Settled Migrants: Economic Contribution to UK
Monday, 19 October 2026
Contributions
Question
Asked by
Lord Moraes
To ask His Majesty’s Government what calculation they have made of the net annual economic contribution to the UK of settled migrants, in particular those with indefinite leave to remain.
The Deputy Leader of the House of Lords (Lord Collins of Highbury) (Lab)
My Lords, the Migration Advisory Committee has published estimates of the static and lifetime fiscal impact of migrants in the United Kingdom on work and family routes. Settlement grants migrants the right to remain in the United Kingdom indefinitely, without conditions on accessing the labour market and public funds. Therefore, it is right to consider the fiscal contribution of migrants with settlement over their lifetime, rather than a shorter period.
Lord Moraes (Lab)
I thank my noble friend for that Answer. He may be aware that the Home Affairs Committee was written to by Home Office officials confirming a net fiscal benefit of ILR recipients up to year 25—a kind of long medium-term point. Will these contributions, and the fact that those on ILR work disproportionately in sectors such as adult social care and the NHS, feature in final decisions on the fairer pathway to settlement consultation, which are to be made soon?
Lord Collins of Highbury (Lab)
My noble friend rightly points out that the proposals for an earned settlement model were set out in A Fairer Pathway to Settlement , published in November 2025. The consultation closed in February and there have been over 200,000 responses. Those responses are being analysed by the Government and the final earned settlement arrangements will be announced in due course, so I cannot predict that. However, he is right about how the calculations regarding the contributions are worked out, which is what the Migration Advisory Committee set out. They vary quite substantially between different cohorts, which will no doubt be considered in the final outcome when the Government consider the consultation.
Baroness Hamwee (LD)
My Lords, does the Minister agree that it is the very resilience of many immigrants that makes them successful entrepreneurs, bringing benefits to them individually and to all of us as a society?
Lord Collins of Highbury (Lab)
There is no doubt that migration has a positive effect and a positive economic effect. What the Home Secretary was attempting to say in her recent speech to the Labour Party conference is that the role of the Government is to make the country fair. Fairness is what unites us as a country. The approach that she has taken, which is one taken by other countries, is to ensure that we win public confidence in the immigration system. We acknowledge that settlement allows migrants to claim support from public funds and seek work without sponsorship, and we need to be fair on those issues. The noble Baroness is right that there has been a huge positive impact on our economy from migration. All of us in this Chamber, I suspect, have predecessors who have been migrants at one point or another.
Lord Kirkhope of Harrogate (Con)
My Lords, it is important that the noble Lord, Lord Moraes, raised this Question, because it is a fact that Governments in this country can determine, under the Immigration Rules, the categories and types of people whom we would like to see here, but also take into account the mutual benefit of having certain people in this country. We have benefited enormously from the rules when they have been well applied. I hope the Minister will acknowledge that, as the choice is that of the Government, they will continue to make choices that are to our mutual benefit, and where we can see that migrants coming to this country contribute fully and positively to our economy and society.
Lord Collins of Highbury (Lab)
The noble Lord is absolutely right. To amplify the point that my noble friend raised, the MAC found that there is undoubtedly significant variation in migrants’ lifetime fiscal contribution depending on their salary and wider characteristics. For example, those arriving via the skilled worker route were estimated to make a larger lifetime contribution, of positive £689,000, than those in a lower category of occupation, care provision, where it is negative £36,000. Even within the health service, we have the huge positive impact of doctors and nurses as well. That is a very positive impact in terms of the economic benefit to the country as a whole.
Lord Londesborough (CB)
My Lords, employers in sectors such as hospitality, retail and social care will tell you that they would cease to function without the ability to hire productive migrant workers. That is an inconvenient truth for the far-right nationalists who claim that migrants are stealing jobs from UK-born workers. Does the Minister agree that, with an ageing population and a plummeting birth rate, our heavy dependency on migrant workers looks set to grow further rather than to decline?
Lord Collins of Highbury (Lab)
I am really tempted to get into a debate about Brexit, but I will not. The simple fact is that there was an unprecedented level of migration to the United Kingdom between 2021 and 2025. That will undoubtedly lead to significant numbers wanting settlement, which is why this Government are looking at the situation and at fairness within that settlement. There is no doubt that, during the period when we were seeking to fill vacancies in the care sector in particular, the system was pretty chaotic, and we are now having to deal with the consequences.
Lord Davies of Gower (Con)
My Lords, there has been much speculation over the past few months about whether the Government are planning to water down the reforms to indefinite to remain. We on these Benches have offered to give the Government our support in Parliament to help push through the urgently needed, if imperfect, reforms announced last year. Can the Minister assure the House that the Government will proceed with these urgently needed reforms as originally planned?
Lord Collins of Highbury (Lab)
As I said in my response, we have had a proper consultation. We have had over 200,000 responses. We will consider those responses as a whole and then come up with a plan. I appreciate the noble Lord’s commitment to co-operate and welcome it very much, but I would appreciate a bit of acknowledgement that his Government were the cause of the problem.
Lord Watts (Lab)
My Lords, is it not the case that we need to have balance here—
Baroness Chakrabarti (Lab)
My Lords, excuse me, but may I take—
Lord Watts (Lab)
Well, excuse me as well.
Baroness Chakrabarti (Lab)
My Lords, I take this opportunity to pay tribute to my noble friend Lord Moraes for decades of evidence-based and compassionate contributions to this debate. I might add the noble Lord, Lord Kirkhope, to those congratulations. However, we have been swimming against the tide in this debate. In the light of last night’s shocking revelations on ITV about the way that this debate is conducted within the Reform Party, does my noble friend the Minister agree that it is more important than ever that parties represented in this House conduct the debate in the way suggested by my noble friend Lord Moraes and the noble Lord, Lord Kirkhope?
Lord Collins of Highbury (Lab)
I thank my noble friend for that. I think the debate across the Chamber has been a moderate one, which is absolutely right. The important thing is that we are talking about an earned settlement process and understanding the reasons why we need to introduce it. There have been significant challenges with migration—I gave the House the figures. We are going to see a spike. One of the things that has changed dramatically is that the number of migrants coming in with dependents has increased substantially. That is going to be an issue we need to consider. Every economy in the world allows migrants to come in to address labour shortages and other issues in the economy, including the United States. The US has not put up a barrier to that because it knows the consequences of doing so. We should not see migration as a negative. It is a positive in its economic and cultural impacts.
Lord Purvis of Tweed (LD)
My Lords, I hope all parts of the House recognise that one of the communities who make a huge contribution to the UK are those from Hong Kong, many of whom have suffered real persecution there. Worryingly, we have heard that some applicants for BNO visas from Hong Kong are being refused access to the United Kingdom because of prior convictions purely from protesting against the repression of the Chinese Government. Can the Minister confirm to this House that applications on that basis will not be refused and that they will be able to have sanctuary here in the United Kingdom?
Lord Collins of Highbury (Lab)
The process for applications is very clear and it is conducted fairly and equitably by the Home Office, so I am not going to comment on individual circumstances. The noble Lord may tempt me to do so, but all BNOs can apply and their applications will be considered in the same way.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5419454.