L

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 18 November 2026

Debate

Milburn Review: Final Report

Contribution

My Lords, I thank the ministerial team for bringing the Statement here for debate, and I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott, for speaking at length about the Conservative’s view on this. I thank the Government for this 278-page report. We do not say anything simply—it is 278 pages. Could the Minister say where and how the trained personnel will be found to implement these reforms? I have some more questions, and I will limit myself purely to questions. First, Alan Milburn is explicit that his reforms require an upfront investment of £500 million in 2027-28. Will the Government commit that £500 million for 2027-28, and where will these reprioritisations come from exactly? Secondly, what assessment have the Government made of the report’s modelling that its proposed policies would reduce the youth NEET rate from 13.4% to 6.8% by 2036-37, particularly given that its NEET zero target is 5% and the lowest NEET rate on record was, sadly, 9.7% in June 2021? Thirdly, will the Government set out a timeline for the phasing in of the reduction of NICs? On that, I agree with the noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott. Will the Government commit to beginning its implementation in the next Budget? Will they consider cutting employers’ NICs beyond hospitality and retail to undo more of the damage caused by the jobs tax? Fourthly, the youth opportunity service is tasked with delivering statutory opportunity and support guarantees across England by 2029, including mental health navigation, vocational rehabilitation, community work and health teams, and a local health and disability fund. Can the Minister say how much funding and staffing resource the Government will allocate to the youth opportunity service? The review proposes a statutory duty to require benefit claimants not to refuse “reasonable offers without good cause”, backed, ultimately, by reductions in the youth allowance. What statutory criteria will define “reasonable offers” and “good cause”? It is very vague. The Milburn review proposes three new support categories: a local health and disability fund, an additional cost allowance, and a severe and complex needs allowance. What is the Government’s assessment of how many young people will move into each category? The review also stresses that existing claimants should move to the new system following a personalised, time-limited transition. Can the Government set out the timeline for this proposed vague change? PIP is a passport benefit for other benefits such as carer’s allowance, yet carer’s allowance does not seem to feature anywhere in the Milburn report. Perhaps I missed it—in the 278-odd pages. How will the Government ensure that carers do not lose access to their carer’s allowance off the back of these changes? How exactly will the Government decide where the line is drawn for the different types of support? The DWP has around 2 million overdue work capability assessments for universal credit health support. The Government want to merge these with the PIP assessment. How will the Government ensure that this process is workable? Will they commit to doing more assessments face to face so that claimants are better and correctly supported? What changes does the department intend to make to the implementation of the curriculum and assessment review in light of the Young people and work: interim report recommendations? Alan Milburn explicitly warns Ministers against taking months to review his report. He calls for a legislative and funding timetable within the first 100 days. Will the Government commit to that 100-day deadline and publish a clear timetable showing which policies they accept, which they reject and when each will take effect? One would have thought that, in light of a 278-page report, I would not have had to ask so many questions. I look forward to the answers.

More from Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.