Hansard·Lords Chamber·Vol. 860

UK and EU: Alignment on Renewable Energy

Monday, 19 October 2026

23 contributions9 members

Contributions

  1. Question

    View contribution permalink →

  2. Asked by

    View contribution permalink →

  3. Lord Moynihan of Chelsea

    To ask His Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of the United Kingdom’s ability to align with the European Union’s acquis on renewable energy.

    View contribution permalink →

  4. Baroness in Waiting/Government Whip (Baroness Curran) (Lab)

    My Lords, this Government are negotiating an electricity agreement with the EU to reduce the cost of trading electricity with our European partners, strengthen the UK’s energy security, support investment in the North Sea and help deliver our clean power mission. As part of the negotiations, the UK and the EU will discuss the relevant rules relating to renewable energy. The detailed commitments under such agreement will be developed as part of the negotiations.

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Lord Moynihan of Chelsea (Con)

    My Lords, the financial benefits to the UK of joining the EU electricity market will be nugatory to possibly negative, but the EU has said that, in addition, the UK would have to join the acquis, which will require us to be producing 42.5% of our total energy from renewables by 2030—not just our electricity, which is only 18% of our total energy—and that we will be sanctioned by the ECJ if we do not achieve that 42.5% target. Can the Minister confirm that the Government accept that 42.5% is entirely impossible for us to achieve in any such timeframe, and that our negotiators have been instructed to accept that target under no circumstances and, indeed, not to join the EU’s electricity market unless we get a carve-out from that 42.5%?

    View contribution permalink →

  6. Baroness Curran (Lab)

    There is a great deal in that question, and I have to say that I would challenge quite a part of it, but let me do my very best to address the details that the noble Lord has indicated. The purpose of these negotiations is to reduce the cost of trading electricity with our European partners. Energy UK has stated that, during the price spike of 2022, between £120 million and £370 million per year could have been saved by efficient trading. I would have thought that all in this House would look for opportunities to reduce energy bills at this time. Trading with our nearest partners is common sense—it makes sense. This agreement requires co-operation. It does not require membership of the single market. The basis of this agreement is mutual prosperity. It reduces inefficiencies and encourages co-operation while it benefits consumers and businesses. We will negotiate all the rules and will engage with Parliament as we see fit—as we should, of course—as is outlined. The UK-EU common understanding sets out that any agreement on state aid should provide for the UK’s dynamic alignment with relevant EU rules and respect UK constitutional and parliamentary processes. That applies across the board. The ECJ will not be involved in the acquis.

    View contribution permalink →

  7. Lord Teverson (LD)

    My Lords, on a more positive note, when the Government negotiate to align with the EU acquis, will they seek to rejoin the North Seas Energy Cooperation agreement that we were a member of before Brexit, which will allow a proper functioning grid in the North Sea, much greater resilience for energy in this country and lower costs for consumers as well?

    View contribution permalink →

  8. Baroness Curran (Lab)

    This Government will always take opportunities to improve our grid connections and reduce costs. We see partnership as part of that. It makes sense that we negotiate with countries with which we have interconnectors, so we will continue to do that. Membership of specific organisations, such as the North Seas Energy Cooperation that the noble Lord suggested, will be part of these negotiations. These negotiations will be discussed in Parliament. We hope to develop partnerships and to participate in the relevant bodies as per the agreement.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. Baroness Whitaker (Lab)

    My Lords, as my noble friend will know, the European Commission funded wave energy substantially, as witnessed at the remarkable prototype site in Orkney. What plans do our Government have to continue the stimulation of this essential renewable for the intermittency mix?

    View contribution permalink →

  10. Baroness Curran (Lab)

    I recognise the noble Baroness’s interest in and knowledge of wave energy. She has raised that issue with me a number of times. We will always take opportunities, if we can, to increase our renewable energy in the UK, because we see it as vital to the production of clean energy, which is vital to the economic security of this country. We hope that we can participate as it is in our interest, and we will always protect British interests first.

    View contribution permalink →

  11. Lord Lilley (Con)

    Can the Minister explain—indeed, is she even aware—why an agreement on the electricity sector, which is less than one-fifth of our energy use, should need to cover the other four-fifths of our energy outside the electricity sector? Given that renewables account for only 16% of our total energy use, how can we possibly meet a target remotely comparable to 42.5% in two years without crippling costs on the cost of living?

    View contribution permalink →

  12. Baroness Curran (Lab)

    I do not believe that that will be the case. In fact, our commitment to renewable energy is ambitious in this country, and we will continue to be ambitious in this country for renewable energy. The acquis allows us to integrate the electricity market, which will help bring down costs and will work in the interests of British people.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. Lord Whitehead (Lab)

    My Lords, does the Minister agree that removing ourselves from the internal energy market, which we did but did not have to do at the time of Brexit, was a fundamental mistake? The internal energy market was a great support for UK energy security and vital for our future. Can she tell me how far the negotiations have now gone and when we can expect to see the outcome of these negotiations following the EU summit of May 2025?

    View contribution permalink →

  14. Baroness Curran (Lab)

    I thank the noble Lord for that question. I emphasise that these negotiations are ongoing and that we see them as in Britain’s interests. We hope that they will be raised at the next UK summit that has been announced, but we are not sure about that. They may continue beyond that. I emphasise the value of these negotiations. It was a mistake to withdraw from some of these agreements and we have lost because of that. This is a bespoke agreement that will help the UK, and I emphasise again that no new EU rules will apply in the UK unless and until the UK agrees to them.

    View contribution permalink →

  15. Lord Redwood (Con)

    Why, when looking at the cost of renewables, do the Government leave out the cost of back-up gas power which is needed, the big increase in grid costs which will be needed to handle unreliability, and the payments that have to be made when there is too much wind?

    View contribution permalink →

  16. Baroness Curran (Lab)

    The noble Lord has often raised the issue of the unreliability of renewables in this context, but one of the big challenges this country is facing is our vulnerability due to the unreliability of gas at the moment and fossil fuels. We are living in a global crisis, where the unavailability and the cost of gas are causing huge problems. As he is so keen on comparisons, perhaps he could undertake that comparison, too?

    View contribution permalink →

  17. Lord Moynihan (Con)

    My Lords, I declare my interest as chair of Amey, Acteon and Buckthorn Partners. Does the Minister agree that the impact of this potential initiative is rule-taking without the right to vote at the table? As my noble friends have said, an economy-wide renewables target in the UK is not on track to be met because—and I regret that she has not addressed this—it is not just the 20% of electricity that we use but the 80% of oil-driven and gas-driven power that we use as well, for our transport and heating, and a permanent, multibillion-pound financial contribution, which is uncosted and would burden British taxpayers.

    View contribution permalink →

  18. Baroness Curran (Lab)

    I emphasise again to the noble Lord that, when the acquis is agreed, along with any implications for the UK, we will not agree to comply with any rules that we have not participated in making. An agreement requires co-operation. We will not have to follow rules; we will negotiate rules. The UK-EU common understanding sets out that any agreement on state aid should provide for the UK’s dynamic alignment and that any further agreement on other dimensions requires constitutional parliamentary processes. It also envisages an appropriate transition period to allow the UK to implement any new requirements.

    View contribution permalink →

  19. Baroness Watkins of Tavistock (CB)

    Can the Minister assure the House that the Government will simultaneously be looking at increasing our gas storage facilities, which are putting us at significant risk compared to most of Europe?

    View contribution permalink →

  20. Baroness Curran (Lab)

    Again, this is an important point that has been discussed. I absolutely assure the House that our gas and energy supplies are resilient and there is no question of having had to address that resilience.

    View contribution permalink →

  21. Lord Lilley (Con)

    I thank the Minister for allowing me to come back. She keeps saying that we will negotiate these individual rules on the electricity market, but the EU’s negotiating proposals say: “The agreement should ensure the dynamic alignment of the laws of the United Kingdom with the rules of the Union on the promotion of renewable energy … and … provide for their simultaneous application in the United Kingdom”. There is no question of subsequent negotiation.

    View contribution permalink →

  22. Baroness Curran (Lab)

    I have made it clear that that will be part of the negotiations and that the negotiations are ongoing. I am asserting very clearly that, when this UK Government are undertaking those negotiations, we will assert the UK interest, and we will not sign up to or agree to anything that we do not believe to be the UK’s interests. We believe in partnership. One thing I would say to the noble Lord is that I clearly have a misunderstanding of Brexit, because I understood that Brexit did not prohibit further negotiations and further agreement with our European partners. It is quite disturbing that every time questions such as this come up in this House, it is as though we have to turn our back on our partners—no negotiation, no joint partnership—because every single time there is agreement or negotiation, the noble Lord raises questions and opposes it.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5419453.