers too, which is why we are working closely with businesses and unions on implementation and listening carefully to the issues raised by Alan Milburn. We do not accept a choice between creating opportunities for young people and giving them decent rights when they get to work. We need to do both.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5440394.