Contribution
My Lords, I thank the Minister for the Statement made in the other place and Alan Milburn and his team for their work on this review. It has been excellent. There is a great deal in this review that all sides of your Lordships’ House can get behind, and I suspect many noble Lords will read parts of it and think, “I have been saying that for months, if not years”.
But publishing a review is only step one. The real test begins now. Can the Government carry their own Benches, particularly in the other place? Mr Milburn recommends savings—not enough of them, in our view, but savings all the same. Reforming welfare means hard choices, getting spending under control and setting a clear expectation to work. The question is whether the Government have the political will to see it through. If they do, there is a bigger question still: where are the jobs?
Yesterday’s figures from the Office for National Statistics tell the story. Payrolled employees fell by 34,000 in October and by 95,000 over the year. Among the smallest businesses, those with between one and nine staff, vacancies have fallen to 73,000. Outside the pandemic, that is the lowest since 2012. The ONS’s own evidence suggests why: smaller firms are holding back on hiring because of labour costs. For young people, the picture is starker. Youth unemployment is 15.6%. There is one starter vacancy for every three young people who are NEET, and graduate vacancies have fallen by 43% in a single year. A welfare system can prepare a young person for work and a programme can build their skills, but neither can give them a job. Only an employer can offer that first chance, that first wage and that first rung on the ladder.
The Government need not take my word for it; they need only read their own review. It says plainly that Britain cannot fix this by making more young people work-ready while demand for young workers keeps falling. Mr Milburn himself writes:
“There is nothing progressive about pricing young people out of work”—
my goodness, he is right. He warns that
“government cannot be indifferent to the cumulative effect of the costs and obligations it places on the decision to hire”,
yet indifference is exactly what we have had, Budget after Budget.
Employers do not feel government policy one measure at a time. As the review says, they feel it all at once, as “cost, complexity and risk”. National insurance, energy bills, business rates, wage rules and employment regulation all lead up to the same simple question: “Can I afford to take on one more person?”
Let us start with the jobs tax. The review finds that the Government’s 2025 national insurance changes added around £800 a year to the cost of a full-time worker on the living wage. Add the rise in the national living wage itself and the cost of employing that worker has gone up by £3,414 in just two years—between 2024 and 2026.
For the youngest workers, it is starker still. As the review says:
“Wage costs for young people aged 18 to 20 on the minimum wage have increased by 65 per cent over the last 5 years”.
The Government taxed jobs, knocked confidence, and then commissioned a review into why opportunities for young people were disappearing. The review has now supplied the answer. I may not be a renowned economist, and I never will be, but I know this much: if you tax something, you get less of it—fewer jobs, fewer chances and fewer first steps.
Mr Milburn’s answer is to double the threshold for 21 to 24 year-olds in retail and hospitality, but only when fiscal conditions allow, giving the Government every chance to put it on the never-never. We would act now. We would halve employer national insurance for 21 to 24 year-olds, saving a business around £1,500 a year for every young person it takes on. We would cut business rates for 250,000 high street shops, pubs and hospitality businesses, and we would create 100,000 more apprenticeships a year, paid for by the £36 billion of welfare savings we have identified. Alongside that, we would deliver “get to work” for young people on universal credit without a strong work record. Instead of sitting at home losing confidence, they would be expected to turn up every day, engaging with meaningful support in return for their benefit. That is tough love, but the alternative is a generation watching their skills fade and their hopes drain away.
Then there is the Employment Rights Act. The review put its cost to business at around £1 billion a year. More than a third of employers were planning to cut permanent hiring because of it. On guaranteed hours, Mr Milburn warns of the unintended consequences, adding:
“I believe this is likely to be the case”.
I ask the Minister three simple questions. Will the Government accept Mr Milburn’s recommendation and today commit not to increase the cost of employing young people any further? Will they cut the jobs tax on young workers now? Will they think again about guaranteed hours, where they threaten seasonal work, temporary work and the Saturday job?
The Government will not bring down the cost of hiring; their answer is to subsidise it instead. But a subsidy should be a bridge to a real job, not a permanent substitution for one. That is the circularity here: the Government raise the cost of employing young people, then spend taxpayers’ money subsidising placements with the very employers who might otherwise have created those jobs themselves. Does the Minister not see the absurdity of that? If the subsidy is the answer, it has to lead somewhere. Can the Minister tell the House what proportion of young people on the jobs guarantee the Government expect to be in unsubsidised work six to 12 months later, after the subsidy ends?
Then there are the savings. The review expects a net saving of around £200 million by 2036-37. Is that it? The OBR expects working-age welfare spending to pass £200 billion by the end of this decade. That is a saving of less than £1 in every £1,000.
Then there is the target itself. The review aims for a NEET rate of around 5% by 2036, but its own modelling gets to only 6.8%. It says that closing the gap depends on higher growth and
“new momentum in the youth labour market”.
In other words, the review’s policies do not meet the review’s own target. What is missing is a thriving labour market and employers with the confidence to hire. On both, the Government are falling short.
We need answers. Which recommendations do the Government accept in full and which do they reject? Will existing claimants be reassessed? Will benefits be withdrawn from those who persistently refuse a reasonable offer? When will we see reform for over-25s, which the review says is urgent? In the meantime, what will happen to all those who are already out of work? The restart scheme has stopped taking referrals and its last participants finish next August. Can the Minister tell the House whether the restart scheme will be extended? If not, what support will long-term unemployed people receive at its end and after the implementation of the review? Although the Statement made no mention of savings, will the Government take forward the changes to the sickness benefit that Mr Milburn proposes?
We have set five tests for this review. First, will it cut costs on business, so that it creates real jobs rather than taxpayer-subsidised jobs? Secondly, will benefits be cut for those who refuse to work or take part? Thirdly, will it reduce the number of young people dependent on the state? Fourthly, will cash benefits be kept for the seriously disabled, with support rather than cash for milder conditions? Fifthly, will it bring the working-age welfare bill down overall?
Yesterday evening, I welcomed a group of young people into Parliament to talk about the review. We sat down and they spoke passionately about their experiences. They all had one thing in common: each of them had applied for hundreds of jobs. Some had been fortunate enough to get a chance, some are still waiting to hear, and some had yet to land a single opportunity. That is why there are fewer vacancies. Will the Government listen to this report and set out clearly when they will stop adding to the cost of hiring and admit that their policies have made it harder, not easier, for young people to get their first job?